THE CLERK: On the count of murder in the first degree, in the death of Walter Prejean, how do you find?
Twelve people take an hour and fifty minutes on Tuesday morning to say a thing that one man said on Monday in forty.
I am not in the courtroom for the closings. Banks has ruled that I may sit through the verdict, as a witness who has finished, and not before, and so I wait on the long oak bench in the corridor outside Division F with Colette on one side and Loretta Aldous on the other, listening to the door. It is a heavy door. Through it come a murmur, a pause, a murmur, the sound of a man being fair.
“They’ll be an hour,” says Loretta, who has not touched the coffee Marisol sent. “A jury always takes an hour to look as though it has thought.”
“They have to find it,” says Colette. “He told them. They have to find it.”
“It’s not about finding it, honey.” Loretta smooths her navy skirt over her knees. “It’s about being seen to.”
At twenty past eight, Pru comes out into the corridor with a sheet of paper in one hand and a stunned expression, and shows it to me without a word.
It is Mr. Voss’s answer to the Judge. It is a single page, typed, on the letterhead of a firm that has occupied the same four floors of the same building on Dauphin Street for sixty years. It says that Mr. Voss has been counsel to the Harbor Pilots’ Association since the death of his father, and has acted for Mr. Lionel Cade in that capacity and no other.
It says that he has no knowledge of any second paragraph. It says that if the Court considers his further participation inappropriate, he will withdraw from the defense of Mr. Cade the younger and Gulfline Detention Services, but not from the Association, which is a client of long standing, and which he cannot abandon in its hour of need.
“He’s resigning,” says Colette.
“He’s choosing which fire to stand in,” says Pru. “He wants to keep the file.”
---
The jury comes out at twenty to twelve.
I go in behind Loretta. I take the aisle seat in the third row where I sat yesterday, and fold my hands, and look at the back of Ray’s head.
He is in the same bad suit. Somebody has found him a belt. He sits with his hands flat on his knees and a face turned to the bench, and I think that of all the people in the room he is the only one who is not afraid. He has the settled, hollowed calm of a man who has put down the heaviest thing he owns and has not yet noticed that his arms are lighter.
The foreperson is a retired schoolteacher in a lavender cardigan, a thin woman of sixty with a folded paper. She stands when the Judge tells her to. Her voice shakes on the first word, and does not shake after.
“On the count of murder in the first degree,” says the clerk, “how do you find?”
“We find the defendant guilty.”
There is no sound in the gallery. There is, instead, the particular quiet of a thing that has been expected and is still a blow.
On the second count, conspiracy, guilty. On the third, tampering with evidence, guilty. The clerk reads each of them in the voice of a woman reading a recipe. Ray does not move. At the first *guilty* his hands tighten on his knees, once, as if somebody had touched them. By the third, they have gone slack.
“Mr. Fenner,” says Banks, “do you wish the jury polled?”
“No, Your Honor.” He stands. His voice carries to the back of the room, not loud, just clear. “I’d like to thank them. It’s a hard thing, to be asked to sit and listen to a man like me. I’d like it said that I’m obliged.”
“The Court will convey it.” Banks takes off his glasses. “Mr. Fenner, the law prescribes a sentence for this offense. It is life, without parole. I would be failing in my duty if I did not tell you that I have no discretion on that point, and I would be failing in another duty if I did not allow the victim’s family to be heard.
Sentencing will take place tomorrow, Wednesday, at two o’clock in the afternoon. Is there anything you wish to say before you are remanded?”
“One thing, sir.”
“Yes.”
“I’d like Mrs. Prejean to speak first.” Ray does not turn. “I’d like that to be the order. I’d like nothing said after she’s finished that isn’t said by her.”
“The Court will take it under advisement.”
He nods. A bailiff touches his sleeve.
He turns then, at the rail, for the first time since he came in. He looks across the well and over the heads in the second row and finds me, and his face does a thing I will carry for the rest of my life. It is not an apology. It is not a plea. It is a man looking at a person he has not truly looked at in years and recognizing her.
“Ada,” he says. It is hardly a sound. “That’ll do.”
I do not know what he means. I think I know.
---
Evangeline Prejean is waiting by the elevator when I come out.
She has her knitting bag over her arm and her good coat on, and she does not look as though she has been crying. She looks, as she always has, like a woman in the middle of a task who has been interrupted by the end of the world and will resume it directly. I have not spoken to her since the plea, in the courtroom, when she nodded.
“Mrs. Prejean.”
“Miss Fenner.” She presses the call button, which is already lit. “I’ll say this once, and you may take it however you like.”
“Yes, ma’am.”
“I am not going to forgive your father. I want that understood. I am sixty-eight years old and I have not got the time for it.” She looks, at last, at me, with her pale, dry, unrelenting eyes. “I am going to stand up tomorrow and say what Walter was. That is all I mean to do. I mean to say that he wrote a kind thing and it was made into an unkind one. And then your father may say what he likes.”
“I am sorry for—”
“Don’t.” It is quiet and exact. “Don’t be sorry to me in a corridor. I have had ten weeks of people being sorry to me in a corridor.”
The elevator arrives. She steps in, with her bag, and turns, and stands with her hands folded on the handle, and does not look at me again. The doors close on the small straight line of her back.
It is the first time anybody has cut me, in this whole business, and I find that it is not a thing I would have been spared. I would rather it was this than comfort.
---
Wynn comes for me at ten to two.
He has a warrant in his hand, and he has the look of a man who has been up since four and is no longer certain he remembers why. He says that Banks signed it at one, in chambers, over a ham sandwich. He says that it is for the offices of the Members’ Relief Fund, on the second floor of the Harbor Pilots’ Association hall, on the grounds that a typewriter in that place is the likely instrument of a forged statement, and that Dr.
Brandt will be present, and that the order, in a paragraph he has marked with a pencil, permits one named civilian witness to accompany the search for purposes of identification.
“You are the civilian witness,” he says.
“I am excluded from Association property.”
“Except under warrant.” He turns the paper so that I can see the line. “It was Banks’s own sanction, Ms. Fenner. I merely read it as written.”
I have my coat. I have no pad. I follow him down the steps into the cold.
The Harbor Pilots’ Association hall is a long, low, handsome building of yellow brick on the harbor road, with a copper roof gone green and a flagpole, and a gilded ship’s wheel over the door. I have driven past it all my life. I have never gone in. It has the look, from the road, of a bank in a small town, or a church that has never been asked what it believes.
There are men on the steps.
I count nineteen, in canvas coats and pea jackets and one or two in suits, standing in two loose rows on either side of the door. Nobody speaks. They are, I think, all pilots, or their sons. They have the shoulders of men who spend their lives going down ladders in the dark. Not one of them is a stranger to me. I have seen them in the gallery. I have taken down their testimony, in my head.
Wynn goes up the steps with the warrant held in front of him like a lantern. The men part. I go after him, in my brown coat, with Otis a pace behind, and Dr. Brandt on my right, a small gray woman with a rolling case, and I feel nineteen pairs of eyes go over me one at a time, as a hand goes over a rope to check for a fray.
At the top step, a man in a navy jacket, one of the older ones, with a white mustache and a face like boiled leather, puts his hand to his lapel.
He takes off a small enamel pin. It is a ship’s wheel. It is the pin that Lionel Cade wore, that all of them wear, a tiny gold and blue emblem of an order.
He does not throw it. He bends, slowly, with a creak of the knee, and sets it on the step at my feet, and straightens, and looks past me at the harbor. He does not say anything at all.
I step over it. It is the hardest thing I have done today.
---
The Secretary’s office is on the second floor, at the end of a long corridor smelling of floor wax and old cigars.
It is a small, square, quiet, extremely clean room. There is a window onto the water. There is a desk with a green blotter and a brass lamp, and on the wall a framed photograph of the Association’s founders, nine men in bowler hats on the steps of the building, squinting into a long-dead sun.
There is a kettle on a hot plate, and a china cup upside down on a saucer. On a table by the window, under a gray quilted cover, stands the machine.
The caretaker, a stooped man with a ring of keys, takes off the cover himself.
It is an old Royal, black and gold, with round glass keys and a carriage the length of my arm. The paint is worn off the space bar in a shallow thumb-shaped saddle. There is a sheet of cream paper in the roller, blank, with the top edge curled.
Dr. Brandt does not touch it. She stands before it for a full minute, with her case at her feet, and her hands in her pockets, as one stands before a fine animal that may or may not bite.
“Ms. Fenner,” says Wynn. “If you would.”
I bend. I put my face level with the type bars, and the little curved basket of them, and I press, with one finger, the e.
It is closed. The loop is a dark pinhole. It prints, in the air, in my mind, the tiny black dot that I have seen four times in two days.
“That is the machine,” I say.
“Thank you.” Wynn nods at the court’s photographer, a young man with a flash, who lifts his camera. “Let the record show that Ms. Fenner has identified it by the fault in the lowercase e, the capital R, and the comma. Dr. Brandt?”
“I will want the ribbon,” says Dr. Brandt.
---
It is the ribbon, I learn, that matters.
The Royal does not use a fabric ribbon, like the one in the machine at my mother’s old office. It uses a carbon film, a thin black plastic strip that passes between the type and the paper and is struck once, and leaves each letter behind in negative. It is a sort of transcript. Every word that has been typed on it is still there, a ghost of the typing, if one has the patience to read it backward.
Dr. Brandt takes the spool out in a pair of white cotton gloves. She sets it on a sheet of black velvet, under a lamp with a magnifying lens on a swing arm, and begins to unwind, one slow inch at a time, with a small steel hook.
Nobody speaks. The caretaker has gone pale. A man from Voss’s office, a pink young man with glasses who has come up from the street to object, stands by the door with his mouth slightly open, as though about to do it, and does not.
“Here,” says Dr. Brandt, after eleven minutes. “The last strike, in sequence, reading from the end.”
She reads. She reads in the dry, quiet voice of a woman who has been paid for thirty years to say what a thing is, and has never been asked what it’s for.
“*I, Imogene Teague Cade, being of sound mind and acting alone, do hereby state and swear*—” She pauses. “That’s four pages. A statement. It runs without correction, a single sitting, two fingers. The typist hits the space bar twice after every period. He is not a secretary. He’s left-handed, and he’s in a great hurry, and he has been taught to type by someone who disapproved.”
“Cade Jr.,” says Wynn.
“I cannot tell you that. I can tell you the date on the ribbon’s counter, which is January the ninth, between four and six in the afternoon.” She turns another inch. “Before it are eleven forms. They are releases. Printed forms with fill-in blanks. They are all in a different hand, a neat one. A good typist. Forty words a minute, with a trained wrist.” She looks up. “It is the hand of the lady who typed the Rules.”
Imogene. Then Cade Jr. And between them, on a spool of film, the whole shape of a family.
“Go on,” says Wynn.
“After the statement, in the other direction, the last thing the machine has done.” She frowns. She runs the hook forward a quarter inch, and then another. “That’s odd. It’s a new strike. It’s not on the counter at all. It’s a short document, one page, done by the neat hand, the lady’s hand, after the ninth. Perhaps Sunday.”
“Read it.”
“*RELEASE AND FULL SETTLEMENT*,” says Dr. Brandt. “*Know all persons by these presents that the undersigned, in consideration of the sum of twenty-five thousand dollars, the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, does hereby release and discharge the Members’ Relief Fund of the Harbor Pilots’ Association, and all of its officers, from any and all claims arising out of the death of*—”
She stops.
“Dr. Brandt?”
“A name,” says Dr. Brandt, in a different voice, and puts the magnifier away from her eye. “I am sorry, Mr. Wynn. I will read it exactly. *Of Imogene Teague Cade, deceased.*” She swallows. “And the date. *Wednesday, the twenty-first of January.*”
---
Nobody moves.
The window is full of gray water. Somewhere far off, on the harbor, a ship sounds one long low note. The man from Voss’s office takes one step into the room and says, in a small clear voice, “I’d like to place a call.”
“Do,” says Wynn, and does not look at him.
I am looking at the photograph on the wall. Nine men in bowler hats, squinting. I count them. There is a woman at the edge of the frame, half cut off, in a long coat, carrying a cup on a tray.
“She typed it Sunday,” I say.
“Yes.”
“After she’d sat on a porch, and handed me her statement, and asked me to put my name to it. Sunday. After the hearing, and after Banks signed the warrants. She came home, and sat down, and wrote her own release.”
“I do not think,” says Wynn, “that she wrote it for herself.”
“Who for?”
“Her Rule. The one they have kept for twenty-two years. When a person’s death will expose the Association to a claim.” He draws a breath. “She has been the Acting Secretary for twenty-two years, Ms. Fenner. She did what a Secretary does. She prepared the paper in advance.”
“And her son,” I say, very slowly, “knew the date.”
“Her son brought her the statement on the ninth. He had the same arrangement, and the same list. It is a schedule. It is a *schedule*.” He has turned away, for the first time, and is looking out of the window, with his hands behind him. “I think it is the schedule that has been doing it. For years. I do not think anybody has been choosing at all.”
I think of a gray envelope. Of a tin, left on a car seat. Of a man who said, *I’ll sign for widows,* and was given a night to sleep on it.
I think of a woman in a gray coat who said, *It is a very nice porch.*
My telephone buzzes in my pocket. It is a number I know. It is the Sheriff’s.
“Otis,” I say.
He is already beside me. He takes the phone out of my hand, very gently, and puts it to his ear, and listens with his chin tucked down. I watch his face. I have learned, in two months, that Otis Hale has one face for ordinary news and another for the kind that has to be translated, and this is the second.
“All right,” he says. “All right, Sergeant. We’re coming.”
He hands me back the phone.
“That was Deloach. Mrs. Cade’s in a holding room at the Sheriff’s, with a matron, and nobody’s allowed in. It is half past four.” He looks at me, then at Wynn, then at the black ribbon on its square of velvet. “A cart has just come up from the commissary with a single item on it.
It’s red, and it has her name on the card. And the man pushing it says he has a standing order, to be filled on a date that the system says is tomorrow, and that it’s no business of his if the lady’s anxious to have it today.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!