Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 9

Crawl Space

By eleven-thirty on Saturday night, I’ve stopped pretending I’m going anywhere else.

I leave the lodge at nine, with a foil package of ham that Vesta pushed into my hands and the cold look of Reyna Koval following me to the door. I drive around the lake twice. I park in a gravel pull-off with my lights off and my hands in my sleeves, and I sit there for an hour, doing nothing, while a cold that has nothing to do with the weather crawls up my spine.

Prudence is going to tell the board. I have a log that doesn’t match a camera. I have a deputy who has started to count the lies. In six weeks I have to put a certificate of insurance and a business address on a table, and I have neither, and the only person in the world who might know why my father died is a stranger who leaves notes.

Ask me anything when you’re alone.

I am alone.

I turn the key. The engine takes its time, the way it does when it knows you have nowhere else to be. I don’t drive to the Voss place, where he’d expect me. I drive the long way around the west end, with the heater roaring in the wrong half of the cab, and I turn into the Hartnell drive with my lights off and coast up the rise in neutral.

Number seventeen isn’t in the pilot. I looked at Prudence’s grid for a long time. Four, nine, thirteen, twenty-two, twenty-six, thirty-one, forty-four, fifty-eight. No seventeen. It’s the one house on the lake that nobody watches.

I think about that, parked under the bare birches, looking up at a big dark house with a pale deck and eleven empty window boxes.

I don’t go in the front. I’m not a fool. I take the headlamp, the ring, the little pry bar from the glove box, and I walk around the side of the house in the snow with my boots set down one at a time, past the garage, past the boathouse path, to the lake side where the sunroom juts out on stilts.

The foundation under the sunroom is a low concrete wall with a lattice skirt hung across it. In summer it hides a gap, and hides, behind the gap, the little access panel my father showed me once in a spring so long ago I can barely remember the day.

I find the lattice by feel. The cold has made it rigid, and it scrapes against the concrete with a sound like a held note. It’s old cedar, silvered, nailed in a frame. I put the light on the bottom corner and I see what I was afraid I’d see.

The snow is packed flat in a half circle in front of it. Not much. A boot-width. But it’s flat in a way snow isn’t when nothing’s walked on it, and it’s been scraped and trodden so many times that it’s stayed down through two thaws.

I put my fingers under the edge of the lattice and pull.

It swings out on a leather hinge, silently, as though it has been oiled.

Behind it there’s a rectangle of black. Cold air comes out of it, not the dead cold of an empty cellar but a thicker one, with a faint smell like wool and woodsmoke and old paper. And underneath, a very clean smell, citrus, as of a washed tin can.

I get down on my knees in the snow.

“Hello?” I say, softly. “Anybody home?”

The dark absorbs it.

I could stop. I know I could. I could turn around right here and walk back through the birches and get in the truck and drive until the road ended in a different state. People do. They do it every day.

But my father went into houses to feed someone, and I haven’t once asked who.

I put the light in my teeth, flat on my belly, and I crawl in.

The crawl space under number seventeen’s sunroom is three feet high at its tallest. It’s earthen floor under a plastic vapor sheet, with joists overhead and a long dark tunnel running toward the main house. The beam of my lamp slides along it and picks out wires, a pipe, a cobweb silvered with frost.

I go forward on my elbows. The plastic crackles under me. My knees scrape the dirt through my jeans. At the third joist I come out of the tunnel into a wider space, a rectangle the size of a bedroom, and there I stop.

Somebody lives here.

I take the light out of my teeth and move it slowly, left to right, with a breath I can feel in my lungs like a stone.

A foam pad, the kind you put under a sleeping bag, lies against the east wall with a bag rolled at its foot. A gray wool blanket is folded in thirds on top of it, the same fold as in the Voss guest room. A row of paperback books stands against a joist, spines out. A battery lantern with the glass turned to the wall. A plastic tub with a lid.

Against the stone footing, in a row, graduated by size from large to small, there are eleven clean tin cans.

I put my hand flat on the dirt.

This is where he sleeps. Not in the Voss place. Not in the guest room with the quilt folded back. He goes into the houses to eat and wash and use the heat. But here, in the dark, in the dirt, under the floor of the one house nobody watches, is where he comes when he’s afraid.

I crawl closer. I can’t stop myself.

The tidiness of it makes my throat ache. Nothing here is stolen. Nothing is broken. He has made a home out of the one resource a house gives away for free, which is the space nobody is using.

The paperbacks are mostly westerns and field guides. Birds of the Great Lakes. A battered book on knots. I touch a spine and my hand shakes. Then I do something I’ll think about later. I pick up the field guide, because it’s the fattest, and let it fall open in my palm.

A photograph is pressed in it, flat and creased in four places from being unfolded many times. It’s a snapshot, the kind printed at a drugstore. A tall man in a canvas coat stands on the steps of the lodge beside a girl of about fifteen with braces and a terrible haircut. He has one arm around her. She is pretending to be annoyed.

It’s me. It’s the first Key Count Night.

On the back, in blue ballpoint, in handwriting I don’t know, someone has written two words. My daughter. And then, under it, in smaller, more careful print, as though copying something from a source: she is a better liar than I am.

I sit back on my heels. The crawl space is so quiet I can hear the lantern’s tiny electrical hum. Somewhere above us a joist ticks as the house gives up its heat, and I think of Greta upstairs, years of her labels on every jar, and not one of them for the dirt under her feet.

He talked about me. He sat in a cellar or a shop with a boy who had nowhere to go, and he took out a photograph and said my name. I imagine it, and something in my chest folds in half.

In the tub, the lid is off. I see a flashlight, a small hatchet, a first-aid kit with a torn corner. A pair of men’s socks, darned at the heel. A paper bag with half a loaf of bread.

And tucked in the lid of the tub, where he could grab it fast, a clear plastic bag holding a single object.

It’s a woman’s hair clip. A big one, tortoiseshell, the kind that holds a heavy twist at the back of the head. There’s a gray hair caught in the spring.

I don’t touch it. I look at it for a very long time.

Greta Hartnell wore her hair in a clip. I told myself that on Monday, standing in her kitchen, while labels in her own hand shone on a row of glass jars. A brisk, kind woman with her hair pinned up.

A loud, wet, silent roar has started in my ears.

“You shouldn’t be in here.”

The voice comes from behind me.

It’s very quiet. It isn’t threatening. It’s a young man’s voice, low and hoarse, the voice of someone who has spoken to almost no one in a year and has lost the knack of volume.

I don’t turn. I can’t.

“Turn the light down,” he says. “Please. It hurts my eyes.”

I lower the beam to the ground. I let my shoulders drop. I put both hands, palms flat, on the plastic sheet, and I turn, very slowly, on my knees.

He’s at the mouth of the tunnel, twelve feet away. He is lying on his stomach with his elbows propped, exactly the way I came in, and the glow of the lantern has found him.

He’s about twenty. Thin. Long in the face and limb, with dark hair that hangs over his forehead and a gray hood pushed back from it. A scar at one eyebrow. Brown eyes, wide, very steady. He looks like somebody who was a child a short time ago and has been rushed. He’s wearing fingerless gloves, and in his right hand, held low and tight against his chest like a thing he would swing, he’s holding a can of peaches.

It’s unopened. It’s the one I left on the Voss windowsill.

“You took the can,” I say.

“I thought it was for me.”

“It was.”

“Then I took it.” He doesn’t smile. “You wrote me a note.”

“You wrote me four.”

“Three and a half.” The corner of his mouth moves, a very small thing, like a nerve. “The first one was an accident. I wasn’t going to leave it.”

“How long have you been under here?” I ask.

He thinks about it. It’s a real question to him, and he gives it real weight.

“Under this one, since that night. Nearly a year. I move around. Leon had a schedule, the houses nobody checks in the week, the ones with the dry crawl spaces.” He turns the can over in his hand. “I lost the schedule after. I had to guess. That’s how I almost walked in on you. I’m sorry about the stove at the Quarles place. I didn’t know you’d be in it.”

“The stove?”

“I lit it once, in November. It was twelve below.” He ducks his head. “I put it out before dawn. I didn’t leave a mark.”

“I didn’t smell it.”

“I used hardwood. It doesn’t smell.”

I find that I’m almost smiling, which is ridiculous. He’s twenty years old and has been living in a hole for a year, and he’s telling me, with perfect politeness, about his fire safety.

“Where do you eat?”

“Leon’s friend leaves things.” He doesn’t say who. “A bag on a fence post, on Tuesdays. I never saw her. I think she’s afraid I’ll say thank you.”

Vesta, I think. Of course.

I look at him, and I feel the strangest tug of recognition. Not of his face. Of his posture, the particular crouch of a person who is ready to leave and has decided, against his better judgment, to stay.

I know that crouch. I’ve had it for ten weeks.

“You’re Abel,” I say.

His eyes jump. “He told you.”

“He wrote it. In the margin. A. Found on Loop Road. Three days. Bad shape.” I can hear my voice shake. “He said you weren’t a bad kid. He said you were just far from everybody.”

For a moment the boy doesn’t move at all. Then he lowers his face and presses the heel of one gloved hand into his eye, hard, and a sound comes out of him that isn’t a word.

I don’t say anything. I let him. I put my hands on my knees and I wait, as my father would, and the dirt under me is cold and damp, and the crawl space ticks around us with the small sounds of a house at night.

“I’m sorry,” he says, after a while. “I’m sorry I didn’t, I didn’t know how to come to you. I tried. I tried the first night. You were in the kitchen with the light on, and I stood at the window, and I thought, she’s going to scream.”

“I might have.”

“I thought you’d call the police.” He lifts his head. His eyes are wet and furious. “I can’t be where the police are, Nika. I can’t. Not yet.”

“Why?”

“Because he’ll know.”

The word sits there in the lantern light.

“Who will?”

“I can’t.” He shakes his head. “I can’t say it here. I don’t know who can hear. I don’t know what’s in the houses. I only know what he told me, the last day. He said, the cameras are for the houses, Abel. They’re not for the people. And then he said I should find you.”

“My father said that.”

“He said, if you came, I was to give you the book.” His voice drops to nothing. “He said it twice.”

The book.

Something in my chest stops. Then it starts again, slowly, painfully, the way a numb hand wakes.

“Where is it?”

“Not here.” He’s backing away. A little, very slowly, along the tunnel, the can still held tight. “It’s somewhere I can reach but they can’t. I’ll take you. I’ll take you tomorrow night. But you have to come alone, and you have to be careful with the light, and you have to”

“Abel.”

He stops.

“Why is there a hair clip in your bag?”

I’ve asked it too fast. I know it as it leaves me. I see his face change, all of it, the stubbornness and the hurt, the way a window changes when a shade comes down.

“You looked at it,” he says.

“It was in the lid.”

“I didn’t touch it.” The words come out in a rush, high and thin. “I swear. I found it on the dock after, on the boards, that same night, just lying there. I picked it up so nobody else would. I didn’t know what to do. I didn’t know whose it was. I knew whose it was.”

“Whose is it?”

“You know.”

“I want you to say.”

He looks at me, and I look at him, and for a moment we are two scared people in a hole in the ground.

“It’s not safe to say it in the house,” he whispers. “But I’ll tell you out here, so it’s out of the ground. Come on.”

He backs out of the tunnel ahead of me and doesn’t stop until he’s in the open air, standing in the snow with the can at his side and the dark lake behind him. I crawl after him, my jeans soaked, my palms raw, and I come up beside him under the black sky.

The cold hits my face like a hand. For a moment I can’t see anything but stars.

“I’m going to tell you something,” Abel says, very low, “and you’re going to want to say it can’t be true.”

“Tell me.”

He doesn’t look at me. He looks at the lake, at a long gray plate with a single dark scar in the middle of it, a quarter mile out. The Narrows.

“The woman everyone says is in Arizona never left this lake.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!