Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 47

Good Man

Yvette Keene received us in her kitchen at four on Sunday afternoon, in a gray cardigan and pearl studs, with a pot of tea on the table and a blue folder at her elbow that I took, correctly, to be her bank.

It was the first time I had been in her house. It was a tall, plain, immaculate frame house with a deep porch, and the kitchen had the scrubbed hush of a room in which nothing had been moved for thirty years because nothing needed to be. A piano stood in the next room with the lid shut. A row of six Christmas cards no longer stood on it. The lid was bare as a table.

Maris sat down opposite her mother. I took the chair by the door. Nita arrived at ten past, quietly, in the rain, with a small gray recorder and a face that gave nothing away.

“I’ve listened to the cassette,” Nita said. “Not here. At the district, with Dr. Thale’s audio colleague, who has done a great deal of this and is not easily impressed. I’ll say what I’m permitted to say.” Nita laid the recorder on the table, not switched on. “The voice on the tape is that of Leona Marsh. It’s an impression of you, Mrs. Keene. It’s very good.

“The pitch, the cadence, the drop at the end of ‘fuss.’ It would not fool you. It might fool a man on a bad telephone line at ten to five.”

“And Mr. Hale?” said Yvette.

“He listened at two o’clock in his rented room, by himself, with headphones. He’s given a statement.” A pause. “He said that the first voice, the one doing you, was close. He said he’d have obeyed it. And then, at the end of the tape, after the laughter, Ms. Marsh speaks in her own voice, quite briefly.”

“What does she say?”

“’Good man, Dunmore.’” Nita folded both hands on the table. “It’s what she says to the audience at the end of every announcement, apparently. A signature. It’s in her own warm voice, with a little lift. Mr. Hale said, quote, ‘That’s the one who said it on the phone. She did you, Mrs. Keene, and then she forgot, and she said it the way she says it.’ He cried, a little. He apologized.”

Yvette did not move. Her hands lay on the folder, and I watched the knuckles, long and fine and a little swollen at the joints, slowly lose their color and then regain it.

“He’s been apologizing to me for a month,” she said. “I should like it known that he needn’t.”

“I’ll tell him.”

“I’ll tell him myself.” She turned the folder a quarter turn, squaring it to the table’s edge. “Inspector Bell’s colleague, you said, would like me to read a script. Into a machine. For comparison.”

“Dr. Thale’s colleague. Yes.”

“Then I’ll read it. Tonight, if that’s convenient. And in the morning, at the hearing, I’ll say aloud what Mr. Skell wishes to say for me.” Her voice was level and rather dry. “He’s filed my payments to Lorraine, I understand. Seventy-two checks of two thousand dollars, a hundred and forty-four thousand in all, of which sixty-six were cashed. A hundred and thirty-two thousand dollars. He means to call it hush money.”

“Mother,” said Maris.

“It was.” Yvette looked at her daughter. “Not in the way he means. It was a thing I did because I knew there was something I didn’t want to learn. Because a woman I’d trusted for nineteen years came to me, the month after Towerfall, and stood in my office, and began to tell me something, and I said, ‘Lorraine, not today.’ And she never said it again.” The line of her mouth trembled and was stilled.

“”I let her go. I paid her. I told myself it was kindness. It was kindness. It was also a way of keeping a door shut.”

Nobody spoke. Rain ticked on the window.

“I’d like to put it in the record myself,” said Yvette Keene, “before he can.”

“There will be a cost,” Nita said, gently.

“There already is.” She took the first page from the blue folder. It was a bank statement, with the monthly debit circled in neat green ink. “I’ve told my board. They met on Friday night, after the vote, in this room, with a very bad sherry. I’ve offered to step aside from the management of the Ridgetop Arena pending the panel’s findings. They accepted it by a show of hands. It took four minutes.” She did not look up.

“I have managed that building for twenty-six years, and owned it for six. It took a show of hands.”

“Mother.”

“Don’t,” said Yvette. “I shall not manage if you’re kind to me.” And then, to the table: “Not just yet.”

Maris put out her hand. After a moment, as if the gesture were in a language she had half forgotten, her mother took it.

Then Nita unfolded a single typed sheet and said, in the careful voice of someone reading a safety card, “Dr. Thale’s protocol is that you read it exactly as written, once through, at your ordinary pace, with no one coaching. I’ll be in the room. Your daughter may stay.”

Yvette read it. It was four paragraphs about nothing: a weather report, a list of room numbers, a line about a missing umbrella. And near the end, because Dr. Thale was a thorough woman, the sentences from Hale’s telephone call as he had described them. She read them in her own voice, dry and level, with the little downward slide that Devon had mimicked in a corridor and Leona had perfected in a kitchen.

Then she came to the last line on the page. It said, in plain black type: Thank you. Good man.

She stopped. The recorder’s small red light kept steadily on.

“I have never said that in my life,” said Yvette Keene. “Not to Dunmore. Not to anyone.”

“Please read it as written,” said Nita, gently.

“I shall.” She looked at the line for a long moment, as if it were a bill that had come to the wrong house. Then she read it, flat and stiff and entirely wrong, a sentence in a borrowed coat, and set the sheet down. “There. Now you have me saying it badly, which I imagine is the point.”

“It is,” said Nita. “Thank you.”

Maris laughed, a short astonished sound, and put her hand over her mouth. Her mother looked at her with something like surprise, and then, for the first time that afternoon, almost smiled.

---

I left them in the kitchen. I walked out under the porch, where the rain slid down a drainpipe in a thin steady line, and found that I was shaking. It was not fear. It was the fury of a person who has been given the identity of an enemy and discovered that the enemy is a woman who did a funny voice at a Christmas lunch.

I walked to the truck. I could not get in. I stood by the door in the rain with my good hand on the cold wet metal and thought: there is a man in an oatmeal coat who learned that an old woman’s laugh, a friend’s joke, a half-sister’s gift and a kind gesture to a nervous bookkeeper were all instruments, and picked them up one by one, as you pick up a screwdriver and a wrench, without ever once raising his voice.

My phone buzzed. Ellis.

It’s done, the text said. Come see it. Don’t bring the sling. I’ll lift the thing myself.

I went. I drove with one hand through the wet, with the wipers and a small hard knot between my ribs, to the long low shed on the edge of Graymill with the lamp over the door, and I walked in and stood for a moment on the sawdust with the water running off my sleeves.

It was a rocking chair. It stood in the middle of the floor in the light of a single work-lamp, the kind of chair a person builds when he has been told he may build only one thing and must make it hold up for a hundred years. Cherry, I thought, and ash.

The back was a fan of thin spindles, the arms were wide and flat and a little curved at the end to fit a palm, and the rockers swept in a long low arc, polished to the color of tea.

“It’s for Hale,” said Ellis.

He was sitting on an upturned crate in the corner, in his shirtsleeves, with a rag in both hands. He looked ten years older than he had on Friday and ten years younger than he had in the spring. His hair was loose. There was a smear of oil on his cheekbone.

“He gave Maris a butterscotch when he resigned,” I said.

“I know. She told me.” He stood. “I thought he might want something to sit in. He’s sixty-eight, he’s lost a job he did for thirty-one years, and he’s in a rented room with a hot plate.” The rag turned over in his hands. “I thought, if I can’t fix the thing I’d like to fix, I can make a chair.”

“Ellis.”

“It’s a good one. It holds two hundred and fifty pounds, which is excessive, and the arms are a quarter inch wider than they should be, because he’s a man who likes to rest his elbows.” He stopped. “I wrote the sentence, too. In the end. The one I said I’d write.”

“What sentence?”

“The one I’ll say tomorrow, if they ask me a question I can’t answer.” He put the rag down on the crate. “I’ll say, ‘I don’t know.’ I’ve never said it in a hearing in my life, Cleo. I’ve said ‘I’ll find out’ and ‘I’ll have an answer next week,’ and ‘It’s under review.’ It’s very strange. It’s a perfectly good sentence.”

“I like it.”

“I thought you might.” He looked at the rocker. “It’s rather a ridiculous thing to be proud of. A chair.”

“You can be proud of a chair.” I crossed the sawdust, and put my good hand on the back of the rocker, and felt the spindles under my palm, smooth and warm and slightly oily, alive as an animal’s flank. I set it rocking. It went back with a long, low, patient sigh, and came forward again, and settled. “It’s the best thing I’ve seen all week.”

“It’s the only thing I’ve finished all week.”

“That’s what I said.”

He laughed. It broke in the middle, as mine had in Jessa’s kitchen, and I turned and did what I had told myself I would not do on a courthouse step: I put my face into the front of his shirt and my arm around his ribs and held on. He smelled of cherrywood and lamp oil and the clean, bitter sap of fresh-cut ash. He did not say anything.

He put his chin on top of my head, and we stood in a puddle of work-light with a chair rocking slowly between us, and neither of us said, because there was nothing to say that was not on the other side of Monday, that it was the last quiet night.

---

I slept four hours in Jessa’s spare room. At a quarter to five I woke to the sound of a kettle and found her already dressed in the good dark dress, standing at the kitchen counter in the half dark, trying to fasten the top button of the gray coat.

I knew better than to move. Her left hand has lost most of what the little finger and the ring finger once did, and a button the size of a pea is a small, stubborn negotiation. She tried it from above. She tried it from below. She turned the coat on the counter and tried it again, with her lips pressed together and her breath going out through her nose.

I stayed where I was, with my hands under my thighs. It was the hardest forty seconds of my month.

The button went through. Jessa looked at it, and then at me, with an expression I recognized, because I had seen it in the mirror at twenty-two.

“Not a word,” she said.

“I wasn’t going to say one.”

“You were going to offer.”

“I was going to sit on my hands,” I said, “and I did.”

“I know. I could hear you doing it.” She picked up her tea and drank half of it standing, which she never does. “That’s the speech, you know. All of it. Everything I’ll say today is just that button, said more slowly.”

I did not answer. There was nothing I could add that would not have been a hand reaching for the coat.

---

The County Annex stood at the head of Mill Street, a low modern building with a glass lobby and a flat roof and a row of flagpoles with no flags, because of the wind. The hearing was set for nine. We were there at a quarter past seven, because Jessa insisted.

“I’d like to see the room empty,” she said. “I’d like to know where the chairs are. I’m going to be sitting in one for six hours, and I’d like it to be the one nearest the door.”

“Jess, it’s a hearing, not a lifeboat.”

“It’s both,” said Jessa.

She had put on her good dark dress and a gray coat I had never seen, and she’d done something to her hair that made her look, for the first time in six years, exactly like our mother. She walked into the Annex lobby at a measured pace, with her stiff hand curled against her hip, and she did not look at the three cameras on the sidewalk or the woman from the Courier by the revolving door.

I thought: she has given her two sentences. She has nothing left to say that wasn’t hers.

The hearing room was on the second floor. It was a long, bright, institutional space with rows of padded chairs, a raised bench for five panel members, a witness table, and, along one wall, a row of long windows that looked out on the car park. The air was cold and slightly metallic. Someone had put a pitcher of water and a stack of paper cups on every table.

We found the chairs. The front row on the left had a card taped to it that said RESERVED: WITNESS, and Jessa took the seat by the aisle without a word, and I sat beside her, and left a seat for Maris on the other side. Behind us, in the second row, Ellis had come in alone in a black suit I had not seen before, and sat down with his hands on his knees, and met my eyes, and made no sign.

Ames came in at seven-forty with Nita, and went directly to the table at the side where the district’s lawyers sat, and unloaded a brown file box. Ames looked tired. It was the tiredness of a person who has had two hours’ sleep and a night of very small clean decisions, and has put the last of them into a folder. Ames looked at me across the room and gave one short nod, the kind a stage manager gives from the wings.

Yvette came in at seven-forty-five on Maris’s arm, in black wool, and walked down the aisle as she must have walked down it at a hundred openings. Odette Fairbanks trailed behind in a hat. Hale was not there. He had been asked to attend at ten, and a deputy was bringing him.

I counted the room. Seventeen people, then twenty. A man I did not know. Priya Lund, in the back row, with a notebook and no pen; her editor had pulled her, and she’d come on her own. Lyle Rowe, in a corduroy jacket, with his big welder’s hands folded. Dolores Pike, with the dog’s leash coiled in her lap and no dog. Oren, in a quilted vest, grinning with fright.

The panel’s clerk, a young man in glasses, going up and down the aisle with a clipboard. Pell and Anselm, together, near the back, in matching scarves. And, a few minutes before ten to eight, Iona and Asa, who sat two seats apart with a coat between them like a fence, and did not look at each other, and did not look away.

It was seven-fifty. I was watching the clerk. He had set a clipboard on the sign-in desk by the door, and a pen on a chain, and a woman was bending over it to write.

I do not know why I looked. A thing goes through you, in a room like that, the way wind goes through a field. The nose had it before the eyes did: a faint, clean, powdery scent like a stage dressing room, face-powder and warm bulbs, and, under it, quite distinct, peppermints.

She straightened. She was a broad, handsome woman in a plum-colored suit, with a gray bob, big glasses and a briefcase in her right hand. She had signed with her left. I saw the pen move, a slanted, fluent line along the page, and the side of her hand dragged along the ink.

The clerk glanced at the sheet. “Witness for the defense,” he read aloud, in a young, unhurried voice that carried to the back of the room. “Ms. Leona Marsh. Called by counsel for Mr. Skell, as voice witness.”

The room went silent. I felt Jessa go rigid beside me, and I felt the rest of them all at once: Yvette’s head turning, Maris’s breath, Lyle’s big hands closing, Ames rising from the table, and, behind me, in the second row, Ellis’s chair creaking as he leaned forward.

Leona Marsh straightened her glasses. Then she turned, and looked down the long bright room, over the rows of padded chairs and the pitcher and the paper cups, and found me, and smiled. It was a warm, rueful, perfectly kind smile. It was the smile of an old friend at a funeral.

“You’ll be Cleo,” said Leona Marsh. It was not loud. It was the most beautiful voice I had ever heard, a low, round, unhurried contralto that carried to every corner of the room without effort, as though it had been built for the purpose. “I’m so very sorry about all of this. I’d like to talk to you, if I may, before anyone else does.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!