Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 51

Exhibit Nine

The chair was twelve feet from the aisle. I have been told it was fourteen steps. I remember only that I took them with my good hand curled against my ribs, the way I had learned to carry it, and that my boots seemed to belong to a stranger who walked very well.

The clerk held up the Bible. I put my hand on it. It was warm from someone else’s palm.

“Cleo Dace,” I said. “Stunt performer, formerly. Ground planner, now, under supervision. I’m not certified. I’d like that said before anyone else says it.”

“Noted,” said Tolliver, and the half-moon glasses flashed once. “The defense called you, Ms. Dace. Mr. Pratt?”

Pratt rose with the leather folder. He had changed, I saw, in the last hour, and it took me a moment to find out how. He had stopped smiling. He had put the smile away, the way a surgeon puts away a joke, and what was left was quicker and more serious than I liked.

“Ms. Dace, you’ve heard your sister’s testimony. You’ve heard your own statement read aloud. Before I ask you to identify another document, I’d like you to confirm one thing. When you wrote that statement for the district, did you intend it to be true?”

“Yes.”

“Did you believe it was complete?”

“No. I knew when I wrote it that it left out things I couldn’t say yet.” I kept my eyes on him. “I said so in the first paragraph.”

“You did. A candid statement, I’m sure.” He opened the folder. “The panel has before it, as Exhibit Nine, a sworn statement dated October ninth, six years ago, in your name. May I hand you the original?”

An usher, a young woman in a navy blazer, carried the plastic sleeve across and laid it in front of me. It was the same sheet. It looked smaller than it had in 2B.

“Is that your signature?”

“Yes.”

“Is that your statement?”

“It has my signature.”

“Is it your statement, Ms. Dace?”

“I signed it,” I said. “I didn’t write it. I’ve been trying to remember writing it since nine o’clock this morning, and I can’t, because I didn’t. I remember signing it.”

A small hush moved over the room, and I felt it settle on my shoulders like a wet coat.

---

I will tell it as I told it to them, because I had decided in the stairwell that I would tell it once and not reshape it.

It was the sixth day after the accident. Jessa had been out of the third surgery for thirty hours.

I was in the family waiting room on the fourth floor of St. Brigid’s Hospital, in a plastic chair beside a vending machine, and I had not slept, and I had not eaten, and I had a cut on my left forearm from the rope that I had not mentioned to anyone. The room smelled of bleach and burnt coffee and the very thin, flat smell of a fear that has been going on too long.

A man had come. A kind man. I remembered that: his kindness was the one fact I had of him, like the single plain tile that survives in a ruined floor. He said he was from the Arena’s insurance office. He said there were some forms to acknowledge before the claim could go through, for Jessa’s coverage, and that it was dreadful to do it at a time like this, and it would take a minute. He had a clipboard. He put a pen in my hand.

“Did you read what you signed?” said Pratt.

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because I was twenty-two and exhausted and he said it was for my sister’s coverage.” I drew a breath. “Because the man was kind. Because I’d have signed a death warrant if it meant a bed for Jessa. There was a notary stamp at the bottom, and I thought, well, he’s official. I put my name where he pointed. He said thank you. He shook my hand.”

“Did he give his name?”

“I don’t remember.”

“Do you remember what he looked like?”

“A man in a good coat.” I stopped. A thing was moving at the very bottom of memory, like a fish under ice. “He had a tray of tea. He brought me a cup. He put it down beside the vending machine, and I didn’t drink it, and I remember the steam coming off it and the smell.” I closed my eyes. “Cedar polish. Not tea. Something warm and clean and woody, like a good chest of drawers.”

The room had gone silent.

I opened my eyes. I did not look at Pratt. I looked at Ames, and Ames, at the district’s table, had put down the pen.

I had been at Jessa’s lane in the dark, four nights before, with a car parked in the shadow and a window down an inch, and I had smelled a man I could not see, and I had written it on my wrist in my head and gone to bed.

On Saturday, in a corridor, I had stood three feet from Devon Skell and smelled nothing at all, the bland clean nothing of a man who has bathed in unscented soap and put on a washed coat. I thought now that nothing was a thing a person did on purpose. It was a decision about what to be near.

“Ms. Dace?” said Tolliver, quite gently.

“I’m sorry, Madam Chair. I’d like to say that I recognize the smell. I can’t say whose. I’m saying it because I’d rather say a small true thing than have anyone think I’m hiding one.”

“The panel appreciates it,” said Tolliver, and wrote something, and said no more.

---

Pratt took a little while to recover his line. He did, because he was good.

“Ms. Dace. You’ve said it to this panel: you signed a sworn statement without reading it. You’ve told them the statement was true, ‘in a way.’ You have told them you are in the habit of concealing things when you believe it is for someone’s good.” He walked a pace. “I’d like the panel to consider how much weight it can place on a witness who has twice, now, put her name to documents whose full meaning she did not state.”

“Is that a question?” said Tolliver.

“It will be, madam.” Pratt turned. “Ms. Dace. Do you consider yourself a reliable witness?”

I had thought a great deal about that question over the past month, in the truck, in Jessa’s spare room, on a bench outside a courthouse. I had had answers. All of them sounded like what a reliable witness would say.

“No,” I said.

Pratt blinked.

“I think I’m a witness who’s trying to be reliable,” I said. “There’s a difference. I’ve signed things I shouldn’t. I cut a line I didn’t ask permission for. I kept it quiet for six years. All of that is on the record because I put it there.

I’ve put every one of those things in front of this panel before anyone asked, and I’ll tell you why, Mr. Pratt, because I think it matters.” My voice was steady. I had not expected that. “A person who tells you the bad parts first gives you the means to check the rest.”

“That sounds rehearsed.”

“It’s not. I’ve never said it before.” I moved my good hand on the table, not far. “It sounds like a speech because I’ve been thinking about it for six years and it came out whole. I’d have preferred a worse speech.”

Somebody behind me coughed. Tolliver’s pencil moved.

“I’ll ask one more,” said Pratt, a little shortly. “You swore, at twenty-two, that no inspection note had been reported to you. The district’s filings say that a tag existed, dated September twelfth, and a carbon in Mr. Rowe’s drawer. If you did not lie, then the note existed and you never knew of it, and your sister never knew of it, and the statement is true. Then why does the district imply it’s forged?”

“I’m not the district,” I said. “I’m only saying what I saw. The statement isn’t false. It’s carefully, exactly true. That’s what’s wrong with it.”

“Madam Chair, I’d ask the witness to be responsive.”

“She is,” said Tolliver. “Quite painfully so. Go on, Ms. Dace.”

“A statement can be true and still be a tool.” I looked at the sleeve. “Whoever put that in front of me knew I’d sign it, because it asked me for nothing but the truth. It didn’t ask me to lie. It asked me to confirm that I’d never been told. And then it sat in a box for six years waiting for a day when somebody needed me to have said so.”

“Who is ‘somebody’?” said Pratt.

“I don’t know,” I said. “I’m told it’s a good sentence.”

There was a sound in the room then, a low wave of breath, not quite laughter. Ellis, behind me, did not move, but I felt the air go slightly warmer in his direction.

---

Haldane asked the question that mattered. He did it in four sentences and one pause, and I understood, as he went, that he was a man who put everything he knew into an inch of text.

“Ms. Dace. May I see Exhibit Nine?” The usher carried it up. “I wish to look at the paper. Not the ink, the paper.” He held the sleeve up to the window. The flat light caught the pale raised ridge across the top. “Does anyone in this room know what this raised design is?”

“It’s a raised monogram,” said Ames, rising. “A Y and a K, on a sheet of engraved stationery which the Marlowe Engraving Company produced, in a batch of fifty, six years ago, on a plate that was kept by the engraver. Madam Chair, the district would ask the panel to look at the lower right corner.”

The sleeve went to Tolliver. I saw her tilt it. I saw her find it.

“There’s a number,” she said. “In pencil. Twelve.”

“The script that Ms. Marsh was given six years ago, and which she surrendered to the district this morning, carries thirty-seven in the same hand,” said Ames. “A memorandum authorizing the refund to Mr. Voss’s account, which the district recovered from Mr. Hale, bears forty-four. The ink on the three differs. The pencil on the three is, in the opinion of Dr. Thale’s preliminary look last evening, the same pencil.”

“Fifty sheets,” said Tolliver, slowly.

“Fifty. Numbered by someone who kept an inventory.”

I thought of Maris’s mother at her kitchen table with a bank statement circled in green. I thought of a woman who counted everything she’d ever done wrong. I thought: someone else also counted.

“I would add,” said Ames, “that the notarial journal of Mr. Walter Ferris, entered into evidence last week, has no entry at all at three-forty p.m. on October ninth. It has an entry at two-fifteen, for the pink carbon. It has nothing for a hospital. Mr. Ferris, I am told, kept a journal for decades and, I am told, never missed an entry. The seal on Exhibit Nine is his seal. It is not, so far as the district can tell, his entry.”

“Which means?” said Tolliver.

“That someone used his stamp,” said Ames, “while he was elsewhere.”

A very long stillness. Pratt had half risen, and I watched him think about objecting, and decide, at the last, that he could not make an argument for the document he had put into evidence without proving that the person who had made it had stolen a stamp.

“I withdraw nothing, Madam Chair,” he said. “The exhibit speaks.”

“It does,” said Tolliver. “It says rather more than you intended.” She turned a page. “Mr. Pratt, the defense has in its possession, I understand, the contents of a number of cartons purchased at an estate auction, referred to in the district’s filings as the Misc. boxes. Box Three is the source of this exhibit.”

“Yes, madam.”

“How many cartons are there?”

“Eleven were purchased on the day of sale,” said Pratt, with great care. “Of which one, Box Three, was reviewed by Mr. Skell and found relevant.”

“And the other ten?”

“Are in Mr. Skell’s possession. He has indicated that he regards them as private property.”

“Does he.” Tolliver’s voice was very mild. “The panel has subpoena authority in this proceeding, Mr. Pratt, and has just found that a notarized exhibit offered by the defense carries a seal with no corresponding entry. The panel orders the production of all ten remaining cartons, intact, with their sale receipts, to the district’s custody by nine o’clock tomorrow morning. If Mr. Skell is not present to comply, the panel will ask the sheriff why.”

“Madam Chair, I’m not sure—”

“I’m quite sure,” said Tolliver. “Thank you, Ms. Dace. You may step down.”

I stood. My legs seemed to arrive some seconds after I did. I took the fourteen steps back, and the first thing that I felt was Jessa’s good hand closing around my wrist as I sat, brief and hard, and then letting go. She said nothing. She turned her face to the front, where Tolliver was lifting a heavy paper.

Tolliver called five minutes. They were not enough for anything, and everyone used them.

I went to the end of the row and stood by the long window, which looked out on the car park and a stripe of wet gray sky. Nita came up beside me with a paper cup and did not say anything for a moment. That was one of the useful things about Nita. A silence from Nita was a place to put your feet.

“Cedar polish,” said Nita at last. “You’ll want to say it to Ames in a sentence that can go in a file.”

“Cedar polish, warm, clean, in the waiting room at St. Brigid’s, six years ago. The same smell at Jessa’s lane last Thursday. I’d swear to the smell. I couldn’t swear to the man.”

“That’s the right shape of oath.” Nita turned the cup. “Mr. Skell wears none. I’ve sat across from him twice. He’d have been a man in his forties then, with a good coat and a kind voice and a tray of tea. A good man to hand you a pen.”

“He’s been scentless in every room I’ve met him in.”

“Yes. I wondered when you’d notice that.” Nita looked out at the car park. “Where do you think he is now?”

I opened my mouth to say that he was not in the room. Then I stopped, because I had not checked. I had been looking at the bench and the witness table for six hours, and the people who count are not the ones at the table. I turned, slowly, and ran my eyes down the back of the room, past the press rows, past Pell and Anselm in their matching scarves, past Dolores with her empty leash.

There was a pillar near the back wall, a square white pillar that held up something in the ceiling. Behind it, on the aisle seat of the last row, with one long leg crossed over the other and a newspaper unopened on his knee, sat a man of about fifty in an oatmeal cashmere coat.

His left hand lay on the newspaper. He was looking at nothing in particular. He had been there, I realized, since before nine. He had come in with the stairwell empty behind him and the room had absorbed him as a lake absorbs a stone.

He looked up. His eyes were mild and rather tired. He gave me, across fifty feet of beige carpet and two hundred people, a very small, very courteous nod, the nod of a man who has been told he’s late.

“Don’t,” said Nita, very low. “Not here. Ames has seen him. So has the deputy. He is entitled to sit in a public hearing about his own case.”

“He’s twenty yards away.”

“He’s thirty. And the point of a man like that is that he’s allowed to sit there. Cleo.” Nita turned and for the first time put a hand on my sleeve. “The thing about a man like that is that he’d love you to cross the room.”

I did not cross the room. I stood at the window with my good hand pressed against the cold glass, and counted slowly to sixty, and breathed, and tasted peppermint.

---

“The defense,” said Pratt, in a flat tight voice, “calls Ms. Leona Marsh.”

He had to say it. It was his turn and his list, and I understood that he would rather have put his own hand in a fire, because he knew less than we did about what she would say. Quill rose at the back like a coat hanger. “Madam Chair,” he said, “on advice of counsel, my client declines to—”

“Mr. Quill.”

It was not loud. It was the most beautiful voice in the room.

Leona Marsh stood in the third row in her plum suit with her handbag over her arm. She had a peppermint in one cheek and her glasses pushed up into her gray hair. She looked at her counsel with an expression of great and almost motherly tenderness.

“I dismissed you at the lunch recess, Raymond,” said Leona. “By text. You were in the lavatory. I do apologize. I’d like to be sworn, please, and I’d like to go first on whatever list there is.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!