Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 22

The Deed of Gift

Win has put out three mugs, which tells me she’s done the arithmetic before we’ve reached the door.

The Listening Room at seven in the morning is a different building. The string lights from last night are still looped over the long table, switched off, and the sixty chairs are stacked in the corner in a leaning wall that I know, with the bone-deep certainty of a person who has been through a reset, will be gone the next time I look.

They’re there now. Win is standing beside them in her gray cardigan, with the reading glasses on their cord and a stack of index cards in her left hand, held the way a dealer holds a deck.

“Come in,” she says. “Shut the glass door. I’d like to do this without a draft.”

Peter and I come in. I haven’t told him what to expect, because I don’t know. He has taken his jacket off in the doorway and folded it over his arm, a thing I have seen him do in every room he has ever tried to be polite in.

“Win,” I say. “I’m so sorry.”

“For what?”

“I don’t know. I thought I should open with something.”

“That’s the most honest thing you’ve said to me since Tuesday.” She sets down the cards, picks up the kettle, and pours. “Sit. Both of you. And you will be the groom, I assume.”

“Peter,” says Peter.

“Peter. You were on my steps yesterday with a paper bag and a face like a man defusing something. I didn’t ask about it. I’m asking now.”

“Yesterday?”

“Yesterday. The day before this one.” She puts a mug in front of me, then him, then herself, and sits at the head of the long table with her back very straight. “I’d like to establish a few things in order, because I did not sleep, because I woke at twelve minutes past six this morning to something falling on a floor above me, and I live in a ground-floor flat with a garden behind it and a landlord who has never once climbed the stairs.”

I close my eyes.

“Win,” I say. “Tell me what you remember.”

She does. It’s like hearing a prosecutor open a case she doesn’t want to win.

She remembers the day. The whole of the gala day, the version where Hazel came to the Listening Room at nine with a tight face and said she was nervous, and Jonah said the tomato man deserved the nurse, and Win dropped a pen under a radiator. She remembers my mother.

She remembers Lorraine in the velvet jacket. She remembers walking to the microphone and saying *In 1991, I called this show,* and looking at her sister, and counting nine seconds before Philippa’s chin came up. She remembers the applause starting in the back with a man in a corduroy jacket.

She does not remember the first time. She does not remember the gala that ended at midnight with no loop, the one I spent beside Ezra. For her, the second gala is the only gala she has had.

“I want to be very clear,” says Win. “I’m not distressed. I’m not confused. I know what I’m looking at. I’ve spent thirty-three years among reels of tape. I know what it is to put a spool on a machine and hear a voice say the thing it said before. I just hadn’t expected it to be my own morning.”

“This is the second morning,” I say, carefully. “Mine, I mean. And Peter’s. We’ve had one before. A longer one. It was the same alarm and the same sound upstairs, but it had a different rule, and that rule ended.”

“What was the rule?”

“We couldn’t lie.”

“Couldn’t.”

“If either of us said something we knew was false, as a fact, to somebody, the day would reset. It wasn’t a punishment. It was a hinge.” I take a breath. “It stopped when we told the truth.”

Win is quiet. She looks at Peter.

“Is that accurate?”

“It’s accurate,” says Peter. “Fifty-five times. She was the one who worked out the mechanism. I was the one who kept sending it back to the start.”

“And now it’s back.”

“Not the same way,” I say. “I haven’t lied. Peter hasn’t. We spent yesterday being scrupulous. It reset anyway.”

“So the lie was not the cause,” says Win.

“Or the lie was one cause and there is another.”

“You say that as if you’d like me to accept it.”

“I’d like you to dislike it,” I say. “I’d like you to find the hole.”

She almost smiles. “That’s fairer than I deserve.”

She turns the stack of cards over. They are three-by-five, lined, a little yellowed, the sort the dental supply shop must have used for inventory when this was a store and not a collection. She has written on the first one in a fine, upright hand. DAY 2, it says. 6:19. Spoon, kettle, alarm? None. No alarm. Heard only the spoon. Hazel’s text at 6:31.

“I’ve been writing it down,” she says. “I always write it down. If I am going to be a woman who has been through something, I’d like to have a log.”

“It won’t last,” I say. “I should tell you. Paper doesn’t survive. Anything you write, any object you move, goes back to where it was at six twelve. Not your memory. Just the world.”

“Then I’d like to prove it.”

“You can’t prove it from the inside.”

“I can prove it by looking at the outside tomorrow,” she says. “I’d like to set up a protocol.”

Peter, who has been staring into his mug, makes a small noise that is almost relief. “That’s the first thing anyone has said to me in two days that sounded like a plan.”

“It’s not a plan. It’s a method.” She turns her glasses up on their cord. “Do you know the difference between a deposit and a gift, Peter?”

“No.”

“A deposit is an object left in a collection for safekeeping. It still belongs to the person who left it. If they want it back, they can take it. A gift is different. In a proper archive, nothing becomes part of the collection until a donor signs a deed of gift. *I give. You accept.* Both parties know what’s happening. Both are on the record. The object changes owner in a single breath.” She looks at me.

“I’ve watched the world refuse to keep my notes, yesterday and the day before. I don’t know what it is looking for. But I would like to see whether it recognizes a transfer.”

I stare at her.

“It’s not mysticism,” says Win. “It’s the only ritual I know that works.”

By eight, the three of us have designed a very small, very sad experiment, and I am aware that I am enjoying it.

Win has cut five cards from the stack and labeled them with her fine upright pen. A, B, C, D, E. She explains what will happen to each.

Card A stays in her cardigan pocket. It’s the control. If it vanishes, we’ve proved that nothing a person is carrying survives.

Card B will sit on the long table, where it can be seen from anywhere in the room, in the open.

Card C will be taped to the wall by the glass door, beneath the first brass plate of the building’s old address.

Card D will be given to me. Not handed. *Given.* At eleven fifty-eight, by the long table, with the three of us present, Win will say what the thing is and who it belongs to, and I will say what I am doing with it.

And Card E will go to Peter. Tossed. Casual. A card flicked across a table with no words at all.

“Why E?” says Peter.

“To see whether it is the object or the ceremony.”

“What if it’s neither?”

“Then I’ll have wasted five cards,” says Win. “I’ve wasted more on less.”

At nine, Jonah comes in with his thermos and the hole in his sweater.

I’ve been dreading it. I’ve been drawing up what I’ll say, and I realize, watching him come through the door, that I’ve been drafting a lie, because the lie is the easy version. *We were just talking about the gala.* *I’m a bit nervous.* They’re small. They’re the sentences I used to make out of reflex before breakfast.

Win beats me to it.

“Jonah,” she says. “I’m not going to tell you something today.”

He stops in the doorway, one hand on the door frame. “That’s a very Win sentence.”

“It’s the truest one I have. Hazel and I have a matter we’re dealing with, and Peter is helping. It’s mine to tell, and I’m not ready to tell you. When I am, I will, in plain English, and you’ll be the first person after the three of us.”

“Is it about the reel?”

“Partly.”

“Is anyone hurt?”

“No.”

“Is it the kind of thing you’d like me to stop asking about?”

Win looks at him over the glasses. “Yes.”

“Okay,” says Jonah. He sets down the thermos. He looks at me, then at Peter, then at the plan on the table that has nothing on it but five index cards. “For what it’s worth, I think you’re all being very brave about something. And I’d like a muffin at ten, if anyone is going to the corner.”

“I’ll go,” says Peter, and goes.

“Is it always like this?” Jonah asks me, quietly, once the door has swung shut. “Being on the edge of her business?”

“No,” I say. “It’s usually worse.”

He laughs. It’s a good laugh. I think, not for the first time, that he notices more than he lets on, and I resolve to keep a respectful distance and then, immediately, I fail, and hand him the second thermos.

The middle of the day is bad, in a pleasant way. We don’t have anything to do and we do all of it. We stack the chairs back into rows that Win has already, somehow, rearranged to her taste. We test the microphones. I sit with a pair of headphones on, listening to Jonah’s cut, the one with the tomato man and the nurse, and I realize I have heard it three times in two days and that it keeps getting better, as if it is learning.

At two, Win calls Philippa.

I’m in the next room. I hear only the shape of it. A long pause. Win’s voice, low, dry. “Phil. It’s me. No, nothing’s wrong. I’d like to ask you something. Tonight, when I say what I’m going to say. I’d like to look at you before I start. Is that all right?” Another pause. Then, quieter, “Thank you.”

When she comes out, her face is the face of a woman who has set down a heavy bag in a train station and found out that it’s lighter than she thought.

“You asked,” I say.

“I asked something I already knew the answer to. It turns out that’s different.”

“Because this time she gets to say it herself.”

“Because this time I asked,” says Win. She takes her glasses off. “Hazel. I’d like to say it again tonight. Not because I’ve been given a script. Because I meant it yesterday and I mean it now. I’d like you to hear it the way it comes, and not tell me what I’ll say.”

“I won’t.”

“And if I say it differently?”

“Then you’ll say it differently.”

“I intend to,” says Win.

She does. In the evening, in the room with the string lights and the sixty chairs and the velvet jacket in the front row, she steps up to the microphone, and I find, to my shame, that I have been holding my breath for the entire afternoon.

She says, “In 1991, I called this show,” and then, “I used a name I’d invented. I’d like you to hear it in my voice, now, because I didn’t dare then.” She looks at her sister. It’s quiet. I count, because I can’t help it. Six. Seven. At eight, Philippa smiles, which she did not do yesterday, and she nods.

Jonah presses the key. The room listens. Nobody coughs.

I think: *this is the thing I’d been afraid of. That if you live a day twice, the second time will be an echo. And it is not.* It is a performance of a different kind, the kind a person gives who knows what they’re about to say and has decided to say it anyway.

After the applause, Lorraine catches my sleeve.

“You left every one,” she says.

“Every one.”

“Good. Don’t ever tell me what you’d have cut.”

I let her hold my hand for a long moment. She doesn’t know that she said it yesterday. She says it as if it had never been said. Somehow it’s the best I’ve ever heard it.

At eleven forty, the room is empty. Peter is stacking the last of the chairs. Jonah has gone home with the leftover cake and a look that says he’s decided not to ask. Philippa and Win left together an hour ago, shoulder to shoulder, in a cab, having apparently decided that two women of sixty can share a fare.

Win stands at the long table in her gray cardigan. The five cards are laid out in a row.

“Card A,” she says, and slips it into her pocket. “Control.”

“Card B.” She places it face up in the center of the table. “Observation.”

“Card C.” She walks to the glass door and tapes it beneath the brass plate. It’s a small, careful gesture; she presses down each corner. “Wall.”

“Card E.” She picks it up, glances at Peter, and flicks it across the table. It spins once and lands in front of him. He looks at it. He doesn’t pick it up.

“Do I say anything?”

“No.”

“Do I take it?”

“If you like. Or not. It’s not part of the protocol.”

Peter picks it up, turns it over, puts it in his shirt pocket. “I’d like to have it,” he says. “For the record.”

“That’s an acceptance,” says Win. “Not a ritual. Interesting.”

“I didn’t know it was a test.”

“It was a test of whether it was a test,” she says, and the corner of her mouth moves. She holds up the last card. “Card D.”

She turns it face out and I can see that she’s written on it. Not the date. Not the time. The words in her fine upright hand say:

*Ask Lorraine what she remembers of Philippa’s first call. Don’t trust me if I say I’m tired. — W.*

“Hazel,” says Win. She holds the card out across the long table, and her hand is not quite steady, which I’ve never once seen. “This is yours. I’m giving it to you. It’s not a loan, and it’s not a deposit, and you don’t owe me anything for it. I’d like you to have it, whatever happens at six twelve.”

My throat is doing something I don’t care for. “I accept,” I say. I take it. It’s a small, yellowed rectangle, and it weighs nothing. “I’ll keep it. I’m very glad you gave it to me.”

“That was plain,” says Win.

“It was a terrible speech.”

“It was perfect,” says Win. “Now go home and sleep, both of you, like people who don’t know what’s next.”

I don’t go home right away. I walk Peter to the corner of Ludlow, and we stand under a streetlight with the stripe of yellow paper in my fist. It’s cold. The street is empty, a few lit windows, a bus sighing past with nobody in it. I hold the card against my chest.

“What do you think?” he says.

“I think it won’t work.”

“And if it does?”

“Then I’ll have to decide what to do about it.” I look at him. “I don’t know what I want to have happen.”

“Neither do I,” says Peter. “That seems about right.”

I go home. I climb the three flights. I sit on the narrow bed in the gala dress with the card in my right hand, and I hold it, and I don’t put it down. I could put it on the dresser. I could tuck it into the dress pocket. I don’t. I hold it the way I held the bouquet in a hundred hotel corridors, by the stem, as if it might try to leave.

At eleven fifty-eight I’m lying on my side with my fist against my chest. The pipe in the wall knocks, and quiets.

Midnight comes. It passes.

Three bright notes.

I’m up on one elbow before I’m awake. The brass alarm is ringing. Six twelve. The hand on the dial says seven.

In the hall, the kettle clicks.

Above me, a spoon falls, rolls, and stops.

The dress is in its zippered bag, with the shoes beneath it, toes aligned. The glass is empty. The room has reset itself so neatly I could weep.

My right hand is closed. It is warm and slightly damp, as if I’ve been sleeping with it clenched, and I open the fingers one at a time.

A card lies in my palm. Three by five. Lined, a little yellowed. In a fine, upright hand, it says:

*Ask Lorraine what she remembers of Philippa’s first call. Don’t trust me if I say I’m tired. — W.*

I sit very still. Then the phone lights up against the blanket. Peter. It’s not a text. It’s a call, and I answer before the first ring has ended.

“Hazel,” he says. His voice is odd. “I’m holding something.”

“What?”

“A card. A three-by-five card, in my shirt pocket. The shirt was on the chair, Hazel. The shirt was clean. And the card is in the pocket.”

I look at the card in my hand. I think of the glass door in the Listening Room, and of one little yellowed rectangle taped under a brass plate, and I’m already fairly sure what Win will find there when she looks.

“Peter,” I say. “Don’t put it down, and don’t move it from that pocket. Come here. I’ll wait on the landing.”

“Hazel. Which card is yours?”

“D,” I say.

“Mine says E,” he says. “She gave me the one she flicked. I took it and said I’d like to have it.” A pause. “Hazel, I didn’t give her anything. I never signed a thing.”

“Then it isn’t the ritual,” I say. “It’s the acceptance.”

On the other end, very faintly, I hear a hotel heating system hum, and a man draw a long breath.

“Win’s going to be so insufferable,” says Peter.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!