Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 8

The Potluck

Vesta makes me bring something, so I bring two bags of dinner rolls and a face I’ve been practicing in the truck mirror.

It’s the first Saturday of December, the night of the lodge supper. Everybody on Pinfeather Lake goes. The eleven year-round households, a handful of summer people who drive up for it, the board in their good coats. My father went every year for thirty-one years and stood by the coffee urn, and I used to think he did it because he liked people. I think now it was a way of counting heads.

The lodge is a log building at the east end of the lake, with a stone chimney and a sign over the door that has said ALL ARE WELCOME since before I was born. Inside, the long room is already hot and loud. Folding tables with paper cloths. A line of slow cookers along one wall, each one with a handwritten card. A Christmas tree somebody has put in the corner and strung with colored bulbs, half of which have given up.

I put the rolls down next to a tray of something orange. There are forty people in the room, and nobody turns around.

That’s not true. Everybody turns around. They turn around the way people do when a grown child walks in at a funeral. A little nod, a lifted hand, a mouth that begins to say my name and settles on a smile.

“Nika, honey. Look at you.”

“Hi, Mrs. Rudd.”

“You’re too thin. Eat the ham.”

I eat the ham. It’s very good. It’s glazed, with a crust of brown sugar, and somebody has carved it into slices so perfect they look machined. I look up, over the paper plate, and see the carver at the head of the table with a long knife and a gray square beard.

Merle looks up and winks.

On the wall behind him, beside the coat rack, hangs a laminated sheet in a plastic sleeve. SUPPER SIGN-UP. It has four columns, MAINS, SIDES, DESSERTS, DRINKS, and a long list of names written in a hand I don’t know. It’s a blocky, careful script, a man’s, trying hard.

I know where I’ve seen the other kind. Greta Hartnell’s lists used to hang there in a looping blue felt-tip, with a smiley face by the names of people who’d brought pie. For eleven years she ran this room. She ran every potluck, every Easter egg hunt, the raffle for the lodge roof.

The sheet this year is in Rex’s writing. I recognize it from the Association’s checks.

He’s across the room, standing by the Christmas tree, with a plate he isn’t eating from. He’s put on a tie. It’s a brown one, wide, a little crooked. Next to him a woman I don’t know is patting his arm and talking, and he nods and nods without hearing, with a face as smooth as a stone.

He glances up. Our eyes meet across the lodge. He looks, for half a second, like a man who has been caught.

Then he looks down at the plate.

I take a seat at the end of a table, near the coffee, with my back to the wall.

It’s an old habit. My father always chose a seat with a wall behind it. When I was ten, I asked him why, and he said, “So nothing can come up behind you,” and laughed, and I thought he was making a joke about bears. I see now there are things worse than bears.

Across from me sits a very old man in a cardigan who doesn’t say a word and eats with precise, enormous attention. On my left, a couple in their sixties are arguing in whispers about parking. Farther down, a girl of about twelve is feeding bits of roll to a dog under the table. And standing by the exit, with a paper cup of coffee and her back to the doorframe, is a woman in plain clothes with a long braid down one shoulder.

Reyna Koval is off duty. She’s wearing a flannel shirt and jeans, and there’s a cinnamon toothpick tucked in the corner of her mouth. She hasn’t taken a plate. She hasn’t spoken to anyone for ten minutes.

She’s looking at me.

I lift a roll in greeting. She tips her cup a fraction of an inch and goes back to looking at the room.

Everyone in the world is here. Everyone who knows my father’s name. The woman who delivers his mail. The man with the plow. The store. The county. The board. Anyone could have driven a truck around the lake last Sunday night, past a house with a stranger in it, and seen a flashlight in the yard.

Everyone could have been in a hood on the ice.

“You are jingling, chief.”

I jump. I’ve taken my eye off Merle for six seconds, and he’s beside me with a plate of ham in each hand, grinning down from his great height. He sets one plate in front of me. He sets the other beside it, and sits.

“Jingling?”

“Your pocket.” He nods toward my coat. “You’ve got more keys in there than a jailer. I could hear you coming from the parking lot.”

I put a hand over the pocket. I can feel the shape of the ring through the canvas. And below it, in my left pocket, separate, where I put it on purpose, the sharp small bump of a key with a letter on it.

“Habit,” I say.

“It’s a good habit.” He cuts a piece of ham with the side of his fork. “Your father never went anywhere without those. I used to say, Leon, you’ll wear a hole in your leg.”

“What did he say?”

“He said a man ought to feel the weight of what he’s responsible for.” Merle chews. His eyes are mild and bright. “Wise man. I never did like to carry anything I didn’t have to.”

I take a bite of ham. It tastes of sugar and smoke.

“Come to dinner Thursday?” he says. “You missed the roast. I made the roast. I made it for nobody.”

“I’m sorry. I got tied up.”

“Sure you did.” He points the fork at me with great gentleness. “You’re a hard worker, chief. Just be careful. A person can get so busy being the hard worker that she forgets to be a person.”

He eats the rest of the ham, and he talks about the plow. The ice is four inches off the north shore and nearly six by the boat launch. The county has promised sand by the fifteenth. He’s thinking of a second blade. I say all the right things. He puts a peppermint on the edge of my plate and goes to refill the coffee.

I look at the peppermint for a long time. It sits on the paper like a small white eye.

Nobody I know is better at being liked than Merle Benedek. He knows every dog and every allergy. He remembered that Mr. Rudd can’t have onions and that the girl with the dog is afraid of the dark. He carries the old man’s plate when the old man can’t. If I had to name the man on Pinfeather Lake who’d come out in a storm, who’d pull a stranger from a ditch, who’d sit with a widow at three in the morning, it would be him.

It would be him.

I push the peppermint away, and then, because it would be strange not to, I pick it up and put it in my pocket.

I’m refilling my cup at the coffee urn when somebody stops at my elbow and says my name as if he’s afraid it will break.

“Nika.”

Rex has loosened the brown tie. Up close, his forehead shines. He keeps his eyes on the urn.

“About Monday,” he says. “The bathroom. The medicine.”

“I haven’t said anything.”

“No, no. I know you haven’t. I know.” He takes his glasses off, rubs them on his vest, and puts them back. “I wanted to say thank you. And I wanted to say, the board meets in a week. I could put in a word. About the contract. About the money.”

My stomach turns over. “You don’t have to do that.”

“I’d like to.” He fumbles a hand into his jacket and brings out a white envelope, folded once. “It’s a small bonus. For the extra visits. For all you’ve done at seventeen. It doesn’t need to go on a form.”

I look at the envelope. It’s fat. It’s the kind of thickness you can feel through paper.

Here is the thing I know about Rex Hartnell. He is a man who spent thirty years teaching himself to look at an envelope of cash and see a crime. He would never, in his life, offer this to anybody unless he was terrified.

“I can’t take that,” I say.

“Please.”

“Rex.”

“Please, Nika.” His voice cracks, very slightly, on the second syllable. “You have to know that. Whatever people say. I loved her. I did. I just, I can’t have people asking about the pills.”

It’s the most honest sentence he has said to me. I take it in, and I don’t know what to do with it.

“Mr. Hartnell.”

The voice comes from my right. Level, unhurried, with a trace of cinnamon on it. Rex flinches as if he’s been shot.

Reyna Koval is standing a pace away with her coffee cup in one hand. She hasn’t moved quickly. She’s simply there, a long braid and a flannel shirt, with the particular stillness of somebody who has been standing a while.

“Deputy,” Rex says. “I was just, we were discussing the Association contract.”

“I’m sure.” She sips. “Don’t let me interrupt. I wanted to say how sorry I am about the supper. It’s a hard night for you.”

“Yes. Thank you.”

“Greta used to do the rolls.” She looks at the envelope, which Rex has not quite managed to hide. “Did you ever find the recipe?”

“I’m sorry?”

“The rolls. Everyone says she had a recipe. Seems like a thing a person leaves behind.” Koval smiles, a small, polite, empty smile. “Seems like a thing you’d take.”

Rex’s mouth opens. Nothing comes out of it.

“Well.” Koval tips her cup. “Enjoy your night.”

She moves away. Rex stands there, hand in his jacket, the envelope crushed in his fist. He doesn’t look at me. He walks, rather fast, to the coat rack, and he doesn’t come back to the room again until the lights go down.

At half past seven, the lights in the lodge go down by half and somebody taps a spoon on a glass.

Prudence Ludlow stands at the front of the room in a dark green dress and a long strand of pearls. She does not need a microphone. She has the kind of voice that carries, and a way of waiting for silence as if she were owed it.

“Friends,” she says. “Neighbors. Thank you for coming. I know it isn’t easy, the first snow, the long road from Chicago, which is a polite way of saying I’m late.”

A soft laugh.

“We’ve had a hard year. We lost people.” She doesn’t look at me. “We’ve had questions. But I want to say, before we eat dessert, that this community has done what it always does. It held on.” She raises her cup. “To Pinfeather. To the long dark. And to Key Count Night, on the twentieth of January, at seven o’clock, in this room.”

“Hear, hear.”

The room drinks. I raise a paper cup of cider and put it to my mouth, and over the rim, I see Rex at the Christmas tree. He hasn’t raised anything. He has set down his plate on the windowsill, and his hands are hanging, loose and white, at his sides.

When I look back, Prudence is standing in front of my chair.

“Danika. A word?”

She doesn’t wait. She walks to a quieter corner, by the coat rack, and I follow with a dread so heavy it feels like food. She has a tablet in her hand, in a gray case. She holds it against her pearls like a hymnal.

“I won’t keep you from the pie,” she says. “But I promised I’d tell you about the pilot, and I’m a woman who keeps her promises.”

“Merle explained it.”

“Merle explains many things.” Her smile is cool and fleeting. “Let me show you what he didn’t.”

She taps the screen. A grid of small gray squares appears, eight of them, each with a name and a tiny status line. 4. 9. 13. 22. 26. 31. 44. 58. Under each, a line of text in pale blue. LAST MOTION. DOOR EVENT. CONTRACTOR LOG.

“Insurance people like data,” Prudence says. “The program records every door event and every motion trigger in the houses we’ve enrolled. It sends a summary to me, and to the chairman of safety, and to the treasurer. It doesn’t spy. It makes a list.”

“I see.”

“I’m glad. Because I wanted to be sure you understood it was never about you.” She swipes. The squares slide away, and a long table opens, rows of times and dates. “However, you’ll want to know what it does record.”

Her finger rests on a line near the top.

NINE. DOOR EVENT. SUN 9:41 PM. CONTRACTOR.

It’s a single row. It could be nothing.

“That’s you,” she says. “Entering the Voss mudroom. The camera over the stoop is a tiny thing, motion-triggered, we put it there because of the old wiring. It saw you.”

My mouth goes dry. “I do the Voss check Sunday nights.”

“I know. And you recorded it.” Prudence taps the second line. “Monday, 12:42 a.m. MOTION, rear door. And the one under it. 12:43. 12:44.”

I look at the rows. They are as dry and flat as a bus schedule.

“There’s a clip,” Prudence says. “I’ve watched it twice. The camera sees a stoop and a bit of yard. You can see you, at 9:41, going in with a sleeping bag.” She says it softly. “At 12:42, it sees the door fly open, and a young man, I think a young man, run past the lens with a hood up. Followed, three seconds later, by you.”

I don’t move. I can’t. Somewhere in the lodge, a child laughs, and the dog barks once.

“Who was he, Danika?”

“I don’t know.”

“You chased him.”

“I thought it was a prowler.” My voice is level. It’s so level it frightens me. “I came to check the house and he was in the kitchen. He ran. I followed him to the dock and lost him on the ice.”

“And you didn’t call the sheriff.”

“It was one in the morning. I was embarrassed. I thought he’d gone.”

“I see.” Prudence turns the tablet in her hands. Her eyes on mine are gray and steady and not unkind. “I have to ask, because the insurer will. Why were you carrying a sleeping bag?”

The room tilts, very slightly, the way a deck does.

“To sit up with the stove,” I say. “The Voss furnace has been tripping. I wanted to watch it.”

“All night.”

“Until it ran stable.”

“All right.” She nods, slowly, as if she’s accepting a donation. “I’ll note that. Though I should mention that we’ve had no reports of the furnace tripping. And that you came back on Wednesday, at 4:12 in the morning, for three minutes.”

“I left food for the cat.”

“For the cat.” She says it without a flicker. “Yes. I’m told there is a cat.”

She lowers the tablet. “One more thing, and then I’ll let you eat.”

She taps the screen a third time. A new list comes up, short, in the same neat font. It’s a log of my own handwriting, scanned from the green notebook I turn in to Rex every Friday. I recognize the slant. The entry for Sunday has been circled in pale red.

Sunday night, 31, Gerrity. Heat 50. Shutoff closed. Roof clear.

“The log says you were at the Gerrity place that night,” Prudence says gently. “The camera says you were at the Voss place.”

I look at the line. I look at my own writing, at its little hopeful slant.

“It’s a long night,” I say.

She waits. She is a woman who can wait for an hour. I stand in front of her with my hand at my pocket, and I feel the whole lodge behind me like a held breath, and I know that Reyna Koval is watching from the door.

“I’m not accusing you,” Prudence says. “I’m saying what I’ll have to say to the board. You were in nine on Sunday night, Danika. Your log says thirty-one.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!