THE COURT: Mr. Kessler, your motion says the State’s witness concealed a note upon her person. I would like you to tell me how you know.
MR. KESSLER: I have been informed, Your Honor.
THE COURT: By whom?
MR. KESSLER: I am not at liberty
THE COURT: Then I am not at liberty to find it credible.
Division F opens at eight-thirty on the morning of the twelfth of January, and by eight-twenty the gallery is full to the doors.
I have never seen it like this. In October the room was a stage, and I sat at the foot of it with my hands on the keys, a part of the furniture. Now I am the thing they have come to look at. I come in through the side door, between Otis and a bailiff, in Nell’s gray coat, with the monitor under my sock and a legal envelope under my arm, and the whole room turns its head at once like a field of wheat.
I do not look for faces. I look at the floor. I count the tiles between the door and the rail. Nineteen.
Ruth Okonkwo is at the steno machine.
She is the young reporter in the green blazer. Today it is a dark blue one. She sits up very straight, with her wrists floating exactly an inch above the keys, and she does not look at me. I know that posture. It is the posture of a person who has been told a thing about herself by someone she admires and is not sure whether to believe it. It is mine, five years ago.
I do not want to look at her hands. I look anyway. They are good hands.
“All rise,” says the bailiff.
---
Judge Banks takes the bench in his bow tie, which is gray today, and the same plain gold spectacles, and he does not sit down. He stands at his chair with his knuckles on the blotter, and looks at the room in the manner of a schoolmaster who has found a note passed in class and intends to read it aloud.
“Be seated. Before this jury is brought in, we will conduct a hearing on the defendant’s emergency motion. I received it at nine last night. I also received, at eleven-forty, by the clerk’s night drop, a sealed submission from Ms. Delacroix on behalf of Ms. Fenner, and a letter. I have read both. I have also, as it happens, been awake.”
Beside me Pru lets out a breath that I think she has been holding since eight o’clock last night.
“Mr. Kessler. Your motion.”
Bram Kessler rises. He is a tall, handsome, well-tailored man in his fifties, with an aristocratic nose and a voice like fine brown paper. He does not hurry. He has the air of a man who is never surprised, because he has paid for the surprise in advance.
He argues for nine minutes. I take it down in my head, as I always do, and it is good: the witness is a self-confessed impostor, a convicted liar, a probationer whose liberty hangs on the State’s goodwill, and who has been, as of yesterday afternoon, “walked through a private commercial property at the elbow of the prosecutor, in the presence of what the defense can only describe as a crime scene arranged for her benefit.” He says the word benefit like a man laying down a card.
“And, Your Honor,” he says, “most troubling of all. She removed a document from that room. We do not know what it said. We know only that she hid it in her shoe.”
A sound runs through the gallery, a low whisper like paper.
“Mr. Kessler,” says Banks.
“Sir.”
“You have said, twice, that she hid it. You have said she did so ‘upon her person.’ Where did you obtain that information?”
“I have represented to the Court that it is reliable.”
“You have represented that it is yours. That is not the same.”
Kessler smiles, faintly. “The defense is entitled to protect its sources.”
“The defense is entitled to protect its privileged communications. It is not entitled to a source inside the State’s own evidence team on the afternoon of a search.” The judge takes off his glasses. “Mr. Kessler, I have been on this bench for twenty-four years. I have never once heard of a defense attorney who knew, within four hours, the precise location on the body of a document in the pocket of a prosecution witness. Unless the person who saw the shoe told him.”
The room has gone entirely still.
“I am not accusing you of anything,” says Banks. “I am telling you what a reasonable man will think, and I am doing it in open court so that the person on the other end of your telephone may hear it from me and not from you.”
I look, despite myself, at the State’s table.
Calder Wynn sits with his hands folded in front of a stack of manila folders, in his gray cardigan, with his half-moon glasses. He is looking at nothing. At his elbow, in a tight jacket, with the round, eager face that I distrust on principle, sits Detective Pruitt, who has not been told to leave. Sloane is not here. Sloane is, I have been told, at the evidence room, with the ledgers.
Pruitt’s ears are pink.
It could be the warmth of the room.
---
“Ms. Delacroix,” says the judge. “Your submission.”
Pru stands. She has not had a minute’s sleep and she has the vivid, brittle, gorgeous look of someone who is going to be sick later and has scheduled it.
“Your Honor, my client was in possession of a handwritten note of an observation she made inside the chandlery. She did not disclose it to the State last night, because she had reason to believe the object of the note had been altered after she read it. She disclosed it to this Court at the earliest practicable moment, sealed, through counsel, so that no party could alter, destroy, or suppress it. It is a motion for protective custody of a copy. I ask the Court to read it.”
“I have read it. Unseal it, Madam Clerk, and hand a copy to each counsel.”
The clerk, a small elderly woman in cat’s-eye glasses, brings it down in a manila envelope. The room hears the clasp. The only other sound is Ruth Okonkwo’s machine, hardly more than a whisper of keys, taking down the clasp.
I watch Wynn open his copy. He reads it. He reads it exactly once.
His face does not change. It is the stillest face I have ever seen. Only the left hand, which lies on the folder, moves, and what it does is so small that I would not have seen it had I not spent twelve years watching hands: the first two fingers press the paper flat.
“Mr. Wynn,” says the Court. “Has the State seen this note?”
“No, Your Honor.”
“Did the State know of its existence?”
“Of its contents, no. I watched Ms. Fenner fold a page into her shoe, Your Honor, and I said nothing.” Wynn rises. He does it slowly, with a faint, creaking dignity, like a ship getting under way. “But of the line it records, yes.”
I stop breathing.
“Explain.”
“At 4:28 yesterday afternoon,” says Wynn, “I entered the back room of the Teague chandlery at the head of three officers. The ledger on the table was open to its last page. I read it from the doorway. I do not claim to read as quickly as Ms. Fenner, Your Honor, but at forty feet I can read capital letters.”
He folds his hands. “There were three pencil lines. Detective Pruitt was instructed at 4:31 to photograph the page before any person approached the table. He did. I have the film.”
“The film.”
“The film, and the contact sheet, and the log. They are in this folder.” He lays his hand on it. “Frame eleven.”
“Hand it up.”
Pruitt reaches for the folder, and then stops, with his hand an inch above it. His face is a pale and rather ghastly pink. Wynn does not look at him. He lifts the folder himself, crosses the well, climbs the one step, and sets it on the bench, with a small bow, like a waiter setting down a plate.
Banks opens it.
I see it from where I sit, at an angle: a glossy contact sheet in a grid, thirty-six tiny frames in rows, each with a number in grease pencil underneath. The judge puts a finger on one. He takes a magnifier from his drawer, a brass, old-fashioned thing, and bends over it.
He reads for a long moment.
“Three lines,” he says. “R. Fenner, twenty-five thousand, pending. J. Marchand, twenty-five thousand, pending. A. Fenner, twenty-five thousand, January twelve, per L.C.” He lifts his head. “I will note for the record, Madam Reporter, that the date of the third entry is today.”
“Yes, Your Honor,” says Ruth Okonkwo, in a voice so small that I almost miss it.
“I will further note that Detective Pruitt photographed the page at 4:31. And that at 6:10 the same page, according to the sworn statement of the officer who stood beside Ms. Fenner, was clean.”
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“Mr. Wynn. You did not tell the witness that you had seen the line.”
“No, sir.”
“Why not?”
And now, at last, Wynn looks at me.
It is not long, perhaps two seconds, but it is level and unflinching, with nothing in it to hide in. I think I will remember it a long time. It is the look of one tired person to another across a very narrow table.
“Because I wished to see,” says Wynn, “what she would do with it. I had been warned, Your Honor, by sources I was not prepared to discount, that someone in my own office or my own investigative team could not be trusted. I could not tell who. I decided to tell nobody what I knew, including Ms. Fenner, and to see whether the line survived the night.”
He draws a breath. “I did not expect it to survive the hour. I ought to have secured the page myself. That was my error, and I put it on the record.”
“You tested your own witness.”
“I tested the room, sir. She happened to be standing in it.”
It is not an apology. It is not quite an insult either. It is something drier than both, a confession of a method, and I find that I am not angry at all, which surprises me. I am, if anything, relieved. I have spent eighteen hours thinking that the man who believes in drawers was shutting one on me.
He was only checking whether the lock held.
“A reasonable man,” says the Court, “might say that is a perilous way to conduct a prosecution.”
“A reasonable man would be right.”
“Ms. Fenner.” The judge turns his head. “Did you know the State had the frame?”
I stand. My knees are not quite mine. “No, Your Honor.”
“Did you conceal your note from the State out of a belief that the State was compromised?”
“Out of a belief that someone was.” The words come out in my own voice, the plain one, the one I use for readbacks. “I didn’t know who. I’m sorry I didn’t know it was Mr. Wynn’s test. I think I’d have behaved the same.”
“I think so too,” says Banks, dryly. “Sit down. You have done what a witness is supposed to do, which is to be right for the wrong reason.”
---
He rules in eleven minutes.
The motion to exclude is denied. The motion for a hearing on the integrity of the ledgers is granted, and set for Thursday, “to be conducted in camera, without the presence of any party who cannot account for the whereabouts of his thumbs.” The State is ordered to disclose the full contact sheet and film log to the defense by five o’clock.
Detective Pruitt is excused from the courtroom “for the purposes of the afternoon,” and goes out through the side door with his round face lowered and his ears scarlet, and does not look at anyone, and the bailiff goes with him, a polite three paces behind.
“That does not mean it was him,” Pru breathes in my ear.
“No.”
“He could have been the person who told Kessler about the shoe, and a different person who rubbed out the line.”
“Or the same.”
“Or the clipboard man.”
“Or Sloane.” I watch the door close. “Or a person I haven’t thought of. Or a person who is sitting in this room.”
I turn my head, slowly, and look at the gallery.
It is a sea of faces. Reporters in the front row, a woman with a sketch pad. The Prejean family in a pew, with Evangeline very upright in her good black coat and a prayer book on her knee. Otis, in uniform, by the aisle.
Two rows behind him, in a pew of her own, in an ivory suit with a pin at the collar, a handsome older woman with silver hair and a straight back, who is looking at nobody. She has a small black handbag on her lap and a pair of leather gloves, folded one over the other, like a pair of hands at prayer.
Imogene Cade.
She is the managing partner of Tall Tide Partners, which poured concrete on the Marchand yard. She notarized a lie that said I confessed at two o’clock in the afternoon on a day when I was on a bus to Mobile. She is not on any witness list. She has simply come to watch.
She meets my eyes. She inclines her head, a small, gracious, entirely proper nod, as one might to a neighbor in a church parking lot.
I look away first. I hate that I do.
“Mr. Wynn,” says Judge Banks. “The jury has been waiting in the hall for forty minutes. Bring them in. And call your first witness.”
---
I walk to the stand.
It is eleven steps. I have never counted them from this direction. From the reporter’s chair to the witness box I used to take nine, and carried a machine, and nobody looked at me.
I put my left hand on the Bible. I raise my right. The clerk’s voice says, “Do you solemnly swear,” and I hear myself say I do, in the voice that is mine, that I took back on a bus and a ferry and in a plea room, and the whole room hears it and writes it down.
I sit. The chair is hard. I place my palms on my knees.
Across the well, at the defense table, in a charcoal suit that fits him better than anything I ever saw him wear, Ray Fenner looks at me.
He is smiling. It is the old smile, a little tired and a little proud, the smile of an uncle at a recital. It takes me in from head to toe. It asks, quite kindly, whether I have remembered to bring my machine.
I do not look away. I count the seconds he holds it. Eleven.
“Ms. Fenner,” says Wynn, from the lectern. He has put on his glasses. His voice is dry and courteous and perfectly steady. “Please state your full name for the record.”
“Ada Marie Fenner.”
“Spell it, please.”
I do. I do not need help.
“Thank you. Ms. Fenner, before I begin the substance, there is one thing I must ask you, and I ask it because the Court has already, quite properly, made it a matter of record.” He hesitates. It is the first hesitation I have ever seen in him.
His fingers rest on the contact sheet, which he has taken back, and which he is holding down against the lectern with the whole flat of his hand, as if the wind might take it. “Frame eleven. I did not show you the next frame. Frame twelve. I have not shown anyone. I am going to show it now, to you, and to the Court, and I would like you to tell me what you see.”
He crosses the well. He sets a glossy eight-by-ten on the ledge of the witness box, face up, in front of my hands.
It is the page. It is the same ledger, the same careful square hand, the same three pencil lines. I read them down, and they are exactly as I wrote them in my own notebook.
Then I reach the foot of the page, where the gooseneck lamp had thrown its edge of shadow. The picture has caught what my eyes did not. A fourth line, below the third, a hair’s breadth lighter, so faint that I would have missed it in a thousand years. A short line. A short name.
C. Marchand. Pending. Per L.C.
No sum.
I look up. And there in the third row of the gallery, in her father’s work coat, with her hands knotted in her lap and her eyes fixed on the ceiling, as if she had not heard a word, sits Colette.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!