Oren called at six on Friday morning, which meant it was bad news, because Oren only ever phoned before eight when someone had been hurt or someone had been cheap.
“Which is it?” I said, with the phone against my shoulder and my left hand trying to work a zipper.
“Neither. Both. It’s the second one.” I heard a diesel engine turn over behind him, and the clank of a ramp. “The Courier ran a follow-up. Priya Lund. Page three, below the fold, headline says ‘Stunt Coordinator Trainee Named in Towerfall Cover-Up Probe.’ It doesn’t say cover-up in the story. It says concealed. Then it says you.”
“I’ve been named for ten days.”
“You’ve been named for ten days in a piece about your sister. This one’s about you. And it’s got a quote from the Harlan Mutual claims office saying they are ‘reviewing exposure on productions engaging persons under active inquiry.’” He let a breath go. “The Fenner Hall date pulled at five-forty. Insurer’s rider. I’ve had it for a year and a half, Cleo.”
I sat down on the cot. The dress form with no head stood beside me, wearing a half-pinned bodice, and had nothing to say.
“I’m sorry,” I said.
“Don’t. It’s not the first time somebody’s insurer got nervous about my crew, and it won’t be the last.” There was a clank, and a shout, and Oren shouted back something about the left hinge. “I’m going to find you something. Farrah’s already on the phone. I want you to know the name on the cancellation isn’t yours. It says ‘ground planner, pending review.’ They don’t even have the courage to put you in the sentence.”
“That’s almost funny.”
“It’s meant to be. I’ll call Sunday.” He hung up the way he always did, without goodbye, like a man shutting a trunk.
I sat for a minute, adding it up. Two bookings gone. A third, if the Courier kept going. Six weeks of shadow hours on a form that now said pending. The price of the thing I had done at Towerfall had arrived on schedule, not as a blow but as a series of polite refusals, each one reasonable and none of them mine to fight.
Then Nita texted. Pettibone is a yes. Leave in 20. Wear something that doesn’t say lawyer.
I owned nothing that said lawyer. I put on jeans.
---
Gus Pettibone lived on the east shore of Tamsin Lake, which was a name that sounded like a postcard and looked, in November, like a puddle someone had stretched. The road ran along it for eleven miles. On the far side a row of summer cabins stood boarded up, with their docks drawn up on the grass like beached boats, and a single motorboat bobbed in a little cove with a tarp over it, going nowhere.
Nita drove. Ames, in the passenger seat, had a file on the knee and a flask of tea. I sat in the back with my sling and the useful knowledge that I was there on sufferance.
“It’s Mr. Pettibone’s house, and Mr. Pettibone’s idea of a witness,” Ames said, without turning around. “He asked who was coming. I told him an inspector, a lawyer and a woman who’s been looking at paper all week. He said, ‘Does she know anything about boats?’ I said no. He said fine.”
“He’s a boat person?”
“Corbel Staffing was a boat person’s business, I gather. He ran it from the back of a marina for twenty-six years. He was licensed by the state as a temporary help agency, which required him to keep a record of every placement for seven years.” Ames did the faint thing with the mouth. “It has been six.”
“So the paper should exist.”
“The paper should exist, if he kept it. The licensing board has no record of an inspection after year four.” Ames reached for the tea. “In my experience people who’ve been forgotten by a regulator either throw everything away or keep it all in a garage.”
“Which is he?”
“We’re about to find out.”
It was a garage.
It was a long, low, tin-roofed garage with a rowboat hull propped against one wall and two ancient filing cabinets standing against the other like prisoners. A man came out of the house to meet us in a yellow rain jacket and an enormous pair of rubber boots. He was seventy-two and built like a barrel left out in the weather. His beard was white. His hands were the color of old rope.
“You’re the law,” he said.
“Inspector Bell. This is Nita Dreyer from the prosecutor’s office, and Cleo Dace.”
I noticed it as it was said. In ten days, I had never once been given Nita’s surname. I filed it away without comment and stepped forward and held out my left hand, and Gus Pettibone looked at the sling and shook it without a word.
“My wife says to say there’s coffee,” he said. “She also says if you’re going to ruin my afternoon you could at least do it with a biscuit.” He tilted his head at the house, where a small woman in an apron was standing at the kitchen window with her arms folded, looking like a very old sentry. “That’s Marjorie. She remembers more than I do.”
---
The filing cabinets held, he told us, every timecard Corbel had ever processed.
“I don’t throw things away,” he said. “I wasn’t allowed to throw things away. Then the state stopped checking and I just never started.” He hauled out a drawer. “Seven years’ worth, in order, by month. I’d like it noted I’m a good bookkeeper.”
“It’s noted,” said Nita.
“Because I’m not a bad man. I’d like that noted, too.”
“It will be.”
“People say that.” He looked at me. “They write it down and then it comes out different at the other end.”
“I’ll tell it the way you tell it,” I said, because it was all I had.
He turned that over with the air of a man tasting something he had not been served in a long time. Then he gave a short nod and started going through the drawer.
October six years ago was a thin folder. Corbel Staffing, it turned out, had spent most of its life supplying dockhands and bartenders for the summer cabins, and October was the dead month. There were nine timecards in the folder, each a long ruled sheet with a name at the top and a column for each day. Gus pulled them out one at a time and laid them on the hood of a pickup, in a row, like cards for solitaire.
“Marsh,” said Ames.
“Marsh.” He ran a thick finger down the corners. “Here.”
L. MARSH. Three days, October seventh, eighth and ninth. Hours 4 to 7. A single signature at the bottom, round and hurried, slanted left. In the box marked Approved By, two small capital letters. B.A.
It matched the green slip like a left hand matching a right.
“Tell us how it was booked,” said Nita.
“On the phone.” Gus rubbed his beard. “On the Thursday before. I remember because we had the Cormack girl’s wedding that weekend and the phone never stopped. A man called. Said he was with the touring office at the arena. A nice voice. Rich. He said they needed a front-desk temp for three afternoons, a particular woman, he’d send her over with a reference, and could we just put her on our paper for the week.”
“A particular woman?”
“That was my impression. He gave me the name. He said she was between engagements.” He frowned, a heavy and unsmiling frown. “I said we generally interview. He said it’s three afternoons, Mr. Pettibone, she’s very reliable. And he said, and I’m sorry to say I remember this, that the house would pay the agency a premium for the trouble. Cash.”
“How much?”
“Two hundred and forty. For ninety dollars of wages.” His eyes went to the mud. “I kept the difference. I’d had a bad summer.”
Nita wrote that down with absolutely no change of expression.
“Did you check her identification?” said Ames.
“I asked for it. The man said she’d bring it Monday.” Gus pulled a manila sleeve from the folder. It held a photocopy of what might once have been a driver’s license, so degraded by copying that the face was a gray smudge and the name a damp ghost. “That’s what I got. I thought, well, it’s three days, who’s going to look? I wrote the number on the card and I never ran it.”
“We’ll run it,” said Ames, “though I don’t expect much.”
“Is there trouble for me?”
“There may be.” Ames said it flatly, because anything else would have been unkind. “Taking cash over rates, failing to verify identification on a placement. The board will want to know. I can’t tell you what it’ll do.”
“I’ll lose the license.” It was not a question. “I closed the business four years ago. It’s the license I’ve got left. The marina still lets me say ‘proprietor’ on the bait cooler.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry.” He lifted his chin. “I’ll tell it to whoever asks. I’d rather it was a clean thing, at the end. I’d rather have one paper in this garage that said what I did.”
---
Marjorie Pettibone was waiting at the kitchen door with a plate of lemon biscuits and a look that dared any of us to refuse. We ate them. I’m not sure I’ve eaten a better biscuit in my life, and I was the sort of person who had eaten biscuits on loading docks in four states.
“It was the coat,” she said.
Ames looked up. “I’m sorry?”
“The man who came Monday.” She stirred the coffee, delicately. “Gus doesn’t remember because he was out back with the cove boat. But I was behind the counter. He came for the paperwork, to drop the woman’s identification and a cash envelope, and he was ever so polite, and I remember thinking he’d walked in off a magazine.”
“Describe him.”
“Forty, perhaps. Dark. Charming. A nice cashmere coat the color of old oatmeal, very good, with a collar. I said to him, ‘You must be cold, in that, it’s October.’ And he laughed and said, ‘It’s all I’ve got that looks like money.’” She tapped the spoon. “Isn’t that a strange thing to say? I thought it was very honest of him. I thought, here’s a man who knows what he is.”
“Did he give a name?”
“No. He signed nothing.” She put the spoon down. “But he held the envelope out in his left hand. I noticed, because the right was in his pocket, and I thought, a man who keeps one hand in his pocket is a man who doesn’t want to be seen to shake.”
I looked at Nita and Nita looked at nothing.
Forty then, I thought, was far too old for Devon Skell, who was forty-one now. And his hair, last I’d seen it, was brown, not dark, and he wore a sports jacket, not a coat. But a young man at thirty-five could have been charming and cashmere and anything else he liked, and a woman who thought he looked forty was not going to be a good witness on a birthday.
“Mrs. Pettibone,” I said. “Would you know him again?”
“In a lineup? I don’t know. But I’d know the coat.” She smiled, a small, sharp, satisfied smile. “I’d know it in a hundred.”
Ames wrote it all down. I let out a breath.
---
It was the telephone number that did it.
We were back in the garage and Nita was copying the booking slip, a half page in Gus’s untidy hand, with a time, a date and a number scribbled across the top. It was a landline, area code three-one-seven. Nita read the number aloud for the recording and then read it again, because the second time Nita had stopped on the exchange.
“Ames,” she said.
“What?”
“I know that prefix.” Nita had a phone out and was scrolling, with the particular speed of a person who has seen something. “SDS Recovery LLC. The payee on Pell’s payment, the one that was eleven days old when the link went out. Its listed phone number, on the application, was a mail-drop line. A prepaid forwarding service in the capital. The number’s here.” The phone turned toward us. “The booking number on Mr. Pettibone’s slip is the same line.”
“Six years ago?” said Ames.
“The carrier’s note says the line was opened under one account at least seven years ago, and the account was moved to the mail drop two years back.” Nita swallowed. “I’ll have to ask the carrier for the account history. But if that holds, the same account has carried this number the whole time.”
“Same line,” I said. “Same person. The same man called Corbel six years ago and booked the woman called Lee, and the same line, or the same man, has been taking Pell’s money for a link.”
“Same line,” said Ames, “is not the same person.”
“I know.”
“A line passes through hands.”
“I know.” I did know. I had been told it four times in ten days by two people who disliked being rushed, and it was true, and it was infuriating. “But the man in the oatmeal coat didn’t sign anything, and the woman didn’t sign anything real, and the only thing in all of it that kept the same number was the thing that sold the money.”
“That’s an inference.”
“It’s a good one.”
Ames looked at me for a moment, with that calm and tiring attention. “It is a good one,” Ames said. “Don’t say it to anyone.”
---
We stayed another hour. Gus Pettibone put his statement in his own words at a card table in the garage, with Nita writing and Marjorie reading over Nita’s shoulder, correcting the spelling. He did not leave out the two hundred and forty dollars. When he’d finished he read it back aloud, the whole thing, and asked if it was all right to have said “I took it and I knew.” Nita said it was fine.
He signed with a ballpoint, and then, to my surprise, offered the ballpoint to me.
“You sign too,” he said. “You were here.”
“I’m not a notary.”
“I know. It’s for the record.” His beard moved. “I’d like it to say somebody who wasn’t paid stood there while I told it.”
I looked at Ames. Ames gave an almost imperceptible shrug.
I signed in the margin. Cleo Dace, witness for the Towerfall injured, present. It was the first time I had put my name on a paper in a week without wincing, and the quiet satisfaction of it surprised me.
On the way out, Marjorie pressed a waxed-paper packet of biscuits into my good hand and said, “For your sister.” I had not mentioned my sister. I said thank you.
---
The sun went down early over the lake. The water turned the color of pewter and then a deep, flat blue, and the boarded cabins along the shore became black cutouts with the tops of pines behind them. Nita drove with both hands on the wheel. Ames was reading a printout by the dome light and had gone silent, in the way of a person whose mind had been given too many doors.
I was in the back with the biscuits when my phone buzzed.
Jessa: Is it a bad day or a good day?
I looked at it for a long time.
Me: Both. We have a name. L. Marsh. A woman called Lee who sat at the phone. And a man in an oatmeal coat who paid for her. We don’t know who either of them are.
Jessa: Is it Devon?
Me: Maybe. Ames says don’t say it.
Jessa: Then I’ll say it for you, quietly, in my kitchen, where it’s allowed.
I smiled. Another buzz.
Jessa: Oren called me. He was furious on your behalf. He said the insurer’s rider was “a coward’s paperwork.” I think he’s in love with you in the way people get about a good trainee. I’ve decided to find it endearing.
Me: He’s sixty-one.
Jessa: That’s why it’s endearing. Cleo?
Me: Yes?
Jessa: The Courier called me this morning. Priya Lund. Asking for a comment on the second piece. I said I’d think about it. I’m still thinking. I wanted you to hear it from me, not from the page.
I read that line more slowly than the others. We were not at a place where I could tell her what to say and she could pretend I hadn’t. We were at a place where she told me first, and I got to keep my mouth shut.
Me: Thank you for telling me.
Jessa: That’s it?
Me: That’s all I’ve got that isn’t an instruction.
A long pause. Then, in the little gray bubble: Good. That’s the right amount.
I put the phone face down on my knee and looked out at the lake going dark, and the biscuits in their paper, and a single light on the far shore that might have been a house, or a boat, or a woman putting a kettle on.
Ames shifted in the front seat.
“The licensing board will have a hard week,” Ames said, to the windshield.
“Because of Pettibone?”
“Because of what I’m going to ask them for.” A page turned. “A list of every agency in the state that placed temps for a Keene Arena or its touring office in the five years around the accident. Corbel’s one. I’d be very surprised if it’s the only one.”
“Do you think there are more Lees?”
“I think,” said Ames, and for once did not finish the sentence with a caution, “that a man with an oatmeal coat doesn’t make one phone call to one marina.”
The road bent along the shore. The headlights swept across a boarded cabin, a drawn-up dock, and a small motorboat under its tarp, still waiting for a season that would not come for months.
And my phone buzzed once more, a number I did not know, with a single line of text that made Nita glance in the mirror when I drew a breath.
Ms. Dace. This is Devon. I’d like to meet. Not a deal. A correction.

