Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 31

What Beck Says

The envelope held half a page.

Ames opened it on Tuesday night in the shop’s back room, under a work lamp, with gloves, a camera on a stand and Nita on speaker from the capital. The rest of us stood against the wall like people at a bedside. It was the only time in the whole month I saw Ames hold still for longer than a minute.

The top half of a sheet, torn straight across with a ruler. A printed header: VERIFICATION LOG, p. 42, WITNESS AND NOTARY REGISTER. Under it, forty-one lines, each with a date, a number, and a column labeled Sworn before me. Forty-one times, in the same cramped hand, the same name and a round seal in violet ink: W. Ferris, Notary Public.

Under the forty-first line, a forty-second was started. A number. A word, Pending. Then the page had been torn away.

“Somebody wanted us to know there’s a missing piece,” Ames said, “and to know they’ve got it.”

“Or wanted us to chase it,” said Oren.

“Both are the same thing.”

Nita’s voice came tinny through the speaker. “Ferris’s journal is real. I’ve asked a clerk at the county for his commission records. The man died two years ago and his estate hasn’t cleared. His journal could be in a shed.”

“A shed,” I said.

“You’d be amazed what ends up in sheds.” The voice sounded tired. “Get some sleep. Both of you. The letters go out at eight.”

---

The letters went out at eight, and the free line rang for two days.

I’m told that by Thursday sixty-one people had called, of whom thirty-four were in the log, and that the volunteers had a running joke about the man who phoned four times to ask whether he was allowed to be happy about it. Pell was one of the thirty-four. The letter, and a volunteer’s patient voice, told him for free what a stranger had charged him a hundred and fifty dollars to say, and Anselm, Pell reported, took it better than Pell did.

Beyond Pell, Iona and Asa, nobody I knew was in the log, and nobody I knew was spared the weather. Farrah wrote to say the Rookvale company had held an impromptu meeting in the parking lot, with doughnuts, and that two crew members had gone home early to talk to their spouses, one of them smiling. Pell sent me a photo of a rubber chicken with a tiny paper hat.

I did not receive a call from D. Nita said he had gone quiet after the notice, that the merchant account had been frozen, and that quiet was the worst sign a man like that could give.

On Thursday morning I was in the district office conference room with a paper cup, my sister, a tray of pastries nobody wanted and Beck Arlen.

---

I should explain how that happened, because I didn’t want it.

Beck’s counsel, a lean, soft-spoken man named Hollis Brandt, had called Nita on Monday night with a proffer. His client would give a full account of the Towerfall paperwork, the log and the consignment, if Ames’s office would agree not to use the statement against him for the counterfeit-concord charges and would let him speak to the injured party in person.

It was an odd request. Prosecutors don’t usually enjoy the second condition. Nita told me later that the answer had been no, twice, and Brandt had said, patiently, that Beck was not asking for forgiveness, only for a witness who had a right to hear it.

Nita didn’t choose. Nita went to Jessa.

“You can say no,” Nita told her, on the phone, on Wednesday night. “Nobody will think less of you. It will be recorded, with counsel and Ames present and a guard. It would be your choice, and it can change in the room.”

Jessa took an hour. She called me at eleven, and I thought she’d tell me what to do, and I prepared three useful speeches.

“I’d like you to come,” she said. “Not to speak. Not to handle it. To sit next to me and keep your hands on the table.”

“That’s the whole job?”

“That’s the hardest job there is, Cleo. You can’t do it. You’ve failed at it your whole life. I’m asking you to try.”

So there we were. Jessa in a gray cardigan, with her bad hand on her knee and her good one flat on the table, her chin level. Me beside her, my braced arm folded, my left hand around a paper cup I did not drink from. Across from us a legal pad, a recorder, Nita with a pencil behind one ear, Ames at the end of the table doing a good impression of furniture, and Hollis Brandt in a charcoal suit that was slightly too big.

Beck Arlen came in at ten past ten with a guard and sat down.

He was forty-five. Last time I’d seen him he’d been tall, red-faced, bellowing, in the middle of a stage with a clipboard and a headset, giving orders in the voice of a man who had never once been told no by furniture. He looked thinner. He had gray in his hair that hadn’t been there four weeks ago, and his hands, which he laid on the table side by side, were very clean.

He smelled of soap and floor wax and something sour underneath. I’d been braced for fear. A wolf can scent fear, though it isn’t a skill any more reliable than a smoke detector, and it doesn’t tell you what the fear is of. It told me he was afraid. It told me nothing else, and I made myself remember that as I kept my hands on the table.

“Ms. Dace,” he said to Jessa. “I’d like to say something first and then answer whatever you ask.”

“Go on.”

“I’m sorry.”

“That isn’t what you came to say,” Jessa said. “I’d like the facts.”

His mouth twitched. He glanced at Brandt, who nodded, and at Nita, who didn’t move. Then he looked down at his own hands.

---

“In September of that year,” Beck said, “I was assistant house manager at Cinderhall. I was thirty-nine. I ran the paperwork because nobody else wanted to. The insurer wanted a quarterly inspection that month, and the state rigging board sent an engineer named Rowe, who spent an evening in the loft with a headlamp. He wrote an inspection sheet in triplicate. White copy to the state, yellow to the house, carbon to him.”

“The yellow came to you.”

“It came to me.” His voice stayed even. “It said the anchor assemblies on the third aerial line should be replaced within thirty days. It said sixty percent. I read it standing up in the box office. I thought: that’s a budget item. I thought: that’s the facilities man’s problem. I put it in the file and told the facilities man, and he said he’d get a quote.”

“Did he?”

“I don’t know. Three weeks later the line failed.” He swallowed. “After the accident, the inquiry asked for every venue document touching the loft. Everything. I had the yellow copy in the file. I could have handed it over. It was the plain thing to do.”

“Why didn’t you?” said Jessa.

“Because I’d been told to replace it and I hadn’t.” He said it simply, the way a man names a diagnosis. “Because the line had your name on it, and the inquiry was going to ask who knew. And I knew.”

My sister did not move.

“I took the sheet out of the file. It was page seven of the appendix, which I’d numbered myself. I tore it along the fold. I renumbered nothing, because I was afraid someone would notice that, and I thought a gap in the numbers would look like an ordinary typo.” He shook his head. “I was the only one who’d ever have noticed an ordinary typo. I was wrong about that, too.”

“What did you do with it?”

“I kept it. I’ll get to that.” He looked up. “The carbon. Rowe’s copy. I didn’t know it existed. I thought he’d been told to destroy it. He wasn’t.”

“And the line on the received block?” Nita asked, quietly. “’Y.K.’”

Beck went still.

“I need you to say it the way you told Mr. Brandt,” she said.

“The received block on the yellow was empty when I read it, and it was empty when I sealed it.” He said it to the table. “I never wrote initials there. The line under it, ‘notified ownership, nine thirteen,’ is mine, in my own pen. I never saw the carbon. Mr. Brandt told me this week that Mr. Rowe’s copy has Y.K. on it.”

“Do you know whose initials those would be?” Nita asked.

“I know whose they’d have to be. Yvette Keene’s. She came onto the board that month, and in her first week she initialed the cover sheet of the arena file. She never read the contents. I know, because I was the one who put the file in front of her.” He rubbed his eyes. “But I didn’t put her initials on any inspection record. I’d like to say it was me, because it would be tidier. It wasn’t.”

“Then the initials on the sheet Lyle Rowe holds--”

“I think someone copied them. And the note on the yellow, ‘notified ownership,’ was a lie. I never told anyone about that sheet. I wrote it so that if anyone ever asked, I’d have passed it up the chain.”

Jessa leaned forward.

“So it’s your pen on the yellow. And the received line on the carbon, with her initials, in a different pen, isn’t yours.”

“I don’t know whose it is.”

“Do you know how convenient that sounds?”

“I do.” He met her eyes. It was the first thing he’d done that I might have called brave. “I can’t make it sound better. I can tell you I never saw that carbon, and I’m not the man who typed that K.”

Brandt put a hand lightly on his arm. “My client has no further interest in characterizing a document he didn’t write.”

“That’s a wise client,” Nita said, and wrote something down.

---

I wanted to speak.

It’s difficult to explain to someone who hasn’t spent her whole life as a fixer. I could see six or seven questions lined up in the air, each of them sharper than the last, each of them a little rope I could throw. Where were the plates after the accident? Who’d had the loft key? Did he know the facilities man’s name? Wasn’t it convenient that the one person who could confirm his story was a notary in a shed?

My left hand tightened around the paper cup until it crumpled.

Jessa put her bad hand over my knee under the table, without looking at me. It was a small, firm, unmistakable pressure. Closed loop.

I opened my fingers. The cup dropped, with a sad little crunch. I breathed out, and I did not say a word.

“Mr. Arlen,” Jessa said. “I have two questions.”

“Yes.”

“Did anyone touch the anchor after you read the sheet?”

“No. I’d have known. The loft key was in my desk. I mean the second key. The facilities man had the first, and he wasn’t in that week. The anchor was exactly as Rowe left it.”

“So nobody sabotaged it.”

“I never saw anyone.” He hesitated. “I never saw anyone, and I’d never have said so if I had.”

“That’s not an answer.”

“It’s the one I have.” He turned his hands over. “It was neglect. It was my neglect, and it was a budget meeting I didn’t want to have, and it was a sheet in a drawer. If somebody wanted to hurt a performer, I never knew it. I think it was nothing so exciting as that.”

Jessa sat very still, with her face smooth as a plate. I felt, rather than saw, what that sentence did to her. For six years, in some corner, she had wanted a villain. I had wanted one, too. It’s easier to survive a crime than an oversight.

“Second question,” she said, after a moment. “Why now?”

“Because I’m in a room with you.” He gave a dry, shaky laugh. “Because I read the paper, and I saw a girl I’d never met had cut a rope for you and I’d been hiding in a storage unit with a box of lies. I’m a coward, Ms. Dace. But I’ve got a limit, and I reached it on Monday.”

“That isn’t why you called a lawyer on Friday.”

“No.” He didn’t flinch. “I called a lawyer because Devon Skell came to see me at the county facility and said people were about to start asking about the log, and I should decide whether I wanted to be a hero or a headline.”

“Devon visited you?” Nita said, very sharply.

“As a liaison for the company. He had the right paperwork. He said he was checking on a former employee.” Beck looked at Ames. “He asked me about the log. He’d had a copy for fourteen months. He took it off my desk at Cinderhall’s closing, when I was clearing out, and kept it in an envelope. He told me he was keeping it safe. He said the forty-one were, and I quote, inventory with a heartbeat.”

I felt the room go cold.

“He asked me what they’d be worth to the right buyer,” Beck said. “I told him nothing. I said they were people. He laughed and said I’d been in the business too long to say that with a straight face.”

Ames’s pen stopped moving. For the first time all morning, Ames spoke.

“Mr. Arlen. When was this visit?”

“Last Wednesday.”

“The day after Ellis Voss told the delegates about his purchase.”

“I don’t know about that. I know it was two days before I called my own lawyer.” He swallowed. “I think he wanted me frightened enough not to talk.”

“And are you?”

“Very.” He looked at Jessa. “But I’d rather be frightened and useful.”

---

They gave us an hour’s recess, which is the polite thing to do when someone has just said that.

Jessa and I stood on a fire stairwell outside the conference room, in the cold, with the door propped open and the clatter of a district office going on behind us. She leaned on the rail with both forearms and breathed. I stood two feet away, hands in my pockets, and didn’t touch her.

“You didn’t ask a single question,” she said.

“No.”

“I counted. You had at least six.”

“Seven.”

“What happened to them?”

“They’re in my notebook.” I smiled, crookedly. “In pencil. I’ll give them to Nita.”

She turned her head. Her eyes were dry and red-rimmed. “I thought I’d feel something when he said it. A click. A door closing, or opening.”

“And?”

“I feel tired.” She laughed, once, without much humor. “I feel as if I’ve carried a sofa up four flights of stairs for six years and someone told me the building was a house the whole time.”

“It’s a good sofa.”

“It’s a terrible sofa. I hate it.” She pressed the knuckles of her right hand against her mouth, then lowered them. “He didn’t cut the rope. He didn’t swap the plate. He put a sheet in a drawer and lied about it for six years, and it still might have killed me. It might have killed me on an ordinary Friday, with no villain at all.”

“I know.”

“That’s worse.” She turned and looked at me properly, for the first time that day. “And it’s better. Isn’t it? There was no one who hated me. There was only a lot of people who didn’t want to have a hard meeting.”

“I think that’s right.”

“Then I forgive no one today,” Jessa said. “And I’ll go back in and listen to the rest.”

She straightened, wiped her face with her sleeve, and held out her good hand to me, palm up, like someone offering a ticket. I put my left hand in it.

---

Beck had one more thing, and he saved it for the end.

It was nearly noon. The recorder was warm. Nita had run out of pencil leads and Ames had been silent for twenty minutes, which meant Ames was thinking. Brandt had started to gather his papers, in the tidy, regretful way of a man who has delivered a bad package, and Beck said, abruptly, “May I say one more thing?”

“Of course,” Nita said.

“I told you I kept page seven.”

“You did.”

“I didn’t destroy it. I couldn’t.” He rubbed his hands together as if they were cold. “I put it in an envelope, plain, no return address, and for four years I kept it in the storage unit with the log. Then, two years ago, when I started to hear talk that someone had begun asking about the inquiry, I thought, I can’t be the only one who has this. I mailed it.”

“To whom?” said Ames.

“The Delegates’ Hall. The office of the chair.” He lifted his eyes to the wall, to a fire-safety diagram, to nothing. “It was the only public body I could think of that sat above the inquiry and the arena both. I thought a person in that office might read an appendix.”

“Who held the chair then?” Nita asked.

“I don’t remember. It was in the papers for a week and I never looked at the name.” He rubbed his face. “I wrapped it in brown paper, wrote the address in block capitals and walked it to a post box at night. There was a note inside, one line. ‘Page seven. Look at the date.’”

“And?”

“I never heard anything. I assumed it was thrown away, or read and ignored. I assumed a lot of things for two years.”

Nobody spoke. I could hear the radiator knocking and a printer chewing paper in the next room and, very faintly, through the wall, the district clerk laughing about a parking permit.

“Two years,” I said. It was the first thing I had said in two hours, and I kept my voice soft. “Before Ellis ever bought the report.”

“Before I’d have known his name.”

“Then it never reached him.”

“I don’t know where it reached.” Beck looked at me. “I only know where I sent it.”

My phone was on the table in front of me, face down. It buzzed once against the wood, and then again, and I turned it over because I’d stopped being able to pretend. Ellis. Two lines.

Cleo, the mailroom clerk found a log entry. Something came to the chair’s office two years ago, was logged, and was never delivered. It’s in the dead-letter drawer. I’m going to look. Come if you can.

I looked at Jessa. I looked at Nita, whose pencil had gone still, and at Ames, who had already stood.

“I’ll bring a camera,” Ames said, “and a witness.”

“I’d like to be the witness,” I said.

“I know.” Ames glanced at Jessa, and then, for the first time that week, almost smiled. “Closed loop. You’ll sit where I tell you.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!