Mr. Beauchene did not shout. I have thought since that it would have been easier if he had.
He stood in front of the lift in his overcoat and a muffler, with a flashlight in one hand pointed politely at the floor, and he watched me climb out of a book lift at ten to two in the morning with dust on my knees and my hair in my face.
His eyes went over me once, from the top of my head to my shoes. He did not say a word. He held out his free hand, the way a doorman holds out a hand to a lady getting out of a car.
I took it. His palm was cold and a little damp.
“Eighty pounds,” said Mr. Beauchene, mildly. “It is rated for eighty pounds, Miss Calderwood. I have been on the committee that rated it.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Yes. I rather think you are.” He looked past me, down into the black square of the shaft, and I saw his jaw work. “I heard it from the Gallery stair. The rope. The groaning, that particular note that it makes when the pulley is overloaded. I thought, no, that is not possible. At this hour. I thought it was the pipes.” A pause. “Is there anyone else down there?”
“No.”
“Is there anyone else up here?”
“No.”
That was not quite a lie. Rhys had gone, I thought, the moment he heard a key in the front door. I had no idea where. I had no idea how he got out, or whether he would be waiting for me somewhere with his jacket pocket full of other people’s debts.
Mr. Beauchene looked at me a little longer. He bent and picked something off the sill of the lift, a single gray thread, and held it up to his flashlight. “Wool,” he said, to himself rather than to me. “Rather like a cardigan.”
He did not look at my sleeve. I was grateful, and I understood that being spared was a kind of debt too. Then he closed the little wooden door of the lift, gently, as one closes the eyes of a sleeper, and said, “Come to my office.”
His office was the same tidy room, with the green blotter and the photograph of the building under snow. At two in the morning, with the radiators ticking, it felt like the inside of a ship. He filled an electric kettle from a bottle of water, set out two mismatched mugs, and dropped a tea bag into each with an air of ceremony. He did not ask me to sit. I sat.
“I have not slept since Tuesday,” he said, to the kettle. “I was walking the building to be doing something. I find that when a person has died one wants to be near the places where he was. It is not logical.
I went up to the Gallery and I stood at the closet door.” He gave a short dry cough. “The seal was intact. I wanted to check that. I thought, if anyone touched it I should know, and no one has. I have an eye for my own signature.”
My stomach turned over. I looked at the surface of my tea.
“Then I came down and I heard the lift.”
“Mr. Beauchene...”
“I am not going to ask you what you were doing, Miss Calderwood.” He turned, with the mug in his hand, and held it out to me. “I have been a librarian for thirty-six years. I know what a person looks like who has gone looking for something in the stacks. It is generally either a book or a secret, and I do not like to be the one who takes either away.”
I took the tea. It was too hot and too strong and tasted of a cardboard box. It was the best thing I had had in three days.
“I will say one thing,” he went on, more quietly, “and then I will let you go to bed. Edmund was not a careless man. He was an eccentric, and he kept his own counsel, and he took the stairs too fast. But he was not careless.
On Tuesday, at a quarter past eleven in the morning, he asked me to lock the Charter Book in the main vault, and he stood and watched me do it. He had never done that in thirty-one years. It was an odd thing. I thought no more about it.”
“The Charter Book?”
“The founding register of the college. It is the most valuable object in the building. The Dean has been, ah, in some distress about it.” He lowered himself into his own chair. His face looked suddenly like a drawing that has been rubbed with a thumb. “It was not in the vault on Wednesday. I do not say stolen. I say it was not there. The Dean has asked that I prepare a statement for a review.”
“That’s not your fault.”
“It is my vault,” said Mr. Beauchene, with great simplicity.
We sat for a while without talking, drinking the cardboard tea. The kettle ticked as it cooled. At some point I realized I was crying, not in any dramatic way, only a slow wetness down my face that I did not seem able to stop, and he handed me a folded white handkerchief without looking at me, as a man hands something to a person in a church.
“Thank you,” I said, “and I’ll pay for the tea. I mean, I’ll bring a box. I’ll bring a whole box.”
“Miss Calderwood.” He almost smiled. “It is a tea bag.”
“I don’t like owing people.”
“No,” said Mr. Beauchene. “I should have guessed. You have the look.” He turned a ring on his finger, a plain gold band, round and round. “Edmund said that about you once. He said you would pay back a kindness before you had finished receiving it, and that it was the loneliest habit he had ever seen in a person so young. I thought it a strange thing to say. I think now he meant something else by it.”
I wiped my face. I said nothing. Under my sleeve, pressed to my wrist, the folded slip of Adaline Roark’s receipt crackled when I moved. I put my hand over it.
“Go to bed,” he said, gently. “And Miss Calderwood. The lift is not a toy. Please do not use it again.”
I slept four hours. I do not remember dreaming. I woke with the receipt still pinned under my cuff, creased into a stripe across my wrist, and read it again before I let myself brush my teeth. Returned in part. I kept the rest. I tried it as a question and as an answer and as a dare. It held up as all three.
Teo Marchetti was waiting for me on the steps of the student union at noon, in a green army jacket with every pocket bulging, holding a sleeve of oyster crackers out in front of him like a priest offering a communion wafer.
“Emergency crackers,” he announced. “Dispensed only in times of grief, exams, and the first snow.”
I took one. It was salty and dry and tasted exactly as it had the day we met, when I came into the writing center with a paper on Ohio mill towns and he told me, kindly, that my thesis was hiding on page four.
He was twenty, a junior, and he had the face of a cheerful owl, round glasses, a heavy black curl falling over one eyebrow, and a stomach that made noises in quiet rooms. He worked for the college paper. He lived in its basement, practically, among the stacks of bound volumes.
“I wasn’t going to come out,” I said.
“I know. That’s why I brought crackers to you.” He took one himself. “Greer. Seriously. How are you? Are you eating? Are you sleeping? Because you look like somebody who’s been hauled out of a river.”
“I was in a book lift.”
“I’m sorry, what?”
I told him.
I had not decided to, and I stood on the steps of the union in the cold with my hands in my cardigan and heard myself telling him, in order, all of it: the card with my name on it, and the Circulation, and the Statement, and Ilse, and the paperback that had come through the chute with a typed card inside, and the torn tape, and Rhys under the desk, and the green knot of the rope.
I told him what the Roark receipt said. Professor Faber had asked me, in his lamplit closet, not to tell my friends. I told my friend.
It was the first time in my life I had broken a promise to a dying man, and it did not feel like a sin. It felt like putting down a heavy bag.
Teo had stopped eating halfway through. He stood with a cracker in one hand and the sleeve in the other, and the owl face had gone very still.
“Say the name again,” he said. “The one on the receipt.”
“Adaline Roark.”
“Twenty-two years ago.”
“That’s what the card says.”
“Come with me,” Teo said, and dropped the crackers into his pocket, and took me by the sleeve.
The Brackenwick Courier lived in the basement of the student union in three low rooms with pipes on the ceiling. The front room was a newsroom, with four mismatched desks and a coffeemaker that had been on since before anyone could remember. The back room held the morgue.
That was what they called it. It was not a morgue in any sense I would have wanted to explain to my mother. It was a long, narrow room of steel shelves, floor to ceiling, packed with bound volumes of every issue the paper had ever printed, as high as a man could reach and then higher.
The volumes were big as tombstones. They were arranged by year, and each spine was stamped in gold with the dates. At the far end stood a microfilm reader, a gray desk-sized machine with a hood and a crank, and a stool that wobbled.
“Everything the college ever did is in here,” said Teo, with a sort of tender pride. “Every vote. Every obituary. Every letter to the editor about the dining hall. You can find out who won the croquet tournament years ago.” He ran his finger along the spines. “Twenty-two years. Let me see. This is the fall. She’d have been, what, a sophomore?”
“Junior, maybe. Senior.”
“Okay. Okay.” He hauled a volume off the shelf with both arms and dropped it on the table with a thump. Dust rose in the lamplight. “Hold the lamp.”
We found her in forty minutes.
She was on page six of a Friday issue, in the lower left corner, in a photograph about the size of a playing card. A group of ten or twelve people stood on the steps of Pellworth Library in winter coats, squinting at the sun, and the caption said: The Library Board with its new student representative. Front row, left to right.
I did not read the names at first. I read the faces.
There was Professor Faber, two decades younger, with thick dark hair and the yellow pencil already behind his ear, grinning at the camera as if he had been told a joke. There was a heavy-set man I did not know.
There was a woman with a gray bob that was not yet gray, in a good wool suit, standing with her chin up, and I knew her before the caption told me. It was Dean Strode, thirty-nine years old, an assistant dean, with the same dry, perfect smile.
And in the middle of the front row, in a navy peacoat with the collar turned up, a young woman stood with her arms crossed and her chin lifted. She was not smiling. She had dark eyebrows and a crooked front tooth and the posture of a person who has been told to hold still for a photograph and is thinking about something else.
Roark, Adaline, the caption said. Class of that year. Student trustee.
“Student trustee,” said Teo. “Student trustee. That’s the seat on the Board of Trustees. One student gets a vote.” He was already turning pages, his fingers quick and cold. “Here. Next spring, here. Look. She resigned.”
It was a three-paragraph item at the bottom of page two. Adaline Roark, a senior from a town the article gave a name for and I do not repeat here, had resigned her seat on the Board of Trustees and withdrawn from the college, effective immediately, for personal reasons. The Dean of Students said the college wished her well. The article did not say where she had gone.
“Two weeks later,” said Teo, flipping, “here. The Board met. Look at this.”
He tapped a headline. Trustees Vote To Close Mill Street Clinic. It was a four-column story with a photo of a plain, one-story brick building with a cross over the door, and a line of people holding signs. The clinic had served the mill town below the ridge since before the college had a library. The trustees had voted seven to six. The student seat had been vacant.
“One vote,” I said.
“One vote. By a margin of one, and the student seat was empty because she’d resigned.” Teo sat back on the wobbling stool. He looked, suddenly, much younger and much less like an owl. “If she’d stayed. If she’d voted no.”
“It would have been seven to seven.”
“A tie fails.” He rubbed his eyes under his glasses. “Greer, that’s not a coincidence. That’s the Return. She had a card, and she had a Return, and somebody wanted her to vote yes. Or to vote at all, or to not. And she said no, and she left, and the clinic closed anyway.”
“Returned in part,” I said. “I kept the rest.”
“What does that mean?”
“I don’t know yet.”
We sat in the cold basement room with the open volume between us and the smell of old newsprint rising in the lamplight. Somewhere upstairs, a door slammed, and a girl’s laugh went up a stairwell. Dean Strode smiled out of the photograph with her chin lifted. I touched the corner of the paper, where Adaline Roark crossed her arms.
“Twenty-two years,” Teo said slowly. “And he was going to forgive her.”
“He was going to find her.”
“Why now?”
I did not know. I had a hundred half-thoughts and none of them would stand up. I thought of a man in a tweed jacket tapping a pencil twice on a cabinet, saying, I had a plan for June.
Teo was quiet for so long that I looked up. He had taken his glasses off and was holding them in his lap, folding and unfolding one earpiece with his thumb. He was looking, not at me, but at the shelf of bound volumes behind my head.
“Greer,” he said. “Can I tell you something?”
“Of course.”
“When you said your card says, accepted without inquiry, I felt it in my stomach.” His voice was very careful. “I’ve been feeling it all morning. I think I’ve been feeling it since Wednesday.”
“Teo.”
“Last spring, there was a thing in the registrar’s office. A cheating thing. A guy named Calvin, who was the Dean’s nephew, had been accused of copying on a chemistry final. It was going to go to a review.
And I was in the library that night, at the table by the window, and I saw him. Calvin. I really did. He was at a terminal for about three hours. I wrote a statement. I signed it.
I said I saw him in the library the whole time, and so he couldn’t have been where they said.”
“Was it true?”
“It was true.” Teo swallowed. “It was completely true. It was all true. I want you to know that. I wrote it because Ilse Vessely came to the paper and said that someone needed to say what they saw, and she was so kind, and I thought, well, it’s the right thing.”
He put his glasses on. His eyes behind them looked enormous.
“A week after, a card came to my mailbox. Cream-colored. Blue type. It said, Your account is now closed. With thanks. And I thought it was a joke, honestly, I thought, what account? I threw it away.” He tried to laugh and it did not come out.
“Then on Wednesday morning I went back through my trash. I don’t know why. I found it in the bottom of the bin, under a coffee filter. It had a typed line under the name. It said, Status: Returned.”
“They used you.”
“They asked me for something true, and I gave it.” His voice cracked. “Nobody told me what I was returning, Greer. Nobody told me there was anything to return. I signed what they put in front of me. Everyone does.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!