Juno agreed to play the cello at the memorial before I had finished asking her to.
“Of course I will,” she said, from the floor of our room, where she was cross-legged on a rug with the instrument across her lap, oiling a peg with the end of a pencil. “Haydn. He liked Haydn. I heard him say so at the Christmas concert. He said the slow movements were the only honest part of the eighteenth century.”
“I need you to play something else.”
She looked up. She had a round, cheerful, freckled face, and a way of tilting her head, like a bird, when she suspected that someone was about to say something interesting. She was nineteen and from Minnesota, and she was not as innocent as she looked.
“Something else like what?”
“Something loud. At ten to four. For about a minute. Something that makes every single person in the room turn around.”
“At a memorial service.”
“I know.”
“For a dead man.”
“I know. I’m sorry. I can’t tell you why.”
Juno set down the pencil. She ran her thumb along the neck of the cello, down the strings, and for a long time said nothing at all.
I stood in the middle of the room in my funeral dress, which was my only dress, borrowed from my mother’s closet in August and never returned, and I felt my face go hot. I added it to the column in my head. A laundry card, nine dollars. A coffee.
A ride to the airport, not yet taken. And now this.
“You’re not in trouble,” she said at last. It was not quite a question.
“I don’t think so.”
“But there’s a thing.”
“There’s a thing.”
“Okay.” She picked the pencil up again. “I know a bit of Shostakovich that sounds like a building falling down. Will that do?”
“That will do.”
“Great. You owe me.” She grinned. Then, seeing my face, she added, more gently, “That was a joke, Greer. You don’t actually owe me. You never owe me.”
I smiled and said thank you, and I wrote it down anyway.
The Reading Room had been rearranged for the occasion. Someone had pushed the long tables against the walls and set out three hundred folding chairs in rows facing the Gallery stairs, and at the foot of the stairs, where the red carpet ended, stood a small podium with a vase of white lilies. The green lamps were all lit, though it was afternoon. The room smelled of lilies and floor polish and wet wool coats.
I had never seen so many people in that building. Students sat in the back rows in their good jackets, subdued, a little pleased with their own subduedness, as young people are at a funeral. Faculty filled the middle, in tweed and gray. Up front, in the first three rows, sat a different crowd: older, quieter, better dressed.
Gray-haired women in silk scarves. Men in dark suits with a certain heavy ease about the shoulders. They did not talk to one another. They sat with their hands in their laps, upright and still, like people waiting for a train they had been waiting for all their lives.
“Alumni,” said Teo, at my elbow. He was wearing a tie. It was crooked. “From all over. They got on planes.”
“For a librarian?”
“For a librarian,” Teo agreed, and looked at the front rows with an expression I did not like.
At the left of the stairs stood a glass display case on a pedestal, the kind the library used for rare books. Mr. Beauchene had put it there that morning.
Inside, on a square of gray felt, lay what he had chosen to represent the life of Edmund Faber: a pair of wire-rimmed glasses with one lens cracked, a leather-bound notebook, a photograph of the Gallery in snow, a small battered tin of peppermints.
And, in the center, as if on an altar, a stub of yellow pencil.
I looked at it from across the room. It was chewed at one end, the paint worn off the tip, a little crooked, the way every pencil he ever owned had been crooked.
That was not the pencil Hannigan had asked me about. The one on the landing had been an inch long and might have come out of anyone’s pocket. This one was the stub that had been behind his ear when they lifted him from the carpet. It was, Mr. Beauchene had told me in the hall in a whisper, the last thing the paramedics had taken from his body, and he had asked for it back.
“He said,” Mr. Beauchene had murmured, with his hand on my elbow and his eyes on the case, “that the key was in his pencil. Years ago, over sherry. I took it for a joke. I have been thinking about it since Tuesday. I never looked.” He had not looked at me. “I should very much like someone to look.”
“What key?” I had said.
“I have no idea, my dear. I am only a librarian.” And he had put into my hand, under cover of a handshake, a small brass key on a ring. “The case. I shall be on the far side of the room, I expect, for the duration of the music.”
I did not know what to do with the key. I put it in my left shoe, and I walked on it for an hour.
Dean Strode gave the eulogy.
She stood at the podium with her hands lightly folded and waited until the coughing died away. She had put on a black dress with a single strand of pearls. She did not use notes. In the green light, with the white lilies at her elbow, she looked like a person who had been born into that room and would stay there after everyone else was gone.
“Let us be clear about what Edmund Faber was,” she said, and her voice carried easily to the back. “He was not a great scholar, though he read more than any of us. He was not a great administrator, though he kept this building standing for forty years. He was a keeper. Of books, of silences, of other people’s treasures. He understood that some things are best held in trust.”
A murmur ran through the front rows, a ripple of small nods. Beside me Teo stiffened, and I felt his shoulder against mine.
“He leaves behind no family,” the Dean went on. “He leaves behind, instead, a very large family indeed. Many of you are in this room. Many of you owe him more than you can say. He would want me to tell you that you are not to say it. He would want you to carry on.”
On the last three words she did something small. She moved her eyes along the front row, slowly, from one end to the other, and the gray-haired women and heavy-shouldered men sat motionless under that look. It lasted perhaps two seconds. I do not think anyone but me and Teo saw it. I felt it as a draft under a door.
“Carry on,” whispered Teo, so softly that only I could hear. “Not, carry on his memory. Carry on.”
Beside the Dean, on the steps, sat Ilse Vessely in a black sweater, her hands clasped between her knees, her gaze fixed on the middle distance. She did not look at me. I thought she looked as if she had not slept. I wondered where she had put the typed card, and whether she had sat up at night and read it.
The reception afterward was held in the lobby, with sherry in paper cups, and the first person to find me was a woman I had never seen.
She was in her sixties, tall and spare, with silver hair cut close to her skull and a dark silk scarf knotted at her throat. She wore a gray suit and carried a small black handbag held in front of her with both hands. She stopped in front of me and looked me up and down with eyes so sharp and so kind that I took a step backward.
“You’re the girl from the Return Desk,” she said.
“I work nights. I’m Greer.”
“Greer Calderwood.” She said it as if she had it written on a card. “He wrote to me about you. Not often. Edmund didn’t write often. But in September he wrote, There is a girl at the desk who counts the stairs. I thought you would like to know that he noticed.”
It went through me like a draft. “He wrote to you?”
“I am Judge Ashdown. I sit on the court of appeals, the state one, in a city I won’t bore you with.” She put out a cool, dry hand, and I shook it. “Forty-four years ago I sat where you are standing. I was nineteen and I was terrified, and I had a card.”
“Did you...” I lowered my voice. “Did you pay it back?”
“I’m still paying.” She smiled, a very small, very private smile. “That’s the thing nobody tells you. It isn’t a debt that ends. It’s a kind of way of being in the world. I am glad of it, mostly. Most days.”
Her eyes went past my shoulder, to the Dean, who stood at the center of a ring of dark suits, nodding gravely. “Most days,” she said again, a shade differently. “I only wanted you to know that he was fond of you.
And to say, if I may, as someone old enough to be careless: be careful what you sign.”
“I haven’t signed anything.”
“Good.” She touched my arm. “That’s the best news I’ve had all week.”
She moved away through the crowd and was swallowed up, and I stood alone with a paper cup of sherry I did not want and the key pressing into my heel.
Officer Hannigan was standing at the back of the lobby, by the door, in a plain dark jacket instead of her uniform, with a paper cup of sherry she had not touched. She raised it a half inch when she saw me. I went over because it would have been stranger not to.
“Medical examiner called this morning,” she said, without preamble. “Preliminary. His heart was in poor shape. Poor enough that the fall might not be the whole story. He might have gone down the stairs because it stopped, or it might have stopped because he went down.”
“So it was an accident.”
“It’s cause undetermined with a nicer coat on.” She looked at the glass case, at the yellow stub on its gray felt. “That the pencil you meant? The one he kept behind his ear?”
“Yes.”
“Funny thing about the other one.” She turned the cup in her fingers. “The one I found on the landing. It’s the wrong yellow. Somebody bought a box of those at the campus store and shaved down one end. It’s not his. I’d say somebody wanted us to find a pencil.”
I could not think of a single thing to say that was both true and safe. Hannigan seemed to expect that. She nodded to herself, set the sherry on a windowsill, and went out into the cold without another word.
Rhys found me at twenty-five to four, by the coat rack.
I had not expected to see him. I had looked for him all afternoon, in the crowd, under the lilies, at the edges of the room, and not found him, and I had told myself it was a relief. He came out from behind a row of overcoats in a charcoal suit that fit him very well, and he was the color of old paper.
“Calderwood.” His voice was low and rough. “I’m so sorry about the lift. I saw Beauchene come in the north door, and I ran. I should have stayed. I should have warned you.”
“You texted me. You said, Hurry.”
“That’s not a warning. That’s a request.” He ran a hand over his hair. “Did he catch you?”
“He made me tea.”
Rhys stared at me, and then, to my surprise, he laughed, a short, cracked sound that did not sound entirely healthy. “Of course he did. Of course.” He leaned on the wall, pressing his shoulder blades to the plaster. “Listen. I have forty seconds. I got the thing I needed from the stacks, I got my receipt, but that isn’t the point. The Return was due yesterday. It wasn’t called. They moved it.”
“To when?”
“Monday. Midnight.” He pronounced the words as if they tasted of metal. “A Reading. They’re calling a Reading, the whole Board, in this room, after the building closes. Everything is going to be settled at once. Whose cards stand, whose are called, who holds the office.” His eyes searched my face. “Everything is Monday midnight now.”
“What’s your Return, Rhys?”
“I can’t,” he said. “I can’t, not here. After. Please.”
“You said we both needed receipts.”
“We do. You do, Calderwood. You need yours more than you know.” He pushed himself off the wall. “I have to go. If she sees me talking to you...”
“Who?”
He did not answer. He walked away toward the double doors with his shoulders very straight, and I watched him go, and a little way off, at the center of her ring of dark suits, Dean Strode lifted her head and turned it, slowly, in his direction, and then in mine.
It was ten to four.
Juno began to play.
She was in the corner by the Gallery stairs, on a folding chair with the cello between her knees, her black dress tucked under her. The room fell silent in the way a room falls silent for a girl with an instrument, indulgently, expecting Haydn. For eight bars she played Haydn. It was the slow movement, the honest one, and it was beautiful, and I felt my throat close.
Then her bow came down on the C string like a hammer.
It was a sound like a building falling slowly in on itself. It started low and ugly and swelled, with a crashing, grinding, unpitched fury that rose up through the floor and shook the glass in the display case and rattled the little cups on the sherry tray. People gasped.
A man in the third row dropped his program. Judge Ashdown’s head came up. Every face in the Reading Room turned toward the cello, and I saw them turn, row by row, a wave of astonished profiles, as if a wind were laying down a field of wheat.
I walked straight across the room.
It was fifteen steps from the coat rack to the display case. I counted them. My legs did not feel like mine. I took the little key out of my shoe, and my hands were steady, which surprised me, and I slid it into the lock on the case, and turned it. The glass lid lifted on a hinge. I picked up the yellow pencil.
It was warm. Of course it was; it had been under the lamp. It had a small, specific weight, a tiny weight, that was heavier at one end than any pencil should be. I held it in my fist against my skirt. I lowered the lid. I locked it.
I did not run. I walked back around the edge of the crowd, with my head down, and when Juno’s bow screamed up to its final, gutted chord and she stopped, and the room let go a collective breath and began, uncertainly, to laugh, I was already in the women’s room on the lower level, in the end stall, with the door bolted.
It was cold in there. A pipe dripped. I sat on the closed lid with the pencil in both hands and turned it end over end.
It was an ordinary pencil. It had a worn eraser in a tin ferrule. The ferrule was loose. I put my thumbnail under it and the little metal band slid off, and with it, the eraser, and a soft wooden plug came out like a cork.
The pencil was hollow.
It had been drilled, long ago, with great skill, down the whole core of its length. The lead had been removed. In its place lay a tight roll of thin paper, no bigger than a matchstick, and beside it, wedged in, a very small brass key.
It was not the night key. It was shorter, with a square bow, and it had one number stamped into the bow in tiny digits. I held it to the light.
Zero.
I took the roll of paper out with my fingernails and flattened it on my knee. It was a strip of onionskin, two inches wide, and typed. The type dipped, every e of it, in a ragged row. It said, in Professor Edmund Faber’s voice, as clearly as if he were sitting on the stall’s cold floor beside me:
Drawer 0. Not the card. The date.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!