Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 21

Two Reports

Joan Tarrow kept the yard’s papers in a tin trunk under the bed in the room where her father had died, and she carried them to the kitchen table at six in the morning like a woman bringing out the family’s worst china.

“I haven’t read the note since the day Hesper signed it,” she said. “I told myself I knew what it said. Sit down. Both of you.”

Iva and Hollis sat. Bram put a pot of coffee in the middle of the table and went to check his traps, which he did whenever a conversation became legal.

The note was three pages, folded in thirds and gone soft at the creases. Tarrow laid it flat and turned it so they could read the first line without touching it.

Promissory note, Carrad Shoal Yard, Hesper Tarrow principal, to Scrip House Marine Credit.

Nobody spoke.

“Scrip House,” Hollis said at last.

“Assigned nine years ago to Harbor Mutual. There’s an endorsement on the back.” Tarrow turned the last page. A line of faded ink read: Assigned without recourse. Harbor Mutual Securities, by L. Pask. “I’d never looked at the first page. I’d looked at the back. The back said Harbor Mutual. I thought that was the whole of it.”

“A coil of rope with a hook,” Iva said.

“Is that what that is?” Tarrow squinted at Iva. “I saw it on his watch chain last night and thought it was a fishing charm.”

“It’s the Scrip House device. It was on the winch on Pell. It’s on the letterhead of a route desk that told a duty officer seven years ago that a return seal applied to freight.” Iva heard herself speaking quickly and made herself slow. “I don’t know that any of that is connected. I’m saying it’s the same mark.”

“Say what you can prove,” Hollis said.

“That the note began with Scrip House. That the man who holds it now wears their device.” She took a breath. “Nothing else.”

“That’s plenty to be getting on with,” Tarrow said. She folded the note. “I won’t act on it. I’ll write down that I saw it. Mr. Pask will get his forty-eight hours, and he’ll get two reports. If it turns out there’s more, we’ll learn it from the frames, not from guessing.”

“Agreed,” Hollis said.

“Agreed,” said Iva.

They finished the coffee in a silence that was not quite unfriendly. When Tarrow went out to unlock the yard gate, Hollis reached across the table and turned the note face down, the way a person might close a book that had said something rude.

*

The trim basin lay behind the yard, a stone-lined pool forty feet across, fed by a sluice from the tide channel. At the far end stood a timber surge gate that could be raised and dropped by a hand winch to throw a wave across the water. In its heyday, Tarrow said, apprentices had spent a third of their training in this basin, learning to read a float’s mood in rough water. It hadn’t been used in years. A crust of green weed lined the walls.

By eight, a crowd had gathered on the bank. A dozen people from the Shoal, mostly retired rope workers and the families of the certified. Dilys stood at the front with her arms crossed. Orrin Voss had brought his wife. Matthias Kell was at the water’s edge with a small copper float on a cradle at his feet, checking a valve with the fixed attention of someone who needed something to do with his hands.

Hollis had a folding table, three sheets of paper, and a stopwatch. He sat on a camp stool at the basin’s lip and laid out the sheets in a row.

“Three failure modes,” he said, to nobody in particular. “Following sea, jammed lever, loss of trim under load. Each builder runs the float through each. I’ll score pass, margin, or fail. I won’t score method. I don’t care how you do it. I care whether it holds.”

Dilys went first. She set her float on the water with a long boat hook, stepped back, and watched it settle. It was a squat, ugly thing, painted a gray that matched the weeds. The surge gate dropped. A hand-high wave rolled across the basin and hit it broadside.

The float rocked, steadied, and settled in less than a count of ten.

Hollis clicked the watch. He wrote.

The jammed lever was harder. Orrin Voss wedged a wooden block under the mechanism, and Dilys tried to trim against it. The float shuddered and began to list.

“Fail,” Hollis said quietly. “Margin of two degrees. It would recover if the crew could clear the block in under a minute.”

“That’s a good result,” Dilys said.

“It’s an honest one.” He wrote. “It’s better than the old method would have managed. Under the old method, a jam in that mode would put the float over.”

“Would it?”

“I’ve worked it through. Your lift curve beats it by about a third.” He didn’t look up. “You don’t need me to say you’re good. I’m writing down the numbers because someone will want them.”

Dilys stared at him for a moment as though he had said something in a language she half remembered. Then she turned away to get her boat hook, and Iva saw her wipe her face with her sleeve.

Matthias went at ten. His float was smaller, black, and surprisingly quiet. When it touched the water it seemed to settle before the ripples reached it. He walked it through the following sea and it barely rocked. He jammed the lever himself, with a block he carved on the spot, and it listed a degree and recovered on its own.

“Margin on all three,” Hollis said.

It was very still on the bank.

“You didn’t tell me it would do that,” Tarrow said, from behind Iva.

“I didn’t know it would.” Matthias knelt to lift the float with a care that bordered on tenderness. “I don’t test them in front of people.”

He didn’t look at Hollis. After a moment he glanced up, and something moved over his face. Not pride. Something closer to alarm.

“Mr. Fen,” he said. “A word.”

“Of course.”

They went down the bank together, out of earshot of the crowd. Iva watched them stop by the sluice, Matthias talking low and fast with his hands at his sides, Hollis leaning on the cane and listening. Matthias said something that took a long time. Hollis said something short. Matthias put a hand over his mouth.

Then Hollis came back up the bank alone, his face carefully ordinary.

He packed up the table. He didn’t look at Iva until the crowd had thinned and the others had gone to eat.

“There’s something I can’t tell you,” he said.

She had been waiting for it, in a way. It still arrived like cold water.

“Is it his story?”

“It’s his. He asked me to keep it. I told him I’d tell you there was something, and that it wasn’t mine to give.” He folded the stopwatch into his pocket. “I said I’d tell him by tomorrow what I intend to do with it.”

“Does it change your report?”

“It might change what’s in it.”

“That’s all I need to know.” She was surprised to find it was true. “Thank you.”

“It’s the rule.”

“It’s your rule too.” She almost smiled. “I’ll hold the door.”

*

She spent the afternoon writing at Tarrow’s kitchen table, with the shed’s four-page log spread in front of her and a cup of coffee going cold at her elbow.

It was slow. She drafted each frame’s entry twice, once in pencil and once in ink. She wrote what she’d heard and how sure she was, and she cut every adjective. Where she’d heard an incomplete instruction, she wrote incomplete. Where she’d heard a man’s voice, she wrote a man’s voice and did not write Hesper Tarrow, because she hadn’t heard a name.

When she reached the section on Matthias Kell’s certificate, she stopped.

The paragraph was already written in her head. Under frame four, a disk commissioned eighteen years ago, the instruction was to hold the apprentice to the method until the yard released him in writing. It did not mention his competence. It did not mention the fairness of the binding. It reported what the instrument had been made to do.

She wrote it. Then she read it back and found, to her annoyance, that it was exactly right and exactly cruel.

“You look like you’re writing a death notice.”

Dilys Perrow stood in the kitchen doorway with her hands on her hips. She hadn’t knocked. The back door was open, as it always was on the Shoal, to let the damp out.

“I’m writing a report.”

“About Matthias.”

“About the frames.” Iva set the pen down. “Come in if you’re coming.”

Dilys came in and didn’t sit. “You’re leaving him bound.”

“I’m saying what the instrument says.”

“That’s what you keep telling everyone.” Dilys’s voice shook with something that wasn’t quite anger. “He’s the best builder on this coast. He’s better than I am, and I’m better than any three people in the Reach. And you’re going to put in a report that says a dead man’s commission is the last word on whether he can do his job.”

“It isn’t the last word. It’s one word, and I’m going to say so.” Iva met her eyes. “I’ll write that the commission is a statement of what the frame was made for and not a finding about his competence. I’ll recommend that Hollis’s results be read alongside mine. I can’t make my report say something different from what I heard.”

“You could leave it out.”

“No.”

“You could say it was unclear.”

“It wasn’t.” Iva kept her voice level. “I’ve told one lie in my life that mattered, and it took seven years and a clerk’s biscuit tin to put right. I’m not going to tell another because the truth is going to hurt someone I haven’t met.”

Dilys stared at her.

“That’s very noble,” she said.

“It might just be cowardice with good manners.”

“Is it?”

“I don’t know. I’d like to think not.” Iva rubbed her shoulder. “But I’d rather you were angry at me than that I’d made it easy for the next person to write it down wrong.”

For a moment Dilys didn’t move. Then she pulled out the opposite chair, sat heavily, and put her elbows on the table.

“Give me a pen,” she said.

“Why?”

“Because I’m going to read the section about me, and then I’m going to find out whether you’ve done it properly.”

Iva handed her the pen, and the two of them bent over the log in the late light, the one reading, the other waiting.

*

Hollis came to the kitchen after supper. He knocked, which Dilys hadn’t, and stood in the doorway with his coat still buttoned.

“Can I sit?”

“It’s the keeper’s kitchen.”

“It’s your table at the moment.” He pulled out a chair. “I’d like to write at the same time as you. Not to compare. Just to be in the room.”

“That’s allowed.”

They set up on opposite sides, her log on her side and his figures on his. The lamp threw a small circle between them. Outside, the wind worked at the shutters. Bram had gone to bed hours ago, and somewhere above, a floorboard creaked as Tarrow turned over.

They wrote for an hour in silence. It was one of the best hours Iva had spent in a month.

At ten, Hollis capped his pen. “Pask will want one document.”

“I know.”

“We could write a table.” He turned a sheet toward her. He had drawn it in square, practical pencil: two columns, each certificate number in the middle, her finding on the left and his on the right, a plain line between. “Not a joint statement. A cross-reference. Each of us signs our own column. Nobody signs the other’s.”

“He’ll say it’s two reports pretending to be one.”

“It is two reports. It doesn’t pretend.” He tapped the line in the middle. “This is the line he’ll be angry about. That’s why it’s here.”

She studied the table. In the left column she could see the shape of her own findings: let them go, let them go, hold. In the right, the shape of his: pass, margin, margin. A row near the bottom showed hold on the left and margin on the right, and the line between them was just a line.

“I like it,” she said. “It’s honest about the gap.”

“The gap is the finding.” He put the pencil down. “I’ve never been good at joint statements. I sign what I’ve seen. I’d like to keep it that way, even with you.”

“Especially with me.”

“Especially with you.” His voice was quieter. “If we blur this, then every time we disagree it’ll feel like a failure. I don’t want that. I’d rather be able to say, Iva heard one thing and I saw another, and both of us were telling the truth.”

“That’s the most romantic thing anyone’s said to me.”

“I’m aware that’s a low bar.”

She laughed. He smiled, the slow one that crooked up on the left, and it did something to her breathing.

He came around the table. She stood, and for a moment they were two people in a lamplit kitchen, neither quite sure who should take the next step.

“I’m not asking for anything tonight,” he said.

“I know.”

“I’d like to kiss you.”

“I’d like that too.”

It was a long kiss, unhurried, with the wind on the shutters and the lamp guttering a little. She felt his hand come up to her jaw, and she put hers against his chest and felt the steady thud under his coat. When they parted he rested his forehead against hers.

“Separate rooms,” he said.

“Separate rooms.”

“I’m going to go back to the tar smell.”

“It’ll be good for you.”

He kissed her once more, lightly, at the corner of her mouth, and went out. The door shut. She stood in the lamp’s small circle and listened to him go down the steps, the soft uneven rhythm of cane and good foot, until the wind covered it.

*

In the morning the wind had dropped, and a thin sun lay across the Shoal. Iva came out of the keeper’s house with her coffee cup in her hand and found Hollis already at the yard gate, waiting.

He didn’t smile. He held up a finger to his lips.

“I need you to see something,” he said quietly. “Before Tarrow. And before anyone else.”

“What is it?”

“I opened frame four last night.” He kept his voice low. “After you went to bed. I had a lantern and a screwdriver and Bram’s permission. He’s a poor witness, but he’s a good locksmith.”

“Hollis.”

“I’ll tell Tarrow I did it. I’m telling you first because there’s a thing in there I can’t make sense of, and I think your hand might.”

He led her to the long shed. The door stood ajar. Inside, a single lantern burned on the stool beside the fourth frame, and its plate lay aside on the floor.

Under the plate, below the felt seat of the core, the cradle had a second compartment she hadn’t known was there. A flat brass stop sat in it, wedged against the lever’s pivot. It was screwed down tight. Hollis had unscrewed it and set it on a cloth.

“This isn’t a trainer’s part,” he said. “It limits how far the apprentice can push the lever. It lets them trim to a point and no further. Everything inside the method is easy. Anything outside it catches.”

“A hold.”

“A hold. A physical one.” He turned the stop over with the tip of the screwdriver. “And there’s this.”

On the underside of the stop, stamped small and deep in the metal, was a mark she knew.

A coil of rope. A hook at the end. Beneath it, a date.

Eighteen years ago. The year Hesper Tarrow took the note.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!