Marcia Marsh Duvall lives in a brick duplex on Alder Street, with a green door and a kitchen the size of a confession, and at five minutes to seven on the longest night of the year she was standing at the counter with a dish towel, trying to decide whether to put on lipstick.
“It’s a phone call,” she said, to nobody. “He can’t see me.”
“He can’t,” I said.
“Then why am I standing here with a lipstick?”
I did not know. I had brought a thermos of soup, a bag of my mother’s dumplings and my phone, and I had propped the phone against the sugar bowl on her kitchen table in Visiting Hours with the screen lit and my hand around a cup of tea. I was sitting for him. That was the arrangement, and it was costing me three percent for ninety minutes, which I considered cheap. On the screen, small and bright, was a bare room with a green linoleum floor and a long table, and a wall phone with a coiled cord, and the whole population of a waiting room standing around it in a ring.
“Honey,” said Antonetta, through the glass, “you tell her to take her time.”
“She says take your time.”
“I’ve been taking my time since 1972,” said Marcia, “I’d like to stop.” She wiped her hands on the towel, put down the lipstick, and picked up an old black rotary phone that her grandmother had owned. She had had it rewired. She stood with it against her chest, a woman of sixty-one in a large green coat she had not taken off, because she had said she might need it.
At seven o’clock exactly, she dialed.
I have thought about that sound often since. It is not a sound you hear anymore. It was a rotary dial, going round and round for each digit, a small dry racket, and then a pause, and then the faint far click of a switch. Quarry 4-1180. She had dialed it fifty-two Sundays a year for fifty-two years. I counted by fives, under my breath, and on the screen, on the wall of the Bench, a phone began to ring.
It was a real ring. It was loud, and old, and shaking on its hook, a big black bell, and the people around it went still. Gary Tibbetts took off his usher’s cap. Nadine, in her front-desk blazer, put a hand over her mouth. Pruitt, with no gloves, sat on the bottom step, not looking, with her two bare hands folded in her lap.
Teddy walked up to the phone.
He was eleven, in a wool cap, short pants, and a jacket that was too big for him, with the sleeves rolled twice. He had been dead for ninety-two years. He walked as I have seen boys walk to the front of a classroom to answer a question they are afraid they know. He took the receiver in both hands, which he could not do, and which he did, because Antonetta stood close behind him, with her hand an inch from his back.
“Hello,” said Teddy.
On the kitchen table, in the little speaker, Marcia’s receiver crackled.
“Hello,” said Marcia. Her voice was a croak. She cleared her throat. “Hello. Is this Edward? Is this Edward Marsh?”
“Teddy,” said Teddy. “It’s Teddy.”
“Teddy,” she said. And then she sat down, hard, in a kitchen chair, with the phone in her lap, the way a person sits when their knees have made a decision. “Oh,” she said. “Oh, hello. My name is Marcia. I’m your grandniece.”
“What’s that?”
“It means,” said Marcia, laughing and weeping at once, “that your sister Ruth was my grandmother.”
“Ruthie?”
“Yes.”
“Ruthie’s got a grandniece?”
“Ruthie had a granddaughter, sweetheart. That’s me.” She wiped her face with the dish towel. “She died in 1998. She used to tell me stories about you. She used to say that you had the best whistle on the street. She said you’d whistle for the dog and the dog would come from three blocks away, and the dog was never yours.”
Teddy’s mouth opened. “It was Mr. Vanek’s dog,” he said. “Biscuit.”
“Biscuit,” said Marcia. “That’s the name.”
I looked at the little room on my screen. Everyone in it was crying and pretending not to. Nadine had turned her face to the wall. Gary was blowing his nose into a lanyard.
“I’ve called every Sunday,” said Marcia. “Because she did. And her mother did. We didn’t know why. It was in the family. You call Quarry 4-1180 at seven on Sunday, and you let it ring, and you say, ‘Hello, Teddy,’ and you hang up. I didn’t know it was a real number. I thought it was a thing like a grace before dinner.”
“I heard it,” said Teddy. “Every Sunday. It rang and rang. Nobody said who it was.”
“I know,” said Marcia. “I’m so sorry.” And I watched her do it. I watched her say it, with her whole face, a good woman with a green coat and a lifetime of sorries she had never been taught to put down. And I watched Teddy shake his head, very gently, and say, “That’s all right. You can stop now. You called. That was the thing.”
She laughed. She cried. She said, “Oh, honey,” and he said, “Ma’am,” and they went on for eighty minutes, about the dog, and the stairs, and who had the better whistle, and whether he was warm, and whether he ate. At the end of the first half hour, with my tea gone cold, I understood I was watching the best use of ninety minutes I had ever paid for.
“I should tell you something,” said Marcia, at last, a little shy. “Grandma Ruth told a story. About the family. It was one of her sad ones, I think. She said that before you, there was Tessie.”
I felt it before I heard it. A small cold click, as of a latch.
“Tessie went in first, you see,” said Marcia. “She was the oldest. Grandma said they put a sign up at the telephone company in 1931, and the girls all went to apply, and Tessie was twelve and said she was fifteen and got the job. She was good with numbers. She said she’d be home for supper.” A pause. “She wasn’t. She didn’t come back. And you went after her, Grandma said. You went all the way to the Exchange, in the snow, in 1934. You were eleven. And they never found either one.”
Teddy had gone very quiet. He stood with the receiver pressed to his ear, small and still. On the Bench, behind him, no one moved.
“Teddy?” said Marcia. “Sweetheart, did I say something wrong?”
I looked at the little room. I looked at the date, 1931, in my head, in blue-black ink on a page I had photographed in the Quarry Pike Inn. Marsh, T. A child. I had thought it was Teddy. He was eight in 1931.
Nobody was looking at me, which was kind. They were looking at him.
“No, ma’am,” said Teddy, finally. His voice was small and flat and very careful. “It’s all right. I just hadn’t thought about her in a while.” He took a breath. “I’ll call you back. Is that okay? Is that allowed?”
“It is allowed,” said Marcia, “as long as I live. I would like very much to have a Sunday where you call me.”
“Okay,” said Teddy. “Okay. Goodbye, Marcia.”
“Goodbye, sweetheart. Good night.”
She hung up. The little rotary clicked, and was still. And on the green wall of the Bench, as the boy lowered his phone, the room around him began, ever so slightly, to hum.
It was a low sound. It was the sound a building makes when something large in it has turned over in its sleep. The telephone on the wall shook on its hook. The coiled cord quivered. And then, very softly, with no one touching it, it rang again.
Teddy looked at it. He looked at Antonetta. He did not touch it.
“It’s for her,” he said, and pointed at me.
I stood up in a stranger’s kitchen. I walked to the screen, and put out my hand, and the phone on the wall in the Bench, forty feet and ninety years away, lifted gently off its hook of its own accord and floated an inch toward the glass.
“Miss Park,” said a precise, flat, tired voice. “I am sorry to interrupt. I would not do it if I had a choice. It is twenty-five minutes to nine.”
“Miss Strand.”
“Section Two was set for eleven fifty-two. The Supervisor has moved it.” The stopwatch ticked, very faintly, behind her. “I regret to tell you that it is not at eleven fifty-two. It is now.”

