The cradle went up into the dark with Tamsin in it, and Lucan stood on the pearl with his ring hand held out in front of him and listened to her go.
It was not a sound, exactly. The ring on his finger carried the creak of the winch and the knock of her knuckle on the rail and, at the very edge of hearing, her breathing, which was ragged and quick and had a small hitch in it each time she swallowed. He followed it for as long as he could. When it thinned to nothing, he found that he was still holding his arm out like a man waiting to be handed a hat.
He lowered it. Kestrel, who missed very little, found something to do with her needles.
“There is a stool,” she said, to the wall. “I made it from the last of the stair. It is not much of a stool.”
It was a three-legged thing of knitted rope gone stiff as bark. Lucan sat on it. It held him, and that was more than he had expected of anything that day.
---
Cassian Varnholt was already at work.
He sat at the foot of the black chain on the wet pearl step, with the golden lamp on his knee and the brass bucket between his feet, and he was counting under his breath with the careful, moving lips of a man doing sums he has been warned about.
“One hundred and thirteen. One hundred and fourteen.” His hand went along the links, one finger at a time. It left a fine bright smear of oil behind it, and each link, as he passed, seemed to draw in a little, as a hand draws in from a touch it does not understand.
Lucan had once watched a famous advocate cross-examine a horse. The animal had been a witness in a case about a runaway dray, and the advocate had gone about it with a solemn, delicate patience that had made the whole court lean forward. It was the only thing in his legal life that resembled what he was looking at now.
*Counsel,* said Fathom.
It was a small word, and a surprised one. The great chamber hummed with it. Lucan had not been called that by the whale before.
“Mister Sterne will do,” he said.
*I should like it understood that I am not instructing you. I am told that is how it is done.* The warm voice was a little rueful. *The creature below has been asking for something since you came. It has been very careful about the manner of it. I think that it would like a word with the one who talks.*
Lucan rose. He found, with some interest, that he had stopped being afraid. It had not gone anywhere. It had merely taken a number and was waiting in the corridor with the rest of the things he did not have time for.
---
“Good morning,” said Tamsin’s voice, from the water.
It was the third thing he had learned to dread about the chamber: how kind the voice was. It would have been so much simpler if it had come up out of the dark like a bellows, all rust and iron. Instead it was her. It was her at six in the morning on a roof, before she had decided to be sardonic, with a little roughness in the throat and the beginning of a laugh somewhere behind it.
“Good morning,” said Lucan. He kept his own voice flat. It was a trick of the Bench: if a thing could not be made small, it could at least be made dull. “I am told you would like a word.”
“I would like several. I do not know how many are allowed.” A pause. “Is it the morning? I have been told that it is. I should like to know what it is.”
He opened his mouth and found that he did not have an answer. It was a very odd sensation. He had been asked, in his time, to define malice, and the reasonable man, and a quorum.
“It is when the light comes into the sky,” said Cassian, from the step, quietly. “It comes first in the east, and it is very pale. Then the pale turns yellow. Then, if one is lucky, someone makes tea.”
“Tea,” said the voice. It said the word the way a child says the name of a country. “I should like to hear about tea.”
“Later,” said Lucan. “Counsel’s first duty is to read the instrument. You will oblige me by reading it aloud.”
“I do not read. I am told.” The voice hesitated. “The wax reads.”
---
The wax read.
It spoke from the third tier, in the same patient child’s monotone as before, and it did not so much recite the instrument as unwind it, in long, level, courteous loops. There was a good deal of it.
Lucan stood with his hands behind his back and his head a little bowed, and Edda’s notebook was not there to take it down, so he did what he had done as a clerk of nineteen and put it all in his memory, line by line, in order, as one lays out cutlery.
It was a plain document, and a dreadful one. It had been written, he judged, by someone who loved a clause.
The security was the household of Orsolay, “in its person and its several voices.” The rate was one voice a day, to run from the Call. The interest was to be paid first by the principal, “being the person named in the entry,” and in default of the principal, by “such sureties as have by gesture of their own hands assented to the cause of the principal, jointly and severally, each to the full amount.”
“Stop,” said Lucan.
The wax stopped. He heard the small dry tick of its pause.
“Read that last again. Slowly.”
“Such sureties as have by gesture of their own hands assented,” said the wax, in exactly the same tone, “to the cause of the principal, jointly and severally.”
He had known it as soon as he heard it, with the cold, clean dismay of a man who finds the missing page and wishes that he had not. He turned and looked at Cassian. Cassian was looking back at him with his pale eyes very wide.
“The Call of Hands,” said the Procurator, in a whisper.
“Is a Ground word,” said Lucan. “Of course it is. It always was. The Houses of Lanthorne did not invent a clause for the disputed seat. They borrowed one, three hundred years ago, from the people who sold them the first season. Raise your hand to say yes, and the hand is bound. It was never a vote. It was a signature.”
---
He was angry with himself for a quarter of a minute, and it was a thorough quarter of a minute.
There had been a hundred ways to have seen it. Edda had said, in the Hall, in a voice dry with doubt, that the Charter’s wording on the Call of Hands was oddly foreign. He had thought, with the vanity of the learned, that it was merely archaic.
And Ground courtesy was not a mystery to him. He had been taught it by a woman in a silver veil with a parasol and nine days to spare. Silence is assent. Thanks are assent. A gesture is assent, if it is a gesture of the hand.
“Nine thousand, one hundred and fourteen,” he said aloud, to the dark. “The Underdeckers raised their hands for a woman who had asked them to. Tamsin raised hers. Every person in the Gallery who stood for the seat is, in the Ground’s reading, a surety for what the principal owes.”
*They did not know,* said Fathom.
“Nobody asked them to read the foot of the page.”
“I did not know either,” said Tamsin’s voice, from the water, very softly. “I should like to say that. I counted the hands because they were there. I did not think it was a harm. It seemed only a thing that was so.”
“You are not the one who drafted it,” said Lucan.
“No. But it is I who am owed.”
---
The way to defeat a creditor, Lucan had been taught at nineteen, was to make him explain himself. A man who was owed money would say anything to get it. But a man who was made to say why he was owed it would sooner or later say something that could be used.
“I should like to understand the daily rate,” he said. “The instrument says one voice a day. A voice of what?”
“Of whom,” said the voice. It had begun to sound interested. “A voice that is spoken in. A voice that is a person’s.”
“Whole?”
“Whole is a very large word. I do not know whether I take the whole. I only know that it has been taken. It is a thing that I have never been taught to count.” The faint, hollow echo of the well came into it again.
“In eleven years of my keeping, there were one hundred and fourteen children. The Straight Mouth sent them to me, a few at a time, and the lie in each of them was a voice. I held them. I did not take them. They came down the chain and I held them.”
“Then you do not know what it costs,” said Lucan.
He had meant it for a leading question. It hit harder than that. The chamber went very still, as a room does when someone has said the unsayable thing at dinner.
“No,” said the voice, after a time. “I do not.”
---
It was Cassian who got to his feet.
He did it slowly, with the lamp held in front of him and one hand on the chain. His long face was the colour of candle wax, and the white thread of frost-light in the glass beside his cheek made him look like a saint on a church door. “My dear,” he said, to the water, in his courteous, tired voice. “I think that you had better learn.”
“I would like to.”
“Then I will teach you the first thing. It is the only thing that I know that is useful, and I learned it from a wife. When a person gives you something, you must ask. If you take it without asking, it is not a gift. It is a theft, and it will make them sorry.”
“I do not take without asking,” said the voice. “I am told that the hands asked.”
“They asked for the Keeper. They did not ask you.”
“It is the same.”
“It is not,” said Cassian, and for a moment his voice shook. “It is not at all. A man who agrees to a thing in the dark has not agreed to it. The Ground may call that assent, and the Ground may be very polite about it. But it is a custom, not a law, and I am not at all certain that it is the way that you would want to be.”
Lucan, who had been listening to the argument with the narrowed, appraising attention of a professional, felt something turn over in his chest. It was an unfamiliar feeling. It took him a moment to place it.
It was respect.
---
“Then I will make a proposal,” said the Under, at last.
The ring on Lucan’s hand had been warming for some minutes, and now it flared, a bright quick burn, as it did when something great and slow was making up its mind. The voice from the water had changed. The first thing was that it was no longer using Tamsin’s cadence. It was using her words, but it said them as someone says a thing they have rehearsed in a language they are still learning.
“I am owed one voice a day. I will not ask for more than I am owed. I will ask the principal first, and if the principal cannot pay, I will ask the hands. And I will not take a voice that has not been offered.” A breath. “I am told that this is a courtesy. I am told that a courtesy is a kind of law.”
“It is,” said Lucan, carefully. “I am gratified.”
“You are the principal’s counsel and the household’s hand. You are in the entry. You have a voice.” It paused. “Will you offer it?”
He had known that it was coming. He had been bracing for it since the wax began to read, and he found that it made no difference whatever. His mouth was dry. “You have the household’s voice already, from the Hall. Paid at the Call.”
“That was the first day’s, and it is settled. The second falls due at noon, by the Ground reckoning. I am told that is when interest falls.”
“Then it will be today’s that you want.”
“Yes.”
He did not hesitate. That was the thing he would remember afterwards: that he had not stopped to count. “I offer,” said Lucan, “as counsel and household, to be taken in the principal’s stead. I have a voice. I have used it in court every day for nine years. I should like it to be accepted.”
“I am not able to,” said the Under, with what sounded like real distress.
---
He stood looking at the water for some time.
“Explain,” said Lucan.
“You are kept,” said the voice. “You are not your own. You came into the Well of your own will, and the term is held in abeyance, and while you are held, a voice of yours is a thing in the Keeping. It cannot be paid out of it. It is not yours to give.”
It was perfectly good law. He could have written it himself. “Then who may?”
“The Keeper may. She is above. She is the principal.” The voice was very gentle. “But she has paid the first day, and I have it. It is all that she had.”
He took a long breath through his nose. He thought of Edda, standing at the top of the shaft with a ledger and no pencil, who was at that moment doing sums she would not like. He thought of the sleeping crowd on the plaza, in long untidy rows, with their lamps burned out.
“What happens at noon?” he said. He did not ask it with any hope.
“The principal is in default. The sureties are asked.” The wax, on the third tier, took up the sentence at exactly the moment that the voice faltered, as a good clerk does. “Interest is due. Surety to be assessed. One voice, in the hour.”
“You said you would ask.”
“I will ask,” said the Under. “I will ask each of them. I have only to find one who will say yes.”
“And if nobody says it?”
“I do not know,” said the voice. “It has never happened.”
---
The morning ran on. He could not have said, afterwards, how, since there was nothing in that pearl-white room to mark it but the oil and the slow wash of the water and the drift of the hollows’ light.
Kestrel brought him a cup of something warm and a heel of bread that tasted of salt. He ate it. He thought, with a dry despair, of Tamsin’s last order, which had come up through the ring, and to which he was being obedient to a degree that she would have found insulting.
He asked Fathom for the day-nine question, because it was owed. It came, as it had come every day: low and deep and rather shy.
*What will you answer for?*
“Both of them,” said Lucan, without thinking. “The city and the woman. I should like to be allowed to say the woman first.”
The whale laughed. It was a low underwater thing, like a door opening somewhere in a large house, and it felt like warmth. *That is true,* it said. *I will keep it. Thank you.*
“What does it cost?”
*A little. The word first. You will find that you cannot put anything before her.* Fathom’s voice was full of an enormous, patient amusement. *I should not think that you will notice.*
He did not. That was the oddest part of it. It was gone as he reached for it, quietly, a loose thread slipping off the end of a needle, and he sat on Kestrel’s stool with his hands between his knees and tried to remember what it was that he had meant to rank in front of her. He could think of nothing. The list of things that came before Tamsin Rook was perfectly, perfectly blank.
---
It was a quarter to noon when the ring began to hum.
He felt it first in his teeth. Then it ran down the long bone of his hand and into the water at his feet, and the pearl floor took up the note and sent it along the walls, and the whole honeycomb of the Keeping began to ring faintly, like a hundred glasses touched with a wet finger.
*It is the Hall,* said Fathom. *The bell for the hour has begun.*
Lucan stood. Cassian, at the chain, had stopped counting. Kestrel’s needles were quite still.
He could hear the plaza. It came up through the ring in a ragged rush, with no more order than weather: a hum of thousands of voices, a child crying, an old man’s cough, boots on stone, and over it all the tolling of the Hall clock, striking the long heavy note of noon. They had woken to the cold thread on their wrists, and they were frightened, and they were trying to be sensible about it.
*Ask,* he thought. *Please ask. Ask each one. Ask until somebody says no.*
He was a man who had never prayed. He found that he knew exactly how.
---
“I should like to,” said the Under, in the water, to the hollow of the chamber.
It was perhaps the first time in a thousand years that the thing in the sea floor had said a thing to a room that had not been paid for. It had her voice, and her cadence, and none of her humour. It spoke to the faces on the plaza, to the thousands of faces that it could not see and had never seen, down the length of its long black web.
“I am sorry to ask. I have been told that I should. I am owed a voice, for the day. Would any one of you give it?”
There was no answer. There was nothing but the clock.
Lucan had stopped breathing. He heard Cassian whisper a prayer of his own. He thought, with a clear, almost cheerful certainty, that it was going to be all right. Nobody would be so foolish. Nobody in a crowd of nine thousand would stand up and say yes to a thing that they could not see, in a language they did not know.
It was a good thought. It lasted for perhaps four seconds.
Through the ring, very small and very faint, he heard a boy’s voice. It was a high, clear, cracked voice, the voice of a child of twelve or thirteen, in the plaza in the noon sun, and it said, doubtfully, with a catch in it, as one says a thing that will be thought a joke:
“Yes, please?”
---
It was the *please* that undid him.
He heard the boy realise it. There was a tiny gasp, and a shuffle, and a woman’s voice screaming a name. *Ned. Ned, no, Ned,* in a rising whoop. He heard the boy say, high and puzzled, “I only wanted to help,” and then he heard nothing at all.
It was not silence. He knew what silence was. This was a stopping, a sound cut off at the root like a cord, and the long cold wail that came behind it was not the boy’s. It was his mother’s.
“Thank you,” said the Under, gently, in the water, in Tamsin’s voice. “I am much obliged. It was very kind.”
*Paid by surety,* said the wax, in the third tier. *One. Nine thousand, one hundred and thirteen remaining.*
Lucan shut his eyes. He stood in the pearl-white warmth of the Keeping with his ring hand clenched in his coat and the sound of a baker’s wife screaming in his ear, and the cold comfortable certainty came to him, as it comes to every lawyer in the end, that he had just seen how the Ground did its business.
It had never needed to take anything. It had only needed to be polite.

