My work-study card still opened the loading dock door at ten past one in the morning.
I stood on the concrete apron behind Pellworth Library, in the smell of wet cardboard and the hum of the dumpster lid, and I held the plastic rectangle to the reader and waited for the red light. It went green. A bolt thunked back. I had half hoped it would not, because then I would have been a person who tried and was refused, and could go home with a clean conscience.
The Dean had given me paid days, not a termination. Bureaucracy, I thought, is always slower than guilt.
A gray dome camera hung over the dock door. I looked at it for a full minute before I understood that the cable trailing from it ended in a junction box wrapped in electrical tape, and that Mr.
Beauchene had complained about that tape at a staff meeting in September, with a printout, and been told there was nothing in the budget until spring. The camera had been watching the dumpster for months without a single wire to carry what it saw. I thanked the budget and went in.
I should explain how I got there, because I did not do it in a rush. I did it in a very orderly way, like a person getting ready for surgery. After Ilse read the card in the Reading Room, she told me to go home. She said it twice, in a voice I had not heard from her, and she kept the card. I let her.
I think I knew even then that she would put it in a drawer and not in a fire. She walked me to the lobby doors and told me she would speak with someone, that I should not be alarmed, that this was a misunderstanding. Her hand shook on the brass pull. She did not say who she thought had typed it.
I walked back to my dormitory and lay on my bed in my coat. Juno came in at eleven from a rehearsal, smelling of rosin, and sat on the end of my mattress and told me about a cellist who had cried in the middle of a Haydn adagio.
I laughed in the right places. Then she went to sleep, and I lay there for an hour and a half and counted the ceiling tiles, and there were forty-two, and at five to one I got up.
Complete the Keeper’s last entry.
It was not a request. It was not even a threat. It was an instruction, typed on a machine whose e’s stood straight, and I had been given no way to refuse it except to do nothing, and doing nothing felt like another kind of signature.
Besides, I wanted to know what he had been going to say to me at nine o’clock Wednesday night, with the lamp on. That was the real reason. I will be as honest as I can: I was not brave. I was owed an explanation, and I could not bear being owed.
The dock corridor was dim and smelled of floor wax. I walked it with my shoes in my hand. At the end was a steel door marked STAIR B, and beyond it a spiral of iron steps that led up to the mezzanine on the north side, the back way, the way book carts went. Nobody used it at night. It had a second, older door at the top with a keyhole beneath the handle.
I took out the small brass key with its loop of green string. It slid in as if it had been oiled the day before.
I had met Professor Faber in September, on my second shift, when I was still counting the minutes until I could leave. He had come down the Gallery stairs one step at a time with a book under each arm, and halfway he had stopped and said, to nobody, “Twenty-two. I have never once got it to twenty-three.”
I said it was twenty-two. He turned and looked at me over his glasses as though I had spoken in Latin. “You counted,” he said. I said I always counted. “Splendid,” said Professor Faber. “Then you will know when someone has changed the number.”
I had thought it a joke. I stood in the dark stairwell with his key in my hand and thought: he had been telling me something, even then, and I had been too busy keeping my face still to hear it.
The Gallery at night was a different room from the Gallery in the afternoon. The railing ran along the edge of the dark like a long brass thread.
Below, the Reading Room’s green lamps had been turned off, all but one near the Return Desk, which someone had left lit, and its glow reached up through the bars of the balustrade and laid thin bars of gold on the ceiling. It was very quiet.
I could hear my own pulse and, from somewhere under the floor, the slow tick of pipes.
I walked down the length of the mezzanine toward the stairs. I could not help it. I wanted to see the landing.
The landing was nothing. It was a small square of dark wood at the head of the stairs, with a brass lamp on the wall that did not work. The bulb was gone from its socket, and when I looked at the socket I saw that the metal at its mouth was bright and clean, with no dust on it at all. Someone had taken the bulb out recently. Mr. Beauchene, I thought. A hundred times I have told him.
Then I thought: Mr. Beauchene would have put one in.
I stood at the head of the twenty-two steps, with my toes at the lip of the first, and looked down. The carpet at the bottom was a rectangle of dark red. There was nothing on it. I do not know what I expected. I looked until my eyes watered, and then I turned away from the stairs and went to the closet.
I crouched and ran my fingertips along the top tread. The wood was old and smooth, worn to a shallow dip, and in the dip, near the left edge, I found a place where the grain was rough. It was only a scuff, the width of my thumb, pale where the varnish had been taken off.
It might have been made by a shoe heel. It might have been made a hundred years ago. I measured it against my own foot, because I could not stop myself, and it was exactly the length of a woman’s heel and no longer.
I told myself that half the college wore that heel. I told myself that a scuff is only a scuff. Then I stood, and I counted the steps down once more with my eyes, twenty-two of them, and I noticed that the brass rod that held the carpet along the edge of the fourth tread was loose at one end and had been bent up a quarter inch, like a lip, just where a falling foot might catch.
The paper tape ran across the frosted glass from frame to frame. It was the broad white kind that archivists use, with a gummed back, and Mr. Beauchene had written across the seam in blue pen: Sealed by C. Beauchene, with the date, and his signature, a neat upright hand with a flourish on the B. I stood in front of it for what felt like a long time. The gold letters said SPECIAL COLLECTIONS. The lamp was still on behind the glass.
The latch on that door had been broken for as long as anyone could remember. Faber used to say that a Keeper should never be locked out of his own closet. There was no way in without opening it, and no way to open it without breaking the tape.
I put my thumbnail under the end of the strip and I tore it from the glass.
It made a long ripping sound, like fabric, loud enough to hear down the length of the mezzanine and into the dark. The signature came apart in two halves. I held them in my hand, the flourish of the B on one piece, the last letters of his name on the other, and I felt something I had not expected.
It was not fear. It was shame, plain and cold. I had just put my hand on a man’s word and broken it. He had sat on a library step on Wednesday morning listing the hours of a dead friend, and I had done this.
I folded the two halves of the tape into my pocket, next to the Statement. I opened the door.
The closet smelled of paper and pencil shavings and a faint, sweetish mustiness that was the cot. The banker’s lamp burned green on the desk. The cabinet stood against the wall, sixty small drawers up to the ceiling, each with its faded blue label. I looked at it for a moment.
I did not go to the C drawer. I told myself I would not. I knew exactly where my name was, third column, second row, between a Calder and a Calderon, and I could have found it in the dark. That was almost the worst part, that the building had already taught me its alphabet.
The Keeper’s last entry.
I have since learned that Professor Faber always typed in the evening. He said the clatter helped him think. His machine was a black upright with round glass keys and a silver bar across the front, a machine that looked less like a typewriter than like a small, patient animal.
It sat in the middle of the desk on a square of green felt. A card stood in the roller, half out, its top edge curled over the platen, its typed lines cut off at the point where a hand had stopped.
I stood over it and read, upside down and then right way up.
RECALL.
BORROWER: Roark, A. CLASS: twenty-two years ago. LENT: Tuition, fees and board, six terms. One conduct matter dismissed. TERMS: Due when called. STATUS: Lapsed. RECEIPT: C4-118. RETURN: Not rendered. Called: this night. The Keeper will forgive upon her signature. She is to be found at
The line stopped there. It stopped, I noticed, in the middle of a sentence, with no period, as if a hand had lifted from the keys. The e’s all dipped. Every one. I counted eleven, in the lines I could read, and each of them sagged a little below its fellows like a row of tiny cups.
I put one finger above the e key and did not press it. The type bar behind it, where it rose from its basket, was bent a hair to one side, as if someone had once caught it in a drawer. A man could have typed on that machine for forty years and never thought of mending it. It struck me that a flaw so particular was as good as a signature, and that nobody could forge him without owning the machine.
Adaline Roark. I turned the name over in my head. I did not know it. It was the name of a student who had come and gone before I was in sixth grade.
A tall man’s shadow moved on the frosted glass.
No. I turned and there was nothing there. It was the lamp, its light swinging a little in a draft from the open door. I let my breath out. My eyes went to the rest of the desk, because I had learned that night that you look at everything.
There was a saucer at the edge of the blotter. A china teacup stood on it, a plain white one with a chip in the rim, and the tea in it had gone cold and grown a skin. It was full to the brim. Beside it was a second saucer, and the second saucer held nothing at all, only a clean, faint, brown ring where a cup had been.
One cup. Two saucers.
I looked at that for a long while, trying to make my mind do the sum. Someone had brought him tea. Someone had set a cup beside his, or taken one away, and left him with the full one, and he had not touched it. He was a man who drank tea at every hour of the day, and in his last evening on earth he had let a whole cup go cold.
I picked up the pencil jar, because it was something to do with my hands. It held three pencils, all yellow, all sharpened, none of them his. I put it back.
The stairwell door opened.
It was the old iron door at the north end of the Gallery, the one I had come through, and its hinge had a particular drawn-out squeal. I knew it. I had made the same noise myself twenty minutes ago. I did not think.
The lamp was on and the closet door was open and I was standing in the light like a figure in a shop window, and I did the only thing there was room to do. I reached out and switched off the banker’s lamp. I got down on my knees. I crawled under the desk.
It was a tight space, and the cot was jammed against one side, so that I lay curled with my back against its metal leg and my cheek on the cold floor. There were dust bunnies and a dropped paper clip and the smell of a rubber eraser. The typewriter sat over my head, a black belly of metal. My heart was going so hard I thought it must be audible down the length of the building.
Footsteps came down the Gallery. They were not a security guard’s. A guard clumps, and these were soft, quick, deliberate, a runner’s steps. A thin white beam ranged ahead of them and danced over the frosted glass.
The beam stopped on the open door. It stopped on the torn tape, hanging by one end from the frame.
There was a pause. I heard someone let out a long, rueful breath, and the click of a phone flashlight being switched to a wider setting.
“Well,” said a man’s voice, very low. “Somebody beat me to it.”
I knew it before the light came in. It was an easy, pleasant voice, a voice that had spent a lot of effort being easy. It belonged to Rhys Dunleavy.
He came into the closet. I could see his shoes from where I lay, sneakers, dark blue, the left lace untied. He swung the beam slowly around the little room. It crossed the cot and the cabinet and the desk, and passed within two feet of my face without stopping. I did not breathe. Then he walked to the wall of drawers and ran his light up it, label by label, and I heard his thumb tick along the brass pulls.
“D,” he muttered. “D, D, come on, D.”
The drawer slid open with a long, dry rasp. His hand went in. I heard the soft riffle of cards, the thin flutter of his fingers walking the dividers, the sound of someone who has been over a pile of paper in his mind a hundred times and is now going over it in the dark. It stopped. There was a very small silence.
“There you are,” Rhys said, softly, almost tenderly.
I heard the card go into his jacket. I heard the drawer close. I thought: he took it. He took his own card. He is a thief, or he is a free man, and I do not know which.
He did not leave. He crossed to the desk, with his back to the door, and I saw his shoes stop beside the chair. The beam fell on the typewriter. For a while there was not a sound in the closet but the tick of the pipes.
“Roark,” said Rhys, under his breath. He read it twice. “Oh, you old fox. You were going to forgive her.”
He leaned in. The light moved closer, and I realized he was reading the card in the roller, and that his knee was now almost touching the cot. I could smell him, mint and laundry soap and the faint metallic ghost of nerves. I shifted my weight, very slightly, to ease the dust in my nose.
The cot’s iron leg, against my spine, gave a short, thin squeak.
Rhys stopped moving. The beam on the typewriter went still.
He stayed that way for what felt like a minute and was probably five seconds. Then the light dropped, slowly, down the side of the desk, and swung across the floor, and lay on my cardigan sleeve.
“You can come out, Calderwood,” Rhys said. His voice was almost kind. “You breathe like you’re counting.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!