On the Tuesday, Rosalind laid the dining table for a dinner that had been eaten three years and ten months ago, and she did it with a ruler.
We had come home from Kinderhook on the early train, grey and silent, and Matthias had stood in the hall with his hat still on and said that he could not see a face. Rosalind, who had been told the whole of it the night before in a whisper on the stair, took his hand, looked at him with her ink-stained exactness, and said, “Then we shall make you see it, Papa. A face is only the last thing in a room. First there is the room.”
So we made the room.
The dining room at Blackwater Hall is long and cold and panelled in dark oak, with a table for twelve and a sideboard that has watched four generations disagree. Agnes brought the good damask from the press without a word, and the good glass in its green baize, and Birdie came behind with the plate. Agnes had her apron on but she did not wipe her hands on it. I noticed that. It is the sort of thing I have trained myself to notice. It meant she had made up her mind.
“Six covers,” said Rosalind. “Mamma at the foot. Papa at the head. Aunt Judith on his right, because she liked to see the carving. Mr. Crane on his left. Dr. Rainsford next to Mamma, on the window side, because he said the draught was good for the digestion.” She stopped. “Who is on Mamma’s other side?”
“Nobody knows,” said Fitch, from under the table, where he was arranging buttons in the shape of a chair.
“That is the point of the exercise, Fitch.”
“Is it a rule or a suggestion?”
“It is a method.”
The household sat in for the absent. Lieutenant Lyman took Mr. Crane’s chair, and was very pleased, and said “Capital” until Colby told him to stop. Constance took Miss Judith’s, with a pair of spectacles pushed down her nose and a perfect imitation of a woman who has been told that her opinion on ice is not required. Dr. Hollis, who had ridden over to ask after Matthias’s hand, was put in Edmund’s place and looked as though somebody had asked him to wear a dead man’s overcoat. Lavinia took the foot.
I will say a word about that. She did not wait to be asked. She stood a moment behind the chair, with her cropped head bent and her fingers at her lips, and then she sat in it, quite straight, with her hands in her lap. Matthias at the head looked down the white cloth at the woman who had been his third wife, sitting in the chair of his first. “That will do,” he said, rather roughly, and nobody breathed.
“Now,” said Rosalind. “The sixth place.”
It was on Adelaide’s left, between her and Dr. Rainsford’s empty chair, with its back to the fire. Rosalind measured it with the ruler to prove that it was a place and not a space. Agnes put the good glass down at it herself. And Matthias, at the far end, looked at that empty chair for a long time, and I watched his lips move.
“Wintergreen,” he said.
“I beg your pardon?”
“A smell. When the soup came. I thought, the maid has been at the liniment.” He turned his head, slowly, to the left. “He sat there. He had his left side to me. I never saw his right ear, I remember that, he kept the fire behind him.” He lifted his right hand and turned a ring on his own finger, round and round. “He wore a ring and he turned it inward, so the stone was in his palm. I thought, a man who hides his ring. I thought, a bachelor.”
“A bachelor with a ring,” I said. I had my pencil out. I always have. “Three wrong things. Wintergreen in the soup course. A ring turned in. A man who sat with the fire at his back, in March, in a house that was always cold.”
“He asked for the salt,” said Matthias. “Twice.”
“He did,” said Agnes, very low, from the sideboard. Everyone turned. She had gone red to the edge of her cap. “I carried it. The second time, Birdie’s mother took it. She was in the scullery that winter, Dorcas. I was minding the roast.”
“Dorcas Hale,” said Rosalind, and wrote it down, and drew a line under it with the ruler.
“He asked for water,” said Matthias, suddenly. “He poured it himself. A jug with a—” He stopped. His face closed like a hand. “No. It is gone. There was a jug.”
“That will do,” said Lavinia, from the foot of the table, quite gently, and for the first time I saw Matthias take it from someone else with a smile. “It has begun to come. Let it come without pulling.”
It was Fitch who found the button.
He had crawled, as he does, among the legs of the chairs, and he came out between Hollis’s boots with his fist closed and his eyes very round.
“It was in the cushion,” he said. “In the crack. At the back, where the seat goes into the chair. I have looked at all the chairs. I do it every Sunday. This is the only one.” He opened his hand. “Is it a clue?”
It was a button of black horn, domed and plain, about the size of a sixpence, with four small holes and a rim worn pale from the thumb. There was a tailor’s mark stamped faint on the back that I could not read without my glass. I held it to the lamp.
“It could have been there for years,” said Colby, who had come in to watch for the Anatomy Act and stayed for the roast beef that did not appear. “A chair collects things.”
“Not Fitch’s chairs,” said Rosalind. “He inspects them every Sunday. It was not there in September.”
“How do you know?”
“Fitch took every button in September,” said Rosalind. “The tin has a list. Fitch, did you take a black horn one?”
“No,” said Fitch. “I would have said.”
So it had been put there, or dropped there, since September, in a chair that none of us used. I looked at Matthias, and he looked at me. The sixth chair had had a visitor since September.
“Birdie,” I said. “Who has been in this room since the autumn?”
“Nobody, miss, only me and Mrs. Dunning, with the polish.” She was very pale. “And the gentleman with the paper that Mr. Caldwell let in, the week of the inquest, to measure for the stove.”
“What gentleman?” said Matthias.
“The one from the Albany stove firm. Mr. Barnes. He was in here ten minutes. Mrs. Dunning let him in. He had spectacles.” She stopped. “I don’t think he was from any stove firm, Mr. Caldwell. He never took a measure.”
Agnes had gone as white as the cloth. “I let him in,” she said. “I thought you had sent for him.”
“I did not send for anyone,” said Matthias. “I have not ordered a stove since 1882.”
I looked down at the black button in my palm, small and cold. And I had a thought I did not like, because it fitted too well. A man had come into this room in the autumn, in spectacles, for ten minutes, and had wanted nothing he could carry away. He had wanted to see a chair.
“Rosalind,” I said. “May I see the Book of Days?”
She brought it, because it was her pride and Agnes’s, the great grey household ledger in which every dinner at the Hall is written, with the covers and the dishes and who was ill. Agnes opened it for me at March, 1881. The page for the sixth was there, in her round hand: Sunday. Soup, saddle of mutton, tongue, a pudding of apples. Covers six.
I turned the leaf. The seventh of March was gone.
It had been cut out close to the gutter with a very thin blade, so cleanly that the stub was no more than a white ridge. But a razor does not take all of a ledger’s writing. On the stub, in the margin of the preceding page, where the last line of the sixth had run over, there was a little hook of ink.
I held the lamp to it. It said, “S., no pud—”
“Somebody has read this book,” said Rosalind, very quietly, “since September.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!