Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 36

The Girl on the Sunday

Theo drove, because he refused to be driven.

“I’m half kept,” he said at six-forty on Sunday morning, standing in my mother’s driveway with the truck keys in his blue-white hand. “I’m not half dead. There’s a difference. Ask the lady with the pen.”

“I’d rather not.”

“Then ask me nicely.” He opened the passenger door for Priya, who climbed into the middle of the bench seat with a thermos, a legal pad, and a cardboard box labeled HARROW in marker. I got in after her and shut the door. The cab smelled like wet dog, pine cleaner, and coffee. Moose had been left behind with Danny, which Moose had taken as a personal betrayal.

We went south on County 11 in the blue half-dark. The snow had stopped overnight, and the plows had thrown up banks as high as the mailboxes. Every field was a sheet of clean paper.

Theo drove with both hands on the wheel, at exactly the speed limit, and I watched his knuckles. In the dash light they looked like candle wax. Twice he flexed his fingers and then looked at them as if they belonged to a coworker.

“Can you feel the wheel?” I said.

“I can feel that it’s there.” He shrugged. “It’s like wearing mittens. Everything’s a guess. I’ll tell you what’s weird, though. I can’t tell hot from cold anymore, but I can tell wet from dry better than I ever could.” He glanced at the rearview mirror. “Which is why I can tell you we’ve had company since the gas station.”

Priya twisted around in her seat. “Where?”

“Four cars back. Gray sedan. No plates I can read.” He kept his eyes on the road. “It has never once come closer, and it has never once fallen behind. The roads are glare ice and it’s doing fifty-five like it’s on a rail.”

I didn’t turn. I knew what I would see. I’d have seen a narrow woman at the wheel with her gloved hands at ten and two, and a small flat scale on the dashboard, swinging gently as if the road were a sea.

“She said she was obliged to follow me,” I said.

“Does she buy her own gas?”

“I’m going to guess that’s a no.”

“Good,” said Theo. “Then she has a limit.”

“Or she doesn’t need one,” said Priya. “That thing runs on someone else’s account.”

“Everything runs on someone else’s account,” said Theo. “That’s the whole racket. I just like to find out whose.”

He said it lightly. But I saw the little muscle jump in his jaw, and I thought of what Voll had told me in the dark of the Lyric, that he heard her at night, and that she tried not to be unkind about it. I’d asked him on Saturday night what he heard. He’d said, “Pencil, mostly,” and changed the subject to pancakes.

Priya was reading from her legal pad, in the flat fast voice she uses when she is frightened and would rather be accurate. “Okay. Facts. Elias Thomas Harmon, born October nineteenth, 1943, Harrow, Minnesota. Resident of Pine Haven Terrace since 2019. No spouse, no children, and the visitor log is blank.

“Seven years, not one name.” She tapped the pad. “Except that he tells the staff, every November, that a girl will come on the Sunday after Thanksgiving. Seven Novembers. They thought it was sweet. They assumed he meant a granddaughter he’d lost track of.”

“And this year, someone finally calls.”

“This year, someone finally calls.” Priya lowered the pad. “I don’t love that I’m the girl. I’d like it noted.”

“You’re not the girl,” said Theo. “She’s the girl.”

“I’d like that noted too.”

Nobody laughed. The wipers ticked. As we came up behind a snowplow blinking amber Theo eased off the gas and the gray sedan, in the mirror, eased off exactly the same distance.

Priya opened the HARROW box on her knees and went through it out loud, because silence in a truck cab is where fear grows. A photocopy of the 1957 condemnation list, sixty family names in two columns. A county plat map with the valley shaded blue. A printout of Lake Harrow’s boat-launch rules, which she had included, she said, “for the vibe.” And at the bottom a manila envelope on which she had written, and then crossed out, the word EVIDENCE.

“What did you cross it out for?” I said.

“Because I don’t know yet what it’s evidence of.” She turned the envelope over in her hands. “I keep thinking, if a whole town was erased on paper, there should be a seam somewhere. A place where the paper was cut and glued. I’ve found two. The school district’s enrollment count drops by exactly nineteen children in the fall of 1957, and nobody ever wrote down why. And the Courier-Standard stops publishing the week before the Skip, with the last issue half printed.”

“Half printed?”

“The back page is blank. White. Like they ran out of the thing they were going to say.”

Theo’s eyes flicked to the mirror and back. “Maybe they ran out of the people who’d have read it.”

Nobody had anything to add to that, and we drove on with the heater ticking and the snowplow’s amber light turning slowly on all our faces.

---

Brainerd was a pine-and-pavement town, awake and shivering. We found Pine Haven Terrace on a street of low brick buildings behind a Walgreens, a long beige wing with a portico, a flagpole, and a ring of fake poinsettias around the sign. It looked like every place I’d ever visited someone’s grandmother.

The front doors were the kind that open by themselves. Inside, a hallway smelled of lemon floor wax and oatmeal. A clipboard hung on a nail beside the sign-in desk, with a pen on a string, and while Priya charmed the nurse I turned back the pages of the visitor log. Priya had been right. Seven years, and the lines for Room 114 were empty.

Almost empty. On the Sunday after Thanksgiving of every year, in a different hand each time, someone had ruled a neat line, written the date, and left the rest of the row blank. A receptionist’s habit, I told myself. Somebody expecting a visitor who never came, and holding the place.

The ink on the newest line was still wet. A paper turkey was still taped to the window of the nurses’ station, though it was the twenty-ninth of November and somebody had begun draping tinsel over its feathers.

“Hi, we’re here to see Mr. Harmon,” said Priya, smiling the smile that has gotten her through three campus police stops and one federal building. “I’m the researcher who called. This is Ms. Kerrigan.”

The nurse looked up. She was a small, broad woman in dinosaur scrubs, with reading glasses on a beaded chain, and her name tag read DENISE. She looked at Priya, then at me, and I watched her face do something I’d learned to recognize in Merrow, a quick flinch of recognition and then a smoothing-over.

“You’re the girl,” said Denise.

“I’m Sadie.”

“Yes. You would be.” She came out from behind the desk. “He’s been up since four. He had me put his good cardigan out. Do you know, in the six years I’ve worked here, I have never once seen that man ask for a shave?” She started down the hall, and we followed. “Now. He’s a talker, once he gets going. Fair warning. He’s very sharp, and he’s very particular, and he doesn’t like to be handled. He’ll say things that sound a little odd. We don’t argue.”

“What kind of things?” said Theo.

“Oh, you know.” Denise waved a hand. “Names. People we’ve never heard of. Places that aren’t on the map. He tells the aides about a schoolhouse, with a bell, and a stove you have to feed with sticks.” She stopped outside the last door on the left. “We figure it’s the memory. He’s eighty-three. Sometimes he’s very far back.”

“And sometimes?” I said.

She looked at me.

“Sometimes,” said Denise, quietly, “he’s the only one in this building who’s right.”

She knocked twice, and opened the door.

---

Room 114 faced the parking lot. There was a narrow bed, a bedside table, a recliner with an afghan, and a window with a view of the Walgreens sign. The only decoration was a single framed photograph on the dresser, black-and-white, of a one-room schoolhouse with a bell tower, the children lined up on the steps in their Sunday collars.

The man in the recliner did not look up.

He was small, bent, and very clean. White hair brushed flat. A navy cardigan with leather buttons, buttoned wrong by one, and a plaid blanket over his knees. His hands lay on the armrests, big-knuckled and spotted, with the thumbnails ridged like old shells. In his lap, closed, lay a black composition notebook, the kind a schoolchild would carry.

He was looking out the window, at the lot. At the gray sedan that had just pulled into the visitors’ space and sat there with its engine off.

“Hm,” said Elias Harmon. “So she came. Seventy years, and she’s finally learned to drive.”

His voice was a dry, precise tenor, with the faint flat vowels of the river valleys. He turned the recliner a quarter turn with a push of one slipper, and I saw his eyes. They were a light, watery blue, very bright, and they went directly to me, and stayed there.

“Hello, Sadie Kerrigan,” he said. “You’ve got the chin of a woman who once tried to argue with a river.”

I had no answer to that.

“Never mind how I know. At my age you pick up a good many chins.” He smiled, and it was a very small smile. “Sit down. All of you. Mr. Lindgren, take the bed, you look like a man whose knees are a project. Miss Priya, there’s a stool.” He turned his head, like a bird, to Priya. “You made a very good chart.”

Priya went still.

“I haven’t shown anyone the chart,” she said.

“No. I know.” He let that stand. “But you made one. I could tell by how you hold your pen.”

Denise cleared her throat from the doorway. “I’ll be at the desk,” she said, and she left, and she shut the door, and the click of the latch was very loud.

Theo sat on the bed. Priya sat on the stool and set the HARROW box between her feet. I stayed standing, because I didn’t trust my knees either.

“I’m told you are the person who has been counting,” said Elias.

“I’m the person who offered the lake a present.”

“Yes. That’s what I meant.” He folded his hands over the notebook. “I’ve waited seventy years for somebody to say that sentence out loud. Do you know what it’s like, to have been telling people for seventy years that the arithmetic is wrong, and to be told that it’s a very nice story, and shall we talk about your lunch?”

“I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be. I wasn’t asking for sympathy. I was making a point about timing.” He turned his hand over, palm up, in a gesture that was almost courtly. “Would you like to know what I am? It’s a short answer. I’m the one they couldn’t close.”

---

He told it plain, as if reading a bill of lading.

“I was born on the Skip. October nineteenth, 1943, in Harrow, on a Tuesday. My mother used to say that the day wasn’t on the calendar for the rest of the world, but the doctor was a practical man and wrote it down anyway.” He lifted one shoulder.

“In Harrow, you understand, we kept the Skip properly. A hundred years and more. The whole town forgot a day and a person, once a year, and the lamps stayed lit along Mill Road, and the river stayed in its bed. We had no idea. We thought every town had a day like that.”

“What did you lose?” said Priya, very gently.

“Someone every year.” His eyes went to the window. “The first one I remember was the Dubois boy, when I was five. They told me I’d never had a friend named Armand. I believed them. It was only years later that I noticed there was a gap in the school photograph, right here.” He touched the glass over the picture on the dresser, as if the gap were physically there. “Everybody else had a sort of space around them. Like a tooth gone.”

I felt Theo shift on the bed. He was staring at the photograph.

“When I was twelve,” said Elias, “I woke up on the twentieth of October and I remembered the nineteenth. All of it. I don’t know why. A flaw in me, a gap in the paper where the ink didn’t take. I remembered who had been taken, and I remembered the whole town sitting down to supper without her, and I remembered that I’d known her name, and I’d said it, and then I’d stopped.”

“Who was she?”

“Margaret Ann Ostby. She sold peppermints.” He said it as if reading a headstone. “I told my mother. She slapped me, quite hard. She said the Ostby girl had moved to Duluth. And I remember, even then, thinking that it was the first time my mother had ever lied to me. And that it didn’t sound like lying. It sounded like she believed it.”

“You wrote it down,” I said. “The notebook.”

“I started that day.” He lifted the composition book. “Thirteen pages by the time I was fourteen. Names, dates, what I could recall of the faces. I was a disagreeable child. I didn’t let it alone.” He stopped. “It was the schoolteacher who found out.”

“What did she do?”

“She read it,” said Elias. “She read every word, with her glasses on the end of her nose. Then she closed it and put it on her desk and said, ‘Elias, this is very good work. You have a gift for accuracy.’ And then she said the strangest thing. She said, ‘You must never let anyone take this from you. Not the church, not the town, not me. Do you understand? Not me.’”

The room was very quiet. Out in the lot the gray sedan sat with its windows dark, and I knew without looking that no one was inside it.

“She was frightened,” said Elias. “I didn’t understand why until much later. She was a good deal more frightened than I was.”

“Who was she?” said Priya.

He turned his light eyes to me, and for the first time there was something in them that was not patience.

“Do you know,” said Elias Harmon, “it’s remarkable how little I’ve been asked? In all these years nobody has said, ‘And what was the teacher’s name?’”

“What was the teacher’s name?” I said.

He looked down at the notebook. He opened it. The pages were soft as cloth, the writing in a boy’s round pencil that had slowly turned into a man’s sharp ink. He turned to a page near the back and put his thumb on a line, and then he held it up where all of us could see.

Miss M. Voll, schoolteacher. Gone the night of Oct. 19, 1957. NOT forgotten by me. Do NOT let them close her.

“She taught every grade in Harrow, in one room, from the primer to the fourteen-year-olds,” said Elias. “She taught me to read, and she taught me to count. And I’ve been looking for her for sixty-nine years.”

I looked at the lot. At the gray sedan. At the narrow shadow that had folded itself, somehow, into the passenger seat of a car that no one had driven.

“She isn’t a ghost,” I said. “She’s an examiner. She told me last night she lost you in 1957. She didn’t know where you were.”

“Then she’s been looking in all the wrong ledgers.” He closed the notebook with a soft clap. “Or she’s been very close for a very long time and been unable to say so. Which is what I’d like to know. Why now? Wouldn’t you?”

Behind me, in the corridor, someone began to walk toward Room 114. The footsteps were small, regular, and very precise, and they made no sound on the linoleum at all. I only knew they were there because the air in the room began, quietly and politely, to smell like lavender and cold water.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!