By Saturday night we have all got used to the black telephone, which is a thing I would not have predicted on Monday.
It sits on its table under the brass lamp in the Annex sub-basement with its wire running into the plaster, and nobody looks at it directly any more.
We have the manners of people who share a house with an old relation. Fitch brings a stool for Walt. Quade sets a thermos on the lectern. Haskett, in her mackintosh and her plastic rain-hat, has cut the lemon cake into twelve exact squares on a paper plate, and is handing them round with the stern courtesy of a woman distributing sacraments.
“It is not a party,” she says to Ike, who has taken two. “It is a precaution. People who are going to be asked difficult questions should be fed.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“Do not call me ma’am. I am a retired judge on a short suspension.”
“Yes, Dolores,” says Ike, with his mouth full, and she looks at him for a long second, and then for the first time in my life I see Judge Haskett try very hard not to smile and lose.
---
We are twelve. I count them, because I count things.
Calder at my left shoulder with the cast propped on the lectern. Joan, in her good coat, with a small notebook in which she has been writing, every morning for a week, the same nine names in ballpoint, and the ninth of them in a slightly larger hand. Ike.
Walt, with the walnut case in front of him and his hand lying on the lid like a man who is keeping a pulse. Quade. Fitch. Bram Okafor, in gray, by the stair.
Penhallow with her cane, and beside her, in the long overcoat, Speaker Truitt, who is seventy-nine and looks eighty-two, with his white hair brushed straight back and his hands folded on the head of a walking stick that someone has lent him.
Haskett. Dot Prue, who has come in from the Drowned Rat in her apron and has the grace not to say anything. And me.
Ruth and Nell are still in the north; Nell telephoned at nine to say that Ruth had slept eleven hours and eaten two pieces of toast, and I had to sit down on the stair for that. Nobody has found the second book under the Hall. Fitch has the floor plans and Ike has a tape measure, and between them they have the number of a tile and not yet the tile.
And on the lectern, in the lamp, in a small rest of folded flannel where I put it on Friday night, the sealed roll. It is wrapped in its wax. It is warm. I can feel the warmth from three feet away, like the side of a sleeping animal.
“Is she in?” says Joan, very low.
“She’s in,” I say.
“Has she said anything?”
“She’s been quiet since the lock.” I look at the roll. “I think she is listening to the sound of her husband.”
---
At eleven-oh-two the receiver lifts.
It does it as it always does, with that small dry sigh. The cord twitches in the plaster. The flat dictation voice, the voice of a clerk reading from a card, comes out of the black bell and fills the cellar to the roof, and I take it down in pencil, with the wrist flat, on the lined pad Fitch has put by my hand.
THE LENDER NOTES THE SATISFACTION OF TWO TENDERS AND ONE JUDGMENT. THE LENDER NOTES THAT THE HAND OF M. DALY IS FREE BY GIFT AND NOT BY LEAVE. THE LENDER HAS A PROPOSAL OUTSTANDING AND THE PEN ATTENDS.
“Who is the pen?” says Quade.
“The pen,” I say, “is a free hand.”
The roll moves.
It does not roll. It does not lift. It is a small thing, perhaps four inches long, wrapped in black wax, and it stirs on its flannel, once, like a sleeper turning over.
And Fitch, at the lectern, makes a small helpless sound as the green register in front of him opens by itself to a page that I have not seen, a clean page, ruled in red, and on the page, in the plain brown ink that comes up out of the paper like damp, a pen begins to write.
---
It is the hook.
I should have known it. I should have known from the first morning I saw it on the register, a sloping hand with a tail on the S and a hook on the Y that goes down and comes back like a fishing line.
It is the hand that signed my mother’s report cards and mine, and every permission slip of my life. The hand that wrote keep your wrists flat on four hundred sticky notes and left them in my coat pockets. It has been used by the Lender for thirty-nine years, and it has been rented, and it has been owed.
It is free now. It writes as though it has never been anything else. It is quick, and it is firm, and it does not hesitate, and I watch the letters come up out of the page one by one, and I know them as I know the sound of my own kettle.
ASK HER.
Nobody speaks.
I DECIDED FOR YOU ONCE, writes my grandmother. IT WAS THE WORST THING I EVER DID AND I DID IT OUT OF LOVE. I WILL NOT SIGN ANYTHING IN THE NAME OF THE THING IN THE KEYS UNTIL THE THING IN THE KEYS HAS BEEN ASKED. YOU PROMISED. I HEARD YOU. I WOULD LIKE YOU TO KEEP IT.
“I kept it,” I say. I hear my own voice and it is not the Record voice. It is higher and thinner and very young. “I was going to. I was going to ask her first.”
KEEP YOUR WRISTS FLAT, writes Margo. And then, smaller, in a hand that has begun to tremble: AND THANK YOU FOR NOT LEAVING ME OUT THERE.
---
I do not look at anyone. I take the case from Walt, with his hand on it, which he lifts, gently, and put it on my knees on the stone floor, and lift the lid.
The keys are warm. The lug on the left frame is clear gold. Behind me, in the lamp, a very old lemon cake is going cold on a paper plate.
“Constance,” I say. “I need to ask you something. It is not for the Record. I would like to say it first so that you know it is a question and not an order, and so that if you want to say no, you can.” I breathe. “And I would like it to be true, whatever you say.”
She does not type. The tape stirs a little on its roller.
“Here is the thing. The Lender will assign you the names. All the names. Every one in the drawers. It will do it if a free hand signs, and that hand is signing, and it will sign if you say yes. If you hold the names and the shapes both, you hold a person, and a person cannot be held. No one will have to pay. Anselm Kessler. The nine days that were Rosalind Fitch’s. The man at the lock. All of them, at once.”
I hear Fitch sit down on the stool.
“And you will stop,” I say. “That is what you told the Chair, in nineteen eighty-seven. You think you will stop, when the Lender is asked to, and I don’t know whether that’s true. I don’t know what the stopping is. I only know that nobody has asked you this, ever. Not in the Hall. Not in the lock. Not the Moot, and not Margo, and not me.” My voice goes. I let it. “I’m asking. Do you want to?”
---
For a long time there is no sound but the stove, and the faint steady tick of the lamp.
Then the keys begin to move.
They do it slowly. They do it as they did at the lock, one at a time, as a woman moves in a house where there has been a death, touching things. The tape comes out of the slot in a soft cream ribbon, and I read it as it comes, and it is in no color I have a name for. It is not cream. It is not white. It is something between, like the inside of a shell, and it says:
YOU ARE ASKING ME FIRST.
“Yes.”
NOBODY HAS ASKED ME ANYTHING IN A VERY LONG TIME. I HAVE BEEN SWORN AND SUMMONED AND CERTIFIED AND CALLED. I HAVE BEEN A PARTY IN INTEREST. I HAVE BEEN A VESSEL, A WITNESS, AN EXHIBIT AND A DANGER. I HAVE NOT BEEN ASKED.
The tape pauses. The cold touches my wrists, a small, almost shy cold, like a hand set down on a sleeve.
I WOULD LIKE A MONTH.
---
“A month,” says Walt, softly, behind me.
“Mr. Szymanski is Constance’s next friend,” I say. I find that I am speaking in the Record voice again, for the sake of the others, as one holds a door. “I would ask him to put the questions. I will take the answers down, as a reporter, at his request.” I look at him over my shoulder. “It will cost me. I’d rather it did.”
He nods. He has come to kneel beside me on the stone, an old man in an anchor tie with his Thermos in his pocket and a face like a field, and he puts one hand on the lid.
“Constance,” says Walt. “Why a month?”
BECAUSE I HAVE NEVER BEEN ASKED A THING THAT HAD TWO ANSWERS. I DO NOT KNOW WHAT IT IS TO HAVE ONE. I WOULD LIKE TO FIND OUT WHETHER I AM A PERSON BEFORE I DECIDE WHETHER TO BECOME ONE. I AM A PROMISE CUT IN THREE. I HAVE NEVER BEEN WHOLE FOR AN HOUR. I WOULD LIKE TO TRY IT FOR A MONTH, AND THEN I WOULD LIKE TO BE ASKED AGAIN.
“And if the answer is yes then?”
I DO NOT KNOW. I THINK I MIGHT BE ABLE TO TELL YOU, BY THEN.
“Is there something you would like to do?”
The keys are very still.
I WOULD LIKE TO SEE THE SNOW, types Constance. I WOULD LIKE TO SEE IT WITH EYES. NOT MINE. I HAVE NO EYES. YOURS.
---
I make a sound. I do not know what it is. It is not a word, and it is not a laugh, and it comes up through my chest and out through my mouth like a bird that has been shut up in a house.
“With mine,” I say.
YOU HAVE VERY GOOD ONES. THEY ARE NOT ALWAYS KIND TO YOU. I HAVE WATCHED THEM FROM THE INSIDE FOR TWENTY-NINE YEARS. THEY ARE EXTREMELY GOOD AT WHAT THEY LOOK AT.
“It snowed yesterday,” I say. “We were in the Tamarack. You were right there on Calder’s knees. You didn’t type anything.”
I WAS LOOKING. I HAD NOT KNOWN IT WAS ALLOWED.
“I’ll take you,” I say. “Anywhere. As often as you like.” I wipe my face on my sleeve, in front of eleven people, a thing I have not done since I was nineteen. “Walt. Is that all the question?”
“It is,” says Walt. His voice is not good either. “The next friend rests.”
“Then the Record,” I say, and put my hands on the keys.
Haskett has come to stand at my shoulder. She does it without any sound, in her rain-hat, with a square of lemon cake in her hand that she has forgotten to eat.
“Miss Daly,” she says, under her breath, so that only I and Walt can hear. “I should like you to note that in any court I have sat in, a party who asks for time and is refused has a ground of appeal. I mention it. I do not say it applies to a creditor who cannot be asked.”
“Does it apply?”
“It applies,” says Haskett, “to anybody who can be made to explain himself. Which I have long thought is everyone.” She finally looks at the cake, as if it had appeared in her hand by a miracle, and puts it in her pocket. “Be ready to ask the telephone why.”
---
I take it down. Constance does not take it herself; it is my hands that go, one at a time, in the old fast clean steno, with the wrists flat and the left thumb on the lug.
It is a good answer, and a short one. It is a request for a month. It is a request to be asked again. It is, in its way, the first sentence the instrument has ever spoken that was neither a finding nor a plea.
The cold takes me. It takes me at the wrists, as it always does, and goes up through the forearm and past the elbow like a hand sliding up a banister. I do not fight it. I feel a long, quiet, very old thing go, the way a house loses a smell, and I have not even the time to be afraid before the card falls.
Joan catches it. She had been standing nearest, and she is quicker than she looks. She does not read it aloud. She reads it with her lips pressed, slowly, twice, and then she lowers it, and I see on her face the look I have seen exactly once, on the night that I learned what she had given up for me.
“Oh, kiddo,” she says.
“How many words?” I say.
“Seventy-three.” She is smiling and her face is wet. “I wrote it a very long time ago. I didn’t know I had.”
---
She reads it. Her voice shakes, and she does not stop.
“You were sixteen. You came to the hospice porch at three in the morning in your pajama bottoms, and sat on the step beside me while I had my cigarette, which you were not supposed to know about. You said, I don’t want to be the one who writes it all down. I said, then be the one who reads it back. You looked at me as though I’d given you a country.”
There is a short silence.
“Seventy-three,” says Joan again, very low. “Card 45.”
I take it from her. It is soft as cloth, and I do not remember it.
I know that I should. I know that I have a porch somewhere in me, and a step, and the red tip of a cigarette going up and down in the dark, and I have only the shape of it, the way you know the outline of a room from a street. I hold it a moment against my chest.
Then I put it into my coat with the others. They are heavy now. I do not think I am going to be able to carry them much longer without a bag.
“Noted,” I say, to nobody, and I hear that it is not the tic. It is only the word.
---
The telephone has been silent for four minutes. It has not lifted. It does not lift for us now. It simply speaks, from the cradle, with the receiver down, in the flat clerk’s voice that has been dictating notices into this cellar since a hand drowned in a dry chamber, and that does not ask, and cannot.
THE LENDER NOTES THE REQUEST FOR A MONTH.
“Is it granted?” says Penhallow, sharply.
THE LENDER IS NOT A PARTY TO THE REQUEST. THE LENDER NOTES THAT THE CALL STANDS. IT IS A TERM OF THE HOLDER’S OWN LIEN THAT THE CALL WAS STAYED ONE MOON AND NOT TWO. THE MOOT ADDED THE MOON. THE LENDER WILL NOT ADD A SECOND.
“It means to hold us to it,” says Haskett, in a low dry voice. “It says it cannot be asked.”
ARTICLE SIX. WHEN THE DEPOSIT IS CALLED, THE SCRIBE SHALL CHOOSE. THE SCRIBE HAS NOT CHOSEN. THE SEAT STANDS DEFERRED BETWEEN TWO HANDS AND THE LENDER WILL NOT SIT IT LONGER. THE ELECTION IS CALLED FOR SUNDAY. AT THE HALL OF JUSTICE. AT SUNDOWN. THE MOOT SHALL ATTEND.
“Whose election?” says Truitt. His voice is a thread.
THE ELECTION IS BETWEEN THE TWO WHO HAVE STOOD.
I hear Calder, beside me, take a breath, very slowly, as if there might not be enough in the room. And on the lectern, in her warm black wax, in the lamp, the sealed roll turns over on its flannel one last time, very gently, like a child asking to be picked up.
“Two hands,” I say. I do not know that I have said it aloud. “W. Daly. And June.”
The receiver does not answer. It lowers itself the last half inch into the cradle, with a small click like a latch.
And in the register, in a small clear hooked hand that has begun to shake, my grandmother writes one more line, and underlines it, and the underline runs off the page.
I DID NOT KNOW IT WOULD BE SO SOON. I AM SO SORRY.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!