Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 66

Courtroom Two

The Canyon County Courthouse in Caldwell had a metal detector, a wreath on the front doors, and a bailiff who had plainly been told not to let anyone from Larch County bring in so much as a hair clip.

Tess went through with her notebook, a pen, and her father’s old watch. The detector sang over the watch. The bailiff, a heavy man with a gray mustache, turned it over in his palm, read the back, and said, “Okafor Pharmacy,” out loud, as if it were a hymn number.

“My father’s,” said Tess.

“Mine had one like it,” said the bailiff, and gave it back. “Courtroom Two. Don’t sit behind the Pell lady. She’s been crying since noon and the judge hates a noise.”

It was one fifty-one on Wednesday, the twenty-third of December, and the hallway outside Courtroom Two smelled of floor wax, wet wool and the burnt coffee of a long week. Through the tall windows the sky over the Treasure Valley hung low and white. The weather service had promised snow by evening.

Nora Feld stood by the water fountain in a charcoal suit with a leather folder against her chest. She had slept, by the look of her, about as much as Tess had.

“Camarena,” she said, by way of greeting. “Magistrate Luz Camarena. Twenty years on the juvenile bench, two grown sons, and a reputation for reading every page of the file before she walks in. Pickering hates her.”

“Is that good?”

“It’s the best thing I know about her.” Nora’s mouth twitched. “Connie’s inside with Birdie. She wore the only dress she owns. Hazel’s with Odum in the side room. The other three are in the car with Ansel and Hoyt, and I’d be obliged if nobody said the word ‘registry’ in front of a child.”

“I haven’t said anything.”

“You’re about to,” said Nora. “You get a look.”

---

Courtroom Two held perhaps sixty people, and fifty-odd of them had come for something else.

The Wednesday docket was, Tess learned from the clerk, the Christmas docket: custody swaps, a tangle about a Labrador, a man in a Santa hat who had misunderstood a restraining order. They sat through two of those. In the second row, Verna Pell sat very straight in her camel coat with her handbag on her knees and a folded handkerchief in her fist, and when Tess slid into the bench behind her, she did not turn around.

“I wrote it all out last night,” Verna said, to the air in front of her. “On lined paper. I couldn’t sleep. Do you know, I haven’t written an apology in my own hand since I was a girl at St. Luke’s. I put the date at the top.”

“It will be all right.”

“It will be correct,” said Verna. “That is not quite the same thing, but I’ll settle.”

On the other side of the aisle sat Pickering. He wore the gray overcoat. He had brought his young associate, a pink and anxious man named Beecham, and between them, in a navy suit with a silk scarf, sat Teodora Marr with her hands folded in her lap and her soft gray bob combed as flat as a cap. She smiled across at Verna with infinite forgiveness.

It was the smile that made Tess’s neck prickle. She wrote in her notebook, *M. smiling = she has not lost anything yet.*

---

“In the matter of Ibarra, Hazel Marie,” said the clerk, at five past two. “Petition to terminate guardianship and for temporary placement. And the related child-protection matter.”

Magistrate Camarena was a short, square woman of fifty-five with a gray streak in her black hair and reading glasses on a beaded chain. She had a stack of paper at her elbow as thick as a loaf, and she had tabbed it in three colors of flag, the way some people tab a Bible. She read from it, without hurry, for nearly two minutes, and nobody coughed.

“I have the guardian’s petition,” she said at last. “I have the placement agreement. I have the sworn statement of Mrs. Verna Pell, which I will say, Mrs. Pell, is the most orderly document I have received from a petitioner in my career, and I include attorneys. I have the report of the Child Protection caseworker, Ms. Odum. I have a motion from the Family Program, through counsel, to dismiss and to vacate yesterday’s order. Mr. Pickering?”

Pickering rose, buttoning his coat.

He spoke for six minutes and was, Tess had to admit, very good. The Program, he said, was a nonprofit placement agency serving the most difficult cases in three states. It had held Hazel Ibarra in a loving setting for twenty-five months. A guardian who now sought to withdraw, in an emotional state, on the strength of an incident at a private ranch in another county, ought to be gently counseled, not indulged.

The child had been removed from a licensed setting by persons with no standing. He noted, with regret, the presence in the courtroom of a woman whose state commission was under suspension.

“Counsel is referring to Ms. Okafor,” said the magistrate, without looking up.

“I am, Your Honor.”

“She’s sitting in the gallery. She isn’t a party. She hasn’t said a word. Do you plan to object to her breathing?”

A small sound ran through the room, and died. Pickering sat down.

---

Nora called Verna first.

Verna Pell walked to the stand like a woman crossing an icy parking lot, and read her statement aloud in the voice that had taught eight hundred children to form a capital letter. She had signed a blank slip at an event in October. She had not read the paragraph beneath it, because it was a nice office, and a nice young man had held her coat.

She had been told, in November two years ago, that the child’s mother was unfit and the placement would be temporary. She had been paid four hundred and ten dollars on the fifth of every month.

“Why did you take the money, Mrs. Pell?” said Nora.

“Because the rent on Locust Street was nine hundred and I am sixty-eight,” said Verna. “And because I wanted very much for someone to tell me that I was needed. I believe now that was the whole of the arrangement. I was paid to be grateful.”

Beecham, at the other table, wrote furiously.

On cross, Pickering was courteous and pitiless. Had she not, in fact, signed the placement agreement herself? She had. Had she not described the Program, in her own letter of November, as “a godsend”? She had. Was it not true that she had formed a strong and, forgive him, rather romantic attachment to a group of strangers on a ranch since Sunday?

“I have been fed soup by a woman named Birdie who has never asked me for a thing,” said Verna. “That is the first time in two years, Mr. Pickering, and I find it informative.”

The magistrate’s mouth moved a fraction. She wrote something down, and then she took off her glasses and let them hang on their beaded chain.

“Mrs. Pell, one question of my own. Did the child ever ask for her mother?”

Verna’s hands, which had been steady all afternoon, found each other in her lap.

“Every Sunday evening, Your Honor, at six, after the visit. She would stand at the window in her good dress and ask whether it was Sunday yet. I told her to practice her letters instead.” She drew a breath. “I was very proud of her capital H. I taught her to make it so neatly that no one would guess what she had been thinking while she made it.”

Nobody in Courtroom Two looked at anybody else. At the front table Pickering turned a page that did not need turning.

---

Odum was brief and exact, like a woman with a bus to catch.

She described the Alder House entry: the hour, the shoes lined up by the door, the packed bags, the instruction to leave at four. She had walked through the house with a flashlight and a clipboard. She had found, in the playroom, a pine board with fourteen hollows, which was in the trunk of her county car, sealed, and which she had not opened.

“A game,” said Pickering, rising. “A toy, Your Honor. Educational.”

“What does it teach?” said the magistrate.

Pickering hesitated, a half second. “Cooperation, I believe.”

“I’d like to hear Ms. Marr on that,” said Camarena. “Ms. Marr, you may be sworn.”

Marr stood, smoothed her scarf, and took the oath with her right hand pressed over her heart. She was, Tess thought, remarkable. She never raised her voice. She said “dear” twice to the court reporter. She explained that the program numbered its cohorts for purposes of grant reporting, that Registry One through Six were simply the first six children to enter a particular care model, and that the board was a hand-print memory game used in group therapy.

“Six,” said Nora, standing. “Who holds Registry Five?”

“I couldn’t say. That would be a confidential case record.”

“Registry Six?”

“The same.”

“Are they children, Ms. Marr?”

“They are persons of the line,” said Marr, and then, very slightly, her chin lifted. She had heard herself. The courtroom had heard it too. “I’m sorry. A technical phrase, in the program’s materials. I meant they are clients.”

“Your Honor,” said Nora, and then, with a glance at Tess, she sat down. “No further questions.”

---

The magistrate took twelve minutes. She went into chambers with her stack of paper and came back in her robe with a single sheet, and she read it standing.

Mrs. Verna Pell’s petition to be relieved as guardian was granted, with the court’s thanks for her candor. The court found the placement agreement voidable for want of informed consent. The Family Program’s motion to dismiss was denied. Its interim placement authority was vacated.

On the question of Hazel Marie Ibarra, the court found that her mother, Consuelo Ibarra, had completed thirteen months of verified sobriety, held employment, and had appeared on three Sundays to see her daughter in a program room with a camera. The court granted temporary guardianship to Ms. Ibarra, on conditions: weekly visits from Canyon County Child Protection, a verified residence, and no contact between the child and the Family Program or its agents pending the hearing on Wednesday the thirtieth.

“A verified residence,” said Camarena, looking over her glasses at Connie, who sat bolt upright between Birdie and a bag of Hazel’s things. “Ms. Ibarra, do you have one?”

Connie rose. Her voice shook. “I have a room with a hot plate in Caldwell, Your Honor. And I have, until the thirty-first, a bunk at a place called the Bench, in Larch County, where I’m told there’s a woman who makes soup.”

“Ms. Haugen?”

“That’s me,” said Birdie, standing without being asked, in her good flannel. “She’s welcome till the cows come home.”

“Verified,” said the magistrate. “For the three children in Child Protection’s custody, the seventy-two hour hold continues to its term, which is twelve-oh-one on Saturday morning. They will remain in the licensed foster placement in Larch County on Ms. Odum’s recommendation, with the consent of that county, and Mr. Pickering’s program will have no access.”

“Your Honor, we will seek a stay,” said Pickering. “We will appeal. We will go to the Supreme Court.”

“Go,” said Camarena. “I’d like to see you find a justice on Christmas Eve.”

---

It was done, and done so cleanly that Tess, in the second row, found she had pressed her pen through her notebook and torn the page.

Connie Ibarra turned. She looked across the room, past the lawyers and the bailiff, to the side door where Odum stood with a small girl in a red coat, who had one mitten on and one in her hand. Hazel looked at her mother. Then she looked at the floor, at the room, at all the grown-ups, and then she ran, the whole width of the courtroom, in her dress shoes, with her mitten flying on its string.

Nobody stopped her. The bailiff turned and looked hard out the window.

In the corridor, Verna wept in earnest, not delicately, with her face in the handkerchief. Hoyt held her by the elbow. Nora said the word *Christmas* four times, and sat down on a bench with her shoes off.

“We won,” said Birdie.

“We won a Wednesday,” said Tess. “I’d like to see what the Thursday costs.”

Ansel had come up from the car. He stood at the end of the corridor with snow on his shoulders, though the snow had only just begun, and looked at her with that steady, tired look that meant he had smelled the whole afternoon on her and could not decide which part to ask about.

“The three are safe,” he said. “Tamsin wants to know if she can see the judge. She says she’d like to thank her.”

“Not today.”

“I said that.” He looked at Hazel, on her mother’s hip, with her head under Connie’s chin and her eyes closed. “She won’t let go of the mitten, even asleep.”

---

The Bronco was parked at the back of the lot, under a leafless elm, with its engine running and the heater roaring.

Tamsin sat in the middle of the back seat with her plait over her shoulder and her notebook shut on her knee. Mica, beside her, was working a loose tooth with her tongue and holding a teddy bear by one arm. Ned sat against the far door in the green sweater, looking out at the snow as if it were a lesson he meant to learn by heart. Hoyt sat in front, turned halfway round, pretending to look for something in her bag.

Tess opened the rear door and crouched in the gap, out of the wind.

“The judge said you can stay in Larch County until Saturday,” she said. “After that we’ll know more. I won’t promise what I don’t know.”

“Is Hazel’s mom going to keep her?” said Tamsin.

“For now. Yes.”

“That’s good.” The girl nodded, as if checking a figure. “That’s what it’s supposed to be like. When it works. I read about it in a book Ms. Marr gave us, and she said it was a thing that happens to other kids.” She looked at Tess. “Warden. Can I ask you something? Not in front of them.”

“Ask it in front of whoever you like.”

“Is a thing still a yes, if you only said it because you practiced?”

Mica stopped working her tooth. Ned did not turn from the window, but his shoulders went quite still.

Tess kept her voice level. It was the voice she used for dogs and drunks and the dying. “Why do you ask?”

“No reason,” said Tamsin, and looked at her notebook, and said it again, fast and flat, so that it would not be a question. “No reason. Just a thing I’ve been thinking about.”

Ansel, at the wheel, did not look round. But Tess saw his knuckles move on the leather.

“We’ll talk tonight,” she said. “At the Bench, by the stove. Everybody gets to be warm first.”

“Okay,” said Tamsin, and shut her mouth over whatever else had been in it, the way a drawer is shut by a child who has hidden something in it and is not yet ready to be asked.

---

They were nearly out the door when the trooper found her.

He was a tall young man in a campaign hat and a heavy tan jacket, with a clipboard and a face that did not like what it had been sent to do. He asked for Ms. Okafor. He said he was Sergeant Ede, of the Idaho State Police, Region Three. He held out a manila envelope.

“It’s a request for an interview, ma’am. It’s voluntary. It concerns a complaint of false personation of a public officer, arising out of a presence at a residential facility last night.”

“I was on a public sidewalk.”

“Yes, ma’am. So I understand.” The trooper’s ears went red. He looked at the envelope in his own hand as if it might have an opinion. “It’s set for nine tomorrow morning, in Meridian. I’m told it can’t be moved. The complaint came from a lawyer, and I’m required to log that I asked.”

“Tomorrow,” said Tess. “Christmas Eve.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“At nine,” said Tess. “With noon the same day, in a meadow two hours from there.”

“Ma’am, I wouldn’t know about any meadow.”

“No. I’m sure you wouldn’t.” She took the envelope. “Thank you, Sergeant. I’ll note the date.”

Behind her, at the courthouse doors, Pickering buttoned his gray overcoat against the weather. He did not look at her. He looked at his watch, then at the dark swelling sky, and then with a small, regretful tilt of the head, at the child asleep on Connie Ibarra’s shoulder.

“Dark by half past four,” he said, to nobody in particular. “People forget how early it comes.”

He went down the steps. The snow had thickened. It came down slow and big-flaked over the Christmas lights on the lawn and the plastic Santa on the corner, and on the black umbrella that Marr, waiting at the curb, held open for him like a woman who had known all along how the hearing would end, and had not minded in the least.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!