Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 49

The Hand That Shakes

Garrity had meant to keep him off the stand.

Petra understood that from the way the heavy lawyer rose, and from what he did with his gold pen, which was to hold it by the cap and tap its point on the table twice, a signal that Denner had plainly been taught to read. A respondent had the right to decline to testify. Garrity said so, courteously, to the dais, and said that his client was seventy-nine and on oxygen, and that his client’s counsel did not propose to call him.

“I haven’t asked you to,” said Kell. “The Board has questions of its own, which are permitted to it by the rules, and which Mr. Denner may refuse to answer. I’d like to hear from him directly whether he wishes to do that. Mr. Denner. Can you hear me?”

“I can hear you,” said Denner.

It was the first time Petra had heard his voice in fifteen years, and it did something to the back of her neck. It had shrunk. The big warm baritone that had called every woman in the office dear was now a dry thread of a sound, pitched a little too high, with a catch in it at the end of each phrase where the oxygen tube pulled at his breath.

“You’ve been advised of your rights.”

“I have.” He did not look at Garrity. “I’d like to answer. It’s what I came for.”

“Aubrey,” said Garrity, very low.

“I know what you’re going to say, Ted. You’ve said it for three months, and you’ve been right every time.” The glasses turned toward the dais. “I’d like to answer, if the Board will let me. I’d rather not do it standing. I couldn’t.”

They did not make him mount the stand. The clerk wheeled the microphone down to the end of the right-hand table on its gooseneck, and Denner sat behind it in his plaid blanket, with the canister ticking at his knee and his lawyer’s hand not quite touching his arm.

---

“Mr. Denner,” said Kell, “I’ll begin with a simple question. Did you prepare, sign or approve the sixty-one vacancy certifications that bear your firm’s stamp?”

“I approved them. Some I signed. After the first few years I stopped signing, and put a surveyor’s name on the surveyor line. It was my instruction.”

“Why?”

“Because I didn’t want my name on them.”

A pause. In the gallery a pen stopped.

“I’d like to say that more precisely,” said Denner, “because Ted will say I’m being cute. I’m not. I didn’t want my name there because I knew that a name on a sheet is a person. If the Register said Aubrey Denner certified this parcel as vacant, somebody would someday knock on my door and ask me whether it was. If it said a surveyor, a field man, a pair of boots, it was a form. A form can’t be asked.”

His mouth quivered. “That’s what I thought. I was very clever.”

“Did you know the parcels were occupied?”

“Some.” He lifted a hand from the blanket and let it fall. “I knew about Bellwether. I read about it in the paper in the fall, after the rescue. I read that there’d been eleven. I’ve had that line in my head every night for two months.”

His voice thinned. “I hadn’t known there were eleven. I knew there were people. I told myself the number was small.”

Petra sat very still. At the left-hand table Pryor had put down his pen.

“And Garnet Row?” said Kell.

“I knew Garnet Row. I knew about the long unit. Five tenants, weekly men, millhands. They had a landlord who wasn’t the owner, and the owner who sold it to Mr. Fenn was in a hurry.” He took a breath that rattled. “I’m going to tell you how that happened, and I’d ask Ted not to stop me, because he’s right about everything but this.”

---

The firm that had come to him, he said, was not the owner and was not the buyer. It was a company named Haskell Holdings. It had no office he ever saw. It had a post office box and a registered agent and a telephone number that rang through to a service. It had one signature, and he had never learned whose.

“It had a letterhead,” said Denner. “I remember the letterhead because it was the first time I’d been given paper that was heavier than my own. Cream, with a watermark. Not Haskell’s. The paper came from the agent, from the firm that handled their survey and grade work, who had the account. A big old outfit with a downtown address. Pellworth Grade and Survey.”

Garrity said, “Aubrey.”

“They were senior to me. They were the people one called when the work was bigger than a two-man shop, and they’d given me a lot of it. I owed them.” He steadied his breath. “Mr. Pellworth himself rang me. The senior. He said Haskell had a small matter. A purchaser would close in a week on a mobile-home park, and the survey would need to match the county’s count. The county’s count was nine. The ground held ten.”

“Ten what?”

“Ten units. Ten pipe markers. One too many.” A cough broke the sentence, and he waited for it to pass. “He said there was one long unit, past the chain, that had been used as a bunkhouse by the previous owner, and that it hadn’t been inspected or permitted. It wasn’t, as he put it, on the books.

He said the buyer didn’t want to inherit it, and the county didn’t want to know. He said if I’d certify the parcel as nine units and one vacant structure, Haskell would take care of the rest.”

“The rest?”

“The tenants. The unit. They’d be relocated. Paid something. There’d be paperwork.” He lifted his shaking hand. “It sounded like a courtesy. It sounded like the way things were done. I struck the word Occupied on the sheet, and wrote Vacant, and I initialed it, and I asked Walter Fenn to countersign, because he was the buyer, and he wanted the sale to close. He didn’t ask why either.”

“Mr. Denner,” said Brandvold, “did you ask the tenants?”

“I asked one.” He closed his eyes. “On the day. At the lane. A young man with a duffel bag. I had a clipboard and a form that Pellworth’s office had drafted, and a check. I said it was a formality. I told him I’d get a witness, and I took the form to my car.”

“Who was in your car?”

“A girl from the office. She rode with me that week to carry the clipboard and keep the forms in order. I handed it through the window and said it needed a witness name. She asked whose. I said the girl who’d done the stakes. It was a name already on the forms in the car, and the girl was gone, and I thought, if anyone ever looks, it will look like her work. It was a name nobody would hurt.”

The eyes opened. “I didn’t watch her write it. I didn’t want to. I was ashamed for about the length of the drive home.”

A sound passed along the gallery, like a hand dragged over cloth.

He turned in the chair, with an effort that made the canister rock, and looked directly at Petra.

“I’m sorry,” he said. “The name was mine to give, and I gave it. I’d like it written down that I said so.”

She could not speak. Pryor’s hand came down, very lightly, on the edge of her sleeve.

---

For several seconds nobody moved. Then Garrity spoke, and for the first time all day his voice was not smooth.

“Madam Chair, my client is exhausted. I ask for a brief recess.”

“Denied. Mr. Denner is speaking of his own volition and the Board can hear him.” Kell leaned forward. “Mr. Denner, you’ve said a name was put on a witness line in your car. Did you write the cards?”

“What cards?”

“The postcards. Twelve years’ worth. Gray stock, printed, with a rubber stamp reading Received, Paid Through, and a signature in the name of Cora Bale.”

“I’ve never seen one,” said Denner, and the bewilderment in his voice was so complete that Petra, who had come to this room prepared to hate him, felt it as a kind of cold. “I don’t know what you mean. A card.”

“Mr. Weir has found them, preliminarily, to be the work of one hand. A simulation. A very good one.”

“I couldn’t have written a signature in nine years.” He held up both hands. They shook like leaves in a draft. “Look at them. I’ve had the tremor since I was seventy. I can’t sign a check. I stamp my name. My wife used to sign my correspondence, God rest her. I couldn’t have done it. I wouldn’t have known how.”

“Who could?”

“A good clerk. A very good clerk.” He closed his hands in his lap. “Vera Sloan wrote the rule. I know that now. But she couldn’t make a loop, even then. Her hand was bad. And I don’t know the other girls. There were two or three who came through the office. One of them rode with me that week. A farm girl from out past the line.”

“Nan Pruitt,” said Pryor, softly. He had not stood. He had said it to the table. But the microphone was close.

“Pruitt,” said Denner. “Yes. I’d forgotten the name. She had a lovely hand. I told Vera we should keep her.” His voice trailed. “She left, I think. I don’t know. I can’t tell you where.”

“Mr. Denner,” said Kell. “I’m going to show you a clause.”

The clerk brought a page down from the dais. It was the covenant, the real one, a photocopy of the notarized closing document that Tamsin Bright had found on Tuesday. The page was marked with a yellow tab.

“You haven’t seen this, to your knowledge?”

Denner pushed his glasses onto his forehead, held the page a foot from his face, and squinted. His lips moved down the lines. He had reached the bottom of the first paragraph when his breath caught and held.

“Read it aloud, please,” said Kell.

“I’d rather not.”

“I’d rather you did.”

He cleared his throat. “Section nine. Custodian of Receipts. The Owner shall designate a custodian to acknowledge payment, in writing, on the first of each month, of each Occupancy Maintenance Installment. The custodian shall be a natural person known to the occupants. The initial custodian shall be Cora Bale.”

The paper began to shake, and he lowered it to his knee, but his voice went on. “Her acceptance of the office shall be conclusively presumed by her signature on the first receipt issued hereunder, and she shall be deemed to hold the office, and the liabilities attendant on it, until released in writing by the Beneficiary.”

Petra had not known she had stopped breathing until she heard her mother, in the back row of the gallery, let out a single sharp sound, like a cough.

She turned. Cora had risen in the row behind Lindqvist, in her gray cardigan, with her coat over her arm. Her face was white. Her mouth was open a little, the way the mouths of people open when they have been struck from behind, with the pain not yet arrived.

“Is that you?” Kell said, quite gently, to the gallery. “Mrs. Bale?”

“I never agreed to that,” said Cora. “I didn’t know there was a covenant. I didn’t know there was an office.”

“No.” Kell looked at the page and then at the old man. “I don’t think you did. I think a woman who was handed a notebook in a trailer park, and who wrote a single receipt that she denies writing, was written into a contract the next day without being told. And that the signature on the first receipt was supplied to make the contract work.”

She put her fingers to her temples. “And I think a very good simulation has been standing in for you, Mrs. Bale, every first of the month for twelve years. Not to pretend the tenants had paid. To pretend you were the one receiving it.”

---

She asked Cora a few questions, after that, because there was no way not to. She did it with the gloves off, with grave courtesy, and Cora answered from her row of the gallery, standing, because she would not be wheeled to a stand. Lindqvist stayed at her elbow and said nothing at all.

Did Cora accept money from Mr. Denner on the day of the move? Yes. Sixty dollars in cash, for the truck and the day. She had kept it. She would return it, if it could be returned to anyone.

Did she know the name Haskell? No. Pellworth? She had heard it once, on a sign.

Did she know that a person was using her name to receive money from five tenants? She had learned it yesterday, from a mechanic with a cap in his hands, at a table with a clock that ran slow. She said it in an ordinary voice. At the end of it, in the same voice, she added a thing no one had asked her.

“I’d like Mr. Dray to know I’m not going to rest until his cat’s name is on something. I don’t mean a monument. I mean a line in the record. It was a small cat. It had an eye that didn’t close.”

Kell wrote something. The stenographer, who had been taking down the whole day with a face of stone, wiped his own eye with the back of one hand and went on typing.

Denner had stopped answering. He sat behind the microphone with the covenant on his knee, and his head had begun to droop forward. The canister at his knee ticked faster. Garrity, who had been standing the whole time, came round the table at last in two long strides and crouched by the wheelchair with a hand on the old man’s wrist.

“Madam Chair,” he said, very quietly. “He’s not well.”

“No,” said Kell. She stood. She was a taller woman than she looked in the chair, and in the cold light of the room she seemed, for a second, tired past anything the hearing could ask of her. “The Board will adjourn for the day. We will resume tomorrow at ten. Mr. Garrity, you will see that your client has medical attention tonight. Madam Clerk, a nurse from the building, please.”

“Aubrey,” said Garrity, with his hand on the thin wrist. “Aubrey. You’re done. It’s all right.”

“It isn’t,” said Denner.

He said it clearly, in the old baritone, for one moment, as if the voice had been waiting in the bottom of the canister. His glasses had slipped to the end of his nose. He was looking at Petra again, not at her face, at her hands, at the way she had pressed them flat on the table.

“Ten years,” he said. “They said ten. It was to be ten, no more. They wrote it down.” He swallowed, and the voice thinned. “It’s been twelve. Somebody has been paying past the end.”

Kell turned the covenant’s page with one finger. “Section four of this document says in perpetuity, Mr. Denner. Who told you ten?”

His mouth opened. “Mr. Pellworth,” he said. “The senior. He said”

But the nurse was there, a calm young woman with a bag, and Garrity had straightened to put his body between the wheelchair and the room, and the canister ticked and ticked. Denner shut his eyes. His head went back against the chair, and the thin shaking hands on the blanket came, one at a time, to rest.

“Ten,” said Pryor, to nobody, to his notepad. “Ten years in his ear and forever on the paper. Either somebody lied to him, or somebody changed the terms. And the box holds a hundred and twenty cards ahead.”

He did not finish the sum. Petra finished it for him, in a flat voice, while the gallery rose in its seats and the clerk’s voice said, over the murmur, that the Board was adjourned.

The cards had begun to run twelve years ago. They would run ten more. Somebody had planned for twenty-two.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!