MR. KESSLER: Mr. Tibbs, who owns the stamp?
THE WITNESS: The Association.
MR. KESSLER: And who may use it?
THE WITNESS: Anybody with a key to the drawer.
Tuesday is a day of paper, and I mean that kindly.
Nothing is typed in the State’s office. Ivers sits at a card table in the corridor outside Division F with a shoebox of index cards and a fountain pen he has borrowed from Garza, and every exhibit that comes into the courtroom is written down by hand before it goes in and by hand again when it goes out. It makes the morning slow. It also makes it quiet. For the first time in a week I have the sense that no one is reading over our shoulders.
I do not believe it. I sit in the gallery, in the fourth row on the aisle, where Otis can see me and I can see the door, and I watch the room breathe.
There are more people than yesterday. Word has traveled in the manner of word in a small port: by the dock, by the diner, by the girl at the pharmacy counter who knew Nell’s cousin. The front benches are full of men in windbreakers who work on the water.
The back benches are full of women who have taken the morning off. Imogene Cade sits where she sat on Monday, in a navy suit, with her hands folded over a small black purse, and does not look at me even once, which is a form of looking.
Ruth Okonkwo is at the machine. She wears the green blazer again. She has put a peppermint on the corner of her desk, a gift, I think, from Otis, and she has not touched it.
I wish I could say that I am not watching her hands. I watch them all morning. It is the only way I know to sit still.
---
D. Tibbs is the tow driver, and he is the State’s second witness, and he does not want to be here.
He is a thick, slow man of fifty with sunburned forearms and a gold tooth, and he sits in the box as though it were a tugboat in a high sea, gripping the rail. When Wynn asks him to say his name he says it twice. When Wynn asks him to describe his work he says, “I tow,” and then, after a visible effort, “I tow boats. For the Association. I been towing for them twenty-two years.”
“On October fifteenth of last year, Mr. Tibbs, did you receive a work order?”
“Yes, sir.”
“From whom?”
“It came on the log. On the clipboard. Wasn’t signed. It said, ‘Authorized per L.C.’”
“And did you know who L.C. was?”
“Everybody knows who L.C. is.”
“Please tell the jury.”
“Mr. Lionel Cade.” Tibbs does not look at the gallery. “President of the pilots. He’s the one signs the checks at Christmas.”
There is a small rustle behind me. Wynn lets it pass. He asks about the order, which was to move a barge called the Margaret Anne from a berth near the Prejean yard to a mooring in the channel, in the dark, with the lights off, on a night when the tide was running out.
He asks what the barge carried. He asks who was on it when it left. Tibbs says he does not know, he did not look, he was not paid to look. He says it flatly, like a man reading a hymn he has never believed.
“You took your instructions from the log.”
“Yes, sir.”
“Did you ever question one?”
“No, sir. You don’t. You get a sheet, you go.”
“Thank you.” Wynn sits down. “Your witness.”
Bram Kessler rises like a man getting up from a good lunch.
---
“Mr. Tibbs,” he says, “I wonder if you’d help me with a small matter of housekeeping.”
“Yes, sir.”
“This log, the one you read from. Where is it kept?”
“On a nail. In the dispatcher’s shack.”
“Is the shack locked?”
“No, sir.”
“So any person who wished to could walk in and write on that clipboard.”
“I guess.”
“Anyone with a pen.”
“Well, there’s a stamp.” Tibbs shifts. “The Association has got a stamp. The initials. ‘Authorized per.’ It’s a rubber stamp, you press it down and then you write in whose. It’s in the desk drawer. Some of the dispatchers use it.”
“I’m sorry. A rubber stamp?”
“Yes, sir.”
“So the notation ‘Authorized per L.C.’ on the October fifteenth log was not necessarily handwritten by Mr. Cade himself.”
“Don’t know that it was. Was in pencil.”
“But the words ‘per L.C.’ might have been put there by a dispatcher. Or a clerk. Or a night man. Or anybody with a key to that drawer.”
Tibbs thinks about it. He is, I realize, an honest man, and honesty makes him slow. He stares at his own hands. “Yes, sir,” he says. “It might.”
“Thank you, Mr. Tibbs. Nothing further.”
It is exactly the right size of blow. It does not knock down the State’s case. It only takes one brick from the wall and carries it away, and the jury, which has watched a man take it, leans slightly back. I see the woman in the blue cardigan write something. I see Ray, at the defense table, bow his head a quarter of an inch: gratitude, or prayer.
And I see a thing that is not in the transcript.
When Kessler says the word stamp, Lionel Cade, in the second row, behind the rail, reaches up and touches the ship’s wheel pin on his lapel. He does it very lightly. It is the gesture of a man making sure that a button is fastened.
I write nothing down. I do not have a pen. I have what I have always had, which is the moment, whole, in my head, like a plate in a cabinet.
---
The corridor at the recess is wide and cold and lined with benches. I am sitting on one of them with a paper cup of water when someone sits down beside me, a respectful yard away, and crosses his ankles.
“Miss Fenner,” says Lionel Cade. “Forgive me. I’ll only be a minute.”
Otis is on his feet in an instant, six feet away, with his hand on his belt. Cade lifts one palm without turning his head.
“Deputy. I am a man of sixty-three with a bad hip, in a public hallway, under the eye of a bailiff and two cameras. You may stand where you like. I only wish to speak to the young lady, in the open, where she can hear me and I can’t be misquoted.”
“You may not discuss the testimony,” says Otis.
“I wouldn’t dream of it.”
He is, I think, the most handsome old man I have ever seen. It is not that his face is kind. It is that it is clear. The white hair is combed straight back. The gray suit has been cut by someone who loves him. The hands, folded loosely on his knee, are the broad brown hands of a man who spent forty years on a ladder in the weather, and he wears no ring but a plain gold band.
The pin on his lapel is a very small brass wheel.
He smiles. It is the smile of an uncle at a christening.
“I knew your uncle,” he says. “Thirty years.”
“Everyone did.”
“Yes.” He tilts his head. “Ray used to say you could tell a man’s whole character from the way he handed you a pen. You, I think, would hand a man a pen and tell him it was dull.”
“Mr. Cade.”
“Please. Lionel.”
“Mr. Cade, if you have something to say to me, I’d like you to say it, because I have a witness room waiting.”
“Of course.” He nods, approving. “Straight to it. I like that. Then let me say two things, and you may do what you please with them.
“The first is that you have been, I’m afraid, badly misled about the Fund.” He lifts a finger, gently. “I am not going to argue the book. A book is a book. Mr. Wynn has it, and I am told it has a number of lines in it that do not reflect well on any of us.
But you have formed a picture, I think, in which an association of old sailors sits around a table and decides who shall die. It isn’t so. It has never been so. I’ll swear it.”
“You don’t have to swear it. You have an oath on Thursday.”
“The Fund has never paid a dollar to a person who did not ask.” He says it quite gently. “Let me say that again. Not one dollar, Miss Fenner. In twenty-two years. When a man’s husband is lost, or his father, or his brother, on the water or off it, there is a certain kind of family that needs help and has too much pride to ask a stranger.
They ask us. Quietly. We help. The word we use is settled. It means that the thing is put to rest. Nothing else.”
“Nothing else.”
“I have sat in kitchens,” says Lionel Cade, “with women whose heat was cut off, and left an envelope under a sugar bowl.”
He stops. For a moment, and I would swear to it, his eyes are wet.
I want to believe him. That is the terrible thing. It is the most seductive sentence I have ever heard. It has a kitchen in it, and a sugar bowl, and the cold. If I had not seen thirteen lines in a locker and a line rubbed out of a ledger, I would have patted his hand.
“Mr. Cade,” I say. “Etienne Marchand left a card in a locker. It said: ‘I was asked to sign. I will not.’”
“Yes.”
“Did he ask for the envelope?”
For the first time in the conversation the old man’s face does not move at all.
“Etienne,” he says, “was an extraordinary man. He was also the single most stubborn man I ever met. He would not take a thing he had not earned.” He takes a breath. “The November after his death, the note on the Marchand yard was paid in full. The whole of it.
Eleven years of arrears, and the principal. Nobody asked who paid. His widow did not ask. His boy was ten years old, and a note is a very heavy thing for a child to inherit, and I will say, Miss Fenner, that I have never regretted that envelope.”
I do not move.
I am thinking of a yard in the rain. A row of boats on stands, and a man with oil on his sleeves telling me that it was the only place in the world that he did not have to be sorry.
“The yard,” I say.
“I thought you ought to know,” says Cade, almost tenderly, “that the ground your young man stands on was a settlement. I don’t say it to wound. I say it because he will hear it eventually, and I would rather he heard it from a friend.”
---
“What is the second thing?” I say.
It is a long moment before he answers. Down the corridor a door opens, and the sheriff’s deputy calls a name, and no one moves.
“The second thing,” says Cade, “concerns what you think you saw yesterday in the loading-dock business. A poor sad man took a bribe. I am sorry for him. I would have given Sloane his daughter’s tuition myself, had he asked. What I want to say is that the Association is a very large house, and there are men in it, and some women, who do not share my notion of how a quarrel ends.
I have been President for nineteen years. I cannot be everywhere. Gulfline is a contractor, Miss Fenner. A contractor does what it is paid to do.”
“Is that a warning?”
“It’s a weather report.” He opens his hands. “Your friend Mr. Marchand will be going into a building in two days that I do not own and do not control. A building has rules. A warden has discretion. An unhappy man in a small cell can accumulate a great many small infractions in eighteen months. I have seen it. I would hate it. Eighteen months is a sentence. Four years is a sentence also, and the second can be built out of the first by a few bad forms.”
“You want something.”
“I want to be understood.” He turns his head and looks at me at last, full on, with those clear eyes. “He is a proud man. He may think, in there, that there is dignity in being difficult. A letter from you, Miss Fenner, in your good plain hand, telling him to accept the protective unit when it is offered, to sign what he is given, and to keep his head down, would do more for him than any judge.
He listens to you. He would sign a thing if you asked him to.”
“And Colette?”
I did not intend to say it. I have said it.
“Ah,” says Lionel Cade. “Miss Marchand. The line in the book.” He sighs. “Yes, that was unfortunate. The sum was never filled in. It’s a convention, you understand, to leave the blank until the matter is concluded. A great deal can depend upon what a person turns out to be worth. I would say, as one who has known the family since before you were born, that she is worth a very great deal to me, and she would find me generous, if I were permitted to be.”
He stands. It costs him a little. He settles his coat and smooths the lapel over the pin, and at the end of the bench he pauses and looks down at me with a sort of admiring regret, the way a man looks at a very fine horse he will not be allowed to ride.
“You have a lovely hand,” he says. “I’ve seen it in the exhibits. Most of the people who have worked for this Association could not hold a pen so steadily. I should like to think that it won’t be wasted.”
He walks away down the long cold corridor. The recess bell rings.
---
I do not tell the witness room right away.
I go in. I sit. Pru is eating a granola bar and reading the Tibbs transcript, which Ruth has already sent up, and says, “You look as though you’ve swallowed a bell.” Wynn is at the window, going through the sheriff’s logs with a magnifying glass. Garza is writing a card. Everything is as it was. And in my pocket, rolled between my fingers, is the thing that a court reporter is not supposed to hold: a sentence I would give anything to forget.
The ground your young man stands on was a settlement.
It is not a threat. That is why it is so exact. It is a fact, delivered like a casserole, with a kindly look.
“Ada,” says Pru.
“The yard was paid for by the Fund,” I say.
They look at me.
“The Marchand yard. The note. The November after Etienne died. Cade says it was paid in full by the Association. He told me in the hall, on purpose, to see what I’d do.” I take out the paper cup, which I have somehow carried in with me, and put it on the table. “Jude doesn’t know. Colette doesn’t know. I don’t think anyone knows. I think the old man has held it for twenty-one years against the day it would be useful.”
Wynn lowers his glass. “He told you this in a public corridor.”
“With a deputy standing six feet away.”
“Then he wished it to be heard.” Wynn sets the glass down. “That is the whole of Mr. Cade’s method, Ms. Fenner. He never takes a thing in secret that he can do in the open and call a kindness. I have watched him run a Port Authority board for eleven years. He once gave a hospital wing to a man who was suing him.”
“He asked me to write Jude a letter.”
“Saying what?”
“Sign what you’re given.” I look at my hands. “Keep your head down.”
“And will you?”
“I’m going to write him a letter,” I say. “Tonight. A good plain one.”
Nobody asks what it will say. Outside the window, on the Port Sable water, a long gray tugboat goes by, pulling a barge with no name, very slowly, as though it were carrying something that it has been told not to drop.
I have thirty hours to decide how to tell a man that he has been standing on a gift. And I find, to my own surprise, that it is not the yard that frightens me.
It is what he will do with it.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!