“Do not reply,” said Ames, before I had finished reading the text aloud.
“I wasn’t going to.”
“You were composing it. I could hear your thumb.” Ames took the phone from my hand with two fingers, read the line, photographed the screen with a second device, and gave it back. “He has your number because it’s on a cancellation notice in a newspaper. That is not mysterious. What he wants is a person he can call a friend when this is written up.”
“A correction,” Nita said, from the front seat. “To what?”
“To whatever he thinks we think.” Ames drew a breath. “Answer him with one sentence, and I’ll give it to you. ‘Please have your counsel contact Inspector Bell.’ Nothing else. No exclamation point. If he’s sincere it costs him a phone call. If he isn’t it costs him a bad hour.”
I typed it with my left thumb, slowly, like a child with a first sentence. I sent it. The phone sat dark on my knee for about four miles, and then it buzzed, and I read it without a sound.
Of course. My counsel will ring Monday. I only wanted you to have heard it from me first. Mind the lake road, it ices.
“He knows where we are,” I said.
Ames did not turn. “He knows there is a lake road. There are two. He’s guessing, and he’d like you to think he isn’t.”
It did not feel like a guess. It felt like a hand closing very gently on the back of my neck. I put the phone in my pocket and kept my eyes on the dark water going by, and I thought that Devon Skell was the first enemy I had ever had who made himself pleasant in order to be believed, and that it worked on me much better than any threat.
---
Ellis called me at eleven that night and said, in the dry flat voice of a man reading a list, that I should know before I read it, and that he was sorry, and that he’d be at the workshop whenever I could come.
“Read what?”
“Finch filed at nine. He’s emailed it to all thirteen of us. It’s a motion to censure.”
I was on the cot at Maris’s, in the dark, with the dress form and the streetlamp. I sat up so fast the cot rang.
“On what ground?”
“On the ground that I accepted an eleven-thousand-dollar payment from a company under investigation, from a company whose principal is a party to the inquiry, and that I failed to report it for a month.” A rustle on the line. “He’s not entirely wrong about the first. I did accept it. I didn’t know.”
“You told the clerk.”
“Monday. He’s dated the motion Friday and the payment October fourteenth. Four weeks. It looks, on paper, like four weeks.”
“It’s not on paper. It’s a statement. It’s dated.”
“I know.” Another rustle. “Come tomorrow, if you can. I’d like someone to read it who isn’t me.”
I said I would. I did not tell him what I was thinking, which was that three weeks ago I would have been in a truck at midnight with the engine running. I put the phone on the pillow and I lay there until I could hear my own pulse, and I did nothing. It was the hardest part of the whole week.
---
The workshop sat behind a hardware store on Maple Row, in the small gray town where the PO box had waited three years with its unopened statements, and it was a long, narrow brick shed with a loading door, a woodstove and about forty chairs in various states of undress.
I had been in it twice. It smelled of oak dust and linseed oil and strong tea. A half-finished rocker stood on the bench with one arm on and one off, the spokes laid out beside it in a neat fan. A radio on the sill played a station that did nothing but weather and hymns.
Ellis was sitting on an upturned crate with a laptop on his knees and his sleeves rolled to the elbow. He had not shaved. There was a streak of glue on his cuff and a long, sleepless crease down one cheek, and when he looked up and saw me in the doorway his whole face changed so quickly that it frightened me. It was not relief.
It was the look of a man who has been holding something very heavy for hours and has just been told he can put it on the floor.
“You came.”
“You asked.” I took off the sling and set it on the bench and sat on the second crate. “Show me.”
He turned the laptop around.
It was a three-page document in the pale blue font of the delegates’ hall. Motion to Censure and Refer. It was written in the passive voice of a man who wanted to be remembered as impartial. It recited, in numbered paragraphs, that the Hon.
Ellis Voss had on or about October fourth made a payment of eleven thousand dollars to Sutter Document Services for the purchase of a state-record appendix concerning a pending inquiry, in a manner contrary to the rules of conduct; that he had on or about October fourteenth received a reimbursement of an equal sum from an account of Keene Arena Co., whose principal had an interest in the matter at hand; that he had not reported the transaction until November; and that the delegates should therefore censure him, refer the matter to the ethics committee and defer the vote on his renewal pending its report.
“It’s fair,” I said slowly, “in the way a wrong answer is fair.”
“That’s what I thought.” His mouth twisted. “Paragraph six is the one I can’t stop reading.”
I scrolled. Paragraph six said that the refund was made under a memorandum bearing the reference SDS-2291.
I read it twice. It did not need a third.
“The invoice number,” I said.
“The invoice number. Sutter’s own, internal. It’s on the wire memo my bank gave me, and it’s on Sutter’s books, and it’s on the one copy that Nita has of the statement, and as of Monday it’s on the clerk’s file.” He put his hand flat on the bench. “That number was not public. Finch put it in a motion at nine o’clock tonight.”
“Where did he get it?”
“There’s an exhibit.” He scrolled again. “Exhibit A. It’s an image of the memo.”
I leaned in. It was a flat, gray scan of a bank memorandum, the same one I’d seen on Ellis’s phone a week ago: KAS REIMB DOC SVCS SDS-2291 PER AUTH. But along the top of the image, in the small bruised capitals of an old fax machine, ran a header.
SDS RECOVERY 317-555-0194 11/12 5:42 PM P1/1
Eleven-twelve. The Thursday before last. The day before I had sat in Jessa’s kitchen and told Ellis there was a refund at all.
“That’s not a bank scan,” I said.
“No.”
“That’s a fax. From a number.” I felt the little cold clarity come over me that I had felt in the shed. “Ellis, that’s the number on Pettibone’s booking slip.”
He looked at me.
“It’s a mail-drop line,” I said. “A forwarding service in the capital. Six years ago it was a man’s phone call to a marina. Two years ago it was SDS Recovery’s contact. And on a Thursday evening at 5:42, eight days ago, it sent out a copy of your wire memo.” I stopped. “You didn’t know the memo existed yet. How would a mail drop have your memo?”
“It wouldn’t.” He said it very quietly. “Not from my bank. The bank sent one copy to me and, later, one to Nita. Someone who had the original sent it. Someone who knew it was being collected and wanted it to arrive in front of Finch before I could walk it in myself.”
“Someone who has your invoice number because he was in the room when Sutter wrote it.”
“Or because he’s Sutter. Or because he’s the man who told Yvette to make me whole.” He put his face in his hands for about a second, and then took them away. “It doesn’t prove anything, does it? It proves someone sent Finch a fax.”
“It proves Finch is holding the same string that Devon is.”
“It proves that Finch has a fax machine.”
I opened my mouth, and then I shut it, because there was a very quiet, very unsentimental part of me that had learned something from Ames and from Nita and from Jessa, and it said: he is right. It said the fax proves exactly what it proves. It proves a line. It gives us a line to follow. It does not give us a man.
“All right,” I said. “It’s a lead.”
“It’s a lead I’ll hand to Nita tonight.”
“And Finch?”
“Finch is a legislator with a motion.” Ellis sat back on the crate. “He might have been handed it by a friend and believed it. That’s the worst of this. I don’t think he’s dishonest. I think he’s the kind of man who’s always sure of the thing he’s been told, and the person who tells him knows it.”
---
We sat for an hour without talking about it.
I watched him sand a spoke. He did it by feel, a long, slow, steady stroke of the paper along the grain, the way my mother used to smooth a hem. The radio told us a front was moving in from the west. The woodstove ticked.
“They’ve moved my vote,” he said, at last. “It’s in the second paragraph, under the motion. Friday, not the end of the month. Finch asked to take the censure first, then the renewal. They’ll do both in an afternoon.”
“Friday. That’s three days before the hearing.”
“It’s three days before the hearing.” He put down the paper. “I could withdraw.”
“Withdraw what?”
“My candidacy for renewal. Walk in on Monday and say I won’t stand. It would cost me the title, not the work. Finch would have no motion to bring.” He said it in a perfectly level voice. “It would take the sting out of everything. It would also keep the hall from holding a public vote on a thing that isn’t finished. It might be the kind thing. To the hearing. To Jessa. To you.”
I saw the whole of it laid out. The clean exit. The generous gesture. The man giving up a small thing to protect a large one, with a little glow of virtue he would carry for years. And I saw it was precisely what I would have done, six weeks ago: made the dramatic sacrifice on someone else’s behalf and called it help.
“Do you want to?” I said.
“I don’t know.”
“Then that’s the answer I’d listen to.” I kept my voice level. “Ellis, I’m not going to tell you what to do. I’ve been given a lot of practice not telling people what to do lately, and I’m bad at it, and I’m going to be bad at it now.”
I took a breath. “I’ll say what I notice. You haven’t said what you want. You’ve said what it would cost, who it would spare, what it would look like. You haven’t said once what you’d do if you were the only one who’d be affected.”
He sat very still.
“If I were the only one,” he said, “I’d stand. I’d walk in and say, this is what happened, here is the paper, here is my statement, here is the fax, and vote how you like.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s true.” He gave a short, astonished laugh. “Because I haven’t done the thing they said, and I’m tired of looking like I did. And because if I leave, the story is that I ran.” He looked at his hands. “That’s a stupid reason. It’s vanity.”
“It’s a reason.”
“It’s a poor one.”
“It’s yours,” I said. “That’s what makes it worth something. Don’t give it away for the hearing. Jessa can look after the hearing.”
He was silent for a long moment. Then he got up, went to the bench, and picked up a flat black notebook that I had seen him write in a dozen times.
“I’m going to write a statement,” he said. “Not a long one. One page. The facts, in order, with dates. I’ll hand it to the clerk before the vote and read it into the record.”
“Good.”
“And I’ll tell the delegates what I’d do if I were the only one affected.” He opened the notebook. “I’ll say I’d stand. And I’ll say I know I’m not the only one affected, and I’ll tell them the vote can go either way, and I’ll accept it.”
“That’s a lot to say in one page.”
“It’s three sentences.” He almost smiled. “I’ll cut it.”
---
It was getting dark when I put the sling back on.
Ellis walked me to the door, past the unfinished rocker and the fan of spokes, and stopped under the bare bulb at the entrance.
“May I say something?”
“You always ask now. It’s very strange.”
“I’m practicing.” He looked down at me, and the long crease on his cheek had softened. “When you said it was my reason. I thought, she doesn’t want me to be saved. She wants me to be someone who knows what he wants.” He hesitated. “I’d like to be that. I think I’ve been waiting for somebody to tell me it was permitted.”
“It’s permitted.”
“I know that now.” He paused. “Could I also say that you look dreadful?”
“I’ve had a week.”
“You’ve had a month.” His hand lifted and stopped, and he left it hanging in the air between us, open. A question. “May I?”
I took it. It was warm and rough and smelled of oak, and he held mine as if it were a thing he had made himself and was still deciding whether it was finished.
“There’s something else,” I said. “I’d like to be told if the vote goes badly. Before the page. By you.”
“You will be.”
“Even if it’s at midnight.”
“Especially then.” He squeezed my fingers once and let go. “Go home. Sleep. I’ll call you when I’ve cut it to a page.”
I walked out into a little cold wind that smelled of snow and woodsmoke. Behind me the loading door rolled shut, and the light went from yellow to a thin gold line along the bottom. At the corner I stopped and took out my phone and, against every sensible instruction I’d ever been given, called Maris.
“Cleo.” She sounded like she’d been asleep on her feet. “What.”
“There’s a fax,” I said. “From a mail drop. It went to a delegate named Finch, with a copy of the memo. Same line that booked Lee. Same line that took Pell’s money.”
A long pause. She didn’t say anything. I could hear a sewing machine, somewhere, running steadily on the other end.
Then: “Then he’s not a ghost,” said Maris. “He’s a man with a fax machine.”
“That’s what Ellis said.”
“It’s what anybody would say who’d spent a week looking for a ghost.” Her breath caught, laughing and not laughing. “Tell Ames. And Cleo, eat something. You sound like you’ve got a nail in your shoe.”
I ate a gas-station sandwich in the truck while I waited for Ames to answer. It was dreadful. It tasted wonderful. And when the phone finally rang and Ames said, “Say it slowly,” I told the story in order, once, without adding a single word that I had not seen.
It took four minutes. At the end of it there was a long silence on the line, filled with the small dry scratch of a pen.
“Friday,” Ames said. “That’s the vote.”
“Yes.”
“And the hearing a week from Monday.” Another scratch. “Ms. Dace. When Mr. Skell’s lawyer rings me on Monday, I’d like to be in a position to ask a question about a fax. I’d like that very much.” A pause. “You’ve been very patient.”
“I have not.”
“You have been exactly as patient as you could,” said Ames, “which is better than most people manage, and I’ll accept it. Go to sleep.”
I started the truck. The heater coughed, and the radio, because there was nothing else on, played a weather report that said a front was coming through by Monday morning and that anyone traveling should expect ice.

