Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 7

The Organ Loft

There are forty-one steps up to the organ loft at Cinder Field, and I know the number because Mari makes me count them out loud.

“Humor me,” she says from the bottom, one hand on the rail and the other on her knee brace. It is Labor Day, a few minutes before eleven in the morning, and the Lamplighters are three hundred miles away losing a series to a team from Indiana.

The park is empty in the way a church is empty on a Monday. Every seat is folded up. The pennants hang straight down. A sprinkler head on the infield, one of the ones Mari opened at 8:50 on the twenty-ninth, has a strip of yellow tape wrapped around its neck like a patient’s wristband.

“Seven,” I say, climbing. “Eight. Nine.”

“Out loud, Reverend. All of them.”

“You count in sevens when you’re nervous,” I say. “I’d like it noted that you asked me to count in ones.”

“Noted.” She doesn’t smile. “Keep going.”

I keep going. The steps are poured concrete with a rubber nosing, and the rail is painted the same dull green as every other rail in the park, and halfway up there is a shallow place in the third tread from the top where sixty years of feet have worn the concrete into a dish. At forty-one there is a steel door with a hand-lettered sign: ORGANIST ONLY. Under it, in a different hand and a different decade, someone has added: AND COFFEE.

Mari is out of the Rules office. She has been out since Saturday. She told me at the gate this morning, in the voice of a woman reading a ticket, that the League had to let her go on a technicality: the schedule calls for a chalked field on the twenty-eighth, and she is the only Bench in the circuit who can lay a line to specification, and the League cannot break its own schedule even to punish the person who broke it. They took the rank-year anyway.

She is unranked until next September. They did not take the knee. The knee she says she did on the stairs of the Rules office, and when she says it my mouth fills with the taste of a rubber band stretched till it is about to go, and a few wet pennies. A swallowed sentence. I have learned not to ask for those. If I ask, they harden.

I look at her with my new eyes instead. The glow in her chest is a small, tight, brownish gold, like a coin held in a fist, and there is something laced through it that I have no word for yet. I put it down to the knee. I am going to put a great many things down to the knee today.

The loft is a square room the size of a walk-in closet, glassed on one side, looking down at the field through a window that has been cleaned by someone who loved it. Inside there is a stool, a space heater, a coffee can of pencils, a framed photograph of a long-faced man in a cardigan shaking hands with a mascot, and the organ.

It is smaller than I expected. A two-manual console in a cabinet the color of strong tea, bolted into the floor in 1962 and never moved. The stops are labeled in a dead man’s handwriting on strips of masking tape. There is a thermos on the shelf above the pedals. It is empty. Someone has kept it clean.

“Hop Dunmore,” Mari says, sitting on the stool because the knee has opinions. “Sixty-one seasons. Started at thirty-one, played his last game at ninety-one, and they say he never missed a stretch. He died in October of 2022 in a nursing home on Linden. The kid who plays now, Brandon, learned the whole book off a recording of him. Every pause. Every mistake. Everyone in this park does the stretch a half-beat behind the organ and nobody knows why. They think it’s tradition.”

“It’s why I said it was the wrong key,” I say. “On the rail.”

“You said it was the wrong key because it was funny.” She almost smiles. “You didn’t know you were right.”

I take the book out of my canvas bag. It is warm under my hand, a warmth like a loaf, and the gold comes up under my fingertips as I turn the pages. I do not hunt for the line. It has been waiting for me since Friday.

When I touched the green cloth on Sunday night, the book opened by itself to a page about two-thirds in, to a line in Ruth’s hand I had not been looking for, with a tiny faint star in the margin like a pencil prick.

Dunmore, H. Room Two, Linden Court. 10/19/22. D.P. Then a row of notation, which I can almost read now: the slash for a put-out, an E with a tiny s over it, and a capital B inside a circle.

“D.P.,” I say. “Double play.”

“Initials,” Mari says. “She puts the initials in a different ink. Look.”

She is right. The two letters are brown and the rest is blue. D.P. is a person. Dolly Pruitt, Gate B, who has sold scorecards at Cinder Field since the year the park installed its first scoreboard clock and who is, at this hour, at the bottom of the forty-one steps with a cane and a shopping bag, being told by a groundskeeper’s cousin that Hop’s good shoes are in a box up in the loft and does she want them.

I had expected a woman in a cardigan. Dolly Pruitt is a very short, very upright eighty-year-old in a Lamplighters windbreaker the color of canned peas, with a scarf over her hair and the sort of face that has been lied to by professionals and is polite about it.

I watch her through the glass as she starts up the stairs. Her glow is the first one I have seen that is not in her chest. It is in her hands. A soft, clear, steady light, as if she were carrying a lamp she has forgotten how to put down.

“She’s slow on the steps,” I say.

“She’s eighty. She’s had two hips.” Mari watches too. “Ansel. What does it cost?”

“Hearing.”

“All of it?”

“Hop lived by it.” I put my thumb on the line. “For the record, that’s the worst of the five. It’s a thing you don’t know is a room until it’s empty.”

“Ansel,” says Mari. She says it quickly, and not in sevens, and I look up. For a second the whole of her face is open. It is the face of someone about to say something that will not be a joke.

Then the stairs creak. “She’s coming,” says Mari, and the face shuts, and I let it.

I press down.

I have felt the seal go three times now, and each one has a different shape. Lucille’s went like a blister. My father’s went like a window shut on my hand. Hop’s goes like a sound you have been hearing all your life, a hum under the hum, a note you never knew was holding up the floor, and then somebody lifts it out of the building like a stone from a wall.

I will not be able to explain this properly. It is not that the loft goes quiet. A quiet room still has a texture. You hear the space itself, the air in the corners, your own pulse. This is the absence of the texture. I look at the window and the field is a picture.

I open my mouth and nothing returns. I stamp my foot on the concrete and feel it in my shin and hear no foot. Mari’s lips are moving, she is saying something to me, and I watch the words come out of her face as if she were underwater.

I put my hand to my ear and I am so frightened that for three whole seconds I am not a chaplain, or a carrier, or any rank at all. I am a man in a closet who has lost a thing he could not have named. And then I do the only sane thing, which is that I sit down on the organ bench.

The door opens. Dolly Pruitt stands in it with her cane and her bag. I see her mouth say something polite. I see her look at the console and her whole face stop, the way a person’s does when a stranger has sat in the chair of someone dead.

My hands lift by themselves.

I know what is happening, but knowing is no help. My fingers settle on the lower manual as if they had done it ten thousand times. My right foot goes to the pedals. My left hand reaches without looking and pulls a stop labeled in masking tape. I feel the instrument wake under me. I cannot hear it.

I feel it. It comes up through the bench and the soles of my shoes and the bones of my chest, a low enormous pulse like a heartbeat in a very large animal, and I understand that the organ is playing and I have no idea what.

Dolly’s hand goes to her mouth.

I watch her face. It is all I have.

I will say now that it is the strangest hour of my life, watching a woman’s expression arrive in pieces at a message I cannot hear, delivered in my own mouth, in a dead man’s voice, over a song I recognize only by the feel of its slow bass in my back.

I know that I am speaking because I can feel my jaw and tongue move, an old man’s courtly shaping of vowels. I know that the voice is not mine because my throat tightens and loosens in places I have never used.

She comes in. She puts her bag on the floor. She takes off the scarf, slowly, and holds it in both hands.

I cannot hear a word of it. Mari tells me afterward, standing at the rail with her arms crossed and her face carefully empty, and I will give it to you the way she gives it to me. Mari does not make a good recorder. She cannot help correcting the grammar.

It begins: “Dolly Pruitt. It’s Hop. I’m dead, which I’m told is why I’m being so polite.”

It goes on:

“Forty-one steps. I counted them every night of my life. You came up them every seventh inning with a thermos of coffee, black, and you stood at my left elbow for the last chorus and never once said a word, and I played the best I knew how with you standing there.

“In 1983 you had the knee done, and the steps took you a minute longer than they used to, and I did a thing. I held the first line of the chorus a half-beat slow so you would get to the top before the last word. Root, root, root. I held it open like a door. You made the landing on ‘home team.’ I never told you.

“I thought it would shame you.

“Then the hip, and then the other hip. And every year I held it a little longer, and the park got used to it, and the park started singing behind me. Forty years, Dolly. I played a song wrong for one woman and taught four thousand people to sing it wrong with me.

“Edith was alive, and then she wasn’t. Earl was alive, and then he wasn’t. I was a coward in both of the years that counted, and I want you to know that I know it.

“I did not ask because I did not want to be refused, and I did not want to be accepted either, because then I would have had to be something other than a man at an organ. I loved you the whole time. It was not tragic.

“It was only a waste.

“You can stop climbing the stairs now. I’ve got the last one. Go sit in the sun.”

I hear none of it. What I see is a very small, very upright woman standing in the door of a closet with a scarf in her hands, listening to a dead man, and slowly, from the chin up, losing every drop of her composure. And then, which I do not expect and which I think the dead man did not expect either, she begins to laugh.

It is the laugh of a woman who has been sitting on a joke for forty years. I see her shoulders go. I see her tears run sideways down the creases of her face. I feel rather than hear Mari take a step toward me. The pulse in the bench changes, the bass note going long and low and trembling, and my own mouth falls shut, and the organ stops, and my hands drop into my lap and are mine.

The room is perfectly still. Dolly is talking.

I can’t hear her. I watch her lips. She says something with a P in it, and something with a long vowel, and my name, I think, or possibly my title, and then she says something to the console itself, and my heart makes a sound.

“What?” I say. “What did she say?”

I do not hear myself say it. I feel the word in my throat, and I know by Mari’s face that it comes out as a shout.

Mari takes a pencil from the coffee can. She pulls a scorecard out of Dolly’s shopping bag, turns it over to the blank back, writes on it in her blocky groundskeeper’s capitals, and holds it up.

SHE SAYS SHE KNEW.

I stare at it. Mari writes again.

SINCE 1983. SHE SAYS SHE’S BEEN CLIMBING THE STAIRS TO HEAR IT HELD OPEN.

I turn to look at Dolly Pruitt. She is looking at me with eyes the color of weak tea and a mouth that is still shaking, and she reaches into her shopping bag and takes out a dented steel thermos. She unscrews the cap. She has brought it, I see. It is the thermos she used to carry.

She has carried it up the forty-one steps again, the first time in four years, empty, because she could not think of anything else to bring. She holds it up as if to ask a question. She points at the stool, at the bench, at the instrument.

Mari writes one more.

SHE WANTS TO PLAY IT RIGHT. ONCE.

I shift down the bench. I do not know what else to do.

She sits. She is so small that her feet do not reach the floor. She puts one finger on a white key and I watch her take a breath, the little whole-body breath of a woman about to try a very high wall, and she presses it, and something comes through the wood into my shoulder blade, and I know it is a note, a plain flat B-flat in the middle of the instrument, held and held and held.

And then the world rings.

It comes back the way a light comes back after a power failure: all at once and a little too bright. There is the note, a round warm single pitch that I could drink. There is the hum of the space heater. There is the faint high tick of a pipe somewhere in the wall, and the rustle of Mari’s sleeve, and a long way off across the park a crow saying a rude thing about the whole business.

I can hear Dolly’s breath going in and out like a rope through a pulley.

It is too much. It is exactly as much as there is. My hearing has come back tuned to the dead man who lived by it, and he lived by it like a man who has built his whole house out of music, and the house is open.

Dolly lifts her finger from the key. The note dies away over about four seconds, and I hear every one of them.

“Thank you, Reverend,” she says. Her voice is cracked, creaky, ordinary. “I’m all right.”

It is a lie.

I hear it in the middle of the word all, where the voice goes slightly out of true, a high thin wobble like a plucked wire. I have sat with the dying for nine years and heard people say untrue things the whole time, and I never heard this. It is a small struck bell underneath the sentence. The sentence does not change, but the bell goes on ringing in the bone behind my ear.

She is not all right. She is a woman who has just heard that she was loved for forty years by a man who died before she could answer. She is about as all right as a dropped plate. And I find that this is the best news I have had in a month, because it means she is a person, and the thing has landed on her.

“Take your time,” I say, and the voice that comes out of me sounds oddly rich. “Please. Sit as long as you like.”

“I’ll sit till the groundskeeper kicks me out.” She looks at Mari and the corner of her mouth goes up. “Honey, I know you’re the one who lied about the shoes.”

“There are no shoes,” Mari says. “I’m sorry. There are no shoes.”

“I know there are no shoes.” Dolly pats the bench. “You got me up here, didn’t you.”

I should feel like a man who has done a good thing. I do, a little. A smaller part of me is listening to Mari’s voice, which I have been hearing for nine days and thought I knew.

“Are you okay?” I ask her. I mean it kindly. I only want to say something.

“I’m fine,” says Mari.

It rings. It rings like a very small bell struck once in a closed room.

I stand very still, and I think: the knee. She’s in pain. A person who is hurt says I’m fine in exactly that voice, and I am a chaplain and I have heard it from five hundred people, and I have never had the ears for it before. I tell myself that. I tell myself again.

We leave Dolly with the organ. Mari goes down the forty-one steps ahead of me, one hand on the rail, counting nothing out loud, and at the bottom she turns and asks whether I want to eat. I say I do not. I say I want to take the book home and sit with it. She looks relieved in a way I do not quite understand.

“Give me a spare,” she says.

“A what?”

“A key. For the apartment.” She says it carelessly, rubbing the knee. “Gideon works the east lot. Two hours a day I’m not on the grounds, and you’re at St. Odile’s, and the book’s in your kitchen drawer like a loaf of bread. If a Scout comes through your door while you’re at work, I’d like to be someone who can get in and move it.”

It makes sense. It makes so much sense that I can hear nothing wrong in it, and I am a man whose ears have been newly tuned to nothing else. I take the spare off my key ring, the brass one with the green rubber cap, and put it in her palm. She closes her fingers over it fast.

“Thanks,” she says.

I do not hear a bell. I want that clear. I listen, and in that second there is nothing.

We come out by Gate B in the bright flat noon, past the dark ticket windows and the stacked bundles of scorecards, and the lot beyond is empty except for one vehicle. It is a long white charter bus with a Lake Erie transit company’s blue stripe down the flank and the Lamplighters’ lantern logo on the door. It sits idling at the curb with its blinker on. The Lamplighters are supposed to be in Indiana, and the bus is supposed to be with them.

The door sighs open. A man comes down the steps with a duffel on one shoulder, and he stands at the bottom with his head slightly down, the way he stood in a church parking lot twenty-seven years ago.

He is forty-one years old. He is bigger than me and grayer and has a jaw like a carpenter’s level, and he has our father’s long upper lip. He wears a gray transit-company shirt with a name tag that says CAL. The sun is in his eyes. He does not smile.

I have not seen my brother in four years. We text at Christmas.

“Hey, Ansel,” says Cal Boyd. His voice, which I last heard on a bad phone line, is lower than I remember and far more tired, and there is no bell in it at all. It is a solid note. It is a man telling me the one true thing he has come three hundred miles to say.

“Dad’s message wasn’t only for you.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!