On Sunday morning the Church of St. Alder, the Ferryman, opens its doors at 5:50 for a congregation of nine, and I am the only one of the nine who has come to commit a crime.
It is not a large crime. A subpoena, if I am honest, is not a crime at all. It is a card in my pocket and a request to a priest. But I have spent my whole working life on the right side of a very polite line, and I find that when I cross it I want to look over my shoulder.
Calder is at the curb. He is leaning on the hatchback, in the black coat, with a paper cup of coffee in each hand, and he is not looking at me. I drove. He asked, last night, whether he might ride along, and I said that he might ride along as far as the curb. He said that this was acceptable. He has not said anything since, which I am learning is how he expresses a feeling.
“Two doors,” he says, as I get out. “Front and a side one, by the vestry. Bell tower, rear. A cellar, probably. I have not been inside.”
“You are not going inside.”
“I know.” He holds out a cup. “It is not poisoned. I tasted it.”
“That is not a thing a person says.”
I take the coffee. It is black, with two sugars, and it is exactly how I drink it, and I stand on the sidewalk with the cup in both hands and feel the particular grief of being known by someone I cannot remember.
“If you hear anything,” I say.
“I will come in.”
“It will be the organ.”
“Then I will enjoy the music,” says Calder, “very quietly, from the street.”
St. Alder’s is a squat brick church from the 1880s, wedged between a feed store and a boarded-up bank, with a square tower at the back and a dozen stained-glass windows of men rowing boats. The nine members of the congregation are scattered across the pews like seeds. Most of them are old, and three of them, I notice, as I slide into the last row, do not breathe quite the way old people breathe. They are wolves. They are saying the Rosary with the rest.
The priest is at the altar with his back to us, a big man in green vestments, and when he turns to give the blessing I see that he is seventy, perhaps older, with a boxer’s flattened nose and a gentle, tired face, and hands the size of dinner plates. He sees me. His hand, raised in the sign of the cross, stops for a fraction of a second. Then it finishes, calmly, and he says, “Go in peace.”
I wait until the nine have shuffled out. Then I go down the aisle and stand in front of the rail.
“Father Pike.”
“Miss Daly.” His voice is a low rumble with the vowels of the river valley in it. “I wondered when. I thought, perhaps, Monday. Margo always said you were the punctual one.”
“Did she.”
“She said you were never late and never early, and that it was the most frightening thing about you.” He smiles, a bit sadly. “Will you come into the vestry? I’ll put the kettle on. I have a feeling you won’t take sugar.”
The vestry is a long narrow room that smells of candle wax and old wool. There is a table with a green baize cloth, and a hot plate, and a row of chasubles on hangers. Father Pike makes tea in two chipped mugs. His hands, I notice, are not quite steady. He puts one mug in front of me and sits across the table, and for a time we do the thing two people do who both know the subject and neither wants to start.
“I have a subpoena,” I say.
“For me?”
“For the register of oaths. The book, not a page.”
“Ah.” He does not seem surprised. “I thought as much. Miss Penhallow came to me on Tuesday. She asked for the entry for the second of October. I gave it to her. It was a copy, in my own hand, certified. She seemed satisfied.” He stirs his tea. “She did not ask for the book.”
“Why not?”
“Because I would have said no.” He lifts his eyes. They are very pale, a washed-out gray. “And then she would have had to take it.”
“Do you have the book?”
“I have two books, my dear. One for oaths, and one for the dead.” He nods at a cupboard behind me. “The register of burials, you may see. It is a public record of this parish, and the Moot has no claim on it. The register of oaths is a different thing. It belongs to the Moot, and I am only its keeper. It is not in this room.”
“Where is it?”
“Where Margo told me to put it.” He is quiet a moment. “In the tower. Behind the bell. She said that no one would climb that stair but a Daly.”
I put my tea down. “Father, I am going to ask this in the most exact way I can. I will be taking it down, in my head, and I will hold you to it.”
“I would expect no less.”
“Is there an entry in the register of oaths, dated the second of October three years ago, that records a renunciation sworn by me?”
He looks at me for a long time, with his big hands folded on the baize.
“There is an entry,” he says, “in my hand. I wrote it.”
“That is not what I asked.”
“I know. I am a priest. We are very good at answers that are not quite the question.” A small, rueful smile. “I will say this, Miss Daly. I wrote that entry on the second of October. I wrote it at the hour I was told. And I have not been able to look at it since.”
“Why?”
“Come and see the book.” He rises, with a faint groan of the knees. “It is a long climb. I would not like to go alone.”
Before we go up, he opens the cupboard and takes out the register of burials. It is a big flat ledger bound in black cloth, with a faded ribbon, and he sets it on the baize and turns the pages with a thumb the width of a spoon.
“You asked about Margo,” he says. “You may as well see where she is.”
I read it standing. It is a column of names in a hundred hands, going back to 1881, each with a date of burial, a plot, a note of the officiant. The last entry on the page is in Pike’s upright hand.
Marguerite Daly. Born 1946. Died October 16. Plot 14B, Sable Rest. Interred: [blank]. Officiant: A. Pike.
And a second line, beside it, in the margin, in smaller letters, as if added at a different time.
With: Constance.
“The date of interment is empty,” I say.
“It is.”
“She was buried on the nineteenth. I was there. I stood at the grave.”
“You stood at a grave,” says Father Pike gently. He closes the book. “I did not say you stood at her burial. The register is exact, Miss Daly. I keep it exact. If I had written a date there, I would have been lying.”
“And Constance?”
“That is the instruction she left. That the instrument be interred with her.” He lays one huge hand flat on the cloth, and I see it shake. “It was not done. Obviously. You have it in your arms.”
I do. I have it in the case at my feet. I did not bring it in. I left it on the back seat of the hatchback, under Calder’s eye, and I find with a lurch that I have been holding my arm as if the case were hanging from it.
“Father,” I say. “What is in the grave?”
He does not answer. He picks up the second book from the cupboard shelf, a small plain notebook, and slips it into his sleeve. “Come,” he says. “The stair is narrow.”
It is narrower than narrow. It begins behind a door in the back of the nave and spirals up inside the tower in a tight, dusty corkscrew, with a rope for a handrail and no light but a bulb at each landing. There are one hundred and four steps. I count them, because I count. Father Pike goes first, breathing hard, and I climb behind with my left hand on the rope and my right hand in my pocket, around an index card.
At the fifth landing the bulb is out.
“It does that,” says Father Pike, in the dark. “Mind the ninth step.”
I mind it. The stair opens at last into a square room, high up, with louvered openings on all four sides and a wooden floor black with age. The bell hangs in the center, a bronze dome the size of a washing machine, in a frame of timbers as thick as my body. The air smells of pigeons and iron. A beam of early gray light comes through the louvers and lies across the floor in bars.
There is a ledge against the north wall, behind the bell’s frame, at the height of a man’s waist. It is empty.
Father Pike stops short. “No,” he says. “No.”
There is an oilcloth, folded on the ledge, and a long square mark in the dust where a book has lain. The dust is fresh at the edges. Someone has lifted the book very recently, and they did not stop to wipe the shelf.
“It was here,” says Father Pike. “Three years it has been here. I climbed up every month to look.”
“Who knew?”
“Margo. Myself. The Warden.” He is gray with horror. “And whoever read the Moot’s schedule, I suppose, and understood that you would come.”
Behind us, something shifts.
It is a small sound, a creak, the sound of a foot settling on a board. I turn.
A man steps out from behind the bell’s frame. He is young, and not tall, in a gray hooded sweatshirt and work gloves, with a black cloth tied over the lower half of his face. He has a book in his arms, big and flat and bound in oxblood leather, and he is already moving.
I do not think. I have never been quick, in my life, in my body. I am quick in my hands, and in the part of me that counts. But I take one step and I say, loudly, “That is a record of the Moot. Put it down.”
He does not. He turns, not toward the stair but toward the louvers on the east side, where a rope hangs from a hook in the wall, and he throws one leg over the sill.
“Wren,” says Father Pike. “He is human. You are not safe from him.”
I know. I know exactly what he means. A wolf who laid a hand on me would sicken for a month. A man who laid a hand on me would only be a man.
I run.
It is perhaps eleven feet from where I stand to the louvers, and the bell is in the way. I go around it by the left, ducking under the frame, and my shoe finds a loose board and slides. I catch myself on a timber. The man, one leg already outside, glances back, and I see his eyes above the cloth, young and scared and furious, the eyes of a person who has been told this would be easy.
He grabs the bell rope.
I do not understand until it is too late. It is a thick hemp rope, coiled by the east wall, hanging from the wheel above the bell, and he wraps it once round his glove and heaves down with all his weight, and the bell swings.
It swings once, a slow, tremendous arc, a ton of bronze moving like a door. The clapper meets the lip.
The sound is not a sound. It is a blow. It comes up through the floor and into my feet and teeth and the bones of my face, and I go down on my hands and knees with the whole tower roaring around me, a noise so large it has no pitch, so large it takes the thought out of my head. I cannot hear. I cannot see. The beam under my palms is bucking like a living thing. Somewhere very far away a man is shouting, and I think it is Father Pike.
The bell swings back.
I see it coming. It is the only thing I see clearly in that whole tilting minute, the lip of the bell with a rim of green, sailing across the room toward my head, and the long, slow, beautiful curve of the arc that will end in my skull.
A hand takes me by the collar and yanks me flat.
The bell goes over me with a wind like a freight train. I feel the air of it on my back. I lie on the boards with my cheek on the dirt and my heart going like a drum, and the clapper strikes again, and the tower rings like the end of the world.
“Stay down,” says Father Pike, very near my ear. His great hand is still knotted in my blazer. He is lying across me, and I realize he has thrown his whole bulk down to hold me flat. “Stay down, child. It will pass.”
The bell slows. The note falls and falls, shivering, into a hum, and then into nothing. When I lift my head the man in the gray sweatshirt is gone. The louver on the east side stands open, and a rope trails out through it, and far below, in the gray of morning, I hear running feet on gravel and the clatter of someone going over a fence.
Father Pike lets me up. He is shaking all over. There is blood in his white hair, from a cut on the temple, where a splinter has opened it. He is seventy-one years old and he has just done the bravest thing I have seen anyone do all week.
“The book,” I say. My own voice sounds muffled and strange. “He took the book.”
“He took it, yes.” The priest sits back on his heels, wheezing. “I’m afraid he did.”
“Father, are you—”
Footsteps on the stair, fast, taking the steps three at a time. A shape fills the doorway, and it is Calder, breathing hard, with the cup of coffee still in one hand and the other already reaching for me. He stops a yard short. I see him see the room: the open louver, the blood, the dust, the priest, me on my knees. I see his eyes go amber, and then, with a kind of force, go dark again.
“I heard the bell,” he says.
“It was not the organ.”
“No.” He sets the cup down on the stair, carefully, as if he did not trust his hand. “I did not touch you. I want you to know that. I came up, and I looked, and I did not touch you.”
“I know.”
“If you want me to go—”
“Calder.” I get to my feet. My legs are shaking too. “Did you see him? On the street?”
“A gray hood, a black mask, over the back fence of the feed store. I could have caught him.” His voice is level. “You said alone. I did not leave my post.”
I look at him. It is an extraordinary thing to be told, by a man with the speed and the teeth of a wolf, that he let someone run past him because I asked.
“Thank you,” I say. I do not trust myself to say anything else.
Father Pike lifts the oilcloth from the ledge, folds it, and sets it carefully under his arm. “He has the book of oaths,” he says. “But he did not look for the other. They never think to look for the other.” He pats his sleeve, where the small plain notebook lies. “Come down with me. There is a thing I would show you, and I would rather show it to you in the light.”
Sable Rest is a small old cemetery on a bluff above the river, behind a stone wall and a rusting iron gate, and at seven in the morning on a Sunday it is empty except for crows. Father Pike has put a Band-Aid on his temple and a coat over his vestments. He walks ahead of us up the gravel path between the headstones, a big, stooped, limping figure, and I follow with the case clutched to my chest and Calder a few paces behind, as I have asked.
Plot 14B is near the wall, under a young maple. The stone is gray granite, newly cut, and it says in plain letters: MARGUERITE DALY. 1946 to this year. And below, smaller, the line I did not choose, that Quade read at the funeral and I did not hear.
…and keep your wrists flat.
The grave is a low mound of settled earth, sodded over, with a ring of chrysanthemums wilting at its foot. Nobody has dug it since the nineteenth. It looks like what it is.
Father Pike kneels beside the headstone. He is breathing hard, and I think it is not only from the climb. He puts his big hand flat on the sod at the foot of the stone, and he presses, and the turf lifts.
It is a hatch. A square of sod laid over a wooden frame, hinged along one side, so cunningly cut that I could have walked across it every day for a year and never seen the seam. Below it is a steel ring set into concrete. He takes hold and hauls, and the hatch swings back, and cold air rises out of the ground, smelling of dust and metal and, very faintly, of snow.
An iron ladder goes down into the dark.
“She had it built,” says the priest. “Eleven years ago. By my cousin, who does masonry. He thinks it is a drain.” He grips the edge. “There is a light. A switch, on the left, at the bottom. I will go first, if you like.”
“I will go,” I say.
“Wren,” says Calder, behind me, very low.
“Hold the hatch.” I do not turn. “If it closes, open it. If something comes, call. Do not come down unless I ask.”
“And if you do not ask?”
“Then I am being a fool,” I say, “in a manner that is my own business.”
A pause. “Noted,” says Calder Voss, and it is the first time he has ever used the word.
The ladder is twelve rungs. At the bottom my shoe finds concrete, and my hand finds a switch, and a string of bare bulbs along the ceiling flickers and comes on.
I am standing in a long, low, arched room, perhaps forty feet from end to end, with a floor of poured gray concrete and walls of raw brick. There is a smell of cold and dry paper. There are shelves, steel shelves, floor to ceiling, in rows, going back and back into the dark beyond the last bulb.
And on every shelf, as thick as cordwood, are rolls of cream paper tape.
They are the size of rolls of coins, and the size of dinner plates, and every size between. Each is bound at the middle with a band of brass, and each band is stamped with a small round seal, a thumb pressed into wax, and under each is a slip of card with a date. 1962. 1971. 1980. 1993. The nearest shelf at my elbow is a hundred rolls of a single year. The one next to it is another.
Thousands. I cannot count them. For the first time in my life I try, and I cannot.
“Sealed rolls,” says Father Pike, from the foot of the ladder. His voice is hushed. “Every one a Scribe ever sealed and did not open. Every secret the Moot ever agreed to keep. Margo gave them a place to lie. She said they should not be in a theme park.”
I walk slowly down the aisle with my arms folded around the case. The tapes are cold. I can feel it from a foot away, the way you feel the cold coming off a window in winter. I read the cards as I pass. A name. A name. A date and a single word: Drowned. A date and a word: Pardoned. A year with no name at all, only a small, careful drawing of a wolf’s paw.
At the end of the aisle, on a shelf by itself, at the height of my breast, a single roll lies on a square of black velvet. It is not large. It has been sealed with a brass band, like the rest, and under the band there is a card.
I know the handwriting. I would know it anywhere. It is the neat, upright, ruled hand of a woman who taught me to type with a ruler across my knuckles.
DALY, MARGUERITE. Sealed on the day of her death. Not to be opened by any hand but a Daly’s. Keep your wrists flat.
I stand there, with my wrist inches from the brass, and I feel it begin.
It is a warmth. It rises from under my sleeves, from the old brass burns on both my wrists, as if they were being breathed upon, and under my arm the case is shivering. I hear the latch tick. I hear something inside move, a small, patient noise, a key lifting.
Behind me, on the shelves, the cold goes out of the air.
“Father,” I say. “Father Pike, is it supposed to do that?”
There is no answer. I turn.
Father Pike has come halfway down the aisle, with one hand out, and he has stopped. His face in the bare bulb is the color of tallow. He is not looking at me. He is looking past me, at the rolls.
All down the shelves, along the whole length of that long room, the brass bands are beginning to glow. Not bright. A dull amber, a coal under ash, one after another, row by row, like a street coming alive at dusk. The little wax seals are softening. A thread of cream paper loosens from the nearest roll and drifts into the air, as light as a hair.
“Do not touch them,” says the priest, in a whisper. “Wren, do not touch them. They are law the moment they are opened. And if one opens, every roll older than it comes due.”
Above me, at the top of the ladder, a voice calls my name. It is Calder, and he is very close to shouting, and I cannot hear what he says, because the nearest roll to my left has just come loose from its brass band with a sound like a sigh, and the tape is unspooling down the shelf and across the floor, long and cream and quick, toward my shoe.
It is typing.
I watch the letters come, one at a time, in the old narrow capitals. By the time the first line reaches my foot I can read it. It is my name.

