I answer Peter in the only way that has ever worked.
Yes. I heard it. All three notes of the alarm, the kettle, the spoon. Call me.
He picks up before the first ring finishes. I can hear a room behind him, a bigger room than mine, with the flat hum of a hotel heating system and the squeak of a man sitting up too fast on a mattress that isn’t his.
“Tell me what you see,” he says. No hello. We have both been awake in this particular emergency before.
“A dress in a bag. Shoes lined up under it. A glass on the sill with nothing in it. The alarm says seven and it has just rung at six twelve.” I’m sitting on the edge of the narrow bed with my bare feet on cold boards. “The bouquet is gone. Ezra bought it at the corner shop last night. Past tense. It was there at eleven fifty-eight.”
“Same,” says Peter. “I had a toy dinosaur on the desk in the hotel. Plastic, green. The one from the paper bag. It’s gone. My shirt is back on the chair. The blue one.”
“Where are you? What floor?”
“Seventh. Top.” He stops. “There is nothing above me. It’s the roof, Hazel. And something fell upstairs at six twelve, and rolled, and stopped.”
I close my eyes. For eleven mornings I woke into a hallway silence that had no spoon in it, and I had begun to believe I was cured, which is a ridiculous word to use about a noise. Now the noise is back and it has followed him to a hotel with no upstairs.
“All right,” I say. “All right. Here is what I’m going to do, and I’d like you to tell me if any of it is a problem. I’m going to get dressed. In about twenty minutes Ezra is going to knock on my door with two coffees.”
“How do you know that?”
“Because he did, yesterday. He’s early. He says he’s on a flight case schedule.”
Silence on the line, then something that is not quite a laugh. “You’re telling me the day is the same day.”
“I’m telling you the first hour is. I don’t know about the rest.” I hear my own voice, flat and quick, the voice I used in the first forty cycles, and I make it slow down. “Peter. I’m frightened. I want to say that first because I’ve learned that if I don’t, I do the other thing, where I sound like a briefing.”
“I’m frightened too.”
“Good. That’s the correct reason.” It’s Ezra’s line from yesterday. I hear myself borrow it and let it stand. “Will you meet me at the diner on Ludlow at seven fifteen? Not for a plan. For a breakfast. I need to look at you across a table and not be alone with this.”
“Yes.”
“And Peter? I won’t use any of it on you. The day. What I know about how you’ll act.”
“I won’t use it on you either,” he says. “I did say we’d agreed on that, didn’t I? Back at the beginning of the other thing.”
“You did. I’m saying it again because words are the only thing we get to keep.”
There’s a pause. “Eat something first,” he says, which is what he texted me a month ago to say yes to telling Ezra, and it lands in me like a hand on the back of the neck, warm and absolutely inconvenient.
I put the phone down. I dress. I do not put on the gala dress, because it’s not the gala yet, and because I would like to see how long I can go without pretending that I know what’s coming.
The kettle in the hall clicks again at six thirty, as it would. I don’t touch it. I stand at the window and watch the gray block of Ludlow Street go from slate to pewter, and at six forty-one there are feet on the stairs. Heavy, uneven, someone carrying two things and a bag.
The knock is three taps, a pause, and a fourth.
He’s on my doorstep with two coffees and a bruise of sleeplessness under each eye.
“Black,” says Ezra, and hands me mine. “I was told to arrive after Friday midnight and before you had a plan. I think I’ve split the difference.”
I know every syllable. I know the pitch of the second sentence. I know that he’s going to say *I’m on a flight case schedule* in about four seconds and I know that nothing I say now will keep my face from doing whatever it does.
“You’re early,” I say.
“I’m on a flight case schedule. Everything is early or a disaster.”
He sees it, then. He’s a lighting designer; he spends his life watching how a face changes when you move a lamp six inches. He tilts his head.
“Hazel.”
“Come in. Please. I need to tell you something and I’d like to do it with the door shut.”
He comes in. He sets his bag down beside the radiator and doesn’t sit, because the only chair is the one with my clothes on it and he’s a person who asks before moving things. He stands in the sloped light under the ceiling with his coffee and waits.
I tell him in the plain order, the way we practiced on a flight case in a backstage corridor three weeks ago. I say: it’s Saturday. It’s the gala day. It was the gala day yesterday as well. I lived yesterday; you lived yesterday; at midnight I slept, and at six twelve this morning the brass alarm rang and the spoon fell and the day was this day again.
I say that you don’t remember it, and that I didn’t expect you to, and that I’m not asking you to take it on faith. I say you came to the door yesterday with those same two cups, and that you said those same words, and I knew every one of them.
Ezra listens. He listens the way he does with his whole shoulders, as if the sentence is a load he’s helping to carry across a floor.
“Say the part you haven’t said,” he says.
“The part I haven’t said is that I don’t know why.
“In the first loop I knew the rule. I told a lie and it reset. We stopped lying and it stopped. This time I have no rule. I haven’t said anything false since five o’clock yesterday evening that I know of. I didn’t say anything false after the gala. I made a point of it.” I look at the coffee. “It might be a new thing. It might be the same thing wearing a different coat. It might be a glitch.”
“A glitch.”
“It’s the most comforting word I’ve got.”
He puts his cup on the sill, next to the empty glass where his bouquet used to be.
“Okay,” he says. “Then here’s mine. I have a flight at four tomorrow afternoon, and a contract I signed in front of three people and a notary’s stamp, and an arrangement with a woman who has never once asked me to stay. I’d like to ask you something I’ve never asked, so I want you to be very exact. If tomorrow doesn’t come, what does that cost you?”
“It costs me everything I planned to do on Sunday.”
“And it costs me my flight.”
“Yes.”
“And if it comes anyway?”
“Then it comes, and you go, and I’m very proud of you, and I miss you.” I’m crying, a little, at the wrong moment, which is how I do it now. “I’m not asking you to stay for a loop. I’m telling you what’s true.”
“You said it plain,” says Ezra, and holds out his arms, and I step into them, and a neighbor’s door clicks open on the landing and, reflexively, politely closes.
“We’ll have breakfast,” he says into my hair. “You’ll tell me what to say when I’m supposed to be surprised. I’m a terrible actor.”
“You’re an excellent actor. You’re a terrible liar.”
“Same thing, at my age.”
I don’t ask him to prove he believes me. He doesn’t ask me to prove I’m telling it. That’s the whole of the miracle, and I’m aware that it’s a small one.
The diner on Ludlow has six stools and nine booths and a waitress whose name tag says RENEE in the handwriting of someone who gave up on the apostrophe. Peter is in the back corner booth under a mounted fish, in the blue shirt, with two untouched coffees in front of him and a toy dinosaur I don’t see because it isn’t there.
He stands when he sees us come in. He’s wearing the particular face of a man who does not know whether to shake a hand or give a hug, and who has therefore decided to do neither.
“Ezra,” he says.
“Peter.”
“You don’t remember anything.”
“I’m told I’ll be very bad at pretending to.”
“I didn’t know that,” says Peter, and for the first time that morning a corner of his mouth moves, “but I’m not surprised.”
We sit. Renee brings menus. I order eggs. I eat them, because I was told to and because I am a person who has learned, over fifty-odd Saturdays, that a body that is eating can think about one thing at a time.
“What do we know?” says Peter. He’s drawn a table on a napkin, because the napkins are paper and the pen is mine and everything on it will be gone at six twelve. He knows that. He does it anyway. “One. The anchor is the same. Alarm, kettle, spoon. Two. Objects reset, as before. Three. We’ve both woken knowing it. Four. There’s nobody else. I checked.”
“You checked?”
“I texted my sister at six thirty. Something small. She answered as if it were a normal Saturday.”
“Did you tell her anything?”
“Not a word. We agreed one person, one conversation, with permission.” He turns the napkin. “Five. I have no idea what the rule is.”
“Neither do I.”
“The old rule was a lie.”
“And I haven’t told one,” I say.
“Nor I.”
“Unless we have and don’t know it.”
“A sincere mistake didn’t count,” says Peter.
“No. It didn’t.”
Ezra, who has been eating toast with the air of a man watching a very quiet fight, puts down his knife.
“Can I say something that isn’t helpful?”
“Please,” we say, together, and glance at each other, mildly appalled.
“It’s day one,” he says. “For me, I mean. I know it isn’t for you. But in a day or two, one of you is going to want to try something dramatic, because trying something dramatic is easier than waiting for something to explain itself. You’re going to want to lie on purpose, or sit in the middle of the lake, or tell someone everything just to see if the world blinks. I’m saying: say it plain first. To each other. Before you try the thing.”
Peter looks at me.
“I’d like to rule out the lie,” I say. “Not by lying. By being scrupulous. We spend today saying nothing we don’t mean. If it still resets at midnight, we’ve learned the lie isn’t the trigger.”
“And if it doesn’t reset?” says Ezra.
“Then I’m going to cry in the diner and Renee will bring me pie.”
“That’s an excellent outcome,” says Peter.
“It’s a very good diner.”
We shake hands on it across the table, the three of us, awkwardly, like three people who’ve agreed to carry a piano.
The day proceeds. It doesn’t want to be told anything different.
At nine I go to the Listening Room and the pipe knocks in the wall where it knocked yesterday. Win is at the long table with her glasses on their cord and a stack of catalogue sheets, and says “You look like you haven’t slept,” and I say “I haven’t, quite,” and that is true.
Jonah comes in with his thermos and the hole in his sweater. He says the tomato man deserves the nurse. It is the same sentence, with the same innocence. I hear myself laugh in the same place.
Here is the first thing I learn about a day I’ve already lived: it’s a lot less like a script than I expected. Jonah says the nurse line, but he says it to the desk instead of to me, and he adds a clause I don’t remember about the cello woman’s second breath. Win drops her pen, but the pen rolls under the radiator and not the table. Little things. The weather in a room, not the plot.
That’s the second thing. Nothing on Ludlow Street knows it’s the second time. They are not performing. They are doing what a person with this history and this morning would do, and sometimes the same person, with the same history and the same morning, does a slightly different thing.
I am tempted, around ten, to tell Win about Philippa. I could do it so neatly. I could say *when the sister nods, count to seven before you let your breath go*, and I would have saved her a very bad half minute. I could say *Lorraine is going to leave you every one of your silences*.
It would be a kindness. It would also be me deciding what Win gets to find out by herself, in the room, in her own seat. I’ve been that person. I was the person at the other end of every wedding, smoothing the sentence before it could cost anyone anything. I put the thought down.
“Is something wrong?” says Win.
“No. I’m nervous about tonight.”
“That’s not nothing,” she says, in her dry way. “Good. It would be a very strange night if someone weren’t.”
My mother arrives at three, in a garment bag and the coat I’ve never seen. She says, “You’re still tall,” to Ezra, and “Hm,” and hands him a folding chair. I am standing in the entrance of an old dental supply shop with a bouquet I didn’t buy and I can see, so clearly I could draw it, the shape the next minute makes. I know my mother is going to hug Peter. I know Peter is going to look surprised and pleased. They do, in that order.
What I could not have predicted is Peter pulling me aside afterward, on the steps, in the late-afternoon light.
“I need to take something back,” he says.
I wait.
“Yesterday I told you I’d stopped waiting for the kettle. I said I was done being ready.” He rubs the back of his neck. “That was true when I said it. It’s not true now. I woke at six twelve and I heard the spoon and I was ready for a second, hard, the way I used to be. I’d like to say that plainly, because last time I said the other thing and I’d hate for it to turn into a lie by default.”
“You said it was about being allowed to be tired.”
“I’m still tired. I’m also ready. It turns out you can be both.”
I think of Lorraine, in the dark, with a headset on, saying *both things are true*. “Thank you,” I say. “That’s a better sentence than yesterday’s.”
“I thought you might say that.”
“You knew I would,” I say, and then, because it’s true, “and I’d like you to know it didn’t make it less good.”
The gala is a room. Sixty chairs, string lights, a velvet jacket in the front row. At minute thirteen Win steps to the microphone, and I find that I’ve stopped breathing, and that I’ve counted ahead without meaning to, and I make myself stop. I don’t want to know what’s about to happen. I want to be in the room while it happens.
“In 1991, I called this show,” says Win. Same words. She has always said them this way; she didn’t need a rehearsal. She looks at Philippa. Philippa lifts her chin. The silence stretches. I count, because it’s the only thing I know how to do, and it isn’t seven this time. It’s nine.
Philippa nods once.
Jonah presses the key.
I’ve heard the tape play, now, twice, once beside Win in her office and once in this room. It doesn’t get easier and it doesn’t wear thin. The eleven seconds of dead air are exactly as long. The thirty-eight after the click are exactly as brave. When the applause starts at the back, it starts in the same place, from the same man in a corduroy jacket, and it isn’t for a performance.
Afterward Lorraine catches my sleeve.
“You left every one,” she says.
“Every one.”
“Good. Don’t ever tell me what you’d have cut.” She pats my hand. I stand very still. The sentence is the same. It does not mean the same thing, now that I know it’s being said to someone who will not remember it. It means more.
I find Ezra at the back, beside the folding chairs. He takes my hand without asking and I realize that he did ask, with his face, a half second earlier, and I said yes with mine.
“I think that went well,” he says.
“I think it went the way a true thing goes.”
“That’s what you said last time.”
“Did I?”
“I don’t know,” says Ezra, and grins. “You told me you said it. I’m taking it on faith.”
By eleven the room has emptied. Peter helps Win stack chairs. Jonah takes his thermos and the leftover cake. Philippa and Win sit side by side on a bench by the door, not talking, shoulders almost touching, with the tired lazy peace of two women who have been through a bad flood and have decided not to wade back in to check the damage.
I go home at eleven thirty. The rowhouse is quiet. I sit on the bed in the gala dress with my shoes beside me and the brass clock on the dresser, hand on seven. I call Peter on speakerphone, because that is the arrangement, and put the phone on the pillow.
“Are you in the hotel?”
“Seventh floor. I’m looking at the radiator.”
“Same.”
“What do we say?” he asks.
“Nothing we don’t mean.”
“That’s a short list.”
“That’s the point.”
“I’m glad it was this day,” he says, after a moment. “If it has to be a day. I’d have hated it to be the one where I got something wrong.”
“It was a good day.”
“It was the best of the second kind.”
The phone’s little clock turns to 11:58. The pipe in the wall knocks and goes quiet. I don’t say any of the things I could say. I don’t say *I’ll see you in the morning*, because I’m not sure it’s true, and I don’t say *goodbye*, for the same reason.
“Peter.”
“Yes.”
“If it’s the same tomorrow, we’ll say so plainly and keep going. And if it isn’t, I’m glad it was you.”
“Me too,” he says. His voice is not entirely steady. “I’m glad it was you, Hazel.”
Midnight comes. It passes. I lie down in the dark with the phone still glowing against my ear, and I listen to the ordinary quiet, and I let it fold itself around me, and I sleep.
Three bright notes.
I come up out of the pillow like a swimmer out of a trench. The brass alarm is ringing. Six twelve. The hand on the dial says seven.
In the hall, the kettle clicks.
Above me, a spoon falls, rolls, and stops.
I lie perfectly still, and I do not cry, and I do not curse. The dress hangs in its zippered bag. The shoes stand toes-aligned. The glass on the sill is empty. On the phone, the call has long since dropped, and the screen says Saturday, and under it, in a gray stripe, there’s one new message.
It’s not from Peter. It isn’t from Ezra.
*Hazel. It’s Win. I’m awake and it’s six twelve and I have had this morning before. I’m not tired. Please don’t tell me I’m tired. Bring the groom. I’ll be at the Listening Room in forty minutes and I’ve put the kettle on.*


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!