I sit on the landing outside my room with a three-by-five card in my hand, and I wait for a man to climb three flights of stairs, and I think about how much I want to be wrong.
Peter arrives at six thirty-six, a little out of breath, in the blue shirt. He has one hand pressed flat against his chest pocket like a man swearing an oath. He comes up the last flight slowly, the way you approach a wild animal or a bomb, and stops two steps below me.
“Show me,” I say.
He takes it out. It’s the twin of mine. Same stock, same yellowed edge, a letter E in the top corner in Win’s upright hand. Underneath, in a different pen, a line I didn’t see last night because I wasn’t looking: *Yes to Peter. Say it plain, always.*
“She wrote that after I picked it up,” he says. “I didn’t watch her do it. She must have done it while you two were talking about the cab.”
“Win doesn’t miss anything.”
“No.” He sits on the step. He looks like a person who has been handed a heavy parcel without a return address. “Hazel. Nothing has ever come across before. Not a note, not a coin, not a stray grain of rice. I’ve tried. Do you know how many times I tried? In the first week I put a ten-dollar bill in my sock. It was gone. I mailed myself a letter. It was gone.”
“I know.”
“So why this?”
“I don’t know yet.”
That’s when the stairs start up again beneath us. Heavy, uneven feet, someone carrying two things and a bag. He stops at the landing below, sees us, and stands there with two coffees in a cardboard tray.
“I brought two,” says Ezra. “I didn’t know there’d be three of you.”
“There’s two of us,” says Peter. “I came with my own.”
“You’re early.”
“I’m on a flight case schedule,” says Ezra, and then looks at us with a faint frown. “I don’t know why I said that. I think I said it last time. I mean, I think I say it a lot.”
I put down the card. I stand up. I take the coffee he’s holding out, and I think, very clearly, that this is the third time I’m going to tell him, and the first time he’s going to hear it.
“Come in,” I say. “Both of you. I’d like to say something plain.”
He doesn’t resist. He never has. He sits in the chair with my clothes on it after I move them, and Peter sits on the bed, and I stand in the sloped light with my back against the door and tell it again, as exactly as I can.
I tell him about the alarm and the spoon. I tell him about the diner and the eggs. I tell him about a woman named Win who remembers yesterday but not the day before, and about two cards that arrived overnight in two people’s hands.
Ezra listens. When I’m done, he turns the cup slowly on his knee.
“Say what’s hard,” he says.
“What’s hard is that I told you all this yesterday and you were wonderful. You held me up in this room. You said you were a terrible actor. You told me to say it plain before trying the dramatic thing.” I wipe my face with the back of a wrist. “And you don’t remember. I’m talking to someone who said all of that and hasn’t said it yet.”
“That sounds lonely.”
“It’s the loneliest.”
“I’m sorry,” says Ezra. He looks at his hands. “I’m sorry that I’m the one you keep having to start over with.”
“It’s not your fault.”
“I know it isn’t. I’m still sorry.” He looks up. “Can I ask for something? Not as a condition. As a request.”
“Yes.”
“If there’s a way for me to know more by morning, I’d like it. I don’t want to be the man you keep rebuilding.”
I don’t answer. I can’t. I look at Peter, who has been looking, with great interest, at the radiator.
“There might be a way,” I say. “I’ll know more by tonight.”
“I’ll hold you to it,” says Ezra, and drinks his coffee.
At eight, in the Listening Room, Win is waiting with the door open and a mug in each hand and the unmistakable air of a woman who has already been proved right.
“Card C is gone,” she says. “From the wall. I looked first thing. There’s a tape mark under the brass plate, which is, I’ll point out, not a tape mark. It’s a clean wall. The brass is shining. The old Ludlow Street sign is back on its hook where I took it down in March.”
“And A?”
“Gone from the pocket.” She pats the cardigan. “I checked at six eighteen. I checked again at seven. Nothing. And B was not on the table. The table was bare. There wasn’t a card in the room.” She sets the mugs down. “Which means three of five failed.”
“And two didn’t,” says Peter. He puts card E on the table.
Win doesn’t touch it. She looks at me, and I put D beside it. The two lie side by side in the light from the high window, three by five, yellow at the edges, in two different inks.
She takes her glasses off and puts them back on, which I’ve learned is the nearest she comes to swearing.
“I would like to say,” she says, “that I’m not surprised.”
“Are you?”
“I’m delighted. It’s very unprofessional.”
She sits. She draws a fresh stack of cards from the drawer, which is full again, and writes a heading. *FINDINGS.* Under it, a numbered list. She does not hurry.
“One,” she says. “Two objects crossed. Both were gifts to a person who had memory of the loop. Both were accepted aloud.”
“Peter’s was accepted aloud?” I say.
“He said, ‘I’d like to have it. For the record.’ That’s an acceptance.” She writes. “Two. The giving of D was explicit and ceremonial. The giving of E was non-verbal. Both crossed. So it is not the ceremony.”
“It’s the taking,” says Peter slowly.
“It may be the taking. It may be the intention to keep.” She looks at him. “Did you intend to keep it?”
“I did. I put it in my pocket and thought, I’d like this to be real.”
“Then it may be that,” says Win. “Three. The cards that remained within my own custody failed. Card A went with me everywhere, in my own pocket, and was not accepted by anyone. It stayed mine, and mine was not allowed.”
“You’re saying it doesn’t count if you just carry it yourself.”
“I’m saying the world will not hold what I hold. It will hold what someone else is holding on my behalf, and holds as their own.” She puts the pen down. “That’s a hypothesis. I’d like to break it before lunch.”
We do try to break it. It takes most of the morning. Peter gives Win a paper clip and says *this is yours* and she says *I accept* in the dry voice of a woman signing for a package, and we mark it with a dot of red nail polish borrowed from the second drawer.
I give Peter a pencil and say, in my worst imitation of ceremony, *This is yours, I’d like you to have it*, and he says, *No, thank you*, and I put it back on the table, and Win writes *refused* and underlines it twice.
“If I give it with no words and it’s refused?” says Peter.
“Try it.”
He slides a rubber band across the table. Win looks at it. She doesn’t pick it up. He leaves it there, in the middle of the long table, where it sits like an insult.
“It’s an unaccepted gift,” says Win. “We’ll see if it holds.”
“What about the person who doesn’t know what’s happening?” says Peter.
Win and I look at each other.
“That’s the part that frightens me,” I say. “Ezra asked for something. He didn’t ask for a trick. He asked if there was a way.”
“Then ask him,” says Win. “Honestly. If he wants a thing, he can take it.”
“And if he accepts something and doesn’t remember accepting?”
“You’d tell him in the morning, wouldn’t you?”
“I’d have to.”
“Then I wouldn’t worry about it,” says Win. She taps the list. “You’ll want to be careful. If it works the way I think it works, it’s very powerful. It’s the first thing in this affair that doesn’t cost us something we can’t pay back. I’d like to be sure we don’t start writing checks.”
That afternoon, at a quarter past two, Win says, “There’s something I’d like to do. It is on the card.”
“On D?”
“On D. In my own hand. From yesterday.” She holds up the one she’s been holding. “*Ask Lorraine what she remembers of Philippa’s first call.* I don’t know why I wrote it. I think I was afraid I’d forget the question. I think a part of me knows I haven’t asked her the right one in thirty years.”
“Do you want me to come?”
“I’d like you to,” says Win. She gives me a look that says she’s aware how enormous this is for her. “And I’d like to not be alone with it.”
Lorraine receives us on her third-floor landing in the gray cardigan with the strong spectacles pushed up into her hair. She has laid out tea. She has laid out a plate of ginger biscuits, in a fan, on a doily. On the windowsill, in a patch of sun, the ceramic bell with the faded blue flowers sits with its clapper stilled.
“Two of you,” she says. “That’s a good sign. The people who come alone want something. The people who come in pairs want to have said something.”
“I’d like to ask you about Philippa’s first call,” says Win.
Lorraine puts down her cup.
“Ah,” she says. “I wondered when. I’ve been thinking about it since Thursday. I don’t know why. A feeling.”
I feel Win go very still beside me.
“What do you remember?”
“I remember she called two weeks after you did.” Lorraine looks at the window. “It was a Thursday. Late. The line was quiet. She said she was the sister of a girl who’d called about a job. She wouldn’t say your name. She said she had told that girl to go, and she hadn’t meant it, and she had.”
“Yes,” says Win. “I know. You told me that.”
“I didn’t tell you what I said.”
Win says nothing.
“She asked me a question,” says Lorraine. She says it slowly, with the care of someone laying a plank across a stream. “She said, ‘How do I know when it’s too late to say something to her?’ And I said, ‘You don’t. You say it as though it were.’ And she was quiet for a long time. And then she said, ‘That’s very hard,’ and I said it was.”
“That was the whole of it?”
“That was the whole of it. I told her a thing I’d have found very hard to do myself.” Lorraine picks up her cup again, and her hand is perfectly steady. “I’d like you to understand that I’m not telling you this because it’s a comfort. I’m telling you because it’s a fact and nobody’s asked for it.”
Win’s mouth is working. She is a woman of fifty-eight and I have seen her stand at a microphone in front of sixty chairs and a sister and say a sentence that had waited thirty-three years, and she cannot, in this kitchen, say anything.
“Thank you,” she manages, finally.
“You’re very welcome, dear.”
“I’d like to ask one thing more.”
“Of course.”
“Do you ever have the feeling you’ve said something twice?”
Lorraine looks at her.
“That’s a strange question.”
“I know.”
“No,” she says, after a pause. She sets her cup down on its saucer. “But I’ve had a feeling lately of a day I haven’t finished. That’s different. At my age, it’s common. I wouldn’t read anything into it.”
“No,” says Win. “Thank you.”
We say goodbye in the stairwell. Lorraine stands at the door, small and straight, and says to me, almost as an afterthought, “I’d keep an eye on that one. She’s gone a bit soft.” She pats Win’s arm. “It suits her.”
On the street, Win stops at the curb and holds the edge of a lamppost as if it were the rail of a ship.
“I wrote that card to myself,” she says, “and I didn’t know why. I thought it was about Philippa.”
“It might still be.”
“It was about this.” She looks at me. “*You say it as though it were too late.* I’ve been trying to learn that sentence for thirty-three years. And I got it in a kitchen, from an old woman with a plate of biscuits, because a day was repeated.”
“Is that a good thing?”
“I don’t know. I’d like to think so.” She straightens. She takes her glasses off, puts them on. “I would like, very much, to find out what the rest of it costs.”
The gala happens. I tell you this the way I’d tell you the weather: it’s there, it’s loud, and I stand in it. My mother arrives at three, in the coat I have never seen, and says, “You’re still tall,” to Ezra. Win says her sentence a third way, without the sentence about the name, and Philippa nods at the count of five, because she has decided she doesn’t need seven. Lorraine tells me I’ve left every one.
What I do, differently, is that I sit in the back row with Ezra for the first time. I hold his hand through the whole of the reel. I stop counting.
At eleven I find him on the steps of the Listening Room, in the cold, under the lamp, with a paper cup of something warm. He’s looking at the street the way a lighting designer looks at an empty stage, with a patient, wide, almost tender attention, as though it might at any moment surprise him with its best angle.
“Hi,” he says.
“Hi.”
“I don’t remember this morning. But I remember your voice telling me, in the third person, what I’d said. It’s the strangest feeling. It’s like being given somebody’s diary and finding out you wrote it.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be.” He shifts. “Hazel, I’ve been thinking about what you said. About a way to know more by morning. I’d like to hear it.”
I sit beside him. I tell him, in the plain order, everything we learned. The cards. The refusals. The rubber band. The acceptances. I tell him that things cross if a person with memory takes them, intending to keep them. I tell him that nobody has ever tested it on someone without memory, and that I’d like to try it with him, if he wants, and that if he doesn’t, I won’t ask again tonight.
“What would it be?” he says.
I take the little paper-wrapped bunch out of my bag. It’s blue wildflowers, cornflower and something purple I don’t know the name of, the cheap kind, the kind sold at the corner shop in a bucket by the till. I bought it myself at ten. It cost four dollars. I paid cash and did not feel a thing, because I knew the dollars would come back at six twelve.
“They’re not a gift to cheer you up,” I say. “They’re a test. And if you say no, I’ll put them in the bin and we’ll have a very good evening anyway.”
He looks at them for a long, quiet minute. The street lamp turns his face the color of old brass.
“Can I say something?”
“Please.”
“I’m frightened,” says Ezra. “I’m frightened that I’ll wake up tomorrow and know less about you than I do tonight. I’m frightened that I’ll do the thing where I pretend I’m fine. And I’m frightened that if this works, I’ll have a reason to hope.”
“Say the last one again.”
“I’m frightened that I’ll hope.”
“That’s the correct reason,” I say.
He laughs, and it cracks in the middle, and he holds out both hands.
“They’re yours,” I say, putting the flowers in them. “I’d like you to have them. You don’t owe me a thing.”
“I’ll keep them,” says Ezra. “I’m very glad you gave me them.”
“That was almost grammatical.”
“I’ve been told I’m a poor actor,” he says, and we sit there for an hour, on the steps, under the lamp, with the cold coming up out of the pavement, not saying anything we don’t mean.
At eleven fifty-eight I’m alone in my room, with the gala dress hanging from the wardrobe door and the card D on the dresser, where I’ve left it, and then, on second thought, in my fist. The brass clock reads seven. Somewhere above me, nothing happens.
Midnight comes. It passes. Three bright notes.
I’m sitting up before the second of them. The alarm. The kettle. The spoon, rolling, stopping. My right hand is clenched around a card. I open it and look, and I’m already crying, and I haven’t even looked out the window.
I sit with the card in my fist until the clock reads six forty. Then I go to the window.
The street is still blue with morning. A delivery van idles at the corner. A man in a gray coat is standing on the stoop of the rowhouse with one hand raised to knock, and in the other hand, wrapped in a crumple of newspaper, is a bunch of cornflowers.
He looks up. I can see his face from here. It is the face of a man who has found something in his coat in the dark and has no idea how it got there.
He doesn’t have the coffees.
I’m down three flights before I notice I’ve forgotten my shoes.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!