A seating chart is a confession in a polite font.
You think you are arranging chairs. You are actually writing down, in a grid, what you believe about every person in the room: who can bear to sit beside whom, who must be able to see the door, which two will say something unforgivable if the soup is slow.
I have seated a mother of the bride beside her ex-husband’s new wife and lived. I had never seated a table whose host had already written the list, and I had never been told, in cream paper, that nobody would be harmed.
I started on Wednesday, with the State’s Attorney.
---
Gia went in alone at nine, and I sat in the corridor of the Cook County building on a bench that had been polished by forty years of nervous trousers, with a cardboard tray of coffee and the Bartek notebook in a locked case on my knees. The case was Gia’s idea. It had a combination, and she had not told me the combination. “That way,” she said, “if anyone asks, you can say truthfully you don’t know.”
She was out in forty minutes. She walked down the corridor in her gray coat with her face composed, past a bailiff and two lawyers arguing about a parking ticket, and sat beside me and did not say anything until the elevator doors had closed on a man with a mop.
“He’s not stupid,” said Gia. “Dunning. He’s fifty, and tired, and he’s been told by someone that Santo Corvino was married in a hurry in front of a judge on New Year’s Eve and that a casket with sandbags has turned up in a church. He’s put the two together and made a shape. It isn’t the right shape, but it’s not nothing.”
“What did you give him?”
“The existence of a man named Luca Bartek, who is a witness, who is dying, and who has made a sworn statement to a notary describing a long-term pattern of extortion and coercion against my family by a person he knows only as Heron.” Her mouth tightened. “I told him the statement would be delivered to his office on Monday, with exhibits, if Mr. Bartek survives to sign the last page. I didn’t tell him about the dinner.”
“Gia.”
“I know.” She looked straight ahead. “I’m an officer of the court. If he asks me directly whether I know of an event at which a person who may have committed a crime will be present, I’ll have to answer, and I’ll lose my license if I lie. He didn’t ask. I’ll live with that. But I want you to know what it cost.”
I took her hand. It was cold, and I could feel the tremor in it, very fine, like a wire in the wind. “You can change your mind. I’ll tell Santo we can’t.”
“I’m not changing my mind,” said Gia. “I’m telling you the price. It’s what you taught me. You say it out loud first.”
She looked at me with an expression I had seen on Santo in the cemetery, the look of someone who has decided, with open eyes, to walk through a door.
“Dunning wants a man outside,” she said. “Two cars on Elston. No one inside. He thinks I think it’s a negotiation. I let him.”
“That’s something.”
“It’s a net,” said Gia. “It’s not a rope. Don’t tell Santo I said so.”
---
I asked them one at a time.
That’s the whole of the work, really, the part that cannot be done by anyone else. I wrote the cue sheet on Wednesday afternoon and the vendor list on Wednesday night, and by Thursday morning there was nothing left on my desk but the eleven names, and I put on my good boots and began to drive.
Salvatore Sabbatini received me in his hotel suite on Michigan Avenue in a dressing gown the color of a plum, with a cup of espresso in each hand, and heard the whole invitation through without moving. When I had finished he put down the espresso and said, “Of course I’ll come.”
“You don’t have to.”
“My dear girl, my wife has been dead for nine years and I sit in a hotel room eating pastries from a tin. A man writes me on handsome paper to say that I’m to be at a table with a bishop’s chaplain and a lawyer in a cane and a woman who sweeps floors.
I haven’t been so flattered since nineteen eighty-one.” He smiled, but the smile did not reach his eyes. “I’ll bring no men inside. I’ll leave two in the car. If it’s a trap I’d like to be in it with Rosa.”
“Thank you.”
“And I’d like the corner piece of the cake,” said Sabbatini. “Which I notice is still owing.”
Mrs. Ada Pellegrino, in her flat on Taylor Street, said she would come if somebody would carry her up the steps, and that she would bring her own cutlery, because she’d been poisoned once at a funeral in ‘fifty-eight and had taken precautions ever since. Father Ostrowski, in the retirement house in Joliet, said, “Yes, certainly,” before I finished the first sentence, and then asked in a hesitating voice whether Luca would be there. I told him I hoped so.
He said that in that case he would bring the stole he had not worn since the boy’s first communion. Gus Fenn, in a rented room over a dry cleaner’s on Archer Avenue, said nothing at all for a very long time and then said, “I’ve been waiting for somebody to ask me to a table for twelve years. I thought it would be sooner.” Mr. Kowalczyk said yes and asked if he should wear black. Anna Dabrowska said that she would wear her hat.
Deputy Lindqvist, by telephone from a gas station somewhere in northern Wisconsin, said, “Nope,” and then, “Wait,” and then, “Does he say I’m not to bring a gun?”
“He doesn’t say.”
“Then I’ll bring one and leave it in the car,” said Lindqvist. “I can do that. I’ve been trained.”
Leo said yes before I got to the end of his name. He had a bag packed. He said it was a great comfort to be invited somewhere by a person who didn’t want to be paid.
And Dom.
---
Dom was in the room above the shop where he had slept when he was twelve. Carlo sat on the stair. It was a narrow, sloping room with a single bed, a desk, a crucifix and a map of the Phoenix suburbs somebody had pinned to the wall with great hopefulness in 1997, and it smelled of old paper, rosemary and the sleeplessness of a man who had been turning something over for four days.
He was on the bed with his boots off. When I knocked he stood, and then, not knowing what to do with his hands, sat down again.
“Margo.”
“I’m here to ask you a question, Dom. I’m going to ask it first, before anyone else decides it.”
“I’ve been told.” He was gaunt. He had shaved, and there was a nick on his jaw, and the famous dimple had gone somewhere I could not follow. “I saw the card. Carlo showed me. My name’s second.”
“Do you know why?”
“Because I’m the one who ought to have been first.” He pushed his palms into his eyes. “It’s a good list. It’s all the people who told you the truth when I was lying. I’m surprised he didn’t put me at the end.”
“He put you after Nonna,” I said. “I’d like you to come, Dom. As a guest. Not as a prisoner and not as a penance.”
“Santo will never.”
“Santo said that if you’d sit where I put you, he’d allow it.” I did not say how long it had taken him. Santo had held out for six hours. He had said “no,” and “I can’t look at him,” and then, at two in the morning, standing at the sink with his sleeves rolled, “If it’s a table, Margo, he’s at it.” I had thought that I had never loved him more, and I had been too tired to say so.
Dom lowered his hands.
“I can’t,” he said. “I can’t look at Luca.”
“He asked for you.”
“He what?”
“He said, in the ambulance,” I lied, and then caught myself, because rule four is not a rule I am prepared to break in a room above a bakery, and said instead, “No. That isn’t true. I’m sorry. He hasn’t asked for you. He hasn’t mentioned you since the cemetery. I wanted to say something kind and I said something false. I’d like to take it back.”
Dom stared at me. And then, slowly, he began to laugh. It was a cracked, helpless, wet sound that turned halfway through into something else, and he put his head down on his knees, with his big shoulders shaking.
“God,” he said. “God. You’re the only person in this city who’d apologize for a kindness.”
“I try.”
“I’ll come,” said Dom Ferrante, to the floor. “If I’m allowed to sit by the door.”
“You’ll sit between Leo and your best friend’s grandmother,” I said, “where she can reach you with a fork.”
---
Mr. Pruss, who never opens on Fridays, came in specially and let us in at four.
I had asked Priya and Teddy to come, and Santo, who had said very little all day and had stood twenty feet from the entrance of the shop for ten minutes with his hands in his pockets, looking at the lettering on the glass. It said BELLWEATHER ORGAN WORKS, in gold leaf, curved over a painted bellows, and underneath in smaller letters, *Est. 1911. Tuning, Voicing, Restoration. We Listen.*
The shop was an old brick storefront on Elston, with a loading door at the side and a stair at the back going up to a loft. Inside, it was a forest. I had not expected that.
Pipes of every length stood upright on trestles along the walls, tin and zinc and spotted metal, in ranks, in families, from the fat bass wooden ones the size of drainpipes to the little silver reeds like pencil stubs. There were chests, and boxes of felt and leather, and a smell of cedar, hide glue and warm wax so thick and sweet that it was like walking into a hive.
At the far end, under a skylight, in a long clear space that someone had swept, stood a table.
It was oak. It was very long. It had been scrubbed and oiled until it shone.
Thirteen chairs stood round it, one at the head and six down each side, the plain pale chairs of a church hall, with the foot left open for a wheelchair. They were new. They still smelled of varnish. Somebody had laid on the white cloth, for each place, a knife, a fork, a spoon, a glass and a folded napkin, in the very particular manner of a man who had read about it in a book.
“Not mine,” said Mr. Pruss. He stood at my elbow in his shop apron with both his hearing aids in and a look of mild, ruined apology. “I want that understood, Mrs. Corvino. I didn’t do it. They came on Thursday from a church supply on Cicero. I was told by the driver it was paid, on a standing order. I said I hadn’t ordered chairs. He said it was a good thing he wasn’t a boy in a hurry.”
“Who signed for them?”
“I did. I’d no choice. I didn’t know. And the tablecloth came from a laundry I never heard of. And when I came in on Thursday the cloth was on the table already, folded, and the cutlery was in a box on the bench.”
“Someone has a key,” said Teddy.
“Everyone’s got a key,” said Mr. Pruss. “I have kept six hundred keys on that board for fifty years. A shop like this is open to anyone who comes to listen. I never thought it mattered.” He turned his head. There was a long wall of numbered hooks behind him, and on it a gap, just one, a tag with no key. “Except this. Number nine. It was Stefan’s.”
“Stefan Bartek’s,” I said.
“He had it from nineteen eighty-eight. He did the stone for our old chapel, you know, in Elston Park, a lovely thing, a cornice with a little bird in it. He used to come in at the end of the day for coffee and to talk to the pipes. He was a man who talked to things. And in ninety-eight he had a young woman with him.” Pruss’s face softened.
“I thought it was none of my business, but I had been a widower three years and I knew a happy man when I saw one. A tall woman, twenty-nine or thirty, in a yellow scarf. She said she wanted to hear a Bach chorale on a real organ before she got married. And Stefan laughed and said that wasn’t the order of things, that she was supposed to want an engagement ring first.”
A little thing stopped in my chest.
“Mr. Pruss. Do you remember her name?”
“Cat,” said Pruss. “He called her Cat. I never had a surname. He said she was a girl who didn’t want her family told.” He put a thin hand on the nearest pipe, as if to steady it. “Four months later he was dead, and I never saw her again.
I had thought it was something to do with the funeral. Then in October, Mrs. Corvino, a woman came in, in a yellow coat, with a voice like a cracked plate, and she walked straight to the hook board and put her hand on the empty hook, and she said, ‘Is this still nine?’”
I turned to look at my husband.
He was standing by the long table with his hand flat on the cloth. He wasn’t looking at me, or at the pipes. He was looking at the head of the table, at the plain pale chair that had been set there for him, and his face had gone the color of the napkins.
“She loved him,” Santo said, to the chair. “Stefan. My aunt. And somebody dropped a block of Carrara on his head from a Corvino Imports truck.”
“Santo.”
“She was twenty-nine,” said my husband. “She went to hear a Bach chorale, and four months later he was dead. And she’s been” He stopped. He pressed his lips together. “Margo, I’m going to be sick.”
“You’re not,” I said. “Sit down.”
---
He sat. He sat in the chair at the head of the table, which I would not have chosen for him, and I knelt on the plank floor in front of him in my good boots and held his two hands with both of mine.
I said, “She’s alive. We know that. She’s been in this shop and in a hospital and on Leo’s doorstep. She took Nonna’s ring. She cried at a grave. She is not a ghost, Santo. She’s a woman with a plan.”
“A plan to do what?”
“I don’t know yet. That’s what the table is for.” I looked up at him. “It’s what you do with a family that doesn’t talk. You put them in a room, and you give them a meal, and you let them be unable to leave.”
He drew a long breath, and let it go.
“Marry me,” said Santo Corvino, hoarsely, in an empty organ shop, in a ring of silver pipes. It was ten past five in the evening. “You have no idea how many times I’ve wanted to say it.”
“You’ve said it every day for a month.”
“I mean today.”
“I’m already married to you. I’ve got the paper.”
“I know,” he said. “I’d like to do it again.”
“Yes,” I said. “Yes. Again. I’ll be late for the first rehearsal.”
Behind us Priya made a small noise like a kettle, and when I turned she was looking at the skylight with great attention. Teddy was counting pipes. Mr. Pruss, in his apron, was standing in the shadow of a Bourdon with his hands clasped and tears running quietly down his face.
---
We set the table that night.
It took five hours and four people. Priya and Teddy and I did the cloth and the candles and the place cards; Santo, who had wanted to leave and had not, did the chairs, moving each one a half inch, back, then in again, as if it were an instrument. Nonna had sent an enormous basket of bread.
Gia had gone to the hospital at six to sit with Luca and see the notary, and at eight she had phoned to say that he’d been very clear, and that Dr. Silva had agreed, in a tone of resignation, to release him Saturday afternoon with a nurse and a portable concentrator, “against advice, in the care of a person who has promised not to play the organ,” and Luca had said that he wouldn’t.
I laid the cards myself. It’s my favorite part, the small ceremony of it: a fold of ivory, a name in pen, a place.
I put Santo at the head, because the card said so. Nonna on his right, where she could see the whole table. On her other side, Leo, with Dom beside him, so that the man who had paid and the man who had told would be sitting shoulder to shoulder and have to pass the salt.
Sabbatini beside Ostrowski, two old men to whom nobody was going to say a rude word. Mrs. Pellegrino beside Gus, who owed her a good turn. Mrs. Dabrowska next to Kowalczyk, because both of them were people who knew when to stop talking. Lindqvist by the door, with her back to the wall. Pruss halfway down, where he could slip out to the shop if he needed his hands.
Eleven guests and the host, a space at the foot for Luca’s wheelchair, a chair behind it for the nurse, and a place for me at the end, behind Priya’s shoulder, where I could get up.
And the twelfth.
The twelfth guest’s place was on Santo’s left. It was the one nobody had told me how to fill. I had laid the knife and the fork and the glass, and I stood over it for a long time with a blank card in my hand, and then I put the card down face up on the plate, unwritten, with the pen beside it.
At midnight I turned off the lights. I had Teddy’s flashlight, and a clipboard, and a list. I walked the whole room once more, as I do, in the dark, from the loading door to the long table. The shop ticked and sighed round me, the way old buildings do when the heat goes off. Every pipe was a little night. Santo, Teddy and Priya were at the front door with their coats on, and I had said I’d be a minute.
At the twelfth place, I stopped.
The pen was gone. The card was written on.
I do not know when it was done. I’d been in the room for five hours, and I would have sworn that nobody had passed within thirty feet of that chair. The card lay face up where I’d left it. The ink was a deep, dry blue. The hand was upright and round, with a loop at the top of the capital and a letter that had been closed at the bottom, like cupped hands.
*Rina.*
And on the plate, set exactly in the middle of the white china, there was a single violet-colored sweet in a twist of paper, which I had not put there.
I picked up the flashlight, and I turned, slowly, to look at the dark.

