Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 74

The Ditch Behind the Church

The Reverend Carol Dunmore telephones the courthouse on Saturday at ten past nine and asks to be served.

Ms. Szabo takes the call, because Ms. Szabo takes all of them now, at the information desk, with the headset she bought herself. She says afterward that she has handled a great many requests in her career and that this was the first in which the other party had requested the paperwork.

“She said, *There is a notice on our corkboard about parcel eleven, and nobody has handed it to me, and I should like it handed to me. I should like it on the record that we were asked.*” Ms. Szabo adjusts her glasses. “I told her that a notice posted was a notice served. She said, *Yes, I know. That is the problem.*”

So I take it up myself, on Saturday, in the afternoon, in the van, with Wren and a folded copy of Schedule A, and I hand it to her in the vestibule of the Ketterly Free Gospel Church, under a framed picture of a lamb.

---

It is a white clapboard building with a short square steeple and a gravel lot, and a sign by the road with movable black letters. The sign says, in the usual way, SERVICE 10:30, and under it, because somebody has had to put something, ALL WELCOME. Somebody has moved the E in WELCOME a quarter inch out of line. It looks, I think, as if it has been fidgeting.

The Reverend is in her fifties, a broad, tired, direct woman in a gray cardigan and sensible shoes, with reading glasses on a chain. She does not take the notice at once. She puts both hands behind her back, as a child does who has been told not to touch, and reads it where it lies on my palm.

“*Parcel eleven,*” she says. “*A drainage way, unrecorded, lying behind the Free Gospel Church, from the north line of the cemetery to the Mill Road culvert.*” She looks up. “It is behind the fellowship hall. We have been mowing it for a hundred and thirty years. The trustees thought it was ours.”

“It isn’t.”

“I gathered that.” She takes the paper, finally, and folds it in four. “Miss Tolliver. I’ve been in this church eleven years. I was told on my first Sunday, by a very kind woman with a casserole, that there are two things we don’t do in the hall. We don’t prop the back door. And we don’t talk about the flood.”

---

She tells me the rest in the church office, over a cup of tea she has not asked whether I want.

It is a small, hot room, lined with filing cabinets, with a typewriter on a metal table and a crocheted afghan thrown over the back of a chair. She keeps the old minute books in the bottom drawer of the left-hand cabinet, in the order of their years, with a bundle of Sunday-school stubs tied up with string.

She takes one out. It is a ledger, bound in green cloth, with a label on the spine in a deacon’s hand. *1949-1955.* She has marked a page with a paper clip.

“It’s four lines,” she says. “I found it in my second winter. I don’t know why I looked. I think I’d come across the word *pump house* somewhere else, and I got curious.” She sets the book on the blotter and turns it toward me. “I put the clip on it, and I put the book back, and I didn’t say anything to anybody for nine years. I told myself I was waiting for the right time.”

I read it. It is four lines.

*Nov. 11, 1951. Following the high water. Voted, 7 to 5, that the family at the hall door, the Garrity family, of Spruce Hollow, be advised, owing to the illness of the boy and the risk to the children, to shelter at the pump house until the doctor can be got. Moved: Bro. Wm. Pettit. Carried.*

---

“The boy was six,” says the Reverend.

“His name was Samuel. I know because the old man who was the church’s sexton in the sixties told my predecessor, and my predecessor wrote it in the margin of the pew roll, in pencil, and nobody ever read it. The family had come up out of the hollow the night the creek went over. They had a wagon. They had a child on a quilt with a fever. They came to the hall door, because the hall was on the hill and had a stove, and it was Sunday, and the church was lit.”

“And the deacons voted,” says Wren, from the doorway. She has been very quiet.

“They thought it was polio, dear. It was that year. It was in the papers every week, and people kept their children at home, and the doctor from Mercer wasn’t due till the morning.” Dunmore takes off her glasses and rubs her eyes. “It wasn’t. It was pneumonia, and he was dead of it by the third night. In the pump house. Which is, I suppose, what you would have called a lean-to. It had a dirt floor, and the pump.”

I do not say anything. There is nothing in the Manual for it.

“The family left on the Wednesday,” she says. “They never came back. And the church has sung over that ditch for seventy-five years, every Sunday, and has not said it once.” She puts her glasses on. “I should like to say it. I should like very much to say it before I’m moved on to Erie. I’d like it said on the ground it happened on, to the person it was owed to, with a Board of View standing there to witness. If she comes.”

---

She has come.

It is the first thing I see on Sunday morning, from the gravel lot, as the sedan and the van and a gray hatchback I do not at first recognize pull in together behind the hall. There is a woman at the ditch. She sits in a folding chair of the kind they have at funeral homes, with a wool blanket over her knees, forty feet from the church’s back door, on the bank, with her back to the building.

Nair has found her, by letter, at an address in Erie. It took the Board three weeks. She is Wilhelmina Garrity Doyle, called Billie, eighty-four years old, a tall thin woman in a good blue wool coat and a hat with a pin, with a cane across her lap and a daughter, in a parka, standing at her shoulder.

She was nine. She has a long straight nose, a hard, mild, level mouth, and her eyes are on the ditch, which is a cinder-lined trench six feet across with an inch of brown water in the bottom and a fringe of last year’s reeds.

“I don’t go in,” she says, when I come up the bank. She does not look round. “I want that understood before anybody makes a speech. I’m not going in that building.”

“No, ma’am.”

“I came to look at the water.” She breathes. “I’ve been looking at it for seventy-five years, from a distance. I thought I’d like to do it from here.”

---

The foal is already there.

I did not see it come. It is standing in the ditch, ankle-deep in the brown water, a small roan creature with a white blaze and a thin white sock on the left hind leg, entirely alone, with its head up and its ears forward, looking toward the back door of the hall. It has walked, by itself, a mile and a half from a lean-to on Water Street, which is against borough code.

“That’s not allowed,” says Wren, with deep feeling.

“Assistance Animal, Other,” says Tully, from behind me, with a kind of tired pride. He has the pillowcase against his chest. “Section six, one-fourteen. I’m certain I wrote an exemption.”

Billie Garrity Doyle looks at the foal for a long time, with her mouth gone small.

“I had a pony,” she says, “when I was little. In the hollow. He drowned the night of the water.” She says it flatly, as one reads a line from a register. “Nobody could ever tell me that was a thing it was fair to be sorry about, after the rest.”

“It’s allowed,” I say.

“Is it?” says Billie. She nods at the foal, once, as one nods at a neighbor over a fence. “Well. Good.”

---

The service is held in the fellowship hall, with the back door propped.

It is the room, I understand, in which they did not want it held. It is long and low and linoleum-floored, with a serving hatch, and a banner on the wall that says ALL THINGS ARE POSSIBLE, and sixty folding chairs set in rows, facing the open door.

The congregation sits in its good clothes. It has turned its chairs, and I think it has done so on its own authority: it faces not the pulpit, which is a lectern borrowed from the sanctuary, but the doorway, and the bank, and a woman in a blue coat with her back to it.

There is an old man in the front row, in a wheelchair, with a blanket and a hat. He is very thin and very upright. Beside him a younger man, a grandson by the look of the jaw, holds his shoulder.

“Mr. Berg,” says the Reverend, to me, in the vestibule, in a voice no louder than a pin. “Hollis Berg. He’s ninety-one. He was sixteen. He was the usher on the back door that night. I asked him on Wednesday whether he would sit in the front. He said he’d been sitting in the back for seventy-five years and would be glad of the change.”

I put my hand on the rule. Tully has it on its dish towel on a card table by the serving hatch, beside the Board’s folding desk, and Szabo has the machine. Strake is in the back row of the folding chairs, in the charcoal coat, with a hymnal in his lap. He has not been in a church, he told me in the van, since a funeral in 1988. “I’ll bill for the attendance,” he said, “at nothing. I’d rather it were not on the sheet.”

---

The Reverend does not preach.

She walks to the lectern, which is a plain oak thing, and takes off the glasses and lays them on it, and takes from the pocket of her cardigan a folded page. She does not unfold it. She stands in the open door, with the bank and the ditch and a woman in a folding chair at the end of her sight, with her broad worn hands at her sides, and she speaks across forty feet of March grass in a plain flat clear voice.

“Mrs. Doyle. Wilhelmina. In November of 1951, your family came to this door in the rain with a sick child, and this congregation, by a vote of seven to five, told you to go and wait in the pump house.”

It rings. I do not have to ask. It goes out over the hall and the grass like a struck wire.

“We did not know what was wrong with your brother. We were afraid. We called our fear prudence, and we wrote it down in four lines in a green book, and put the book in a drawer. Samuel Garrity died on the third night in the pump house, of a sickness that was not the one we feared. We never said so. For seventy-five years this church has sung above that ditch, and nobody here has said your brother’s name.”

She draws a breath. “We turned you away. It was wrong. I say it, on behalf of the people who were here and the people who are here, because someone has to say it who can.”

---

It rings again. It rings, I think, as it rang for Hal at the fence, a soft and almost painful sound, and when it ends, I hear in the hall behind me the sound of sixty people trying not to be heard breathing.

Then the old man in the wheelchair says, in a high dry voice, “I held the door.”

He has not been asked. The grandson’s hand tightens on his shoulder, and he shakes it off, with a flick, and wheels himself forward by the rims, a foot, two feet, into the aisle between the chairs, until he is at the door.

“I was the usher,” says Hollis Berg. “Mr. Pettit sent me to tell them. I said, *Mrs. Garrity, the deacons say you’ll have to wait in the pump house,* and she said, *With the baby?* and I said it wasn’t the baby, it was the fever. I held the door while they went. I was sixteen. I told myself I’d only said what I was told.”

He is looking down the bank at the back of a blue wool coat. “I’ve said it every night since. I never got to the part where I said it to you.”

“*Hollis Berg held the door,*” I say, to the rule, and it rings. I had not known that I would speak. It does not need me.

---

“We ask you to come in,” says the Reverend.

She has said it, and I see her face change, because she has heard that she has said it wrong. She goes on, quickly, with her hands out.

“We don’t ask to be forgiven. We haven’t the right to ask that. It isn’t ours to ask, and it isn’t yours to give, unless you want to, and you needn’t. We ask you to come into this hall. There’s a stove. There’s a table laid. It’s laid for ninety-one, and there’s a place at it with your name on a card.” She swallows. “We ask you to come in and sit down and be fed. That is all. It’s what we should have done.”

The hall is entirely silent. Nobody coughs. The foal in the ditch moves one ear.

Billie Garrity Doyle does not turn round.

“No,” she says.

It carries. It is not rude. It is the plain, calm, absolute voice of a woman who has had seventy-five years to think about a question and has got the answer right.

“Not today. I’m not coming in that building.” She lifts her chin. “You asked. That’s what I came for. I wanted to be asked, out loud, in front of everybody, by somebody who meant it, and you did. You can take that as paid. You can’t take it as more.” Her hand moves on the cane. “And I want you to say his name. Not in a prayer. Just say it. Say it loud.”

---

“*Samuel,*” says the Reverend.

She says it alone, once. And then, from the back of the hall, a woman’s voice says it, and a man’s, and a girl’s. It runs from row to row, through the folding chairs, not in unison, but as a thing is passed along a line of people who have been given something heavy: *Samuel. Samuel Garrity. Sammy.* Sixty people. Hollis Berg says it last, hoarsely, with his hat in his lap.

On the bank, the earth moves.

It is a small movement. The wall of the ditch, a yard below Billie’s chair, on the side toward the church, settles, as a loaf settles, and a piece of the cinder bank the size of a doormat slides inward and down into the brown water, and lies open. In the dark wet seam, a foot below the surface, something square and black stands up out of the clay, like a stone at the end of a plowed field.

“Miss Tolliver,” says Nair, very quietly. She has come up behind me, in the parka, with the tape on her belt.

“I see it.”

It is a book. It is small and black, in a cloth cover, and it is dry. It has lain seventy-five years in the bank of a ditch, in clay, in water, and it is as dry as a biscuit. I see Billie Garrity Doyle lean down out of her folding chair, with her daughter’s hand under her elbow, and take it up out of the ground in both her gloved hands.

---

It is a hymnal. It has a name on the flyleaf in brown ink, which she reads without opening it, from memory, in a voice I can barely hear. *Nell Garrity. Her book.*

“I dropped it,” she says. “I was fetching water. I was nine. I put it down on the bank so I’d have both hands for the bucket, and when I came back it was gone, and nobody believed me, and Mama cried, because it was the one thing she’d brought out of the hollow.” She turns a page with a gloved finger. It is stiff, and turns. “I thought the water took it.”

“It did,” says Tully, so low that I hardly hear. “Legally speaking. It held it.”

She finds the page without looking for it. It has a ribbon. I cannot see the title. She holds it in her two hands in the cold sun, and I see her lips shape the first line before a sound comes out, and then there is a sound: an old woman’s voice, dry, high, perfectly true, singing alone across forty feet of grass the first line of something I do not know.

And behind me, one by one, from the folding chairs, from the door, from the back row where a man in a charcoal coat has risen without noticing that he has, sixty people join in the second line.

---

The horse lies down.

I see it from the corner of my eye, in the middle of the third line. It is the first time. I have seen it stand and walk, and watch, and sleep on its feet in a lean-to, and in a month it has not once lain down. It folds its forelegs and then its hind, with a long slow settling like a very old man sitting on a porch, and lies in the brown water of the ditch, on its side, with its chin on the cinders.

And the water moves.

It is not a flood. It is no more than an inch deep, and brown, and it has been standing since the thaw. It stirs, along the length of the foal’s body, as a pond stirs when a man steps in it, and then it begins to run. It runs the wrong way.

It runs up the ditch, against the fall of the ground, past Billie’s chair and the cemetery’s wall and the place where the culvert goes under the Mill Road, uphill, in a smooth shallow glittering sheet, toward the ridge. I can see it going. I can see the reeds lean.

They sing the whole hymn. It has five verses. The water runs through every one of them, and at the last line it stops, all at once, and stands, as water stands in a glass.

---

Ruth brings the plate.

She has been standing at the end of the serving hatch since half past ten, in the funeral hat, with a covered dish. I had not known she would come. She does not say where she heard. She takes a paper plate from the stack, and fills it, in the hush, from the hall’s own warming trays: a slice of ham, a spoon of scalloped potato, a roll. She walks it out the propped door, and down the bank, and holds it out to a woman in a folding chair.

“I’m not asking you in,” says Ruth. “I’m asking if you’ve eaten.”

Billie Garrity Doyle looks at the plate, and at the hat, and at Ruth, for a long moment.

“I haven’t,” she says.

She takes it. She puts the hymnal on her knee, and eats, in the sun, on the bank, with a plastic fork, slowly and with attention, as one eats a thing that has been a long time owed.

And after a while a woman comes out of the hall with a second plate, and sits on the grass, and another, and the Reverend, in her cardigan, with her glasses crooked, carries out a folding chair. Nobody goes in. They eat in the yard, on the ground that never was theirs, with the ditch at their feet.

---

Nair measures it afterward, kneeling in the cinders with her tape.

She does it as she does everything, in two goes, and writes it in the Manual’s margin, and sits back on her heels with the pencil in her mouth. The water has not moved since the last line. The foal has risen, and shaken itself like a dog, and gone to stand at Wren’s shoulder, with its dry hooves steaming.

“The Board,” she says, “should like to say something.”

“Auditor?”

“I laid the parcels on a map on Friday night. I do not know why. It is the sort of thing one does when one has a bad night and a large desk.” She takes the pencil from her mouth.

“One, two, four, five, six, seven, eight. Nine. The cut at the ford. Now eleven. They do not run in a line along the roads, Ms. Tolliver. I had thought they might. They do not run along the old county lines. They run along a *contour.*”

She looks down the ditch, at the standing glass of the water, at a hill with a church on it. “They follow a bed. A very old one, very shallow, which has not carried water since before the county, and which falls, if one follows it, from the barn-ground, past the ford, through the courthouse, to the creek.”

“A riverbed,” I say.

“I think the Road was not a road.” She stands up. Her knees crack. “I think it was a river, and it was never granted, because who grants a river? The Board does not know what that means. It is an observation. It will be entered as one.”

Behind her, in the ditch, the water stands in its glass. Every reed in it leans a little toward the ridge, the way a congregation leans toward a door.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!