Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 25

Privilege

Orphans' Court sits in City Hall, up a marble staircase worn into shallow dishes by a century of people carrying the paperwork of the dead. Courtroom 411 had a ceiling like a wedding cake and a heating system that clanked every four minutes like a prisoner rapping a cup on bars. I sat in the third row of the gallery, a woman on leave with a legal pad, and nobody told me to leave because there is no rule against watching.

Joanne Pruitt sat in the front row beside her husband, Ray, a big quiet man in a bakery-supply jacket who held his cap in both hands as if it might go off. Across the aisle, Cole Whitaker sat alone at the Commonwealth's table. At the other table sat Ellery Sachs, in a charcoal suit with a pocket square the color of cream, and next to him a younger, sleeker version of him named Gordon Marsh, with a very new briefcase.

The Honorable Isadora Pell was sixty-eight, five feet tall in her heels, with pearl-gray hair and reading glasses she took off to look at anything she meant to remember. She had a habit of saying "I see" after every argument, in a tone that gave nothing away. By the second hour I had come to think of it as her entire jurisprudence.

"Mr. Sachs. You have a petition."

Sachs rose with the courtly boredom of a doctor discussing someone else's illness.

"Your Honor, eight years ago a man came to my office with a wish to start over. His name was Dale Kimmel. I drew his petition to change it. I drew his will. I advised him on the opening of a safe deposit box, which he leased in the name he'd chosen. He is deceased. The Commonwealth proposes to open that box on a theory of its own. I say that every paper in it was placed there in confidence, on my advice, as part of my representation, and that I am bound by the oldest rule in the profession to assert his privilege on his behalf."

"I see," said Judge Pell.

"The privilege survives death. It is not mine to waive. It is his."

"And who speaks for him?"

"No one has yet qualified, Your Honor. Which is why my colleague Mr. Marsh has filed a petition with the Register to appoint a neutral professional administrator, a fiduciary with no stake in the Commonwealth's case, to preserve the estate until a proper personal representative can be named." He smiled. "For the family's protection."

Cole rose, politely. "Your Honor, the Commonwealth's position is that the crime-fraud exception applies. And that there's a living next of kin in this courtroom, Mrs. Joanne Pruitt, the decedent's sister, who has already delivered documents to the police voluntarily."

"Has Mrs. Pruitt been appointed?"

"She has applied, Your Honor."

"I see," said the judge, and she took off her glasses, and looked down at the front row. "Mrs. Pruitt. Do you have a lawyer?"

Joanne stood up. Her hands went to her cardigan buttons, then dropped.

"No, ma'am. I run a cafeteria. For six hundred children." Her voice cracked once on the last word and then held. "I didn't know I needed one until about Friday."

A ripple went around the gallery that was not quite a laugh.

"Mrs. Pruitt, you need one by Friday." Judge Pell turned a page. "Here is what I will do. Box 2218 is sealed. The bank will keep it in the vault, unopened, in the presence of its own officer, and nobody enters it until I have heard argument. Friday at three o'clock. I will hear who has the right to speak for Mr. Kimmel. I will hear Mr. Sachs's privilege. And I will hear from someone in this room who is not a lawyer." She looked, for a moment, directly at Joanne. "I see you, madam. We'll find out who you are by Friday."

"Your Honor," said Marsh, "the Register has set the competing petitions for hearing on Monday."

"Monday," said Pell, "is after Friday, Mr. Marsh. I can count." Gavel. A fraction of a smile. "We're adjourned."

I stayed in my seat after everyone stood, because I had stopped hearing the room.

The privilege belongs to the client. The client is dead. His privilege passes to whoever represents his estate. Whoever holds the letters of administration, the personal representative, has the power to assert it or to waive it. Sachs had been so careful to say it was not his to waive that he had told the whole room whose it was. And he knew it as well as I did, which was why a younger man with a new briefcase had been tasked with making sure the person who held it on Friday would be someone he'd chosen.

It was a race. Not between lawyers. Between two kinds of loyalty, over a woman in a cardigan who had never once been asked what she wanted.

I went down the corridor quickly, looking for Cole, and caught him at the drinking fountain.

"Yes," he said, without turning. "I got it at seven this morning, in the shower. Whoever's administrator holds it. I can't be her lawyer. I'm the Commonwealth, and I'm a witness in her brother's case, and she'd have a conflict you could drive a bus through." He straightened, wiping his mouth. "And you can't, either. You're not her lawyer. You can't advise a woman whose interests might diverge from your client's. You haven't got a client. That's worse."

"I'm aware of the rule."

"I'm aware you're aware. I'm saying don't give her a look. A look is advice."

"I'm not going to give her a look."

"You're giving me one right now."

At 1:15 I stood in the hallway outside Courtroom 411 with Joanne and Ray, in a line of people waiting for the elevator that has not worked in living memory. Joanne was holding her purse with both arms, a mother carrying a sleeping child. She said she hadn't known the judge would say madam. Ray said nothing. Joanne said that Ray had been laid off in October and that they were three payments behind on the roof, and that she only wanted it entered somewhere.

"I'm not entering anything," I said. "I'm listening."

It was then that the man came down the hallway.

He was in a gray suit, forty, polished, carrying a flat leather folio against his chest the way a waiter carries a menu.

"Mrs. Pruitt? Joanne Pruitt?" He did not wait for an answer. "I represent a party with a deep and sincere regret about your brother's death. Mr. Marsh asked me to bring you this personally, with condolences. Please take as long as you need."

He pressed the folio into her hands and walked toward the stairs without hurrying.

She opened it right there against the wall.

A certified check, drawn on a bank I had heard of. Payable to Joanne M. Pruitt. Two hundred and fifty thousand dollars. A cover letter in a very warm font, offering the family's heartfelt assistance with funeral costs and with settlement of "any and all claims between the Estate of Leonard Fisk and Kasparian Hospitality LLC." And under it, stapled, a twelve-page release that I read upside down in four seconds, because it is a skill. An assignment of "any right, title or interest in the contents of any safe deposit box, storage unit or other property of the decedent." A clause about voluntary cooperation. A line for her signature, with a sticky arrow.

Ray had gone gray. Joanne stood there with the check in her hand, and I could see the roof in her eyes, and the cafeteria, and a clean kitchen on a street of brick twins.

"It's the mortgage," she said. "It's Christmas. It's the roof." Her voice was almost flat. "It's my whole life paid for. And all I have to do is let somebody else keep Dale in a box."

"Joanne," I said, "you should speak to a lawyer."

"I know I should. I know." She turned and looked at me. Her eyes were very clear, and very tired, and held a question the size of a house. "But there's only one lawyer who ever said his name. I can't ask you, can I? You're not allowed."

"I'm not allowed."

"I know. I read about it on my phone last night." She held the check out, flat on her palm, like a hot plate she was too polite to put down. "Tell me not to."

I have never in my life wanted so badly to say a sentence. It sat behind my teeth like a stone. It would have taken three words, and it would have been the right three words, and every rule I had ever sworn to said I could not utter them.

Not because I was afraid of losing.

Because it would have been the same thing I had done to Terrence Mabry, in the other direction: deciding for a person what she could survive.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!