Margie Dunmore had set the table for two and then, being Margie, set it for four.
It was Tuesday morning, the twenty-second, a quarter to nine, and the Dunmore kitchen smelled of coffee and cinnamon toast and the cold lemon polish she used on everything. Gil had gone to work at six. A Larch County deputy sat in a cruiser at the end of the drive with the engine off.
Margie, seventy-one, small and straight in a blue cardigan, with white hair brushed back from a face Tess could read only by its voice, poured the coffee herself and would not be helped.
“I’ve been thinking about the barn since Friday,” she said. “I’ve thought about it for twenty-five years, and not one time out loud. I didn’t know it would be so heavy to carry across a kitchen.”
“You don’t have to tell me.”
“I do, though. That’s the trouble.” She sat down. “Gil said you’d bring Mr. Baptiste, and I said I’d rather it was just us two. I hope that’s not unkind.”
“It isn’t.”
Orrin Baptiste had come anyway. He sat in the corner of the kitchen with his hat on his knee and a cup he had not touched, and he had said, at the door, only, “I’ll sit where I’m no trouble.” Tess had let him. She did not yet know why she had.
Margie folded her hands. “It was the nineteenth of September, 2001. A Wednesday. I was forty-six. I’d gone to the Grange fish fry the Saturday before, and a man in a brown hat had sat down across from me and said my mother’s name. Not her married name. Her name, the one she had before. He knew where she was buried in Weiser, and the year, and what was on the stone.”
“Franklin Weir.”
“He didn’t say. He said he was with the state, and that there was an old matter of a family register, and that a small number of persons of my mother’s line were being asked to attend a signing.” She looked at her hands. “I said yes. I’m not proud of it. I’d lost my mother twenty years before and nobody had said her name to me in all that time.”
---
The barn had been an apple barn, on a dirt road outside a town she could not name now, in a dry hollow between two ridges, with a tin roof and a smell she knew at once when Tess described the Bench calving barn. Hay. Machine oil. Anise.
“Anise?” said Tess.
“Somebody had put it in the lamp oil. I’ve never smelled it since without being sick.” Margie’s voice was steady. “There were nine of us in nine chairs in a ring, and Mr. Weir besides, and a young man who took notes. And in the middle of the barn, on two sawhorses, a board.”
“What kind of board?”
“A plank, oak, four feet by two, and gray with age. There were holes in it, shallow, hand-shaped. Fourteen. I counted.” She looked up. “He said it was a copy of a very old thing. He called it the dry board. He said it was only for practice, so that when the real day came nobody would be afraid of the real lid.”
“And you put your hand in it.”
“We each did. In turn. He said the board would be warm, and it was. It wasn’t warm like wood. It was warm like a person’s hand.” She shuddered. “And you were to say a name, a neighbor’s, and then *yes.* Just that. *I consent to return.* He wrote it down.”
“Do you remember who stood next to you?”
Margie closed her eyes. “A woman with a cough, very thin, with a man’s winter coat on, a few years older than me. She said her name was Doreen. And on my other side was an old man with a shaking hand who said he was a stonemason.”
“A stonemason.”
“I thought it was a joke.” She opened her eyes. “I’ve remembered it all these years because it was the one thing in that barn that was ordinary.”
---
It was Orrin Baptiste who spoke next, and he did it without lifting his head.
“The old man was Frank Meline,” he said. “He died in 2007. He’d have been eighty-two.” He turned the hat on his knee, a slow quarter turn, as Tobias did. “I was in that ring, Warden. I was on Margie’s left. I never said so because I wasn’t sure she’d know me. I wasn’t sure she’d want to know me.”
Tess sat very still.
“You said yes,” said Margie quietly.
“I did, ma’am. Aloud. In the barn, with my hand in the hollow, and the board warm as a loaf.” Orrin raised his head, and his voice was low and level. “Mr. Weir told me it was a family reunion. I was fifty-six and I’d buried a wife, and I hadn’t had a family in fifty years. I’d have said yes to a ham sandwich and a hand to hold. I’d like to say that’s the whole of it. It isn’t.”
“What’s the rest?”
“I’m one of the nine he’s counting.” He met Tess’s eye, or the place where it would be. “I knew it Saturday, when your Wynne rang me at the motel in Elko, and said *Eleven.* I knew he’d have kept the list. I came anyway. I came because I thought, if there’s a way out of what I did in that barn, it’s in the place, in front of the Warden. And the gate opened for me.”
“It opens for all of Eleven,” said Tess.
“It opens for everyone who ever said yes and meant it as a kindness. That’s the thing about the old law, ma’am. It was written by people who knew what a lonely man will do for a name.”
---
She had Wynne bring the carbons at ten, in the Bronco, with the folder open on her knee, and they went through the thirty-eight names at the Dunmore kitchen table with Margie’s toast gone cold and Orrin’s finger moving down the line.
“I know six of the nine,” said Orrin. “Myself. Margie. Doreen Lisk. Anita Tull, who was forty-six and brought a husband’s photograph she kept turning over. Frank Meline, who’s dead.” He tapped a name on the third page. “And Rudy Cantrell.”
“Rudy’s here,” said Wynne.
“I know. I saw him come in Sunday afternoon, with a trucker’s cap, and I kept my own counsel.”
“Rudy drove from Billings,” said Wynne slowly. “He’d have been thirty. He said he’d never been west of Pocatello.”
“He’d have said that to you. He’d have said it to himself.” Orrin shook his head. “He was the youngest in the barn. He was in the corner with his hat in his hands, and when it came to his turn, he said *no.* Very quietly. And Mr. Weir smiled and said, *I’ll write it down as yes,* and Rudy went home and told himself that wasn’t true.”
Tess said, “Did he say it twice?”
“I don’t know.”
“Because it makes all the difference, Orrin. A no, said aloud, to a man who doesn’t have the right to hear it, may or may not count. If it was before no witness, it may not count at all.”
Wynne, who had been staring at the folder, said, “Tess. That’s six. He said nine.”
“Three I can’t place,” said Orrin. “I’d know their faces. I never knew their names.”
“Then three of the people on this list were in that barn and haven’t told us. Or they don’t know it counts.” Wynne lifted her head. “And one of the six is dead. Weir’s counting a man who died in 2007.”
“He’s counting what he can write down,” said Tess. “A dead man’s yes is just as good on paper.”
---
The Table did not take it well.
Tess told them at noon, in the kitchen, in the plainest voice she had, and watched the room go cold from the edges inward. Rudy Cantrell, fifty-five, six foot three, with a trucker’s cap in his two big hands, stood by the door with a face that Tess could not see and a body that she could.
It was the body of a man waiting for a blow he’d been owed for twenty-five years.
“I never said it,” said Rudy. “I said *no.* I said *no, sir.* I’ll swear to it. I swore to my wife on her deathbed.”
“You’ve been in this house since Sunday,” said Ines Wickersham. “You ate at this Table. You slept in the loft over the calves. You didn’t say one word.”
“I didn’t know it counted.”
“It counts,” said Odell Pruden dryly, “for the ones who weren’t asked.”
“Then put me out.” Rudy’s voice cracked. “I’ve got a truck in a lot in Pocatello, and I’ll walk. I’ll take my bag down the road. I’ll go and say my no to the first cop I see.”
“Sit down, Mr. Cantrell.” It was Birdie who said it, not loudly, standing at the head of the counter with a wooden spoon in her hand like a gavel. “You’ll do nothing of the kind. We took the salt from you Sunday. We put your name on the Guests page. It’s not a trade, and it’s not a test, and it isn’t taken back because a man tells us something hard.”
“Birdie,” said Ines. “A man who said yes in front of Weir.”
“A man who said no in front of Weir, and had it written down wrong.” Birdie did not raise her voice. “I would sooner be wrong about nine people than right about one.”
Nobody moved. Then, from the far end of the counter, in a clear, high, carrying voice, Hazel said, “Is somebody in trouble?”
Greta had her by the hand. “No,” said Greta, composedly. “They’re being honest. It’s very noisy when it happens.”
---
Tess found Tobias at one, on the north fence, in the snow.
He had borrowed a pair of Burt’s old gloves and a shovel and was clearing the drift from the bottom rail, slowly and methodically, with the steady, tireless motion of a man who had been walking and working for sixty years and saw no reason to change now. He did not turn round. She stood beside him, and she knew him by the shoulders, and the angle of the old green hat.
“I’ve been thinking about a barn,” said Tobias.
“I thought you might.”
“I went and found a room in the sawmill office with a stove in it, and I’ve sat there since last night with the cold and the hat. I’ve been trying to remember a thing Margit said.” He leaned on the shovel. “It wasn’t about the lid. It was about the practice of it. *Never rehearse a hand. A hand that’s been rehearsed has been told what to say.*”
“A dry board.”
“Margit would have burned it. She’d have called it a lie in oak.” He shook his head. “A hand that’s said yes to the dry board has said it to nobody. It’s not the lid. It’s just a hand that’s learned to say a word, and the word’s meant nothing to anyone until somebody found a way to make it.”
“Weir thinks it counts.”
“Weir thinks anything counts, that a document can be made to say.” Tobias looked at her for the first time, the pale blur of his face turned to hers. “But the Fourteen’s not paper, Tess. That’s the only thing I’m sure of. The Fourteen is a place, and a law, and fourteen people who say each other’s names. You can’t practice that.”
“Tobias.”
“Yes?”
“Anita.” She had not meant to say it. “Where is she?”
He did not answer for a long moment. Then he drove the shovel into the drift and said, “The Annex rang at six this morning. Hoyt had them call. Anita was moved at two a.m., with the other four, in a van. A holiday retreat.”
“Where?”
“The night girl, Kayla, didn’t know. But she saw the van’s sticker.” He turned away. “It had a little picture of an apple.”
Tess felt the skin tighten along her arms. *An apple barn,* said Margie’s voice in her head. *In a dry hollow between two ridges.*
She said, “I’ll find her.”
“I know you will,” said Tobias. “You do it with your hands in your pockets. I’ve been watching.”
Rudy found her in the mudroom before she left, with his cap crushed in both fists. He said he would stand wherever the Table told him, and he would say whatever he was asked, and he’d only ask to say it plainly, once, before anyone else spoke. Tess told him that was the only way anyone would believe him.
He nodded, and then he asked, quite humbly, whether she thought a no, said twenty-five years late, could still be a no. She said she hoped so. She said she would have to find out.
---
Joss caught her at the post, on the way back from the north fence, with his hands jammed in his coat pockets and his chin down in his collar.
He had grown, that autumn, three inches and a decade. He still stood sometimes like a boy who had been told to wait outside the principal’s office, but he spoke now with the careful bluntness of someone who had decided to stop apologizing.
“I want to stand in the ring,” he said. “On Thursday. Whatever it is.”
“You don’t know what it is.”
“I know it’s the same ring. I stood in it in October, and I said Harlan’s name, and the lid came up.” He looked at the snow. “It’s Lonnie’s bowl. Nobody else was ever going to sit with it, and somebody should.”
“Joss. If I go to that meadow and say no, there may be nobody left in it who remembers what they came for.”
“Then I’ll remember for you.” He said it quickly, as if the words might spoil. “You keep my face, don’t you? You said you’d never spend it. You said it on the porch, and my mother heard.”
“I did say that.”
“Then I’m the one you can’t lose.” He shrugged, the long loose shrug of seventeen. “So I’ll be there. It’s only fair.”
She could not answer him. She put her hand on his shoulder, and then, because it did not seem enough, put her arms round him, boots and snow and all, and he stood stiffly for a moment and then bent his head onto her shoulder, like a colt.
The afternoon went to Nora Feld and to the law, in the library, with the door shut.
Nora had driven up at three, in a wool coat and a pair of men’s boots, with a banker’s box of Idaho statutes and an expression of settled fury. She read the Declarations of Standing Return one after another with a pencil in her teeth, and when she had read them all, she put the pencil down and said, “These are legally incoherent, and that’s what makes them dangerous.”
“Why dangerous?”
“Because a court won’t enforce them and a Closure might.” She took off her glasses. “The Compact of 1938 is a state-law instrument that no one has ever seen the inside of, and nobody can say what a judge would do with it. The Department says it controls Closure law. You say the Closure controls itself.
“A Canyon County magistrate is going to sit tomorrow afternoon at two, look at Verna Pell’s guardianship letters, and decide whether to give a five-year-old to a company with a Placement Agreement.”
“And if we’ve got Connie’s sobriety, and Verna’s affidavit?”
“We’ve got a decent chance. If we’ve got nothing else.” Nora stood. “Here is what I’d like. A witness who can say, under oath, that the Family Program’s registry numbers its children in order of readiness for something that is not foster care. I need a second child.”
“I know where there are three.”
“Where?”
“I don’t know where yet,” said Tess. “But Verna Pell does. The boy in the green sweater had an address on his tag. She told me at lunch.” She reached for the green notebook. “It’s a house in Caldwell. Alder House. They call it a residential group home. It has a night aide, a license, and a clean inspection. And on the third of last month, it received a shipment of green sweaters.”
Nora stared at her. “How do you know that?”
“Because Wynne has seen the invoice,” said Tess. “She read it upside down on Pickering’s associate’s briefcase. She remembers the lines the way other people remember a song.”
“Then I’ll need a judge who’ll sign at night,” said Nora, and reached for her phone.
Ansel was waiting in the hall when Tess came out. He had a mug in each hand. He gave her one, with the handle turned, and said nothing, and walked beside her down the length of the passage and out onto the back step, where the snow had begun again, fine and dry and bright as flour.
“You’re going tonight,” he said.
“If Strand signs.”
“I’d like to be in the truck.”
“It’s a child-welfare entry. There’ll be a caseworker, a deputy, a sheriff.” She turned the mug in her hands. “There’s no room for a wolf.”
“There’s room for a man who can carry a seven-year-old,” said Ansel, “and not frighten her. I’ve been doing it all week with Greta.” He looked at the snow. “I’m good at being quiet.”
Tess drank. It was strong and black and too hot. She said, “All right.”
“All right?”
“Don’t make me say it twice,” said Tess.
Her phone buzzed against the mug before she had finished it. Nora: *Strand will sign tonight if Verna swears the affidavit by eight. Bring her.*
Tess read it twice. Then she looked out at the fine bright snow and thought of an apple painted on the side of a van, and of a board that was warm as a hand, and of how many of the people who had once said yes in a barn were, at that moment, asleep under her roof.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!