MR. KESSLER: The witness concealed evidence in her footwear, Your Honor.
THE COURT: Where did you read that word?
MR. KESSLER: In the State’s own log, I believe.
THE COURT: Then I would like to meet the State’s own log.
Calder Wynn’s office is on the fourth floor of the annex, at the end of a hall that smells of toner and burnt coffee, and at six o’clock on Monday evening it looks like a place that has been robbed by an honest thief.
Every drawer is open. The files are out of them and stacked on the floor in careful towers, each one squared at the corners, each one labeled in the gray cardigan’s small upright hand. The windowsill holds three half-eaten sandwiches. The cardigan itself hangs on a coat rack, where it has the look of a man who has gone home early.
Wynn sits at his desk with his sleeves rolled to the elbow and a legal pad in front of him. He has drawn a line down the middle of the page. On the left he has written the names of everyone who stood in the chandlery on Sunday. On the right, nothing yet.
“Sit,” he says. “Not there. The chair is Mr. Pruitt’s, and I would prefer not to inherit his luck.”
I sit on a box instead. Otis stays in the doorway with his hat on his knee. Pru is on the floor with her back against the file cabinet and her shoes off, reading Kessler’s motion for the ninth time.
“It’s a good motion,” she says. “That’s what bothers me. It’s tight. Eleven pages. He wrote it in the time it takes to eat a sandwich.”
“He did not write it in that time,” says Wynn. “He received it.”
“Received it from whom?”
“That,” says Wynn, “is the left-hand column.” He taps the pad. “Sloane says Pruitt or Ivers. Sloane may be lying, though I think he has run out of that. Sloane also says he was in the kitchen with you and the box, which means he did not see the shoe. So someone else saw the shoe, or heard of it.”
“Nobody saw the shoe.”
“I saw it, Ms. Fenner. I was in the doorway, and you folded a page into your shoe with your back to the room. I said nothing, and I wrote down that I had seen it.” He lets that stand. “I am aware of how that sounds.”
“It sounds like the left-hand column.”
“It does. Put me in it.” He writes his own initials on the pad without ceremony. “I am the only man alive who saw you do it and did not tell Mr. Kessler. So how did Mr. Kessler learn of it?”
I do not answer, because I have just remembered a thing about the motion, and I am turning it over very carefully, the way you turn over a coin you suspect is counterfeit.
---
I should explain what a court reporter does with a document.
You think she reads it. She doesn’t. She hears it. Twelve years in a chair beside other people’s sentences will change the way your eyes work. A page stops being a page and becomes a transcript of somebody speaking, and a person who speaks has a habit, a hitch, a favorite word, a spot where the breath comes. Lawyers think they are writing in their own voices. They are not. They are writing in the voices of the forms they have copied from.
“Give me the motion,” I say.
Pru passes it up. I read page three.
“Footwear,” I say.
“What about it?”
“Mr. Kessler would not say footwear. Look at his other pleadings. Look at the Rule 404 notice, or the motion about the tape. He writes ‘shoe.’ He writes ‘boot’ when the boot is a boot. He’s a man who likes short words, because he wants the jury to like him. And here, on page three, in the paragraph about me, it says: ‘The witness secreted a handwritten note in her footwear and withheld it from the State from 4:28 p.m. onward.’”
“Four twenty-eight,” says Wynn, quite slowly.
“To the minute.” I look up. “Mr. Wynn, who counts the minutes in a thing like that? Not a lawyer. A lawyer writes ‘late Sunday afternoon.’ Somebody who keeps a log. A form with a column for time observed and a column for time disclosed.”
For a moment nobody says anything. Then Wynn does something I have not seen him do all day. He gets up, goes to the window, and stands with his hands behind his back, looking at the black glass and his own reflection in it.
“Footwear,” he says.
“Yes.”
“It is a word I use,” he says. “I wrote it myself. On Sunday evening, in my car outside the chandlery, in the evidence-tracking system, in a field marked ‘Source of recovery.’ I thought I was being precise. Source of recovery: witness footwear. Time observed, 4:28. Time of photograph, 4:31.” He turns. “I entered it at 6:40 p.m. Mr. Kessler’s motion was filed at 7:52 that same evening.”
“Who can read that system?” says Pru.
“The State’s attorney’s office. The county evidence room. Two detectives.” He is very still. “And the vendor.”
“What vendor?”
“The county’s case-management contract was renewed in the spring. I signed the purchase order myself, because it was cheaper and the old software crashed.” He passes a hand over his eyes. “It’s hosted off-site. It’s called Gulfline Information Systems. I did not look at the parent company. One does not, with software.”
---
It is Ivers who comes, in the end, and it is not for the reason I fear.
Wynn calls him up at half past six, and he arrives at seven, stooped, bespectacled, in a raincoat that is too short in the sleeves, with the pencil still behind his ear and a face that has gone the color of old paper. He stands in the doorway as if he expects to be fired, or arrested, or both, and in the second or two before anyone speaks I realize that I have been unfair to him for two days.
He is not a man who sells things. He is a man who counts them.
“Mr. Ivers,” says Wynn. “Sit down. Nobody is accusing you.”
“Mr. Pruitt says it was me.”
“Mr. Pruitt,” says Wynn, “has said a number of things.”
“I numbered the shelves.” Ivers does not sit. “I wrote the Roman numerals on the tape. I did not tell anyone about any shoe. I didn’t know about the shoe. I did not even know there was a note until I read it in the motion, and I thought, that poor girl, they’ve got her.”
“I believe you.”
“I’ve worked here nineteen years.”
“I know. I signed your last review.” Wynn comes around the desk. “I need to ask you a technical question. I would like you to answer it in the way that you would answer it for a stranger. When I log a piece of evidence into the system, where does it go?”
Ivers blinks. Of all the questions he expected, it is plainly not this one.
“It goes to the database,” he says. “It’s synced overnight to the vendor, and there’s a nightly digest. Every morning at six a.m. they email a report to the evidence officers. Chain-of-custody entries, new items, items moved. I print it and file it.”
“And the vendor? Does anyone at the vendor read the digest?”
“The vendor writes the digest.” He frowns. “There’s a support desk. There’s a man named Mr. Beck who comes when the printer breaks. And there’s an administrative account, for the security audit. I think it’s called SECR.”
“SECR,” I say.
It comes out of my mouth before I know that I have said it. Ivers turns and looks at me, a little startled.
“Short for Secretary?” I say.
“Security,” says Ivers. “Security and Records. It’s a rights account. It can see everything.”
The room has gone so quiet that I can hear the building’s heating system ticking, somewhere in the walls, like a clock with no hands.
“Mr. Ivers,” says Wynn, “would you please sit at my computer and tell me when that account last logged in?”
---
It takes nine minutes.
Ivers sits at the desk with his coat still on and his glasses pushed up onto his forehead and navigates screens I have never seen, in a program the color of a hospital corridor. Wynn stands behind him. Pru, in stocking feet, stands behind Wynn. I stand behind Pru and read over her shoulder, and nobody tells me to go away.
“There,” says Ivers. “The audit log. It lists every account, every login, every record viewed. Here is the State’s office. Here is Detective Sloane, at 6:20 Sunday evening. Here is Mr. Pruitt, at 6:52. Here is Mr. Wynn.” He scrolls. “Here is, ah. SECR. Viewed record 25-4471, Sunday, 6:58 p.m. That’s the chandlery item.”
“Eighteen minutes after I entered it,” says Wynn.
“It’s not alone.” Ivers sits very straight. “It has been through everything. The tow log. The Prejean file. The tape. The sealed submission.” He stops. “It was in the sealed submission.”
“That is under seal with the Court.”
“The copy was scanned for the Court, sir. By the clerk. Using the county’s scanner. And indexed in this system for the record. I’m sorry. I didn’t know it would be a problem.”
“Ms. Delacroix,” says Wynn, in a very quiet voice.
“I know.” Pru has gone white. “Plea paragraph nine. The part where we told Judge Banks which pages of the ledger we had and what Ada said about the shoe. It was in there. Ada, I wrote it in there. I put the shoe in a sealed filing.”
“You did what any lawyer would have done.”
“I put it in a database.”
“You put it in a vault,” I say, “and the vault had a second door.”
It is, I realize, the second time tonight that I have said something in a tone of strange calm. I am finding that fear, taken in a sufficient quantity, turns into a sort of clarity. It’s like being very cold. After a while you cannot feel your hands and you can see everything.
“It was never Pruitt,” I say. “It was never Mr. Ivers. And it wasn’t Sloane, except for one line with a glove. The man who told Mr. Kessler about the shoe is a login. He has been reading this office’s mail for six months. He knows what we know a quarter of an hour after we know it.”
“Six months,” says Wynn. He has put his hand on the back of Ivers’s chair, as if to steady himself. “Every filing. The Prejean exhumation. The chain of custody on page 312.”
“The tow log,” says Pru.
“Teague’s tape.”
“The letter from Ms. Fenner,” says Ivers, in a thin voice, “to her lawyer. I scanned that. It was a legal letter. I thought it was privileged.”
“What letter?” I say.
“The one dated Wednesday. ‘Dear Pru. Here is a list of names that I think were in the room.’” He swallows. “It had the six names. I’m so sorry, Ms. Fenner.”
I did write it. I wrote it in the Hale kitchen on Wednesday night, in longhand, on lined paper, and I gave it to Pru at the courthouse. It was ours. We thought it safe. It was safe in the way a coat is safe when it is hung on a stranger’s hook.
“Close it,” says Wynn.
“Sir?”
“The whole system. Shut it. Get on the telephone to the county, to the vendor, to whoever you must, and tell them the State’s office is suspending the account for security cause. Tonight. We go to paper.”
“Paper.” Ivers looks as though a prayer has been answered. “Yes, sir. Paper. I like paper.”
---
By eight o’clock the stacks on the floor have grown. They have a new rule, and the rule is that nothing is typed.
Ms. Garza has come back from wherever she goes, and has sat down at the long table with a stack of index cards. Ivers is writing on them, one by one, in a hand so small and regular that it looks printed. Otis has gone to fetch coffee from the machine on the second floor, and is, I gather, locked in a long argument with it.
Pru has put her shoes back on. Nobody has yet said what we all know, which is that we have been, for six months, a family sitting at a dinner table with the windows open.
I take the chance to sit with Wynn. He has gone back behind his desk, and has the legal pad in front of him again, and is looking at the line down the middle.
“You said to me once,” I say, “that the only thing a drawer cannot do is lie.”
“I did.”
“You said it again this afternoon. To Sloane.”
“Yes.”
“I’d like to correct the record.” I wait until he looks up. “A drawer doesn’t lie. It also can’t keep a secret. A drawer has a keyhole, Mr. Wynn. You can’t blame the drawer when somebody has been making copies of the key.”
“That is a very kind sentence.”
“It isn’t kind. It’s a transcript.” I try for a smile and do not quite get there. “I spent five years sitting beside a man who made me think that being in the room was the same as being innocent. It isn’t. You were in the room. So was I.”
“You are suggesting we should forgive ourselves.”
“I’m suggesting we should read it back.”
He regards me for a very long moment. In the lamplight he looks tired in a way that has nothing to do with the hour. Then, unexpectedly, he laughs: a short dry cough of a laugh, the first I have heard from him, and takes his glasses off to wipe them on his tie.
“Ms. Fenner,” he says, “I have been a prosecutor for twenty-six years. I would like to say that I have never been lectured by a defendant in my own office, but it is rapidly becoming the custom.”
“I’m not a defendant. I pleaded.”
“Quite right. A witness. A cooperating witness. It is worse.” He puts his glasses back on. “Go home. You have a curfew, Deputy Hale is hovering, and it is ten past eight.”
“I’m not hovering,” says Otis, from the doorway, with a Styrofoam cup in each hand. He has a splash of coffee down his sleeve. “I am stationed.”
---
We are at the elevator when the printer starts.
It is in the corridor, on a little steel stand, a big gray copier with a tray of paper and a green light, and for the last two hours it has been so quiet that I had stopped seeing it. Now it clears its throat with a small mechanical cough. A light goes from green to amber. Something inside begins to hum.
“Is that yours?” says Pru.
“The system is off,” says Ivers. He is still at the long table, and has stood up. “I unplugged the network cable myself. I took out the card. It’s on the desk.”
“Then who is printing?”
Nobody answers.
The machine takes a long breath. A single sheet slides out into the tray, white and slightly warm, and lies still.
Wynn gets there first. He does not touch it. He takes a ballpoint from his pocket and uses the tip to turn the page, very gently, so that it faces him, and I see his shoulders change.
“Ms. Fenner,” he says.
I come around him. The page is blank except for a line of black type, centered, in a plain font, with a gap above and below it like a name on a door. It is not a long line. I could read it in the dark.
It says:
A. FENNER. PENDING.
And under it, smaller, in the same font, with a date and a time, the sort of stamp that machines put on things for the record:
Mon 01/12, 8:14 PM. Printed from: SECR.
Behind me, from the long table, Ivers makes a small sound, the sound of a man who has been told that the cable he pulled was the wrong one.
I look at the page. I look at the green eye of the machine, steady and patient. It is not looking at me. It has no way to. And I think, with a calm that I do not at all feel, that for the first time in this whole long season I have been asked a question by someone who wants to hear me answer.
Then the light on the printer goes amber again, and the machine begins to hum.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!