I came out from under the desk on my elbows, with dust on my cheek and a paper clip stuck to my sleeve, and Rhys Dunleavy held out a hand to help me up.
I did not take it. He did not seem to mind. He switched on the banker’s lamp, which I had turned off in my panic, and the closet filled with its green light. He looked at me, and I looked at him, and we both took a quiet inventory of what the other had been caught doing.
He was tall, lean, dark-haired, with the kind of face that photographs better than it meets you. He had been in my section of the library for six weeks, and in that time he had never once been rude to me or let me see him sweat. Now he was sweating. A thin shine stood on his upper lip, and the hand holding his phone was not perfectly steady.
“You tore the tape,” he said.
“You came in after I did.”
“I came in because it was torn.” He glanced at the dangling strip. “I had a plan. I was going to lift it with a hair dryer and put it back. Very clean. Very patient. I practiced on a roll of my own.”
“I didn’t have a hair dryer.”
“No. You had a thumbnail.” The corner of his mouth moved. “Calderwood, you are the most direct person I have ever met.”
“What is in your jacket?”
The easy look went off his face. He put the hand that was not holding the phone flat against his chest, over the pocket, and for a moment he looked less like a competitor and more like a boy who has been caught at something and is trying to decide how much it is worth to lie.
“Mine,” he said. “It’s my card. D, Dunleavy. I have a right to it.”
“Do you? It said Open.”
“It says Open until Friday.” He said it fast, and then looked as if he wished he had not. “Look. You read them. I know you did, because nobody in this closet reads only the labels.
You have been in here before tonight, and you know exactly what this is, and you went up under a desk when you heard me coming instead of calling out. So we are both in this room for the same reason.”
“What reason is that?”
“We both have a name on a card.” He said it very simply, like a man naming a disease he shares with a stranger on a train. “And somebody just died who could have told us what to do about it.”
I sat down on the edge of the cot, because my knees had decided. The springs groaned. In the lamplight the closet looked smaller than I remembered, and the cabinet looked bigger.
“I got a note,” I said. “A card. In my mailbox. It said my account was open.”
“I got one too, Wednesday.” Rhys leaned against the desk. “Mine had an addendum. Return named. It’s due Friday.”
“What is it?”
He did not answer that. He looked at the floor, and then at the typewriter, and then at the half-typed card with its cut-off sentence. “That,” he said, nodding at it, “is the most interesting thing in this building. He was going to forgive somebody. Forgive. I’ve never seen that word on a card. Have you?”
“There was one. In the R drawer. It said Forgiven in a different typeface.”
“Different how?”
“Straight.” I heard myself say it, and the word felt odd in my mouth. “The e’s were straight. Everything he typed has a dip in the e. I noticed it the first night.”
Rhys stared at me. “You noticed the e’s.”
“I count things. I notice things.”
“Huh.” He rubbed the back of his neck with his free hand. “Okay. That is either very useful or very strange, and I think it’s useful.” He pushed himself off the desk. “Tell me what the Roark card says. Everything. Exactly.”
I told him. I said it the way I would have recited a phone number, and I watched his face while I did, and when I got to the line about C4-118 I saw something flicker behind his eyes. It was greed, I thought at first, and then I looked again and thought it was something more like hope.
“Receipts,” he said. “Every card has a call number. Mine is C5-310. Do you know what that is?”
“Shelf marks.”
“Closed stacks. Row C, a range, a particular book. The borrower writes a receipt when the loan is made, a little handwritten acknowledgment, and it gets slipped inside a volume at that number. That’s the proof. The card is the Circulation’s side, and the receipt is yours.” He lowered his voice, though no one could have heard us. “If the receipt is gone, so is the proof. A card with no receipt is a promise nobody can show anyone signed.”
“You want your receipt.”
“I want mine, and I think you want yours, and I think you want hers.” He nodded at the typewriter. “The one person who wasn’t going to let her stay lapsed is dead. Somebody typed a note this morning telling you to finish his last entry. The last entry says she has to be found. We can go and find the first piece, and it’s a hundred and forty feet from here.”
“The stacks are locked. Mr. Beauchene has the day key.”
“Mr. Beauchene has the day key,” Rhys agreed, “and the building has a lift.”
I looked at him. He smiled, with a hint of the old charm, and some small, wary part of me thought: he has been planning this for days.
The one thing he did before we left was reseal the door. He took a roll of white archival tape from the pocket of his jacket, tore off a length with his teeth, and ran it from frame to frame across the frosted glass. Then he took a blue pen out of the same pocket and wrote, along the seam, in a small upright hand with a flourish on the B: Sealed by C. Beauchene. He added the date. He signed it.
It was perfect. I would have sworn on a Bible that it was the same signature I had torn in half an hour before. It had the same slant, the same little hook on the final e.
“You forged it,” I said.
“I practiced.” He capped the pen. “It’s a good hand. Honest. It’s the kind of hand people trust.”
“That’s the worst thing I’ve ever heard.”
“Is it?” He looked at me, and for the first time there was nothing easy in his face. “You wrote a reference letter for your chemistry teacher, didn’t you? In his voice. And he never knew.”
I had no air. “How do you...”
“Because it’s the same hand that wrote mine,” Rhys said, quietly. “Everybody’s card says something, Calderwood. Mine says a conduct matter dismissed. It was a lie I told a dean when I was nineteen. It wasn’t a very big lie. It’s just that somebody noticed, and wrote it down.”
I did not say anything. There was nothing in me to say it with.
The book lift was in the north wall of the Reading Room, behind the Return Desk, set in the plaster at hip height. It had a little wooden door the size of a bread box, with a brass ring for a handle, and I had stamped fourteen hundred books past it without ever once opening it. Rhys crouched in front of it with his phone light in his teeth and slid the door up on its track.
Behind it was a shaft. It was black, square, lined with raw brick, and it smelled of old rope and cold dust. Inside hung a wooden cab, the size of a small trunk, from a rope as thick as my wrist. The rope ran up into the dark over a wooden pulley and down the other side to a counterweight I could not see.
“It’s hand-hauled,” Rhys said. “There’s a knot every floor. Desk level, a blue knot. Stack level one, a red. Level two is yellow, three is green. You stand at the knot, you pull the rope, and the cab goes where you want.” He took the light out of his mouth. “It’s rated for eighty pounds. That’s about a sack of books.”
“I weigh a hundred and eighteen.”
“I weigh a hundred and seventy-two, and you can see why you’re going.” He held up a hand before I could speak. “I’ll work the rope. I’ve done it twice, with a box of nothing. It goes down smoothly. You get out at green, you go down row C to the fourth range, you get your receipt and mine and hers, you come back, I haul. Ten minutes. It’s a ride.”
“It’s a coffin.”
“It’s a very well-made coffin with a great view.”
I did not decide to do it. I have gone over that night many times, and I cannot find the place where I decided.
I only remember that the cab was colder than the room, and that I folded myself into it with my knees against my chest and my back against a plank that smelled of lemon oil and mice. Rhys looked in at me, framed in the little square door.
His face was lit from below, and he looked, for a moment, like a boy about to push a sled down a hill.
“If you tug twice, I stop,” he said. “Once, I go on. If you tug three times, I haul you back up like a fish. Okay?”
“Okay.”
“Hey. Calderwood.”
“What?”
“Count something. It’ll help.”
He slid the door down. Dark closed over me like a lid.
I counted the knots. They passed under my fingers on the rope beside my head, one at a time, with a jerk and a hush as the cab sank. Blue. The pulley groaned.
I felt the shaft walls slide by, brick and mortar and brick, near enough to touch with an elbow. Red, and a breath of colder air. Yellow. I counted my own breaths to match.
I was at forty-one when the rope slowed, and I felt the small, certain bump of the cab touching bottom.
Green.
I pushed on the little door and it rolled up. The closed stacks opened in front of me like a cathedral of iron.
I had been in the main stacks, the open ones, a hundred times. These were different. These were the sealed levels, three iron decks of shelving, stairs of perforated steel that rang under your feet, aisles so narrow a person had to turn sideways to pass a loaded cart. Everything was brown.
The books were brown, the light was brown, and the air carried a flavor of leather and glue and the faint sour sweetness of paper slowly deciding to be dust.
A single yellow bulb burned at the end of each row on a timer, and when I crawled out of the cab, one of them blinked on above me with a click, and I thought my heart would climb out through my mouth.
I tugged the rope once. Far above, a small answering jerk.
Row C, range four. The call numbers were stamped on brass tags at the end of each shelf. C1, C2. I walked with my hand on the spines, reading the tags by the light of my phone. C3. A cat or something small ran across the end of the aisle and was gone. C4.
C4-118 was a fat green-bound volume on the third shelf from the floor, with gilt letters worn down to the shape of the letters: The Brackenwick College Bulletin, Volume Forty-One. I eased it out. It was heavy and cold, and when I opened the cover a smell of old attics came up. Somewhere in the middle it fell open at a place where a flat object had been kept for years, and the paper there was a little darker, a little stiffer.
A slip of paper lay in the gutter. It was ruled, lined paper torn from a student notebook, with a ragged left edge, and it had been written in blue ballpoint in a clear, fast, slanting hand.
I, Adaline Roark, acknowledge that I have received what is written on my card, and I accept it. I will return what I can.
Under it, in a different pen, smaller, as if added at another time:
Returned in part. I kept the rest. A.R.
I read that last line three times. It had no flourish. It had the simple, set pride of a person who has made a decision and is not going to explain it. I held the slip against my chest and stood for a moment in the brown light, and I thought: this is the first time since Tuesday night that anybody has said no.
Then I noticed the shelf.
I almost missed it. The volumes on either side of the Bulletin were the same green-bound set, Volumes Forty and Forty-Two and Forty-Three, and each of them had been opened and shut and opened again so many times that the spines had gone soft.
But inside the cover of Volume Forty-Two, where my light fell, there was a slit. A thin, clean, straight slit, the width of a razor blade, and a little strip of paper stood out of it like a tongue. Someone had cut something out of the book.
I looked at Forty. Slit. Forty-Three. Slit. A fourth, farther along the shelf. Four slits in a row, four small, careful rectangles of nothing.
Four receipts, I thought, taken out by someone who knew where they were.
My phone buzzed against my palm, and I nearly screamed. It was a text from a number I did not know. Two words:
Hurry. Someone’s here.
I ran. I did not think about the iron stairs ringing. I ran down the aisle and flung myself into the cab, folded my knees into my chest, pulled the little door down over my head, and tugged the rope once, hard, and then, because I was frightened, twice.
Nothing happened.
I tugged again. Once, and then once more. The rope went slack in my hand, and then, with a groan I felt in my teeth, the cab rose six feet, and stopped. It hung there. It swung, very slightly, on its rope.
Above me in the dark, I heard a sound like a man trying not to be heard saying something unprintable. Then the rope jerked, and jerked again, and I knew from the grinding of the pulley what it was. I had put a hundred-and-eighteen-pound girl and a green-bound Bulletin into a cab rated for eighty, and Rhys had hauled it past the counterweight.
I tried to think. The cab hung in the black between levels. The brick walls pressed in on three sides, and beneath me the shaft fell away into nothing I could see. The sweat in my hair was cold. I had no phone light; I had dropped the phone when I ran, and it lay on the floor of the cab with its screen dimly lit, showing a text that said Hurry.
All right, I thought. I count things.
It was not an eighty-pound cab with a hundred-pound counterweight. It was a cab and a bag of something heavy on the other end of a rope, and the question was which one weighed more. When Rhys hauled, the cab rose, which meant the counterweight was lighter than me and the cab together. When he stopped, it hung. If I took away weight, the cab would climb easily.
I looked at what I had. There was the Bulletin, twelve pounds if it was an ounce, with a gilt spine and a slip of paper in it. There was my own body. There was nothing else.
I took the slip out of the gutter of the Bulletin, folded it, and put it inside my cuff, against my wrist, where I could feel it. I wedged the huge green book up against the corner of the little door. Then I put both hands on the cab’s inner wall and pushed it hard, so that it slid out from under me, and I dropped it, as quietly as I could, out the open side of the cab and into the black.
I heard it fall a long, long way. It hit the bottom of the shaft with a distant crack like a dropped plank.
The cab shivered. The rope went taut. And slowly, groaning, easy as an elevator on a Sunday, it began to rise.
Blue knot. The little door slid up and light came in, thin and green, and I saw the foot of the Return Desk with its brass chute and the oak legs of a chair. Rhys was nowhere in sight.
I put my hands over the sill and started to drag myself out.
A pair of shoes stood on the Reading Room floor in front of the lift. They were brown, polished, narrow, with soft rubber soles, and they were set neatly side by side, the way a man stands when he has been standing in one place for a long time.
The lift door opened on Mr. Beauchene’s shoes.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!