Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 33

The Raffle Stubs

Hester Skorupa lived over a florist on Mill Street, up a staircase that smelled of wet cut stems, and on Sunday afternoon, eight days to the Cutover, she opened her door with a loupe pushed up into her white hair and a parakeet riding her shoulder like a small blue epaulette.

“You’re early,” she said. “Good. Hamlet is in a mood. He thinks you are the man about the gutters.”

“I’m not the man about the gutters.”

“He doesn’t listen to explanations. Come in, wipe your feet, and don’t touch the desk lamp.”

Odessa Hennig came up the stairs behind me, one hand on the rail, with Docket padding at her heel and a thick brown envelope held flat against her coat. The greyhound stopped on the threshold. Hamlet looked at her down his beak. Docket looked back with great courtesy and lay down on the doormat, and the matter was settled.

I should explain the envelope, because the whole afternoon hung from it.

On Thursday night, at the Grange Hall, Hennig had bought five raffle tickets for the double wedding ring quilt, at a dollar each, from a woman with a cash box and a left hand. She had paid with a five. She had given her name, and her office number, and the woman had written both on the stubs, five times, in small deliberate strokes, and torn them off with her right hand and slid the long halves across the table.

Hennig had folded the short halves into her purse, with a saltine, and had thought nothing of it until she woke on Friday at four in the morning.

“A lawyer buys tickets from a witness at a charity supper,” she had said on the phone, “and goes home with a signed sample of the witness’s hand. If I had planned it, I would be ashamed. I did not plan it, and I am merely delighted.”

She had put the stubs in a clear sleeve, and the sleeve in an envelope, and the envelope in a log with a time on it. Ruth Mallender had retained Hester on Saturday morning by telephone, at a rate Hester described as *an insult I intend to enjoy.* The chain of custody ran from Hennig’s purse to Hennig’s hand to Hester’s desk, and I was not in it.

I was there because Hester had said she would look at the stubs only if I sat in the corner and kept my mouth shut.

“You can speak when spoken to,” she said. “You are a witness, not a participant.”

The room was one long attic, with a slanted ceiling and a dormer and a big north window. Shelves of reference books ran along every wall, and a worktable stood under the glass, bare except for a copy stand, a cold lamp, two magnifiers, and a steel ruler. A cage hung in the dormer with its door open, empty. Hamlet flew to it and settled in with ostentatious calm.

Hester seated herself, put on cotton gloves, and slid the stubs out of their sleeve with a pair of tweezers, one at a time, and laid them side by side on a gray card.

They were small things, an inch and a half of red paper with a printed number and a perforated edge. On each, in blue ballpoint, in a hand I had seen on a card and a lanyard and a tab in my own imagination: *Odessa H.* and a phone number, and the numerals leaning slightly backward, as left-handers’ often do.

“Five exemplars,” said Hester. “Five lines, perhaps twelve letters each. It is not much.” She bent. “A raffle stub is the worst thing you can ask a document examiner to look at. Fast, small, written at a card table, standing, by a woman who is talking to someone else. No one’s true hand is on a raffle stub. That is the very reason you want it.”

“Why?”

“Because she was not thinking about it.” She did not look up. “A forger is a person who is thinking about the hand. She slows, she controls, she copies. But a person selling tickets is only writing. The hand comes out the way it was taught at nine years old, with the little bad habits underneath.” She lifted the loupe from her hair and settled it over her eye. “Now be quiet. I am going to look at an H.”

She was quiet for eleven minutes. I counted them on the wall clock, a tin sunburst over the cage. Hennig sat on a stool by the door with her knees together, in the posture of a woman at a recital. The parakeet murmured. A truck went by below. Hester moved the stubs a quarter inch, and took them a quarter inch back.

“Hm,” she said.

She laid down the first loupe and picked up a second, and brought out of a flat file three photographs I recognized at once. They were prints of the handwritten H.B. entries, the eight she had shown me in her kitchen weeks before, the ones that began to drift. She put one beside the stubs.

“This,” she said, and touched the crossbar with the tip of the tweezers, “is the capital H in *Haldorsen*, from the certificate in the folder Mrs. Dellaverna sent over on Wednesday night. This is the H in *Hennig*, from the stub. The posts are drawn bottom to top, which is rare in a left-hander, and the right post carries a flick at the base that is not a serif.

It is a pen-lift habit. The left foot has a tail.” The tweezers moved. “It is the same tail. The same angle, the same length, the same slight hook at the end, as if she were hanging a coat on it.”

“Is it her?”

“I will tell you what I will write.” Hester sat back. “I will write that the questioned writing on the certificate and in the eight later entries, and the known writing on these stubs, share a combination of features that I would expect to find in a single writer, and that I have found no significant difference between them. I will write *probable.* I will not write *identified.*”

“Why not?”

“Because I am seventy-four and I have testified three hundred times and I have never once been sorry that I waited.” She put the loupe down. “Five stubs are not enough. I need what the Court calls requested exemplars, fifty lines at least, written at dictation, by her, knowing she is being asked, on a form we supply.

Then she may do what she likes. She can write it with her right hand. She can write it badly. A person cannot disguise a hand for fifty lines as she can for one.”

“Will she give them?”

“She will give them if a judge tells her to, and she will have a lawyer who informs her it is a very short sentence.” She said it with a faint satisfaction. “It is not for me. Ruth will ask. I would like very much to be a fly on her wall.”

Hennig took a notebook out of her handbag. “Can you say this in writing by Tuesday noon?”

“I can say it in writing by Tuesday noon. I can say it more clearly by Thursday.”

“We have a hearing Thursday at ten.”

“Then I will say it as clearly as I can by Tuesday noon, and in a footnote I will be rude about it.” She turned to me, and the corner of her mouth moved. “And you, young woman. You are looking at me.”

“You said I could speak when spoken to.”

“I have spoken to you.”

“Marcy’s ten samples. She’s left-handed too. Did you ever…”

“Ah.” Hester rose, with a hand on the table, and crossed to a drawer and drew out another print. “Marcy Ingstad. I looked at her ten last week, in an afternoon I could ill afford, and I wrote Ruth three lines. Ms. Ingstad writes a plain H, big and round, with two square feet and no tail.

She does it ten times, and she does it the same way each time, and then she signed her statement, and she did it eleven.” She laid the print down. “I do not say that she could not forge. I say that the hand that forged H.B. is not her hand.

If you were hoping for a more interesting answer, I am sorry.”

“I wasn’t.”

“You were,” said Hester Skorupa, with great gentleness. “A little. Everyone does. A person who has been good to you is never the villain. It is a very restful rule, and it has ruined a great many cases.”

I did not answer. She was right, and I didn’t like it. Somewhere in the pit of the last month there had been a small bad stone of suspicion about a woman with a plate of pancakes, and I had carried it without looking, and it was a relief, which I did not trust, to put it down.

Hester had gone back to the flat file. This time she took out six photographs and laid them in two rows, three above, three below, on the gray card.

“Now the other one,” she said. “You asked me last time about the teacher, and I told you the right hand came first, slow, and the left hand came after. I have been thinking about the right hand. I have spent three weeks thinking about it, and Ruth sent me a gift on Saturday, from a young man’s telephone.”

I knew them before I looked. A spiral notebook on a nail inside a door. A hand like a bowl of round fruit. *Marin J, face, fall, went home.*

“This is the Cold Room Book. It is written by a man.” She said it with certainty, and then, with her usual scruple, qualified it. “By a person who learned to write in a classroom with a penmanship chart, with a very round, very quick, very practiced right hand, and a firm downward pressure that dents the page.

He writes a double *l* like two boys holding hands. He crosses a *t* with a flat bar halfway up. He has done it for years and never once slowed down to think.”

“Vern.”

“Vern, I assume. I have only your word, and the young man’s, that the book is his.” She took a magnifier from the table and handed it across to me, and I took it in my left hand like a spoon. “Now look at this.”

It was the first H.B. entry. The slow one, the one written four days after Hollis Brewer retired, the one Hester had said in her kitchen was a right-handed hand, unskilled and afraid. I had looked at it a dozen times. I looked at it now, under the lens, next to the round fruit of the Cold Room Book, and for a moment I could not tell what she wanted me to see.

“Tell me what is different,” said Hester.

“It’s slower.”

“Yes. What else?”

I bent. The letters of the first entry stood up very straight, upright and tight, with a hesitation at the start of every stroke, a little blob of ink where the pen came down and waited. The round hand of the Cold Room Book ran across the page like water.

“It doesn’t blob,” I said. “It doesn’t stop. Vern doesn’t stop.”

“A man does not unlearn fluency. If you made Mr. Tauber write a name he did not know, slowly, to copy, he would slow his speed and his letters would still be round.” Hester took the glass back. “The first forger is a right-handed adult who does not write by hand much at all.

Look at the figures. The sevens have no crossbar. The ones carry a flag, the way someone writes who learned figures from a typewriter and a keypad. This is a person who prints form fields in capitals and signs with a scrawl.

A person who is afraid of paper.”

“It’s not Vern.”

“It is not Vern.” She said it flatly. “I will tell Ruth so in writing. I have no wish to see a man accused of what another man did, merely because the first man has a loud jacket.”

My heart did something odd. I had lost something, and I knew exactly what. For three weeks, Vern Tauber had been the man with the keys and the donuts and the jingle, and his hand on the desk, and his look at the drawer, and the whole shape of the thing had rested a little on his broad shoulders.

Now there was a hole in the shape. Someone who did not write by hand had sat at a desk four days after Hollis went home to his trailer, and copied H.B., slowly, with a straight back, and handed the pen over.

“Who else?”

“That is not a question for an examiner.” But she was already holding a seventh photograph, and she held it a second before she put it down. “I will tell you what I tell every student. The right hand is the person who knew what to write. The left hand is the person who was trained to write it well. The first needed the second. A man does not train a left hand for a year without a reason to hold it.”

“You think he’s a boss.”

“I think he is a person who does not do his own writing,” said Hester Skorupa. “That is a very different thing.”

Hamlet, in the dormer, said something that sounded precisely like *Mind the gutters.* Nobody laughed.

Hennig had closed her notebook. She was looking at Hester with an expression I was beginning to know, the one she wore when she found someone in a room more useful than she had expected.

“And the certificate,” she said. “Waddell hasn’t withdrawn the hold on the lessor. If Cardwell asks you on Thursday morning, in a courtroom, whether the signature on that page is Ms. Haldorsen’s?”

“It is not.” Hester put a finger on the oath card, the plain H of fifteen years ago, and on the certificate, the H with the tail. “It is a skilled imitation of her *name*, made by a person who studied the first stroke and missed the habit. I will swear to that Tuesday. I will swear to it Thursday. I will swear to it on top of a parakeet.”

“I appreciate that,” said Hennig.

“Do not appreciate it. Pay me.”

“Ruth’s paying you.”

“Ruth is paying me an insult. I mean to collect.” She was already stripping off her gloves. “Now go. I have a cage to clean and a nephew to disappoint at three. Leave me the stubs. Take the dog.”

We went down the stairs into the smell of wet stems and carnations. In the street, the light had gone thin and yellow, the way it does at three in the afternoon in the second week of an onion lift, and a florist’s van was backing up with a beeping noise, and a boy was kicking a can along the curb. Docket walked in a straight line between us and paid no attention to any of it.

“I owe you an apology,” I said.

“Not yet.”

“I thought it was Vern. I think I built half of it on Vern.”

“You built it on what you had.” Hennig stopped to let a woman with a stroller go by. “And now you have less of the thing you built it on, and more of the truth, and it is going to feel, for a while, like going down a flight of stairs in the dark.”

She patted her pockets for her keys. “Don’t say it aloud, in front of anyone, that it isn’t Vern. It is a fact that is going to be valuable to someone, and I would like it to be us.”

“Who would it be valuable to?”

“Anyone who is waiting to see how far down we’ve gone.” She found her keys. “The Sheriff, for example.”

Her phone rang. She looked at the screen without any change in her face, and then at me, and then answered it with a clipped, neutral “Hennig.” She listened for twelve seconds. She said, “Yes. I’ll tell her.” She said, “Both of us.” She said, “Nine-thirty. That’s fine. Thank you.” And she hung up, and held the phone a moment against her coat.

“That was the Sheriff’s secretary,” she said. “He would like to see us. At his own desk, on Monday morning, at nine-thirty.”

“About the complaint.”

“He didn’t say.” Hennig opened the car door and held it for the dog. “He asked, and I quote, that you come as you are. In a manner that suggested he knew exactly what that meant.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!