Room 2B had not changed. The tissues were still in the middle of the table. On the table beside them lay a clear plastic sleeve and, inside it, a single page.
Ames let me stand over it for three minutes, by the clock, with Nita in the doorway. That was the arrangement: look, do not touch, do not copy, do not speak until you have heard the question. I put my good hand flat on the table beside the sleeve and read.
It was typed. It was a plain statement, four short paragraphs, in the voice of someone who has been told what happened and is agreeing. I, Cleo Dace, being of lawful age. No defect, inspection note or maintenance warning concerning the anchor plate had been reported to me or, to my knowledge, to my sister Jessa Dace before the accident of October third. I make this statement freely and have read it. At the bottom, in blue ink, there was a signature.
It was mine. I knew it the way you know your own face in a shop window, a half second before you decide it is yours. The C was too big. The D had a hook at the end that I had abandoned at twenty-three. The signature had been written by someone whose hand was trembling very slightly, in a hurry, and it had a stamp under it with a notary’s name and a date.
Walter Ferris. October ninth, six years back. Three-forty p.m.
“I have read it,” I said. “I didn’t read it.”
“I know,” said Ames.
“The sentence is true. In a way. Nobody reported anything to me. I never saw a tag.” I was talking too fast. “That’s what makes it good. It’s a thing I’d have signed in my sleep, because it was true, and it left out the only part that mattered.”
“Say that in the room,” said Nita, softly. “Not here.”
I looked at the paper once more. The ink was blue, and cheap. But I noticed, as a person notices a crooked picture, that the paper was not cheap. It had a deckled edge and a slight shine, and across the top was the pale ghost of a raised design I had seen four times that morning without knowing why I kept seeing it.
I did not say it. Ames was already watching me not say it. I had learned that month that a person may keep a thing to herself for an hour if she knows exactly where she is putting it.
---
The panel reconvened at eleven-twenty. They called Ellis next.
He went to the table with the stride of a man crossing a ballroom, and then, a step before the chair, slowed. I saw him do it. I saw him decide, in front of two hundred people and a bench, to stop being a man who can cross a room.
The clerk held up the Bible. Ellis put his hand on it as though it might be hot. He gave his name, Ellis Voss, and the word “delegate,” and then, because Tolliver was waiting, “currently.”
“Mr. Voss,” said Tolliver. “You are here as a witness, not a party. The district has asked you to explain your purchase of a private report on the Towerfall accident from a broker named Sutter, and the subsequent refund. Would you do so.”
“I’d like to say first that I’m going to answer what I know,” said Ellis. “And that when I don’t, I’ll say so. It may be a long morning of the same two words.”
A small ripple. Tolliver said she thought the panel could stand it.
He told it plainly. In early October he had been told by someone he trusted that a document existed. He had not wanted to ask the family. He had paid a broker eleven thousand dollars out of a workshop account he rarely used. He had read the report. He had found it incomplete and he had said nothing to anyone for a month, because he had been ashamed, and because he had told himself that the shame was patience.
“And what did you do with it, Mr. Voss?”
“Nothing, for too long. Then I gave it away. To the district. Then, when the woman I’m in love with told me what I’d bought and what it meant for her family, I told the council, and the panel, and I’m told on a good day the Harlan County Courier.” He did not look at me. I was grateful for that. “I thought I could handle it. That was the mistake. It wasn’t mine to handle.”
Pratt’s cross came at eleven-forty, and it was exactly what I had been braced for. He did not raise his voice. He asked about the refund.
“On October fourteenth, ten days after your payment to Sutter, eleven thousand dollars was returned to the very account you paid from. Did you request the refund?”
“I did not.”
“Did you know it had been sent?”
“I did not. Statements for that account went to a post office box in Maplewick I hadn’t opened in three years.” The edge of a rueful smile. “It’s a sentence I’d like to remove from my life.”
“Who sent it?”
“I don’t know.”
“Who authorized the memo on the wire? KAS REIMB DOC SVCS SDS-2291 PER AUTH?”
“I don’t know.”
“The invoice number SDS-2291 belonged to Mr. Sutter’s records and, you’ve testified, to yours. Who else could have known it?”
“I don’t know. I can tell you who I told, which is no one. I can tell you who Mr. Sutter says he told, which is no one.” Ellis put one hand flat on the table, a gesture I had seen him use on a plank. “I think someone found out the way a person finds out where a river goes. By standing at the bottom and watching what floats down.”
“That is not an answer, Mr. Voss.”
“It’s an accurate description of my ignorance. I’m sorry that it isn’t prettier.”
I watched Pratt. He had been ready for an evasion or a boast, and he had been handed a sentence in which a man was cheerfully describing the contents of his own empty hands. It threw him half a beat, which is a long time in a cross-examination.
“Isn’t it true, Mr. Voss, that this refund looks very much like a payoff?”
“It looks like one,” said Ellis. “It was sent to look like one. I’d have thought that was the point, Mr. Pratt. Somebody wanted me to look bought. Whether I’m bought, I do know.” He paused. “I do know. That’s the only one I’ll say with any confidence this morning. I am not bought, and I’d like it noted that I’ve nothing to prove it with except what I’ve done since.”
He sat very straight.
“I’ll add one more,” said Ellis, “if the chair permits. I should have opened my mail.”
Somebody at the back made a sound that was half a laugh and half something else. Tolliver gave it a moment. “The chair permits,” she said, “and the chair notes that this will be the first hearing in which a witness has been guilty of an unopened post office box.”
In the gallery I found Finch. I had not noticed him come in, a broad pink man in a good gray suit, in the seventh row on the aisle with his arms folded. He was the delegate who had said, How unfortunate for you. He was not smiling. He was watching Ellis the way you watch a tire that has not yet gone flat.
---
Haldane asked the last question, at five to twelve.
“Mr. Voss. The refund came ten days after you paid Mr. Sutter. Whoever sent it knew you had paid. Did you tell anyone, when you paid?”
“No.”
“Did Mr. Sutter tell anyone?”
“He says no.”
“Then it’s a short list. Someone who watched Mr. Sutter’s shop. Someone who watched you.” Haldane’s heavy, patient face did not move. “Or someone who had access to Mr. Sutter’s books, which were found by the district to have been copied, with the copier’s consent or without, in the week of October first.”
“I don’t know that,” said Ellis. “That’s the third time. I’m told it’s a good number.”
Haldane wrote it down. I realized that the man had been waiting all morning to hear someone say a thing three times without gilding it. I think he trusted triplicates.
Ellis stepped down at noon. He walked back up the aisle to the second row with his hands at his sides, the long stiff stride of a man with a sore back, and as he passed the aisle seat of the row where I sat, I did not turn my head, and he did not turn his, and his hand brushed the back of my chair, once, with two fingers, the way you touch a doorframe when you leave a room you hope to see again.
---
The lunch recess was an hour and forty minutes, which meant an hour and forty minutes of corridor.
The corridor had changed. At nine it had been full of people pretending not to wait. At noon it had a kind of weather. There was a small knot of reporters near the stairwell, and a larger, quieter knot by the window, in which I could see Priya Lund, notebookless, listening. A man in a gray cardigan, a delegate I knew only by his reputation for moving amendments, had gone silent in front of Ellis, then bowed, a curt, odd little bow, and walked on.
Odette Fairbanks found me by the water fountain. She was in her hat, with her purse held in front of her in both hands, a woman of seventy-one in full battle dress.
“Miss Dace.” She did not usually say Miss. “I’ve been told there’s a key.”
“A key?”
“The district’s lady asked, a moment ago. About the Arena’s front office. It seems someone made photostat copies of Yvette’s check records on Friday night at eleven.” She breathed through her nose, hard. “On our copier. In our office. With a stamp on them. I’ve been at that desk thirty-four years, and I can tell you, nobody does a thing on that copier at eleven on a Friday without leaving a fingerprint of toner.”
“Who has keys?”
“Yvette. Me. Dunmore, who returned his in an envelope on Saturday. And Mr. Arlen, who had one and was told to give it back and, I rather think, gave back one that wasn’t.” She lowered her voice, which on Odette was like lowering a flag. “And mine. Which was on the hook behind the register on Thursday, where it’s always hung, and was not on the hook on Saturday morning, and was on the hook again Monday, and I told myself I’d been confused.”
“You weren’t confused.”
“No,” said Odette. “I was frightened I’d been confused. It’s not the same thing. I’d like you to remember I said so.”
“I will.”
“Good.” She gripped the purse. “I’ve never in my life been robbed by a polite man. Don’t tell Yvette I said that. She’d put it in her ledger.”
She went off toward the stairwell with her hat level and her back like a ruler, and I stood by the fountain with the sound of the water running over its little brass lip and let myself think about the key.
Not who had taken it. I knew better than to guess at that with a hearing still going. I thought about the hook behind the register, and a woman of seventy-one who had looked at it every working morning for thirty-four years and had never once, until last Saturday, seen it empty.
Jessa came up with two paper cups of coffee and held one out. I took it with my good hand and did not drink it.
“You didn’t tell me you were being called,” she said.
“I didn’t know. Not until nine.”
“Mm.” She sipped hers. “You look like somebody who’s been told the rope is fine and has just seen the frayed end.” She did not ask what the exhibit said. She stood beside me and looked at the people moving in the corridor, and after a while she said, “Whatever you signed, I’d have signed it too. I want that in your head before you sit down in that chair.”
It was a good sentence. I carried it with me like a coin.
---
Yvette took the stand at ten past two.
She had put on the black wool again, and pearls, and a hat that I thought was perhaps her mother’s, and she walked to the witness table with her cane, not leaning on it, carrying it at an angle like a conductor’s baton. Maris sat in the front row. I had been placed beside her by some arrangement of the clerk’s, and I felt her go taut as a drawn string.
Pratt took her through it himself, which was bold. He established that she was the owner of the Ridgetop Arena, that she was the signatory to its accounts, that she had for six years been making monthly payments of two thousand dollars by check to a former employee named Lorraine Vance. He asked whether she would care to explain the purpose of the payments.
“I would,” said Yvette. “I’ve been asked by my daughter, and I’ve been advised by the district, and I have, in the matter of my own conscience, been asked by myself, and I’ve concluded that a person should say a thing in her own voice rather than wait to be quoted.”
“Mrs. Keene,” said Pratt.
“Seventy-two checks. Two thousand dollars apiece. A hundred and forty-four thousand dollars in all. Sixty-six were cashed. A hundred and thirty-two thousand dollars.” The figures came out of her like beads off a string.
“You are going to say it was hush money, Mr. Pratt, and I’m going to say it was. It was, in the sense that I knew there was something my secretary wished to tell me, and that she’d told me part of it in my own office the month after the accident, and that I said, ‘Not today.’”
The room was dead still. I had not expected her to open the box herself, and neither, I thought, had Pratt.
“I was afraid of what she’d say,” said Yvette Keene. “So I paid her to stop saying it. I told myself that was kindness. It was both. A person can be both.”
“You’ve paid a woman a hundred and thirty-two thousand dollars to keep silent about what she knew of a falsified inspection.”
“I didn’t know it was falsified. That’s the point I’m making against myself.” She raised her chin. “I knew only that it was something I would not be able to put back. And when she stopped asking, in the spring, I was relieved. I should like the room to know that. I was relieved, and I’ve been relieved six times since, each time a check went uncashed. I thought: good, she’s well, she’s finished. I never asked what she was finished with.”
I did not look at Maris. I could smell her anyway: salt, and the chalky sweetness of something that has been held in a closed fist for a long time and then dropped.
Pratt tried twice more. The second time he asked if she had destroyed any records. She said no. The third time he asked whether she had had occasion to supply a copy of those checks to anyone, and she said, a little coolly, that she supposed he had them better than she did.
“You mean the photostats,” said Tolliver. “Mr. Pratt, I’d like to know how the defense came to hold copies of Mrs. Keene’s bank records.”
“They were provided to the defense,” said Pratt, “by Mr. Skell.”
“And how did Mr. Skell come to hold them?”
“I’m instructed that it is not my place to say.”
“I’m instructed that it is mine.” Tolliver took off the half-moons and rubbed her eyes. “Mr. Pratt, the district informs the chair that the photostats carry the footer of a copy machine in the Arena’s front office, stamped Friday, eleven-twelve p.m. This is the night Mrs. Keene’s board sat at her home and accepted her step-down. Mrs. Keene, were you at the Arena that night?”
“I was at home, madam. With a very bad sherry.”
“Was anyone from the Arena in the office after eleven?”
“Not to my knowledge. It was locked.”
“So it was entered,” said Tolliver, “by someone who had a key.”
She put the glasses back on. Pratt, for the first time that day, said nothing at all. In the pause, I looked at Ames at the district’s table, who gave me, with great discretion, a slow half-shake of the head, which meant: not yet, not here, don’t stand up.
Behind us, in the fourth row, Hale sat with his big scrubbed hands on his knees. He had come at ten and been shown a seat. He did not look at the witness or at anyone. He was looking, with an expression of enormous mild attention, at the floor, and his lips moved. I thought for a long moment that he was praying. Then I saw that he was counting. He was counting the checks.
Yvette stepped down at three-ten. She walked back, with her cane, with no help, and she did not look at her daughter, and she did not need to. When she reached the row she stopped. Maris stood, and for a second I thought that she would say something. She said nothing. She took her mother’s arm, and sat her down, and kept her hand there, on a black wool sleeve, until the clerk called the next name.
It was not the next name I had expected.
“The defense,” said the clerk, “calls Ms. Cleo Dace.”

