Nobody in the chamber moved for the space of three breaths, and in that time Iva learned a great deal about Serle Maddox.
He did not look at Pask. That was the first thing. A man disowning a colleague in public generally looks at him, once, to see how it has landed, and Maddox did not; he looked at the arbiter, steadily and with respect, as a good waiter looks at a table that has not yet ordered. The second was that he had not sat down.
He stood with the dispatch case in the crook of his arm, and he kept it there, and she understood that it was a prop, that whatever was in it had been read and settled in a hotel room across the street and would not be opened unless he needed an exit.
The third was that Pask had stopped thinking about doors.
“Mr. Maddox,” said Venable. She had put her spectacles on and was regarding him over them. “You have an interesting way of arriving.”
“I’m obliged to you for hearing me, madam. I came as fast as the committee could put me on a boat.” He inclined his head. “The Mutual received, last week, a wire from its trust department. It read, in effect, that the collector of the late Mrs. Dane’s estate had destroyed estate property and that the matter was before you. It said nothing of any letter. It said nothing of an agency.
I read the wire twice and found that I did not know the gentleman’s authority to send it.”
“You are saying he had no authority.”
“I am saying that on the morning I left the capital I asked the committee’s secretary for the file in which Mr. Pask was appointed agent of the late Mrs. Dane’s wax. There was no such file.” He said it quite gently. “There was an index card, which I have seen since, in a drawer at the Redhaven office. It says the letter was withdrawn for personal keeping. It does not say by whose instruction.”
“By his own,” said Wray.
“So I gather, Mr. Wray. And I gather also that there is a clerk, a statement, and a postal card, and I shall not pretend that I have read them with any care. I arrived at eleven.” The smooth face did not change. “I should say only that the Mutual does not adopt, and does not defend, and has never authorized, any paper that appoints Mr. Pask the agent of anyone.
The committee has suspended him from all duty as of ten this morning, by wire, and has instructed me to cooperate with the circuit entirely.”
“Cooperate,” said Hobb, very quietly, as though it were a word in a foreign language.
“Entirely.”
Pask spoke at last. He did it without raising his voice, and so everyone in the chamber heard it.
“Mr. Maddox. I am sorry to have to ask this in public. Did the committee instruct you in what terms to disown me, or did you compose them on the boat?”
“The committee’s instruction was clear.”
“I do not doubt it. I wrote half of the committee’s instructions for six years.” Pask folded his hands again. “It occurs to me that if the Mutual does not know me, it cannot very well know the tally.”
There was the faintest pause. It was not in Maddox’s face; it was in his case, in the arm that held it, which shifted by about the width of a thumb.
“I do not know what tally you mean,” said Maddox.
“I’m sure you don’t.”
“Mr. Pask.” Venable’s voice cut across it, dry as a ruler. “You are not in a position to put questions to counsel. You are in a position to sit down, and you will do it now. Mr. Wray. Is there a warrant before the circuit magistrate?”
“I shall apply this afternoon, madam, on the clerk’s statement.”
“Then until he has one, Mr. Pask will not leave Redhaven. If he does, I shall hold it against him on every occasion for the rest of his life.” She turned a page. “That is not an arrest. It is a warning. Mr. Pask, you may stay for the rest of this, since it concerns you, or go to your hotel and think. I recommend the hotel.”
He stood. For a moment she thought he would speak again. He looked at Iva, directly, for the first time since the corridor, and there was nothing in the look she could use: no hatred, no appeal, only a kind of tired clear attention, as of one professional glancing at another who has done her work better than he expected.
Then he bowed to the chair and went out. The door shut quietly behind him.
---
Venable gave her judgment at ten minutes past one.
She gave it from her bench, without notes, in the flat dry voice with which she had begun the morning before, and she did not look at the tables at all. She looked at the stove.
“I have before me a complaint of destruction of estate property. It was brought by the Mutual, in the person of its trust officer. The Mutual, through counsel, does not now press it, and I note that. I do not take the withdrawal as ending the matter. The wax was not only the Mutual’s concern. It was the estate’s, and the estate belongs to the people who must live with it.”
She put down her pen.
“I find these facts. Ada Dane left a letter, sealed with her wax. It was found by her daughter, the collector of her estate. The collector broke the seal and kept the pieces. She did not list them. She did not ask leave of the circuit before she had them consumed in an experiment. She had warned the cutter and signed his slip. She told this court, the day before yesterday, in a sentence I shall remember, that she had not thought of asking.”
“I find that the wax was part of the estate. It was not the property of any agent, because there was no agent.” She looked at Wray, and then, for the first time, at Iva. “I find that the collector had a duty to list it and a duty to ask, and did neither.
I find that the consumption of the wax served an honest purpose, and in fact established that a die was forged, and that no one was misled but the collector herself, who suffered by it.
“I therefore find the complaint, in its form, not made out, and its substance partly true.”
The stove ticked. Iva stood with her hands behind her back and found that her left one was gripping her right wrist so hard that the skin had gone white.
“The administration continues,” said Venable. “Collector, you are admonished. It is a mild word and I mean it to sting. You will pay to the circuit the sum of forty dollars as costs, being the clerk’s time and Mr. Wray’s, in addition to the sum already ordered, and you will pay it within the thirty days.
You will list every object in the estate, daily, until I discharge you, and you will not take a step in that estate without asking, even if you think I have gone to bed.”
“Yes, madam.”
“The letter of the third of November, as produced, is void. I direct that it be held in the circuit’s custody as an exhibit, with the plates and the tissue and the carbon and the card, under my seal. I refer the question of its alteration, and of the die, and of the certificates, to the circuit solicitor, for such proceedings as he thinks proper.” She took off her spectacles. “That is all. I am going to have my dinner.
I should like, for the rest of the week, to hear of no more paper.”
She rose. There was the shuffle and scrape of benches. Iva did not move. She was doing a sum. It was not an easy sum, and she did it twice, with her eyes on the grain of the table.
Two thousand eight hundred and eighty, and now forty on top of it: two thousand nine hundred and twenty. Paid in so far, two thousand eight hundred and twenty-two dollars and sixteen cents. Ninety-seven dollars and eighty-four.
Yesterday it had been fifty-seven eighty-four. She had thought, for a whole day, that she was nearly clear.
---
Maddox caught her in the corridor.
He did it so well that she did not notice she had been caught. He had waited by the stair window with his back to the light, and when she came out with Hobb on her right and Hollis’s chair going slowly after, he stepped forward with his hat in his hand and said, “Collector Dane. I wonder, might I have five minutes of your time?” in the voice of a man who has already decided that you will say yes.
“She may not,” said Hobb.
“Then Mr. Hobb, you may attend. I’d be glad of it.” Maddox smiled at him. “It is, I think, a matter that will interest you.”
They went into an empty clerk’s room off the corridor, a dusty cell with a table and three chairs and a brass spittoon that nobody had emptied since the spring. Maddox sat. He opened the dispatch case. He took out a single folded paper, and laid it on the table, and did not touch it again.
“I’ll be plain,” he said, “because I think you prefer it, and because I’m told you are no fool. The Mutual has a difficulty. A servant of the Mutual has behaved very badly, and in doing so has given a good many people a good many things to be angry about. The Mutual would like to put that right. It has no wish to spend the next three years in your courts.”
“I imagine not,” said Hobb.
“I am authorized to propose a settlement.” He tapped the folded paper once, lightly. “The Mutual will forgive the restitution of two thousand eight hundred and eighty dollars ordered against the collector, return what she has already paid toward it, and release the fund to be administered as the circuit directs. It will release the lien on the Dane estate and abandon the claim of unremitted fees and penalty. It will see that Mr.
Carrad’s note of eleven thousand dollars is not called, and extend it, on terms to be named by Mr. Carrad’s own counsel.” He raised his eyes. “It will pay your costs, Mr. Hobb. Within reason.”
It was a very large sum of money to put on a table in a dusty room. Iva sat and looked at the folded paper, and for a moment, in the part of her that had been doing sums for a week, it looked like a door.
“In return?” said Hobb.
“A release.” Maddox’s voice was warm and regretful. “Of the Mutual, its officers, its servants and agents, from all claims arising out of the referral program and the loft frames and the certificates, by the estate and by the collector in her own name. It would be a general release. Quite short.”
“And the thirty-five?” said Iva.
“Collector?”
“The thirty-five certificates that my mother adopted. The retests. The girls who have been tested honestly.” She heard her own voice, very steady. “Nell Ansley. Do they release too?”
“They would not be parties.” He spread his hands. “They would be free to bring their own claims, in principle. But a release by the estate would bar any claim founded on the estate’s rights, and I shall be honest, I think the girls’ claims are very much founded on the estate. The loft was the estate’s. The scoring was done on the estate’s frame.”
“So they’d be left with nothing.”
“I would not say nothing. The Mutual would honor the retests where the girl’s own results are sound.” He smiled. “At its own discretion.”
“And the other frames?”
She had not meant to say it. It was only that the word had been sitting in her since midnight, like a stone in a boot, and it had got out.
Maddox’s smile did not alter. But the paper on the table moved, a very little, under his fingers, as if the hand had pressed it flat.
“I’m afraid I do not follow.”
“Mr. Dunmore says there are twelve.”
“Mr. Dunmore is a very troubled young man.” He turned the paper round and slid it across, open, with his forefinger on the heading of a list. “I’ll show you the schedule. It’s no secret. It names the frames and devices the release covers, for the avoidance of doubt.”
She read it. It was a short list, in a lawyer’s small clear type. The loft frame at Carrad Shoal, number twelve. And above it, in a column, with the same small clear type, as if there were nothing in it to remark on: Frames numbered one to eleven, at the stations listed in Schedule B, with all cores, auxiliary devices and associated records, whether in situ or withdrawn for maintenance.
“Withdrawn for maintenance,” said Hobb.
“Routine.”
“When?”
“I could not say. I’m told that the committee ordered a general inspection, three months ago.” Maddox looked mildly puzzled. “It is a very old schedule. It was drawn by my firm last winter as a precaution. It is not the Mutual’s wish to hide anything. The opposite.”
Three months ago. Three months ago nothing in her own life had yet gone wrong, and somebody in an office had already been unscrewing frames. She knew, with a kind of cold clarity, what Hollis would say when she told him. Cores withdrawn from eleven frames before anyone asked.
“Eleven frames,” she said, “and no one allowed to look at the cores.”
“I should say that is rather less than the truth.” Maddox’s voice was gentle as a nurse’s. “I should say they are safely stored. Collector, I’d like you to consider what I’m offering. You have a year of trouble before you, in my honest estimate, and a fund you cannot pay and a friend who cannot walk. I am offering to take all of it away. In exchange for the right to sue a company with, I might say, a great many lawyers.”
“Not a right to sue. A right to say what happened.”
“It comes to the same.”
“It does not.” She stood up. “Mr. Maddox. My mother wrote, in her last letter to your Mutual, that no one at the Mutual was to hold her wax or her name. I have spent this week proving she meant it. If I sign that, I put her name on the one paper she’d never have pricked.”
“I should not call it that.”
“I know you would not.” She pushed the schedule back across the table. “Mr. Hobb, I think we’ve heard it.”
Hobb rose with a perfectly blank face. At the door, Maddox said, in the same pleasant voice, as though it were an afterthought:
“The offer stands until tomorrow noon. After that I am afraid I must lay certain matters before the committee, which meets at two. One of them is the note of Mr. Carrad’s. It has not been called, you’ll understand. It has only been put on the list.”
“And if I do not sign?”
“Then it will be discussed,” said Maddox, “as every item must be.”
---
She told Hollis in the cab. She told it without leaving anything out, and when she had finished he sat for a long time with his hand over his mouth and his eyes on the wet streets sliding past.
“Cores withdrawn from eleven frames,” he said at last, “three months ago.”
“Yes.”
“Before Senn ever came to the Shoal. Before Pip’s test was cancelled.” He shook his head. “It means someone at the Mutual knew, three months back, that this was going to be looked at. It means this isn’t Pask’s design. It’s older. It’s the Mutual’s, and Pask is a man who stood in front of it, and when it began to tip he was the first thing it shed.”
“And I said no.”
“You said no.”
“I’m short ninety-seven dollars and eighty-four cents.” She laughed, because there was nothing else to do. “I turned down nearly three thousand dollars because of a pin. It was my mother’s, I know. But, Hollis, I did it in about four seconds.”
“It took you eleven,” said Hollis. “I counted.”
She turned and looked at him. He was gray with fatigue, and the knee was propped on the opposite seat, and he looked back at her with that grave tired attention she had come to find so hard to meet.
“It was right,” he said. “I’d have done it a good deal slower. And been wrong.”
“You’d have said Carrad’s note was too much to lose.”
“I would have said so. Then I’d have heard myself say it.” He took his hand from his mouth. “I’m a man who wants Nell’s retest to be worth something. If we sign that paper, they’re all just a story. It would be easy. And it would be the one dishonest thing either of us has done.”
The cab jolted over the bridge of planks. Down the river, past the wharves, the long white shape of the afternoon packet lay at its moorings, and a thin plume of coal smoke trailed from it, and she thought, of nothing at all, that somewhere out beyond the harbor a man called Senn was on a boat, with a bag and a hat and a face that had seen a ghost.
“It’s tomorrow at noon,” she said. “Maddox’s offer. And the committee at two.”
“Then we’ve the night,” said Hollis. “And Carrad.”
“And what do I say to Carrad?”
“Nothing, I think,” said Hollis. “I think he’ll say it to you.”

