Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 63

Standing Consent

Burt brought Connie Ibarra up from the Larch bus stop at ten to two, in the old sheriff’s Bronco with the heater roaring, and the whole Bench found a reason to be somewhere else.

It was a small act of grace and nobody remarked on it. Josephine Aikens suddenly needed to look at the root cellar. The Stickney sisters went to the barn to help with the calves. Orrin Baptiste put his hat on and took his cane and walked out to the pipe gate, where he stood with his back to the house, in the cold, as though he had agreed to guard a door.

Tess waited on the porch with Gil. She had spent an hour at the kitchen table that morning trying to decide what she would say, and had thrown it all away.

The Bronco stopped at the foot of the steps. The woman who climbed out of the passenger side was thirty-four and looked fifty and had made an effort, with a clean gray sweater and a ponytail pulled so tight it lifted her eyebrows. She carried a paper grocery bag in both arms. When she stood, she stood very straight, and Tess knew the posture.

It was the stance of someone who has been told for two years that she is a risk and has decided not to flinch.

“Is she here?” said Connie.

“She’s in the kitchen,” said Gil. “Mrs. Ibarra, I’m the sheriff, and I have to tell you how this works. She’s in my protective hold until ten past midnight Thursday. I can’t release her to anyone. But I can let you sit in a room with her, with me in the doorway, for as long as you like.”

“I don’t need to hold her,” said Connie. Her voice cracked. “I just need to see.”

“Then come on in.”

---

Tess did not go into the kitchen. She stood on the porch with her hands in her pockets and heard it through the half-open door, the way a person hears music from another house.

There was a long silence. Then a small, wary voice said, “Mama?”

“Hi, baby.”

“Did you come on the bus?”

“I came on the bus. And a very nice man drove me in a truck with no seat belts.”

“Verna says that’s not safe.”

“Verna’s right.” A laugh broke in the middle and turned into something else. “I brought you something. It’s in the bag. It’s not a present, exactly, it’s just a thing.”

The rustle of paper. A pause. Then Hazel’s voice, serious and a little puzzled: “It’s a lunch box.”

“It was mine when I was little. It has a rainbow on it. It’s got a lock, see, and a little key.”

“Why does it have a lock?”

“Because it’s yours,” said Connie. “Nobody gets in it unless you let them.”

Tess found that she had turned her face to the wall. Beside her, Ansel said nothing at all, and she leaned against his shoulder for the length of a breath and then stood up straight again.

“Am I good?” said the small voice inside. “I did all of it. I stood at the post and I didn’t open the gate.”

“Oh, Hazel.” There was a scrape of a chair. “Baby, you were always good. You don’t have to do a thing. You never had to.”

---

They talked in the Bench library at four, with the stove lit and the door closed and a plate of cold chicken nobody touched.

It was a narrow room lined with bound ledgers and old almanacs, and the window looked out on the orchard where Ansel had buried three of the dead. Tess sat in Margit’s chair. Connie sat across from her on a footstool with her hands wrapped round a mug, and Wynne sat on the floor with her back to the shelves and the folder from Doreen’s steel box open on her knee. Gil stood at the door.

“I need to see what you signed,” said Tess.

“I don’t have the originals. They kept them.” Connie dug in the grocery bag and came up with a sheaf of folded paper, soft as cloth at the creases. “I kept the copies. I always keep copies. It’s the only thing they taught me in the program that’s any use.”

It was a single sheet, typed. Tess read it by the stove. It was headed DECLARATION OF STANDING RETURN, with the date, OCTOBER 19, and Connie’s name typed in capitals, and below it, four paragraphs of careful, dull language that she read once for sense and once for the words.

*The undersigned, being of the line of Closure Eleven, acknowledges the place of release and consents to return thereto upon lawful call. This consent extends to any minor in the undersigned’s care. It stands until revoked. Revocation shall be made in person, at the place of release, before the Warden of the Fourteen.*

At the bottom, a signature in blue ballpoint: *Consuelo A. Ibarra.* Beneath it, a line for a witness. The line was blank.

“Margie said the same thing,” said Wynne quietly. “At the Annex. Revocable only by going to the place.”

“It’s a form,” said Connie. “That’s what I thought. A form. They had them in a stack at the Family Day, with a pen on a chain, and a woman said it was a *reunion waiver.* She said it was so we could all be called to the reunion on the twenty-fourth and have our names on the list. I thought it was a holiday lunch.”

“Did you read it?”

“I read the part about the lunch.” She set the mug down. “I was thirteen months clean and I wanted a Christmas I could take my daughter to. I’d have signed a blood oath.”

---

It took Tess some time to see what the paper meant, and when she did, it was not a moment of triumph but a slow, cold drop, like a bucket going down a well.

“It’s not a trap for the gate,” she said. “It never was.”

“What?” said Wynne.

“Weir said everyone at the Annex was free to go. He wasn’t boasting, and he wasn’t lying. He doesn’t have to hold anybody. They’ve already said yes. A yes that stands until revoked, and revoked only in person, in the place, in front of me.” She set the paper on her knee. “He doesn’t need the thirty-eight in a van. He needs them in the ring on the twenty-fourth.

“Some of them to say yes aloud. And the rest of them, if they want out, have to come.”

“Come to the meadow,” said Gil from the door.

“Come to the meadow, and say *no,* in front of a Warden.” Tess stared at the stove. “That’s the hinge. That’s what Margit built. The witness doesn’t only stand for a yes. She stands for a no. If a hand says no to the Warden’s face, with the Warden’s eyes open, the consent is gone. It’s the only way out, and it’s the only way in.”

“Then you could just not stand,” said Connie.

“Then no one gets out. Every standing consent on every one of these forms stays standing, forever, and any Warden Weir finds or makes can stand for them.” She looked at the woman on the footstool. “He’s not trying to take me. He’s trying to make me the only door.”

Nobody spoke. In the window, the orchard stood black and bare against a sky going yellow.

“I can’t take it back from here,” said Connie, very slowly. “Not on the phone. Not by letter.”

“No.”

“And if I come to the meadow on Thursday and say no to your face, I’m out.”

“If you say it before the Fourteen, with me standing.”

“And Hazel?”

“Hazel can’t consent, and you couldn’t consent for her. The guardian is Mrs. Pell. Mrs. Pell’s signature is on a permission slip that someone made into a different thing.” Tess paused. “But Greta says the hand speaks for itself. A hand that was signed for isn’t a hand that was asked.”

Wynne, from the floor, said suddenly, “Tess. The witness line.”

“What about it?”

“It’s blank. It’s blank on hers. I’ve got the thirty-eight copies Rojas took from the steel box, and I’ve been reading them since Saturday, and I never looked at the bottom.” She turned the folder around. “It’s blank on every one.”

---

They went through them at the library table until seven, the four of them and Gil, in a ring of lamplight.

Thirty-eight carbon copies, each one typed on the same machine. Thirty-eight blank witness lines. Under every line, in the same small gray type, a single phrase that Tess had passed over on Saturday and which now looked like a signpost: *Witness to be entered at the place.*

“They’re incomplete,” said Gil slowly. “As a document. A lawyer would say there’s no consent until the witness signs.”

“Nora would say that,” said Tess. “But a lawyer’s not what Margit was writing for.”

“Then who?”

“Whoever stands at the lid.” She pressed her fingertips to her eyes. “If I’m standing there, and I put my name on a line, then it’s witnessed. If I’m not, it isn’t. And if somebody else puts a name there, in my place, in a ring, in front of fourteen, then the old law may not know the difference.”

“Weir said that,” said Wynne. “To Doreen. *A Warden can be made.*”

“Tobias said it. In the tack room.” Tess let her hand fall. “The Department’s been making them since 1938.”

Gil said, in a low, uneasy voice, “You’d better have someone with you, Tess. Not just Ansel. A lawyer. And a witness of your own.”

“I’ll have both.” She drew a breath. “I’ll also need the Table.”

---

Greta found her in the library hall at ten past seven, a small barefoot figure in the gray cardigan, with a wooden spoon in one hand like a scepter.

“I have to tell you something about Hand One,” she said. “I remembered it in the bath. Birdie says it was a very long bath.”

Tess sat down on the bottom stair so that her face was level with the child’s. “Tell me.”

“You have to ask her three times.” Greta frowned with enormous concentration. “Gran said asking once is a trap, because anybody will say yes to be nice. You ask once, and she says yes. You ask the second time, and she thinks. You ask the third time, and she says what she means. That’s the one that counts.”

“Three times.”

“And you can’t ask the same way. You have to ask it a different way every time, so she can’t just say the same thing again.” The spoon wavered. “Gran asked me in the kitchen, and in the meadow. I said yes, and then I said *go.* The yard was in the middle.” She frowned. “Somebody asked me in the yard. It wasn’t Gran. I can’t see who.”

“Who asks?”

“The Warden. Or the Lead. Somebody who loves her and isn’t going to lie.” Greta looked at her squarely. “Is that you?”

“I don’t know yet.”

“Well,” said Greta, “you’d better get good at it,” and she tapped Tess smartly on the knee with the spoon, and went back to the kitchen, where somebody had begun, loudly and wrongly, to sing.

Tess sat on the stair a long time with her notebook in her lap. Then she wrote, in the plain hand, *Ask three times, three ways.* And under it, because it seemed a fair thing to put down: *Who asked the second time, in 1962?*

The Table met in the kitchen at half past eight, because the calving barn had been turned into dormitory space and there was nowhere else with a stove. It was not a formal sitting. Twenty-eight bowls stood on the long counter in a ragged line, and people ate standing, and argued with their mouths full.

Ines Wickersham, who had voted against the walk-in and had not forgiven anyone for the result, stood at the end by the sink with her arms folded.

“I’ll say it plain,” said Ines. “We have seventy-one people in this house who are not of the Bench. We’ve got a sheriff’s child in the back bedroom and a state commission that’s been pulled and a federal order sitting in Pickering’s pocket. Send them home. Send them all home before the twenty-fourth, by bus, in the dark, and let the Department sort out what it does with a lot of old people who’ve gone back to their own beds.”

“And they’ll be fetched on Christmas Eve by a lady in a van,” said Birdie evenly, “from their own beds.”

“Then they’ll be fetched, and it won’t be our doing.”

“Ines.” It was Odell Pruden, eighty-one, who rarely spoke at the Table and was heard in total silence when he did. “I walked the Long Meadow the day Eleven went out. I was seventeen, old enough to know better and young enough to be told it was none of mine. I stood on that road and watched the hay truck go, and I thought it was none of mine. I’ve had sixty-four years to think what that cost.” He put down his cup.

“I won’t say we should stand them all in a ring. I say we don’t send a soul out of this gate before the twenty-fourth, and I say any one of them who wants to say no, says it on the meadow. That’s what the law is for.”

It went to a show of hands, which was not a vote, because it could not be, and which carried by nineteen to six. Ines Wickersham stood at the sink and watched it with her mouth set. She did not raise her hand. But she did not leave, either.

Greta, who had come in from the back with Hazel on her hip, sat the child down at the end of the counter with a plate of crackers and a very solemn explanation of the bowls. Hazel listened. She touched one with a finger, the white stoneware, and said, “That one’s got a chip.”

“That’s Dorrie’s,” said Greta. “She dropped it in 1991.”

“Why?”

“She was cross.”

“Oh,” said Hazel, and Tess, across the room, found her hand pressed hard to her mouth.

After supper Connie asked, shyly, whether she might wash the plates. Birdie handed her an apron without a word. Tess watched from the doorway while the thin woman with the hard ponytail stood at the sink, her sleeves pushed up, scrubbing a stoneware bowl with a competence that came from years of kitchens she had not owned, and Hazel stood on a stool beside her drying each plate with exaggerated care and putting it on the wrong shelf. Nobody corrected her.

---

It was twenty to ten when the phone rang in her pocket.

She took it out onto the back step, in the cold, with Ansel leaving the door a hand’s width open behind her. The number was blocked. She let it ring four times and answered on the fifth.

“Warden Okafor.” The voice was dry, courteous, unhurried, and she knew it before he gave his name. “I hope I’m not disturbing a meal.”

“Mr. Weir.”

“I’ll be brief, since you have a houseful. I understand you’ve met Mrs. Pell. A conscientious woman. I’m told she forgot to leave her Placement Agreement in the kitchen drawer.”

Tess said nothing.

“I’m not angry. I’d have done the same.” He cleared his throat. “I want to make you an offer, and I want to make it plainly, since you’ve shown me you prefer plain. If you stand witness on the twenty-fourth at noon, in the place, in front of the ring, I will withdraw Wednesday’s order and the Family Program’s claim on Hazel Ibarra. She will stay with her mother.

“I will see to Mrs. Pell’s housing. Carys Okonkwo-Reyes’s custody case will be closed, in her favor, on the day after. And no one on your Bench will be fetched by anyone. That’s a fair price for an hour of your time.”

“What happens in the hour?”

“A Closure is re-closed. That is all. The law of 1938 provides that a closed Closure has a Lead of record, who is named by the Department. In law, the people of Eleven are returned to the status of the original release. Class R, if you’ve read the ledger. Retained.” He said it as gently as a physician naming a condition. “It will make no difference to anyone’s life.

“They will be cared for. They will be *studied,* carefully, with consent. It is the only way the Forgetting can be reached.”

“They’ll be priced.”

“They will be *valued,*” said Weir. “I take considerable trouble to value them highly.”

“Mr. Weir,” said Tess, “I’d like to know how many hands you’ve got.”

There was a pause on the line. For the first time, she thought she heard him smile.

“There are fourteen hollows in the lid, Warden. You know that. You’ve stood in the ring. Thirty-eight was never the number, any more than twenty-nine was the number of bowls. Thirty-eight is the pool.” The dry voice went on, quite gently. “I need fourteen hands to say it aloud. A child first, as Margit wrote. Then thirteen more.”

“You’ve got one child.”

“I have one child and nine who have already said yes. Not on paper. Aloud, to me, in my own hearing.” He let it settle. “I’ll leave you to wonder which of them are in your kitchen.”

The line went dead.

Tess stood on the back step for a long time with the phone in her hand. Behind her, through the door, the sound of seventy-one people eating soup came muffled and warm, a hundred separate voices she had not yet learned to hold, and she did not turn around.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!