Twenty-nine bowls stood on the long table at sundown, and for the first time since Tess had known the Bench, nobody had been told which way to turn them.
Greta had not called it a trial. She had not called it a vote, either, though that was what it was.
She had walked into the big kitchen at five with the green ledger in both arms and set it down in the middle of the table, on a clean white cloth, and said to the room, “There is a thing I have never told you, and there is a thing my mother never told me, and tonight we will learn whether they are the same thing.” Then she had sat, and folded her hands, and waited for the room to fill.
It filled slowly. They came in by ones and twos with snow on their shoulders: Wade Aarons with sawdust in his beard, Birdie with her leather satchel, Joss behind her, taller than he had been a month ago and quieter, carrying a stack of folding chairs for the guests.
Marcus Bell and Hana Lund and old Cyrus came in from the bunkhouse, and sat in the back row by the stove, as the guests of a Table do, hearing and not voting. Joan Halvorsen came last, in her Montana coat with the elk-horn buttons, and stood against the wall by the door.
Ansel came in with the cold on him and took the place by the wall where a brother stands. He caught Tess’s eye across the room. He did not smile. He only moved his right hand, down by his thigh, two fingers, a gesture so small that she was never sure afterward whether she had seen it, and it said: *I’m here.*
“The question is this,” said Greta. “Shall the Long Table open the back board of the Ledger of the Closure, which has not been opened since the spring of 1938?”
Nobody breathed.
“I’ll hear speech, and then I’ll hear the bowls.”
---
Harlan Voyles spoke first, as everyone had known he would.
He was Lonnie’s older brother, a lean gray man with a long jaw and a way of sitting very straight, as though the chair had been built by an enemy. He had abstained on the guest-right vote with the children, and Tess had spent a week wondering why. She understood now. He was not a cruel man or a stupid one. He was a man who had buried a brother in October and had decided, privately, never to bury another thing he could have prevented by keeping still.
“I have nothing against the Warden,” said Harlan, to the table. “I want that said. She cut Lonnie’s wire. I’ll not forget the hands that did it. But I want to know why Margit sewed a book into a book, and why she wrote a rule that it could not be opened, and why every Lead since has kept the rule.
“Not one of them was a coward. Not one of them was stupid. They kept it shut because whatever’s in there is worse for us read than unread.”
“You don’t know that,” said Birdie.
“I know that Margit Haugen was the wisest woman this Closure ever had, and she hid a thing from her own daughter. That’s not a woman who thinks a secret is a *harmless* thing.” Harlan’s eyes went to Tess. “There’s a man in a felt hat who wants this book.
“He wants it by the twenty-fourth. I’ve seen a few men in my life who ask nicely for what they mean to take. I say we do not give him the satisfaction of a hunt. I say we let it lie.”
“And the guests?” said Joan Halvorsen quietly, from the wall. “If the Compact’s declared void, there’s ten people out in that bunkhouse who are trespassers by morning.”
“That’s a cost,” said Harlan. “I’ll own it. I’d rather pay it than hand a man the key.”
“There’s another cost,” said Wade Aarons.
He had not stood. He had not raised his voice. He sat at the end of the table with his big hands flat on the wood, and he looked down the length of it at Greta, as if the rest of the room had gone out.
“My mother is behind the orchard,” he said. “She’s behind the orchard because somebody read the den map and somebody knew where to put a wire. I voted to keep the boy because he was a boy, and because the things that killed her were a map and a book and a man with a phone, and I didn’t know which of them I was meant to be angry at.
“I’ve decided.” He nodded to Harlan, with great courtesy. “It isn’t the book. It’s the not-knowing. We’ve been dying for three months by guesses. I’d like to read the thing that’s been used to kill us. Even if it’s worse.”
“That’s a speech,” said Greta softly.
“I’m not a speaker.”
“No. That’s why it’s a speech.”
Nobody else rose. After a time, in the long quiet, Greta stood, and lifted the stack of white stoneware bowls from the shelf, and set one in front of each voter.
“Rim up to open. Rim down to keep it shut.”
She sat. The kitchen did the old, slow thing it did. There was a scrape of stoneware, then a clink, then another, then a patient shuffle as twenty-nine hands made up twenty-nine minds. Tess did not vote; she had no bowl. She watched the table and counted, because it was what she knew how to do.
*One. Two.* Birdie, up. Wade, up. Harlan, down, with the great steady gravity of a man laying a stone. *Fourteen. Fifteen.* Joss, who was not yet a voter and had been given Lonnie’s bowl by Greta without comment, turned it up with both hands. *Seventeen. Eighteen.*
“Eighteen,” said Greta, “to eleven. The back board is opened.”
Harlan Voyles looked at his turned-down bowl for one long moment. Then, with the same dry stiffness, he reached over, rolled it rim-up, and set it back on the cloth.
“A Table that loses a vote and keeps its quarrel is no Table,” he said. “I’ll hold the lamp.”
---
Birdie cut the stitches with a scalpel from her satchel, and nobody offered to help.
The ledger lay open to its last leaf, and she worked from the inside, with her reading glasses low on her nose and the lamp that Harlan held steady over her shoulder. The stitches were not the original thread. Tess saw that at once. They were waxed linen, brown, too even, and the holes in the board had been pricked fresh.
“Somebody’s been in here,” said Birdie, very quietly.
“Margit’s thread was black,” said Greta. She had gone grey around the lips. “My mother said black.”
“This is a month old at the most. Walt’s, probably.” Birdie’s scalpel slid under the last loop. “Look at the knot. He tied it the way he tied everything. Thumb through twice.”
The whole table made a small sound, like wind through a keyhole.
“He opened it,” said Harlan.
“In August.” Tess had known, in her chest, before the scalpel moved. “He came to this kitchen in August, and he stayed late, because he stayed late every Thursday, and you all went home. He had a key to the Bench. He had a thumb-through knot.” She looked at Greta. “He broke the lock, and he told no one, and he sewed it shut again.”
“Because he couldn’t ask,” said Greta. Her voice had gone thin. “He knew the Table would say no. He thought it was kinder to take the sin on himself.” She pressed her fist to her mouth, and a sound came out of her that was not quite a laugh. “Oh, you stubborn old man. You *stubborn*, kind, stupid old man.”
The board came open with a small soft crack, like the spine of a hymnal.
Inside the thick cloth was a hollow, and in the hollow lay a flat bundle wrapped in oilcloth, and in the oilcloth a book. It was not large: a quarto, black buckram, the corners rubbed to brown, a paper label on the spine in a dry, tight, clerical hand.
*INVENTORY OF THE CLOSURES. 1938.*
On top of it, laid flat, was a single sheet of yellow paper, folded once, written over in block capitals.
Greta did not touch the sheet. She did not touch the book. She looked at Tess, and Tess understood that she was being asked to be the one, the way a bride is asked to lift a veil.
She lifted the cover.
---
The title page read, in the same dry hand:
*INVENTORY OF THE WOLF POPULATION OF THE STATE OF IDAHO, PREPARED UNDER THE DIRECTION OF COMMISSIONER W. A. WEIR, FOR THE USE OF THE DEPARTMENT. APRIL 1938. CONFIDENTIAL.*
There was no preface. The next page was a ruled table, with six columns, and a hundred lines to the sheet, and the lines were full.
*NAME. KIN. LAST KNOWN LOCATION. HOLDING. CLASS. VALUE.*
She read the first entry, and the second, and the tenth. Then she read the last column again, and again, and felt the heat rise in the backs of her hands, and she pressed her palms against the cloth and counted, *fourteen, fourteen,* until the page stopped shaking.
“Warden,” said Joan Halvorsen from the wall. “What does it say?”
Tess did not answer. She turned the page. And the next, and the next. It was written like a stockman’s tally.
*Tarkington, A., 41. Wife, two sons. Larch Cty., Bench Rd. Holding: 9 acres leased. Class C, field. $35.* *Haugen, M., 52. Alpha female. Closure Fourteen. Class A, lead. $400. NOT TO BE TAKEN WITHOUT INSTRUCTION.* *Voyles, T., 29.* *Aarons, D., 22.* Two hundred and fourteen names, with the wolves of every county in the state, each in a line, each with a price, each with a stamped letter. A, B, C, and one called *R*, for *reserve*.
“It’s a livestock ledger,” said Marcus Bell, in a flat voice from the back.
“It’s an inventory,” said Tess. She heard her own voice go very level. “Of what the Department thought it owned. Every wolf in the state, named, located, priced. It says here, under a column marked *Disposition*, whether each could be *retained, relocated, or reduced.*”
“Reduced,” said Hana Lund, and put her hand over her father’s.
“There’s a note on the flyleaf.” Tess turned back. In the margin, in brown ink gone to rust, in a swift upright female hand, someone had written four lines down the edge of the paper, and then underlined them twice.
*Taken from the Commissioner’s desk, April 11, 1938, by M. Haugen. This is the paper he meant to use if the Handshake failed. I have bound it where it cannot be read, for it will be needed only by a man who thinks the Handshake has. Let no Lead read it for pleasure. Let no Warden read it for duty. Let the Fourteen read it once, in grief, and then not again.*
*The original is with the Roll. This is my fair copy. Weir does not know I made it.*
The kitchen had gone entirely silent.
“The original is with the Roll,” said Tess slowly. She read it aloud. She read it again. “Margit made a copy of the book she stole. The copy’s here. The original is under the stone.”
“Thirty-one inches,” said Wade, softly. He was not looking at her. He was looking at the table, at the white cloth, at the first page of a book in which his grandmother had been priced by the head. “Under the stone. That’s what rang.”
“There’s two,” Tess said. “The W book is a pair. Weir wants the one that’s here, but he’ll want the other, too, and he already knows where the stone is. He put a stake in the grass.”
“He doesn’t know what’s under it,” said Ansel, from the wall.
“No.” She closed the book. It was a small movement, and it took all of her strength. “But he’ll find out on the twenty-fourth, because I’ll be the one holding the shovel.”
---
It was the loose yellow sheet she read last, and she read it alone, at the window, with her back to the room, because the block capitals were Walt’s, and she wanted that one minute to herself.
*AUG 29. OPENED THE BACK BOARD AT G.’S TABLE. I AM A THIEF OF A LOCK AND I KNOW IT. G., IF YOU READ THIS, I AM SORRY. I NEEDED TO KNOW WHY.*
*SIX WARDENS DEAD BY FALLS SINCE 2019. I HAVE THE NAMES. THREE (BRANDT, 3; KOVACS, 6; ESTRADA, 11) I CALLED ON THE FIRST OF THE MONTH AS ALWAYS, AND EACH TOLD ME THE SAME THING IN THE LAST CALL: F. WEIR, DEPUTY IG, PHONED TO ASK ABOUT THE FOURTEEN FILE. ASKED IF THE WARDEN HAD A “SECOND BOOK.” ASKED WHERE THE “ROLL” WAS BURIED. THEN THEY FELL.*
*I AM THE FOURTH THEY WILL CALL FOR. I KNOW IT BECAUSE HE CALLED ME LAST WEEK AND SAID, “WALTER, THE NEW WARDEN IS ON HER WAY, AND I WOULD LIKE YOU TO KEEP THE SEASON QUIET.”*
*I SAID I WOULD.*
*SEPT 13 (ADDED LATER). HE CALLED AGAIN. 6:40 P.M. SAID: “STAY OFF 1411 TONIGHT.” I HAD NOT TOLD ANYONE I WAS GOING.*
Below that, in a heavier pencil, pressed in with a thumb:
*IF F.W. ASKS FOR W, SAY IT WAS BURNED. IT WAS NOT BURNED. THE COPY IS IN THE BOARD. THE ORIGINAL IS UNDER THE STONE. THE ONLY THING THAT HAS EVER STOOD BETWEEN HIM AND HIS PAPER IS A NUMBER THAT NO ONE ELSE CAN SAY.*
*T. OKAFOR: IF YOU ARE READING THIS I AM DEAD, AND I’M SORRY. SORRY I DIDN’T TELL YOU. SORRY I TOLD YOU TO COME. I LIED ABOUT THE GUTTERS.*
*DON’T BE ALONE WITH FRANKLIN WEIR.*
*SAY “FOURTEEN.”*
She did not realize she had slid down the wall until she was sitting on the cold floor with the sheet in her lap, and Birdie’s hand was on her shoulder.
“He knew you’d read it,” said Birdie.
“He knew I’d be *here*.”
“Yes.”
“He didn’t know my *name*. He wrote *T. Okafor* in August. I wasn’t hired until October.” She laughed, a dry, wounded, wondering sound. “Birdie, he wrote my name six weeks before the Department sent me. How?”
“Walt was always ahead of the paper,” said Birdie. She sat on the floor beside her, an old nurse on a kitchen floor with her satchel in her lap. “That’s all I know. He was a slow man with a fast mind. He might have heard it on the phone. Weir said it himself, you see: *the new Warden is on her way.* He’d already picked you.”
“Picked me?”
“Walt guessed,” said Birdie gently, “that you were chosen. I don’t think I’ll ever know why.”
---
At the end, there was the matter of the line.
It was nearly nine. The bowls had been cleared, the ledger put back in its green cover with the board stitched shut again, this time with black thread, by Birdie, with a small, rueful, careful hand. The W book, the fair copy, had been wrapped again in its oilcloth and put in the one place Greta said no one would think to look, and no one but Greta and Tess would ever know, and Tess had been told not to write it down.
Greta had opened the front of the ledger. She turned the page to the end, to the long column of signatures: A. Tarkington, H. Pruden, C. Wickersham, a long march of names down the years, and at the bottom, the last one, in block capitals, W. BANNERMAN, MARCH 1989. Below it, a clean white line.
She held out a pen.
“You don’t have to,” said Greta.
“I know.”
“The state’s end is yours or it isn’t. This is the *Closure’s* end. This is your name beside the pack’s. There’s no seat above it and no Department behind it, and when a man takes it back, he takes the whole book with him.” Greta’s hand was steady, but her breath had gone shallow. “It means that when the Fourteen falls, you fall. You’ll not be able to say you were only visiting.”
“I haven’t been visiting since the first morning.”
Tess took the pen. It was heavy, black, old, a fountain pen with a nib worn to a different angle by every Lead who had held it. She leaned over the ledger. She wrote her name, slowly, with the bleed on the second *a*, *T. A. Okafor*, and under it, because there was room, and because it was the only thing she could think of, she wrote a number.
*14.*
When she looked up, Greta was gazing at her with an expression Tess had never seen on that face.
“Isolde,” said Greta Haugen. “You’ve gotten so tall.”
Nobody moved.
“Mama?” said Greta. She said it in a voice from seventy years ago, high and surprised and small, with a seven-year-old’s lisp. She looked around the kitchen, at the stove, at the bowls, at the circle of faces. “Why is everyone so old? Where is Papa? Where’s the...” Her mouth worked. “I had a tooth. I had a tooth that came out. Why are you wearing a man’s coat?”
The pen slid from Tess’s fingers and clattered on the table.
“Greta.” She was on her feet, though she had not felt herself rise. She took the old woman’s hand in both of hers. It was cold and dry and light as a bundle of sticks. “Greta Haugen. Born in the Bench house on the third of April.
“Lead of the Fourteen, who has signed this book thirty-one times. Ansel is standing by the wall, and Birdie is beside you, and you’re in your own kitchen, and I’m Tess. Do you hear me? I’m Tess Okafor, and I remember you.”
For one second, nothing. For two, the old woman’s eyes were someone else’s. Then, softly, like a latch dropping, something in them clicked. The seven-year-old went out of her face, and Greta Haugen came back to it, stern and tired and appalled.
“Oh,” she said. “Oh, that was *unpleasant*.”
“How long?” said Ansel, from across the room, in a voice Tess did not know.
“Forty seconds,” said Birdie, who had been counting.
Greta looked at her own hand in Tess’s. She did not pull it away. “It has happened twice before,” she said. “In September. Once at the stove, once in bed. I told no one, because I thought, *it’s only age.*” She tried to laugh. “I should have known my mother’s forgetting had to come to me by some road.”
“It isn’t only age,” said Tess.
“No.” The old Lead looked at her, long and level. “No. I think it is a great deal closer than that. And I think, Warden, that you have just paid for it.” She tilted her head. “Your nose is bleeding.”
Tess touched her lip. Her fingertips came away bright red. She had not felt it start. A drop fell on the open ledger, on the last page, on the empty line beneath her own signature, and spread into the paper in a small dark circle, round as a coin, neat as a seal.
Nobody spoke. Behind her, in the doorway, for the first time that evening, someone laughed, one rough note, and it was Harlan Voyles, shaking his head, with the lamp still in his hand and tears running unashamedly down his long gray face.
“Well,” he said. “That’s the Warden’s mark, then. Nobody’s going to say she didn’t sign in blood.”
Greta did not blot it. She closed the ledger gently, with the stain inside, and laid both her hands on the green cloth, and said, in the voice of a Lead calling a Table to its feet, “It is done. The Warden of the Fourteen is on the book.”
Twenty-nine chairs scraped. The room rose. And outside, beyond the dark windows, from the pine ridge to the frozen creek, a long wave of wolf voices went up into the clear cold night, one by one, until it seemed to Tess that the whole Wolfwood had stood.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!