Kell did not bang anything. She took off her glasses, set them on the dais, and waited until the room had run out of sound on its own.
“Mrs. Fenn,” she said, “you are not a party to this matter, and I am not going to put you through an oath you have not volunteered for. But a document purporting to carry your signature has just been placed in the Board’s record. I would like to hear from you for two minutes, sworn, if you are willing. Your advocate may stand beside you.”
“I’m willing,” said Odalys.
She came down the aisle in her good blouse with Audra at her elbow, and took the oath with her free hand pressed flat against her sternum, as if to keep something in. At the stand she looked small. She also looked, Petra thought, more like herself than she had at any time since the day the freeze notice came: upright, angry, and entirely unafraid of the microphone.
“I’m Odalys Fenn. I own Garnet Row Park. My husband was Walter Fenn.” She took a breath.
“This morning I woke at six. I fed the dog next door, because the Voss girl’s away, and I fed the cat in Unit 3, because Pearl’s knee is bad. I did the tees and the meter. I took the bus here. I got here at ten. I haven’t been near a notary, or a lawyer, or any firm called Haskell, in my life. And I told the Board on Tuesday I wouldn’t sign their paper. I said so in writing.”
“Is that your signature?”
The clerk carried the sheet down. Odalys took it in both hands and held it far from her face, the way people do with letters from the tax office. For a long moment she studied the bottom of the page.
“It looks like mine,” she said. “It looks like my best one.” Her mouth twisted. “I don’t write like that. I write like a person who’s got eleven things to do. That’s me on a day I’ve had a nice cup of tea and a whole afternoon.”
“Thank you,” said Kell. She took the page back, handled it by the edge, and studied it herself for some seconds.
Then she said, in the tone of a woman reading out a bus timetable, “The Board will direct that this document be sealed and handled by gloved hands from this moment. Mr. Rusk, you will find out who notarized it, at what address, and in front of whom. Mr. Pryor, I’ll hear no objection from you or Mr. Garrity. Mr. Weir will be asked to attend this afternoon at three. We resume with Ms. Bale.”
Petra rose. Her legs were not quite her own.
---
She had been told it would be short, and for the first ten minutes it was.
Kell asked her to state her name and the allegations against her as she understood them. She did. Kell asked whether she wished to say anything, in her own words, about the work she had done at Denner Survey in the year she was nineteen. Pryor had written it in a single page. She knew it by heart, and she said it as written, in the plain voice he had told her to keep.
“I worked at the firm from June to the following August. For the first six weeks, I was a stake setter. I drove survey pins on lots that the crew chief assigned me, according to numbers he gave me. I did not ask what the pins were for. I was told they were property markers and I believed it, though I had a feeling, at the time, that I ought to ask.
After those six weeks I was moved into the front office, where I did mail, copying and filing. I had access to the office stamp and the card cabinet. I signed nothing on behalf of the firm. I initialed six certification sheets as the person who had personally set the stakes. I did not know what the sheets were certifying.”
She stopped. Nobody coughed. A pencil rolled across a table and was stilled by a hand.
“I did not know about the sheets after I left, and I did not know what happened on the parcels afterward.” She laid her hand flat on the paper. “I know what the sheets did now. I’m not going to say I’m sorry in a way that sounds like a defense. I’m saying I was there, and I set the stakes, and the sheets were wrong.”
“Thank you, Ms. Bale,” said Kell. “That is the plainest statement I’ve heard from a respondent in this room in some years.” She sat back. “Mr. Garrity.”
Garrity unfolded himself from the chair like a man opening a ladder. Behind him, in the wheelchair, Denner had raised his head. He was looking at Petra, for the first time since morning, with the unfocused attention of someone searching a crowd for a face.
“Ms. Bale,” said Garrity. “I’m going to be brief. I understand you’ve had a long day.”
“Thank you.”
“You said you signed nothing on behalf of the firm. Did you ever apply the office stamp to a document?”
She had known the question was coming. Pryor had run it past her four times on Tuesday night, in the lodge dining room, with a salt shaker and a sugar caddy for props, and every time she had given the same answer. It still caught in her throat.
“Yes.”
“On how many occasions?”
“I don’t remember. I did the mail. When Mr. Denner or Mrs. Sloan handed me a stack that needed stamping I would stamp it. A few hundred times, maybe.”
“On green certification sheets?”
“I may have.” She kept her eyes on his. “I’d say probably. If they were in the stack. I stamped what I was given. I didn’t read all of it. I should have.”
“Thank you for that.” Garrity made a note with the gold pen. “You understood, did you not, that the stamp was shared by several people in that office? That it could be taken from the drawer by anyone who had the key?”
“I knew the key hung on a hook.”
“And that the person with the hook, in your tenure, was you.”
“Yes.”
“So when Mr. Tern testifies that the stamp was in the keeping of the youngest person in the office, and when your initials appear on six sheets and the stamp’s nick on all sixty-one, you will see that a reasonable person might ask which hand lifted it from the drawer on the other fifty-five.”
Pryor stirred. “Objection. Is there a question?”
“There is. Ms. Bale, you’ve heard it.”
“I heard it,” said Petra. “The answer is that I stamped what I was given in the fourteen months I was there. I didn’t stamp anything after I left. I wasn’t in the building. You can ask Mrs. Sloan.”
“Mrs. Sloan,” Garrity said mildly, “was the person who asked for you to be named on the Register, I’m told.”
“She was the person who wrote a rule that named me. That’s different, and she’s said so under oath.” Petra heard the edge in her voice and drew it in. “And I’d like to say, since you’ve asked, that I didn’t know about the rule until Saturday.”
“Of course.” He tucked the gold pen into his breast pocket. “Let’s turn to something else. I’m going to show you a document from the copy of the exhibit list that was given to you in discovery. Exhibit thirty-one, page four, the margin.”
The clerk set a photocopy in front of her. In the margin of a page of numbers, someone had written a line of pencil in a thin sloping hand. She had seen it a dozen times, and had asked herself every time why it made her wrist go cold.
Ask P.B. about the lane.
“Do you recognize that note?”
“It was on the copy that was sent to me. I don’t know who wrote it.”
“It’s your name, Ms. Bale. Or your initials.”
“It’s the initials that appear on nine sheets. Six are mine. Three I’ve told the Board aren’t.” She kept her voice level. “I don’t know who wrote it. It isn’t my handwriting. I’ve never called that place a lane in my life. I’ve heard the word from Mrs. Fenn and from the tenants. But no one in the firm used it.”
“No one?”
“We said access drive. The turnaround. The chain.” She frowned. “Mr. Denner said the lane. In the field. Sometimes. I remember him saying it once to the crew chief, and nobody else.”
She had not meant to say it. It had come up from somewhere under the sentence, like a stone coming up under a plow. She heard it land in the room.
Garrity’s face did not move, but his shoulders did, a quarter inch, like a man hearing a car pull up in the drive.
“I’d like that clarified,” he said. “You’re testifying that my client used the word lane to describe the access chain at Garnet Row.”
“I’m testifying that I remember him saying it once. Fifteen or sixteen years ago, when I was at a gate with a pail of stakes, and I wasn’t paying attention.” Petra turned to the dais. “I can’t say whether he wrote the note. I’d only say that if somebody wanted to write Ask P.B. about the lane, they’d have to have been in the habit of saying lane. And I think it’s a short list.”
“Move to strike the last sentence,” said Garrity.
“Granted,” said Kell. “The Board will disregard the speculation. It will not, I should add, forget the fact.”
Behind Garrity, the wheelchair creaked. Denner had turned his head toward her. He was looking at her now with open, helpless attention. His lips moved. He might have said something, or only breathed.
---
Garrity had one more subject, and he went to it the way a man goes to a locked cabinet in a house that is not his.
“Ms. Bale, you’ve told the Board you currently have a suspended license.”
“Yes.”
“And that for some weeks you’ve lived in temporary lodging and held no regular employment.”
“Yes.”
“And yet your counsel’s disclosure to the Board records a payment to you of three hundred and sixty dollars, a few weeks ago, for the assembly and installation of a dining table.”
“A table assembly,” said Petra. “It was a flat-pack. A family had bought it and couldn’t put it together. It wasn’t contracting. It was four hours with a hex key. I told the Board the date and the amount in my first supplement, and I took it to my counsel before I took the job.”
“Did you inquire whether assembling furniture for money, while a license is suspended, violates the terms of the suspension?”
“I did. Mr. Pryor read the order and the guidance and told me it didn’t. A table’s not a structure.”
“But it was a paid job.”
“It was.”
“And your insurance had lapsed at the time.”
Pryor rose. “Objection. Relevance. The insurance relates to contracting work, which she was not doing.”
“I’ll allow one question on it,” said Kell. “I want to hear what the respondent will say.”
Petra looked at her hands. She thought of the policy ending at noon on a Friday, and the truck keys put away, and the small flat bright cash in an envelope she had been saving since August.
“The policy lapsed because I couldn’t afford the installment. I chose between the policy and the bus pass and food for my daughter, and I took the bus pass and the food. I’d do it again.” She raised her eyes. “I know it makes me look like a bad bet. I’d rather be a bad bet who’s honest about the arithmetic.”
There was a small noise in the gallery, a single hand clap, quickly stifled. Kell looked up, and the clapping stopped as if a plug had been pulled.
“Nothing further,” said Garrity, after a moment.
“I have three questions,” said Brandvold, mildly, from the right-hand end of the dais. She had not spoken all day. She spoke now with the dry unhurried courtesy of a woman who had spent twenty years asking contractors why a wall was out of plumb. “Ms. Bale, when you drove those stakes, did you do so under the supervision of a licensed surveyor?”
“The crew chief was licensed. Yes.”
“Was the crew chief ever present when you set a pin?”
“Sometimes.” Petra thought. “Not at the end. On the last day he had me finish alone. He’d been called away. He left the pail and a list.”
“Do you still have the list?”
“No.”
“But you’d know it if you saw it.”
“I think I’d know my own handwriting on a list I made,” said Petra, “if I made it.”
“”It’s a good answer,” said Brandvold, and made a note.
---
The Board broke for fifteen minutes. In the corridor a deputy from the clerk’s office presented Pryor with a slip bearing the hearing room’s hourly rate, the stenographer’s rate, and the minutes of delay. It came to four hundred and ten dollars. Pryor read it with his lips pressed and handed it to Petra, and she folded it twice and put it in her coat pocket beside the loaner phone and a bus transfer.
“It’s less than I feared,” he said.
“It’s two weeks of Tilda’s lunches.”
“I’ll ask for a payment schedule.” He looked, very briefly, a man in his sixties with a cardigan and a broken radiator at home. “Ms. Bale. That answer about the lane.”
“I shouldn’t have said it.”
“You shouldn’t have, and I’d like to buy you a drink for saying it.” He took off his glasses and rubbed the bridge of his nose. “He’s not going to like it. A man like that doesn’t remember a word he used in a field twelve years ago. But he’ll remember hearing it said in a room. It might be the first thing Garrity’s been unable to prepare him for.”
At two minutes to three, a hush went down the corridor like a draft. Weir arrived by the side door, a tall bent man with a cane and a bad hip, in a corduroy jacket, being pushed in a Board wheelchair by an embarrassed intern. He was carrying a leather case on his knees, and when he passed Petra he lifted two fingers from its handle in a sort of salute and said nothing.
---
They put the ratification under the Board’s own glass, a stand-mounted magnifier on a flexible arm that the clerk’s office used for notary seals, and Weir examined it standing, with the intern holding the wheelchair brake and one hand ready to catch.
He took twelve minutes. He had asked first for a sheet of white paper and a ruler and the lights dimmed. He did something with a pen light, held almost flat to the page. He did not speak. At one point he made the small noise, hm, and Pryor, who had learned, did not lean forward.
At the end, he straightened, with an effort.
“I’ll give the Board three observations,” said Weir. “I’m going to keep them short, because I’ve been asked to say only what I can see. First, the signature in the name of Odalys Fenn was made by the same writer who made the other fourteen questioned items. The construction, the slowness, the even pressure. I’d put it at the same level of confidence. It is a simulation of a woman’s hand by a person who is not tired.”
“The second observation?” said Kell.
“The ink is wet.” He said it simply. “I mean that it has not cured. If you press a clean thumb to the bottom edge of the page, as I’m not about to do, you would lift a little blue. The ink on those twelve gray cards was dry as a bone, as you’d expect. This was written today. Within a few hours.”
“At eight-forty,” said Kell.
“I’d say that’s consistent.”
“And the third?”
Weir bent again, and with one long tweezer drew the edge of the signature line a quarter-inch toward the light. Under the glass Petra saw nothing, and then, as the angle shifted, she saw it: a faint gray groove beneath the blue, running along the baseline in the exact shape of the name.
“There’s a pencil underlay,” said Weir. “Someone drew the signature first, very lightly, then inked over it. It isn’t a freehand signature at all. It’s a tracing. A drawing of the name, laid down in lead, and then filled.” He set down the tweezers. “A person who does that is not confident. They are careful. They’re being as careful as I would be if I were making a thing I couldn’t afford to get wrong.”
“Which means?” said Pryor.
“I don’t know what it means. I’d say it means whoever did this has a model sheet in front of them. And that they don’t have all of Mrs. Fenn’s signature in their wrist yet. The practice sheet you’ve shown me from Mrs. Sloan’s biscuit tin, with the forty copies of Odalys, would be the model.”
He lowered himself into the wheelchair with a grunt, and the intern, red to the ears, stepped into place behind it.
“One more thing, because it’s the sort of detail I’d regret not mentioning.” Weir looked toward Kell, over the top of his glasses. “The paper isn’t the paper of the cards. It’s heavier. Cream laid, a cotton blend, not the cheap gray stock. It’s good paper. A firm buys it by the ream, for letters of consequence. And somebody bought it recently, because it hasn’t yellowed at the edge, and the cut is clean.”
He nodded to the intern. The wheelchair began to turn.
“Mr. Weir,” said Kell, “the Board is grateful.”
“No, ma’am,” said Weir. “It isn’t. But thank you.”
The side door closed behind him. Kell looked down at the sealed page for a long moment, and then, with her hands folded before her, at the left-hand table, and then the right.
“Mr. Garrity,” she said. “The Board will hear your client next.”
Denner’s hands, on the plaid blanket, had begun to move again.

