Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 13

Request for Public Records

Form PR-7 has eleven boxes, and I filled in nine of them before the woman behind the counter told me I had used the wrong pen.

“Blue or black,” said Mrs. Dellaverna, without looking up. “Never red. Never gel. The scanner reads gel as a smear.”

“This is black.”

“This is a very dark blue.” She slid a different pen across the counter, a county ballpoint on a beaded chain, and I felt the old comfort of being corrected by a person who is correct. It was Monday morning, nine-oh-five, in the Clerk of the Board’s office on the first floor of the courthouse annex, a room that smelled like toner and the lemon cough drops Mrs. Dellaverna kept in a dish for the public.

A brass plate on the counter said TAKE A NUMBER. There was no machine. There was just a number, written on a pad, that she wrote on a sticky note and handed to me, and the number was one.

I had come to be a citizen. It was harder than I had thought.

The first thing Pellegrini had said, over the phone on Sunday night, after the deputy’s report and the long silence about the girl, was that I should stay away from any record that required my county login. “Anything you pull as an employee, someone will say you pulled as an employee on leave,” he had said. “Go in as a resident. Use the front door. Sign your own name.”

So I had signed my own name, Greta Haldorsen, address and phone, under REQUESTER, and in the box marked RELATIONSHIP TO COUNTY, which is meant for contractors and journalists and the occasionally litigious, I had written, after thought, Resident.

I had asked for four things.

The Cutover contract between the county and the vendor, with all change orders. The county’s records retention schedule for the Emergency Communications Center. Any certification of legal hold review for the scheduled destruction of the Center’s legacy data. And the list of administrator and service accounts that the vendor had been given access to in the last twelve months.

Mrs. Dellaverna read the form from top to bottom, with her lips moving very slightly. She was in her sixties, small and exact, in a cardigan the color of oatmeal, and she wore her reading glasses on a chain that clicked against a name tag that said she had been with the county for thirty-one years.

I thought of Lorraine, who had kept a shoebox of logs for the same reason this woman kept every request she had ever stamped: she believed the paper was the county, and the county was something you could be loyal to.

“Item three,” she said. “Certification of legal hold review. That’s the LH-1.”

“Yes.”

“You’ll want the agenda packet, then. The LH-1 gets attached to the consent calendar when a department asks to destroy more than a cubic yard.” She tapped the form. “I can give you that today, it’s public. It’s in the reading room. The rest has to go through the department.”

“Which department?”

“Yours.” She did look at me then, mildly, over the glasses. “Emergency Communications. All requests for departmental records are forwarded to the department head for awareness. It’s not a permission. It’s a courtesy.”

“When?”

“Within one business day.”

I thought about Roy Kellaway, in his office with the fire helmet, receiving a copy of Form PR-7 with my handwriting on it. I thought about the word courtesy.

“Is there any way for it not to be forwarded?” I asked.

“No.” She said it kindly. “Is there something that you’d rather the department didn’t know?”

“There’s a great deal,” I said. “But it’s the kind of thing they’ll know by Wednesday anyway.”

She nodded as though that were a normal answer, and I understood that she had been hearing versions of it for thirty-one years. She stamped the form in three places, tore off the pink copy, and slid it to me with the pen still attached to its chain.

“Reading room’s through the glass door,” said Mrs. Dellaverna. “Don’t take the packet out. If you’d like a copy of a page, it’s twenty cents, and I’ll need a quarter in the jar.”

“I have a quarter.”

“Then you’re ahead of most of them.”

The reading room was a former jury deliberation room with a long oak table and four chairs that did not match. A window looked out on the courthouse lawn, where a man in an orange vest was leaf-blowing a single oak. On the table, in a white three-ring binder with BOARD OF SUPERVISORS stamped across the spine, was the agenda packet for the meeting of three weeks ago.

It was four hundred and twelve pages long. I turned to the index and went down the consent calendar with my pencil, and at item 14-C, I stopped.

14-C. Request of Emergency Communications to retire legacy data in connection with the Cutover. Fiscal impact: none. Recommended action: approve.

Attached was a memo of two pages from Roy Kellaway, Director, on county letterhead. It was a clean, confident, boring memo. It said the county was moving to a new platform. It said the legacy system and its recorder had reached end of life and were costing the county twenty-two thousand dollars a year in support, a figure I noticed he had rounded in the county’s favor.

It said that after the Cutover the legacy data would be destroyed in accordance with the schedule, and that the vendor would certify the wipe.

And under that, on its own page, in the plain grey boxes of a county form, was the LH-1.

LEGAL HOLD REVIEW FOR SCHEDULED DESTRUCTION. Department. Record series. Date range. Volume. Then a block of four statements with boxes beside them, and Roy’s blue check mark in every one.

The records have been reviewed for pending or reasonably anticipated litigation involving the county. No holds identified.

The records have been reviewed for pending subpoenas, records requests, or investigations. No holds identified.

The records have been reviewed for claims, notices of claim, or tort filings. No holds identified.

The department head certifies that the foregoing is accurate. Signed, Roy J. Kellaway. Reviewed for the Office of County Counsel by a name I did not know, Walter Emmerich, Paralegal.

Four statements. Four marks. I read them twice. Then I read the third one a third time with my pencil under each word, because it was a very short sentence, and I had been reading the county’s short sentences for fifteen years and had never once failed to find what was wrong with one.

It said no claims. It did not say no claims about the calls. It said no claims about the records, in the plural, as a series, with a date range that ran from the Center’s first recording to the day before Cutover. All of it. Seven years of audio, fourteen years of narrative, and one night in March.

I thought of the fog.

County Road 9. Eleven vehicles and a stock trailer. A night I had not allowed myself to think about as anything but my own failure, because the only part of it that had ever belonged to me was a four-word call. I had not thought about the pile-up itself in years. But a pile-up does not end when the roads are cleared. It ends when a lawyer says so.

I took out my notebook and wrote, in block capitals, WHO SUED?

Then I went downstairs to the court clerk’s counter and asked for the civil index.

The Superior Court clerk’s office has a terminal for the public, a beige tower with a trackball and a laminated sheet of instructions that begins, “Do not attempt to print without a receipt.” I did not want to print. I wanted to type a date range and the word LADD, and the terminal took four minutes to think about it, because everything in this county has a little spinning wheel somewhere.

The index returned eleven hundred cases. I narrowed by year, by type, by defendant. Tort, personal injury, property damage. I had the date of the pile-up, which I could have recited in my sleep, and I filtered for anything filed within two years of it.

There were nineteen. Eighteen were auto cases with ordinary names, the sort of thing that settles. The nineteenth was not.

Kolb Livestock Hauling, LLC, et al., v. Ladd County, Ladd County Emergency Communications Center, et al. Filed ten months after the pile-up. Cause of action: negligence, delay in emergency response. Status: stayed.

Stayed. Not dismissed. Not settled. Stayed, which in my limited experience of law means that somebody has agreed to stop and the case is sitting in a drawer, alive, for as long as everyone’s patience lasts.

I clicked the entry. The docket was short. A complaint. An answer. A motion for a stay, filed by the county, granted by agreement. A status report every year, and the last one filed seven months ago. In the entry for the most recent report, there was a line that I read with the dispatcher’s stillness, hands flat, nothing else in the room making noise.

Parties report that discovery is deferred. No records preservation order entered. Defendant county represents that relevant recordings are retained under policy. Next status report due in five months.

Relevant recordings are retained under policy.

The policy said seven years. The seven years would end in the spring. The county, in a document filed with a judge, had told a court that the recordings of the night of the pile-up were safe, and three weeks ago the county’s board had signed off on a memo that said the whole recorder would be wiped, and in between the two documents there was a single check mark in a grey box.

I did not feel triumph. I felt something much smaller and much more administrative, which was the cold click of a form going from correct to false.

Roy had not lied, I thought. Not necessarily. A man who signs thirty documents a week does not read the third line of every one. He signs where the paralegal tells him. The paralegal signs where the template tells him. And the template had four statements and no space for a case that had been stayed for six years and forgotten by everyone but the people who had been in the fog.

But I had been in the fog. And so, I realized, standing at the beige terminal with my hand on the trackball, had Dinah’s call. The pile-up was a lawsuit about delays. Every call in the Center that night was a call about delay, and the one at 2:14 a.m., the one I had closed without dispatch, was part of that evidence.

If the Kolb case ever woke up, a lawyer would ask for every recording from that hour, and my sixty seconds of failure would be played in open court, with my name on a transcript, and the person who had edited it would not be asked to explain.

I was the evidence. I had been the evidence for six years. I had just never been served.

“Ma’am?” said the young man at the counter. He was in a tie that did not belong to him. “Are you finished? Because the terminal’s got a timeout, and I’ll have to log it.”

“I’m finished. Thank you.” I wrote the case number on the back of the pink copy of Form PR-7. Then I wrote the docket line, word for word, and under it, because I could not stop myself, the date of the next status report.

Five months. The recorder would be sold for parts in twenty-eight days.

I was halfway down the courthouse steps when someone said my name.

“Greta.”

I knew the voice before I turned. Soft, unhurried, with the faint apologetic air of a man who has spent his life explaining to other people what is wrong with their computers.

Cade Farnsworth was standing at the bottom of the steps in the grey hooded sweatshirt, a canvas bag over one shoulder and a cardboard box under his arm. He had been to the courthouse, I thought, to deliver a printer. It was the sort of errand he was always on.

“You’re not supposed to talk to me,” I said.

“I’m not supposed to talk to you about the Center,” said Cade. “Roy said that. He didn’t say anything about the weather.” He looked up at the sky, which was a pale October blue. “It’s nice out.”

“Cade.”

“I know.” He shifted the box. He had a tired, long face, and he was not looking at me but at a point a little to the left of my shoulder, as though he were reading the courthouse sign. “I got into the building at five on Saturday. I’d been told you’d had a problem. I sat at the server terminal and I looked at the account list. All of it. The sessions. The admin accounts.”

“And?”

“And TCHADM2 isn’t on it.”

I did not move. The man with the orange leaf blower had started up again across the lawn, and the roar made a wall around us.

“It was there Friday. I know it was there, because Marcy called me and I looked at the phone and I knew I’d be coming in.” His voice had dropped, and I leaned toward it. “On Saturday it was gone. Not disabled. Gone from my console. It still shows up in the revision history, but I can’t see it, and I can’t touch it, and I can’t turn it off. I’m the technical coordinator.

If I can’t see an account, there’s somebody with more privileges than me who doesn’t want me to.”

“The vendor.”

“Or somebody who has the vendor’s keys.” He finally looked at me, quickly, and away. “I haven’t told Roy. I haven’t told anyone. I’m telling you because you were the only person this week who asked me whether I’d edited those records instead of telling me I had.”

I had asked him no such thing, as far as I could remember. I had thought it, in a hallway, with a cold hand. But I did not say so. I said, “Did you?”

“No.”

“Would you tell me if you had?”

“No,” said Cade, and for the first time in the three years I had known him, he almost smiled. “But I’d tell you I hadn’t, and I’d mean it, and you couldn’t check. I know that’s no good to you.”

“It’s something.”

“It’s a fact. It isn’t proof. You taught me that, you know, in the break room, over a bad call about a gas leak. Write down what you saw, not what you decided.” He hitched the bag higher. “That’s what I do. I build things that tell you what happened, and nobody reads them. I’m sorry about Friday.”

He walked away down the steps toward a county van with its hazards flashing, past a woman pushing a stroller and a bailiff eating a sandwich in the shade of a pillar, a thin man in a grey sweatshirt carrying a box, and I watched him go, and I wrote nothing down, because there was nobody I could be honest with about it except the page.

I called Pellegrini from the third step, with my back to the wall so that nobody could read my notebook over my shoulder. I read him the docket line. I read him the LH-1. I read him the case number twice, because he asked for it twice, and I heard him writing.

“A stayed civil case,” he said. “That’s a preservation duty. The county told a judge it was keeping those tapes. Whoever signed that checklist either didn’t know or didn’t care, and I don’t have to decide which.” He breathed out. “This is the first thing in a week that doesn’t depend on whether somebody believes you.”

“It depends on whether somebody reads it.”

“Same thing, in a courthouse.” A pause. “Ruth Mallender, the District Attorney’s clerk. Wednesday morning, nine o’clock. She’ll want you, your statement, and that docket line. Wear something you wouldn’t mind being photographed in.”

“I don’t own anything like that.”

“Then wear the grey one,” he said. “You always look like a person who read the whole thing.”

I did not ask how he knew what I wore. I had worn the grey one to the Sheriff’s lot. I wrote Wednesday, 9:00, Mallender, beside the case number, and then, beside that, a smaller line I did not mean to write.

Roy gets the form today.

I sat on the courthouse steps and copied his words into my notebook anyway. Then I turned to the back of the pink copy of Form PR-7 and looked at the little box at the bottom that Mrs. Dellaverna had stamped, the one that said when I would receive an answer.

Response due: five business days. Copy forwarded to department head: today.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!