Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 32

Standing

The seventh strip arrives at 7:52 Monday morning, while I am standing in my kitchen with a piece of toast, and it is exactly where the arithmetic said it would be.

Constance does not ring a bell. She does not shake the shelf. The case on the radiator shelf simply warms, and I know the warmth the way a person in a dark house knows a door has opened somewhere. I carry the toast across the living room, open the lid, and there under the left frame, a handspan of ash-gray paper has come out of the machine and curled itself over the edge of the case like a tongue.

It is two lines. The letters are thin and perfectly even.

WHO STOOD FOR HER WHEN SHE WAS NOT YET. ASK THE ONE WHO IS BOUND TO OBJECT.

I read it twice, and I cut it off with the little brass shears, and I wind it onto the pencil stub with the others. It is tidy work. My hands do it without me. I put the toast down and notice that I have eaten none of it.

“Seven fifty-two,” I say, to nobody. “A little over two days. The curve is holding.”

At the courthouse, Port Harlan is having the sort of Monday that makes the building smell of floor wax and wet wool. The Marlow County Courthouse was built in 1931 by people who believed in marble and stairs, and the stairs have been climbed by so many plaintiffs and defendants and jurors and relatives of both that the middle of each step has gone concave, like a spoon. Department 4 is on the third floor.

Judge Haskett is on the bench by nine o’clock, because she has never once been late in the six years I have taken her record, and she looks down over her half-glasses at the two lawyers in front of her with the expression of a woman who has already read their briefs and has forgiven neither.

“Estate of Wetherell,” says the clerk. “Contested probate. Petitioner, Mr. Linwood Wetherell; respondent, the estate, by counsel.”

I settle the machine. Not Constance. My day machine, the plain black Stenograph that belongs to the county, a lesser creature with a gray plastic case and nine years of other people’s coffee in its keys. It is a good machine. It has no opinions. I am grateful for that this morning, and I am a little ashamed that I am grateful.

Haskett is also aware that I look like a woman who has not slept. She does not mention it. She puts her pen down and says, “Counsel, begin.”

The facts of Wetherell are the sort that make probate lawyers happy and everyone else tired. Walter Wetherell, a retired tool-and-die man with a lake cabin on the Sable, died in August at eighty-one. His will, executed in 2024, leaves the cabin and its forty acres “to my grandniece Hollis, whom I have named, though she is yet unborn, and whom I charge my heirs to find a place for.”

His grandniece, Dana, a nurse in Columbus, is seven months pregnant, and has said, to everyone who will listen, that if it is a girl it will be Hollis. The petitioner, Walter’s nephew Linwood, has sued to void the gift on the ground that you cannot leave land to a person who does not exist, and that the cabin therefore passes to him.

It is a real question. It is, I realize about ten minutes into the argument, a very old one, and I find that the hair on my forearms has risen, and I lay my hands in the home position on the keys and make myself take it down.

“The common law,” says Linwood’s counsel, a bald man named Kreutz with a voice like a leaf blower, “has long held that a conveyance must have a grantee. A person who is not in being cannot take title. A person who is not in being cannot be served, cannot be heard, cannot object. Your Honor, my client’s late uncle did not leave a gift. He left a wish.”

“Your Honor.” The respondent’s lawyer is a gentle, rumpled woman named Ruiz, who has come in with a banker’s box and a look of private amusement. “Mr. Kreutz has argued that the child cannot be heard. He has therefore made my argument for me. That is exactly why courts appoint a guardian ad litem.”

“Explain it for the record,” says Haskett, which is the thing she says when she wants something to be in the transcript.

“A guardian ad litem is a person the court appoints to stand in a case for someone who cannot stand for herself. A minor, an incompetent, or, as in the old estate cases, an unborn person whose interest is contingent on her birth.” Ruiz hands up a bound page. “The court does not decide for the child.”

“It sees that someone is bound to object on her behalf, and that nothing is done to her interest while she is not there to defend it. Standing, Your Honor, is the right to be heard. A court may grant that right early.”

I take it down. My fingers know the words: guardian, ad litem, contingent, standing. The steno outlines come the way they have come for years, soft, quick, without thought, a little river of chords.

Kreutz says, in his leaf-blower voice, “A person cannot have standing before she is in being.”

“A person can have standing before she is in being,” says Ruiz, “if someone has the courage to give it to her.”

Haskett takes a long time to answer, and in the long time I hear the radiator tick and a juror’s paper cup somewhere in the gallery crackle as it is set on a floor.

“I will tell you what this court is going to do,” she says. “Dana Wetherell’s child, if living at birth and named Hollis, takes. Until then, the cabin is held in trust, and the court appoints a guardian ad litem to represent her. Ms. Ruiz, you will submit three names by Friday.”

“Mr. Kreutz, your client will understand that a will is a letter written by a dead man to someone who cannot yet read, and that it is the duty of the living to hold the door.” She taps her gavel once, the little taps she uses when she means it. “We are adjourned.”

I sit, and my hands do not come off the keys.

The gallery thins. The lawyers pack their boxes. In the back row, with his arms folded and his work coat on, sits a man I have not seen in thirty-six hours, and I do not look at him, which is the same as looking at him.

Calder has not come forward. He is not in my line of sight to talk to me; he is in my line of sight to be seen. He has sat through an hour of probate law on a wooden bench for no reason except that I was in the room. A man standing post, I think. A man doing, in public, the last thing he can think of that is not managing.

On my table, on the corner of the steno stand, there is a cup of coffee. It is from the cart on the ground floor, the one with the dented lid, and it is the exact color I like. I did not see it set down. I look at it for four seconds. Then I look at the back row, and the back row is empty, and the door is swinging softly on its closer.

I leave the coffee where it is. I drink it at 10:40, cold, and tell no one.

“Wren.” Haskett’s voice, from the bench, mild as milk. “A moment, when you have your things.”

Haskett’s chambers are exactly as they were: green blotter, brass lamp, a framed photo of a Labrador long dead, and a window with a view of the parking structure. She takes off her robe, hangs it behind the door, and sits down, and for the first time in six years I see that her hands are not entirely steady.

“I want to ask you something,” I say.

“Of course you do. You have been wanting to since you stood in my courtroom with that face on.” She folds her fingers. “You are going to ask me about a docket.”

“Margo told me that you were a Scribe’s witness in 1987.”

“I was, and I have said what I will say about that.” Haskett looks at the window. “You are going to ask me about a docket, and I am going to tell you that on a day in October of 1994 I was a twenty-eight-year-old clerk in the Marlow County Probate Court, and a woman I knew came in with a manila envelope and asked me to stamp it. She would not let me read it.”

“She would not let me file it in the ordinary docket. She asked for a number from the guardianship series, and she asked that the petitioner be recorded as a person yet unborn.”

“The same Margo.”

“The same Margo.” Something moves behind Haskett’s eyes that is neither a smile nor the opposite. “I told her it was impossible. She said the doctrine was older than I was. I looked it up, and she was right, and I stamped it under protest. The number was 94-GL-0611. It has been in the vault for thirty-two years. Nobody has opened it, because it is sealed on the petitioner’s motion, and the only person who can unseal it is the party it concerns.”

“Me.”

“You,” says Judge Haskett, “once you were in being. And I have been waiting twenty-nine years for you to ask, and I confess, Wren, I had stopped believing you would.”

I sit very still.

“The order named a guardian,” I say. “Didn’t it.”

“It did.”

“Who?”

“I cannot tell you.” She says it quickly, and then very gently. “It is not that I will not. The order is sealed, and I am a judge, and the rule is the rule. But I will tell you something that is not in the file. In thirty-two years I have seen that guardian’s name come across my desk on eleven occasions, always on a sealed objection, always stamped, always on a different date.”

“Eleven times someone has stood up for a person who was not in the room. And each time I thought: how very lonely, to be bound to object, and never be told what you are objecting to.”

“Eleven,” I say.

“Eleven. And the last was filed two weeks ago, on a Tuesday, before the doors were open. I stamped it myself.” She looks at me over her half-glasses, and I see that she is, quite plainly, afraid for me, and has been for a long time. “I am a human judge, Wren. I have no wolves, no machines, no Moot. I have a vault and a stamp.”

“But I will tell you the one thing the law has taught me about being a guardian. It is a promise you keep without an audience. It is the most dangerous kind.”

“Thank you,” I say.

“Don’t,” says Haskett. “Go home. Go to the apartment, or the clinic, or wherever it is you are going. You have a look about you of a woman who is about to be right.”

I pick up my bag. At the door she says, in her bench voice, “And Wren. Eat something. The transcript will keep.”

The rest of the day I take down a plea, a continuance, and a dispute over a boat.

My phone buzzes against the steno stand during the lunch recess. It is Ike, who texts the way other people sneeze, in sudden bursts with no punctuation.

Raman closed the clinic today sign on the door says family matter back Tues. never in a year of mopping. also she asked me Friday if I knew where you park. is that weird. its weird right

It is weird. I type back, Noted. Stay home tonight. Lock the door. Then, because he is twenty-four and will read an order as a dare, I add: Please.

He sends back a thumbs-up and, a moment later, a picture of the three Margo tape boxes in a neat row on my counter, as though he is reassuring me about the safety of a pet. I put the phone face down. Something about the picture bothers me, and I do not know what, and I let it go, which is the kind of thing I will want back.

At the afternoon recess Quade finds me in the corridor. She is in her county windbreaker, a paper sack in one hand, and she does not stop walking, so I fall in beside her.

“Charlie Prue’s file,” she says, low. “The coroner is on leave. As of this morning, a leave he did not request. Somebody wrote it up and it was approved before breakfast.”

“Somebody being the person whose phone number we do not have.”

“Somebody being a person who owns a pen that works on Sundays.” She hands me the sack, which holds a ham sandwich. I do not remember asking. “I took Hester’s Remington to a typewriter man on Fulton. The thumb plate is not an add-on. It is cast into the frame. It is a different machine than the one in the catalogs, Wren. It has a serial number with a letter in it that doesn’t match any year.”

“What letter?”

“C,” says Quade, and then, because she is a detective, she holds up one hand before I can ask the obvious.

She is walking faster now, past the metal detector and the sleepy deputy, who nods at her as at furniture. “My grandmother wrote on the back of her one photograph, in pencil, the year she died. Not a name. A sentence. ‘If it asks, say yes, and mean the smaller thing.’ I have carried that around since I was fourteen and thought it was about a marriage. I don’t think it was about a marriage.”

“It means something. I don’t know what yet. Eat your sandwich.”

She is gone before I can thank her.

I do not eat the sandwich until four. I eat it standing on the courthouse steps, in the long gold light of a November afternoon, with the river down at the bottom of the hill showing its stones and the wind off the water smelling of dry mud. The city is brown and quiet and very pretty, the way a place is pretty when it does not know it is being watched.

I am thinking about eleven objections. I am thinking about WHO STOOD FOR HER WHEN SHE WAS NOT YET and about ASK THE ONE WHO IS BOUND TO OBJECT, which is in the machine’s grammar a command, and in my grandmother’s a favor, and in Haskett’s a warning. I am thinking that someone has been standing up for me for twenty-nine years without ever having once been introduced.

And I am thinking, as I go down the steps, about the clinic.

Dr. Raman’s practice is four blocks from the courthouse, on the ground floor of a brick building that used to be a bakery. Ike has mopped it three evenings a week since the spring, as part of the year he owes the clinic, and the smell of her waiting room, floor soap and old magazines and lavender hand cream, is the smell of the one summer I can remember having a childhood.

She is a short, round, quiet woman with gray in her braid. She has, in all the years she has been my physician, never once asked me a question I could not answer. Ike says she hums. I have never heard it.

And on her cabinet, I remember, standing at my door with my keys, there was a file with my name on it. I saw it in the winter. Age seven.

I have not let myself think about that file since.

I turn the corner onto my own street. The porch light at my building is already on, though it is only half past four, and it is the yellow bug-light that Mr. Delgado at the front keeps on year-round to attract nothing. Under it, on the third stair of my stoop, sits a small woman in a long gray coat with her braid over one shoulder and a manila folder across her knees.

She has been waiting for some time. I can tell by the way she is sitting, the stillness of it, the way you hold your body when you have decided to wait as long as is required and have stopped counting.

She raises her face to me.

“Counselor,” says Dr. Raman, in a low, plain voice, the voice of someone who has rehearsed this sentence for twenty-nine years and has decided to say it badly rather than not at all. “I have been your guardian ad litem since the sixth of October, 1994. I am sorry that I am the one. You are late, my dear. Please, sit down.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!