Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 15

A Plea of Humanity

The tape stops at my shoe. I read the second line before I let myself breathe.

WREN DALY. DO NOT LET THEM TELL YOU YET.

It is the sentence on the card under the false floor of my shoebox, in the same words, in the same order. A woman wrote it three years ago in pale blue ink and hid it. Now it is typed in the narrow capitals of an instrument, and it lies on a concrete floor in the dark with its end curling against my foot like a cat that has brought me something.

“Father,” I say. “What is a roll doing that will not wait?”

“Overdue,” says Pike. He has not moved. His big hands are held out from his sides, as if the air were wet paint. “Every one of these is overdue. The law says a Scribe may seal a roll for twenty-four hours, no more. Then it must be read or burned. Margo could do neither. She kept them. A roll past its day is law that has not been paid, and it wants to be.”

“That one is from the second of October.”

“I would imagine so.”

I crouch. The card under the brass band, where it has slid half out, is in my own writing. I know my hand the way I know my face in a mirror. W. DALY. Sealed 6:51 p.m. Not to be opened.

Six-fifty-one. Eleven minutes after the renunciation.

I do not decide anything. I pick up the end of the tape in one hand and wind it back, slowly, round the loose roll, the way you wind a spool of thread. The paper is warm as skin. The glow runs along the shelves, row on row, like a wind through wheat, and I feel every roll in the room lean toward me.

“The Scribe,” I say aloud, and my voice shakes, “requests that the Record show this roll unread.” I press my thumb against the wax of the brass band.

The wax takes my thumb. It is a very small thing: a soft give, a warmth, a little click of the brass closing over the paper like a latch. The tape lies still. And one by one, along the whole length of that long cold room, the amber goes out of the bands.

At the top of the ladder, Calder has stopped calling my name.

“That,” says Father Pike, very quietly, “was not supposed to work.”

“Why not?”

“Because a renouncing Scribe has no thumb.” He looks at me with enormous, terrified respect. “The wax has accepted you.”

I put it on a card in the car, outside the cemetery wall, in the weak October sun, while Calder watches the road and does not ask. I write: The wax took my thumb. Then, under it: Ask Walt whether that proves anything.

It is Sunday, and the rest of the day goes to the telling.

I said I would not hear it until I had decided what I wanted from him. I decide in the front seat of the hatchback, with a cold coffee in the cup holder and the whole of the Sable valley lying gray and quiet below the bluff. He is behind the wheel. He has not started the engine. He is looking at his hands on the rim as if they belonged to someone else.

“Ask me anything,” says Calder. “I will not choose.”

“You chose on Saturday.”

“I did. I would like to stop.”

So I ask, and he answers. I ask in order, the way you take a witness through a day, and he tells me, plainly, without ornament, with no contractions, which is how I know it costs him.

On the second of October, three years ago, Margo came to his door at four in the afternoon and asked him to stand witness. She did not say to what. He went. In the Justice Hall, which was empty and smelled of dust, she sat me down in the well, with Raman beside her and Pike at a card table with his big book, and read me a sentence. I repeated it. I signed. I was calm, he says, calmer than anyone in the room, and when I put down the pen I looked up at Margo and said, “Is that enough?” and she said, “It will have to be.”

Then I got up, he says, and sat at the instrument and typed for a very short time. Margo took the roll and left by the side door. I went home. Neither of us spoke to him, and he went to the Rat and did not drink, which he mentions as if it were a sin.

“You saw me seal a roll,” I say.

“I did not know it was a seal. I thought it was a note.” He looks up. “I should have asked. I have told you what I have told you. That is all I know of that evening, and I will swear it on any instrument you like.”

“Did she tell you why?”

“No.” His voice goes very quiet. “She told me, eleven years ago, when I was twenty-two, that the machine was not a machine. That it held someone. That one day I would have to choose between you and the Moot, and that I would choose you, and that I must never tell you until you asked.” He takes a breath. “You did not ask. For eleven years, you did not ask. And I was a coward, Wren. I let you not ask.”

I look at the river. It is the color of pewter, with a skin of light on it.

“I am still angry,” I say.

“I would think less of you if you were not.”

“You are still benched.”

“I am aware.” The corner of his mouth moves. “I enjoy it more than I expected.”

I do not laugh. But the thing under my ribs that has been a fist since Saturday loosens by one finger, and I start the engine myself.

At one in the morning on Monday, the Justice Hall is full to the doors, and the air smells of snow, and of a large number of people who have not slept.

Constance sits on the floor of the well, at the foot of the witness stand, in her walnut case, with the lid open and the paper tape coiled in its tray. Nobody has touched her. This is the compromise, and Walt and I worked at it for two days with a Thermos and a tin of ginger candies. Truitt ruled that a Record may be made by the instrument without a hand on it, because on Friday morning she printed a case number in my bedroom with nobody at the keys. A thing that has done it once may be asked to do it again. Penhallow agreed, with grace, in a letter. She said she would be curious to see.

I sit in the witness chair, a plain wooden chair set in the well at the right hand of the bench, under Judge Hickory’s open eye. My hands are in my lap. They are empty. It is the first time in my life I have sat in a court without a machine to hold, and I find that I do not know what to do with my wrists.

Calder is in the third pew, on the aisle. He does not look at me. He is counting something under his breath, and I realize it is the exits.

“The Petitioners,” says Truitt, “may open.”

“Miss Daly,” says Odile Penhallow, and she rises from her table in the lavender suit with her hands clasped before her, like a woman about to sing. “I will be brief, and I will be gentle, and I will ask only what must be asked.” She comes forward four paces. She stops at the very edge of the well. “May I state the Petitioners’ position for the benefit of the Moot?”

“You may.”

“The Petitioners offer the Respondent a plea of humanity.”

A murmur goes through the benches.

“It is simple,” says Penhallow. “If Miss Daly is a human being, an ordinary woman of this county, then she is a woman who sat in this hall three years ago and renounced the office of Scribe. She is a private citizen, and every Record she has taken since her grandmother’s death is a Record taken by a stranger, and void. We would be sorry for it, and we would ask her to go in peace.”

She spreads her hands. “If, on the other hand, she is not entirely a human being, if the instrument she carries is not merely something she uses but something she is, then the Scribe’s immunity was never hers. It belongs to the office, and to the humans who hold it. What sits before this Moot is not a Scribe. It is a part of the machine.”

“Objection,” says Walt, rising. “This is a closing argument and the witness has not yet said her name.”

“Sustained as to form,” says Truitt, tiredly. “Miss Penhallow, put your questions.”

“Gladly.” She turns back to me. “Miss Daly. State your name.”

“Wren Daly.”

The tape does not move. I glance down at it, and it lies in its tray, untouched, cream and clean.

“Your age?”

“Twenty-nine.”

“Your occupation?”

“Official court reporter, Marlow County, Department 4.”

“Are you a human being?”

I have been waiting for this. I have rehearsed it in the car, in the shower, in the cold corridors of the courthouse. I had planned to say yes. It is what I believe. It is not a lie, because I believe it, and the tape does not mark what I believe.

But I have learned something about Odile Penhallow in two days, and it is that she never asks a question she does not already know the answer to.

“The Scribe,” I say, “requests a clarification of the term.”

A faint, appreciative breath goes round the pews. Penhallow smiles.

“The Moot,” says Truitt, “allows it.”

“By human, does the Petitioner mean a creature born of a woman, of a human mother?”

“I do.”

“Then I was born in Marlow County General Hospital on the ninth of March, twenty-nine years ago, to Joan Daly, who is a woman.” I say each word flat, the way I would read a record back. “I have a birth certificate and a Social Security number. I have never been anything else, to my knowledge. That is all I can say.”

The tape lies still.

“To your knowledge,” says Penhallow, very softly.

“Yes.”

“Let us explore your knowledge.” She walks the length of the well, once, with her hands behind her back. “When you were seven years old, you were taken to a clinic with a fever of one hundred and four. Is that correct?”

My mouth is dry. “Yes.”

“When you woke, you asked for paper.”

“Yes.”

“And you typed a single line, on the instrument, without instruction. Do you remember what it said?”

I did not remember until yesterday. Now I know it by heart. “THE DOG DID NOT BITE.”

A sound runs round the Justice Hall, like a wind through dry leaves. Forty wolves, and a few dozen more, and one human detective in the back row, in a trench coat, who has come without being asked, and who writes in a notebook.

“And your grandmother,” says Penhallow, “said that sentence was true.”

“She did.”

“Did you know, Miss Daly, that a child cannot type on that instrument? That in two hundred years, no Scribe has ever touched those keys without a year of teaching? That the keys do not warm, and the tape does not print, for a hand that has not been taught?”

“I did not know it.”

“Do you know it now?”

“I know that I did.”

“Do you know what you are?”

The room has gone still. I can hear the broken skylight tick as the night wind moves it. Beneath my chair, a draft stirs the end of the tape.

“No,” I say. And the tape lies clean, because it is true.

Penhallow stands very still, her face grave and kind. It is the face of a woman at a deathbed. For some reason that frightens me more than anything she has said.

“One last question,” she says, “and I will let you rest. I ask it as a friend of your grandmother’s. Miss Daly. Do you wish the Moot to know what you are?”

It is a trap. I can feel the jaws of it. But I cannot see the shape, and the silence is growing, and Walt is half out of his chair with his lips parted, and the answer is plain, because I came here for it. I came to this room, and to the vault, and to the church, and to a desk drawer in a clinic, for exactly this. I have spent six days chasing the thing in the dark. I want to know.

“Yes,” I say.

The tape slides from the left of the case.

I see it before anyone else, because I am watching. The paper is the color of cream, and then a thread of rose, and then a whole, wet, living scarlet, from the first letter to the last, as bright as a wound. The sentence is a single word. I know what it says without reading it. I do not need to.

In the pews, forty wolves breathe in at once.

“The instrument,” says Penhallow, almost tenderly, “has marked the Respondent’s answer as false.”

“Objection,” says Walt. “The instrument marks what the speaker knows to be false. She said she wished to know. Somebody else obviously knows otherwise.”

“Sustained,” says Truitt hoarsely. “The Petitioner will not characterize.” And then, in a very different voice: “Miss Daly. Are you well?”

I am not.

The cost is already in me. It is a cold, clean, quiet thing. It is not like the others. It does not take a face or a name. It takes something smaller and older and worse. A kind of weather. For an instant I am standing in a doorway, a little girl in a yellow raincoat, with a fever, in the dark, and a voice above me is making a sound I have heard every night of my childhood, low and tuneless and warm, a sound like a hand on a forehead.

I reach for it.

There is no sound. There is the doorway, and the raincoat, and the dark, and a shape of a woman bending down, and her mouth moving. I can see her lips make the tune. I cannot hear it. I know that it had words. I know that it ended on a note that went down, like a hand lifted slowly. I know that I have heard it ten thousand times, and I would know it in my sleep.

I do not know it now. It is gone as if it had never been.

“Miss Daly,” says Truitt again.

“I am well,” I say. It is a lie, and the tape does not care, because it is not on the record yet. “The Scribe would like a minute.”

“Granted. Mr. Szymanski, you may cross when the witness is able.”

I sit with my hands in my lap and breathe. Beside the bench Walt is already moving toward me, with his Thermos and his gray face. The Moot is murmuring, a low, rising sea of voices, and Penhallow has gone back to her table and sat down, very straight, with her hands clasped and her eyes closed, as if in prayer.

I look for a face in the crowd. I do not know whose. I look at the pews, the aisles, the folding chairs at the back. I look at the doors, the saloon doors, swinging in the draft. And I see, in the last row, under the dead neon, in a hospice nurse’s scrubs and a gray cardigan, with her handbag clutched in front of her in both hands, a small tired woman of fifty-six, who has come, uninvited, in the middle of the night, to a bankrupt theme park in the dark.

My mother is humming.

She hums when she lies. I have known it since I was four. It is a tell as sure as a flushed face, a little thread of sound in the back of the throat, and I have heard it ten thousand times, at the kitchen table, at the funeral, in the car, saying nothing, saying fine.

I do not know this tune.

She is humming it very low, to herself, with her eyes on me, and her lips are trembling. It is a slow tune, going down at the end, like a hand lifted from a child’s forehead. And I understand, with the whole cold weight of the last ten minutes, that I do not know it, that I will never know it, that this is the thing I just lost, and that my mother knows exactly what it was and is sitting in the dark humming it to me, like a letter in a bottle, because she has just watched me forget it and has no way in the world to say so.

“Wren,” Walt whispers. “Who’s that?”

“My mother,” I say.

At the back of the Justice Hall, Joan Daly stands up.

“Speaker,” she says, in a clear, small, steady voice that carries to the bench. “My name is Joan Daly. I would like to be heard.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!