Abel doesn’t tell me anything else that night, and I don’t make him.
He says tomorrow. He says it three times, backing away through the birches with the peach can against his chest, and every time his voice goes a little higher. I say all right. I say it as gently as I know how, the way you speak to a horse that’s already halfway into the trees.
Then he’s gone, and I’m alone in the Hartnell yard with snow in my boots and a lake in front of me, and I know that I will not sleep.
On Sunday I do the east shore, the north shore, and a long loop of nothing, so that nobody can say I wasn’t working. I eat the ham from Vesta. I wash at the rec center. At a quarter to ten that night, I park at the gravel turnout behind the lodge, as instructed, with my lights off and my phone in my sock, and wait.
The turnout is a slot cut into the spruce a hundred yards behind the lodge’s kitchen door. In the dark the lodge is a long black shape with one dim bulb burning over the back steps. It’s empty on Sundays. It has been empty since the supper.
At ten sharp, there’s a tap on the passenger window.
I don’t scream. I’m proud of that. I unlock the door, and Abel slides in with a gust of cold and the smell of wool and washed tin, and sits very upright with his hands under his thighs.
“You came,” he says.
“I said I would.”
“People say that.” He doesn’t look at me. “Go slow. Park behind the woodpile. There’s a place.”
I do what he says. He points, and I ease the truck down a rutted track I never knew existed, past the back of the lodge and into a clearing beside a long stack of split birch. I cut the engine. We sit for a moment with the ticking of the motor.
“What is it?”
“Come see.”
He gets out. I follow.
Behind the woodpile, half buried in a bank of old snow and drifted brush, there’s a low mound of stone with a plank door set into it. It looks like a root cellar from a hundred years ago. A rusty padlock hangs on a hasp. The door is only as high as my chest.
“The ice house,” Abel says. “Before there were freezers, they cut blocks off the lake and stored them in here, in sawdust. Everybody forgot. It’s on no map.” He fishes in his hood and brings out a small key on a string. “Leon showed me my first winter. He said it was the only place on the lake nobody would ever look, because nobody would ever think the lodge had a basement.”
“Where’s the key from?”
“He gave it to me.” He fits it to the padlock. “The last day.”
The lock clicks. The door swings inward on a breath of cold that smells of sawdust and stone.
We have to stoop to enter. The inside is a round room twelve feet across, lined with fieldstone, with a floor of packed sawdust and a domed ceiling that drips. Abel pulls the door shut behind us and finds a battery lantern on a ledge. A soft yellow glow fills the room.
On the ledge, in a coffee can, there’s a notebook.
It’s yellow. It’s small, waterproof, with a strip of white tape on the spine. WINTER 31.
I don’t remember crossing the floor. I only know that I’m holding it, and that it’s very cold and a little damp, and that my hands are shaking so hard the pages chatter.
“Read it here,” Abel says. “Please. Not in the truck.”
I sit down on an upturned bucket. He crouches against the wall with his knees against his chest, and he watches me the way you watch someone open a letter from a hospital.
It begins on the first of December, last winter. The same entries. Parcel, temperature, pump. A raccoon at the Ashford place. A broken window at forty-four. I turn the pages with my thumb, and the rhythm of his short square lines is so familiar and so precisely his that I have to stop and press the heel of my hand against my mouth.
On the fourteenth of December, the entry changes.
12/14: Sat. G. Hartnell closing 17. Heard she’s staying till Sun. Saw her car at 2.
12/15: Sun. Car still in garage. House dark. Heat 40, not 50. Not like her. Left a tie on the pantry.
12/16: A. came to the shop at dark. Shaking. Wouldn’t eat. Said he was under 17 Sat night. Said a man came after G. Said he heard it. Said it was not a quarrel.
I look up.
Abel is staring at the floor.
“I’ll tell you,” he says. “Let me say it in order. Then you can read.”
“All right.”
He draws a breath. He keeps his eyes on the sawdust.
“I was under the sunroom. Where you found me. It was the fourteenth. It was cold, and I’d been in the house since the afternoon, because I thought they were gone.” He swallows. “Leon had said the Hartnells were done for the year. He didn’t know she’d come back to close up. I heard the car in the drive at two. I heard the front door. I lay still.”
“Did she know you were there?”
“I think she knew somebody was.” His mouth twists. “She’d left a bag of food on the back deck twice, in November. A casserole, and then a loaf of bread. She never said anything. She just put it on the rail. I thought, she knows. And I thought, it’s okay.”
The lantern flickers. A drop falls from the ceiling and hits the sawdust with a small flat sound.
“She was upstairs for hours. I heard her walking. I heard the water. Around five, it was dark, I heard another car. It stopped in the drive, with no lights. I could hear the engine tick. Then a man’s boots on the porch.”
“What kind of boots?”
“Big.” He shows me, with a flat hand, how much space they took. “Heavy. He was a big person. He didn’t knock. He had a key.”
I don’t move.
“I heard the door. I heard her say, oh. Surprised. Like she’d found somebody she knew. And then she said, you can’t be here, and he said something low. I couldn’t hear that.” Abel is shaking now, a little, the fine shiver of a boy who has told this to a wall for a year. “They went into the kitchen. I could hear them through the floor. He was calm. He was so calm.”
“What did she say?”
“She said, you gave your word to Leon.” His voice cracks on the name. “She said, nothing in this house is yours. Nothing in any of these houses. She said, I’m going to the sheriff on Monday, and I want you to know that, because you’re a man who ought to be told.”
My throat is closing.
“And then?”
“And then it was quiet for a long time.” He looks up for the first time, and his eyes are enormous. “And then there was a sound. Like a sack. It wasn’t loud. It was a very, very ordinary sound.”
I put the notebook down on my knee. I put my hands on top of it.
“I didn’t breathe,” Abel says. “I lay there. I heard him moving. I heard him drag something, and a door open, and cold air. He was out on the deck. I crawled to the lattice and looked out through the crack. I saw boots. I saw, that’s all I saw, boots, and the bottom of a long coat. And a lantern, hooded, with just a slit. And a sled.”
“A sled.”
“A plastic one. The kind for hauling gear on ice. He had it pulled up by the steps. He had something on it under a tarp.”
My own breath has gone shallow and strange.
“He went down the lawn. Down to the dock. I followed. I stayed back, I stayed behind the boathouse, and I watched him pull that sled out on the ice.” He’s whispering. “It was thin. It was the middle of December. It was two inches. I could hear it crack under him. He didn’t care. He walked straight out toward the Narrows with a light in his hand, and I couldn’t see his face, the light was only for the ground.”
“You never saw his face.”
“I never saw his face.” He says it very clearly, like something he’s said to himself in the dark many times. “I wish I had. It’s the only thing I’ve wished for a year.”
“What did you see?”
“Lights. When he came back. Coming off the ice, empty. And a truck, up on the road, with an amber beacon on the roof, turning. And a sound.” His mouth works. “A backup beeper. One of those slow ones. Beep, beep, beep, and the second beep was cracked. Flat. Like the speaker was wet.”
I’m so cold I can’t feel my feet.
Plow trucks have beepers. There’s a plow on this lake that goes up and down Loop Road at four in the morning, scraping the snow in lines, and I have heard it every winter morning of my life. I never noticed its beeper. I never listened.
There’s the county plow. There’s a private rig that the Ashfords hire. There’s the Association’s orange truck in the shop.
“That could be anyone,” I say, and my voice sounds terrible.
“I know. I know it could.” Abel’s eyes are shining. “That’s why I never told. I never saw his face. I don’t know whose truck. I only know it wasn’t a stranger. A stranger doesn’t have a key to the Hartnell house.”
The light trembles. In the corner of the room a drop falls, and falls, and falls.
“What did you do?”
“I waited till he left. I waited an hour. Then I went out on the dock.” He lowers his head. “And I found a hair clip lying on the boards.”
I think of the plastic bag, of the gray hair in the spring. I think of a woman who left a casserole on a rail for a boy she’d never seen.
“I went to Leon,” Abel says, “that Monday. At the shop. I told him the whole thing. He sat down on a bucket like you, and he was white as paper, and he said, thank you. He said it twice.”
“What did he do?”
“He said, nobody can know. Not yet. Not until he was sure.” Abel rubs his face. “He said it’d be your word against a lake. He said we’d need a body, and a name, and a person who’d believe us. And he said he had to be careful, because the man had a key to everything. He said, the one thing this man can’t do is be in two places. So I should stay hidden, and he’d watch.”
“And then?”
“And then he watched. For a month.” Abel’s voice breaks. “And on the ninth, he came to find me at four in the afternoon. He gave me the book. He said, if I’m not back by dark, take it to Nika. He said, tell her I’m sorry about the money.”
I go very still.
“What money?”
“I don’t know.” He looks up. “He said it like it was a joke, and it wasn’t.”
“And then he went out on the ice.”
“On the sled. To the Narrows.” Abel’s whole body shudders. “He said he had to be sure. He said, a man ought to see a thing with his own eyes before he says it to a deputy. I told him not to go. I said, the ice. He said, I’ve been walking ice for thirty years.”
“You followed him.”
“I stayed on the shore.” He presses his fists against his eyes. “I watched the lamp. It went out on the lake, and it stopped, and I saw him get off the sled. I saw him walk to the place. And then the ice.” He can barely speak. “It went all at once. There wasn’t any sound. The lamp tipped, and it was just, it was just gone.”
I close my eyes.
“I ran out. I did. I lay flat, like he taught me, I slid on my stomach. I could see his hand. I got close enough to see his hand.” Abel is sobbing now, without noise, his shoulders heaving. “He looked at me. He said your name. He said, Nika. That’s all. And then he wasn’t there.”
The ice house is silent. A drop of water falls from the stone dome into the sawdust.
I can’t speak. I put my hand out, and I put it on the boy’s shoulder, and he turns and leans into me without a word, and we stay like that, two strangers on a bucket and a crouch in the dark.
I don’t know how long it is. A minute. Ten.
“There were headlights on the road,” he says at last, into my coat. “While I was in the water. I saw them. They stopped, and I ran. I’m sorry. I’m so sorry. I should have stayed. I should have shouted.”
“No.”
“I left him.”
“You didn’t.” I hold him by the arms and make him look at me. “You were nineteen years old in the dark, and you’d just watched a man walk off the ice from killing a woman. You did the only thing that would keep you alive. He’d have wanted you to.”
“You don’t know that.”
“I do,” I say, and I find that it’s true. “He wrote it down.”
I pick up the book. My hands are steadier now, in a strange way, the way they are on the last mile of a long drive. I turn to the last page that has writing on it.
It’s the ninth of January. The ink is a little blurred where the page has been damp, but the capitals are firm and square and unmistakably his.
1/9. 3:58 PM.
GAVE THIS BOOK TO A. HE BRINGS IT TO NIKA IF I’M NOT BACK BY DARK.
17 IS NOT EMPTY AND G. IS NOT IN ARIZONA. SHE IS AT THE NARROWS. I’M SURE OF THE PLACE, NOT THE HAND.
SAME HANDS THAT CUT THE KEYS.
DON’T TRUST THE KEY COUNT. IT COUNTS WHAT THEY WANT COUNTED.
GOING OUT TO THE NARROWS TO BE SURE. THEN KOVAL. IF YOU ARE READING THIS I WAS NOT CAREFUL ENOUGH.
HEAT, WATER, ROOF. THE FOURTH PART WAS A LIE. IT WAS NEVER MINE TO MIND.
I read it three times. Then I read the last line on the page.
It’s a single word, set apart from the rest by a blank line. It’s printed very large, and underlined once, with a pen pressed down so hard that the paper has torn at the stem of the final letter.
NIKA.
I put the book against my chest and bend over it. For a very long time I can’t feel anything at all. Then I feel everything.
When I look up, the lantern has burned low, and Abel is sitting with his knees up and his face turned to the wall, giving me the privacy of a boy who was raised by a man like my father.
“Tomorrow,” I say. My voice is raw. “Tomorrow, you and I are going to the Narrows.”
“It’s frozen.”
“I know.”
“Nika.” He turns. “The ice is two inches.”
“Then we’ll be careful.” I stand up. I tuck the book inside my shirt, against my skin, the way he did. “He never got to be sure. I’m going to be.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!