Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 36

Who Else Has the Right

At 2:06 on Saturday afternoon, on the credit union steps, my grandmother says four hundred and six, and Beckett Whitfield, who has a thirty-eight million dollar question and a face like a man holding a full bowl of soup, looks at her as though she has handed him a key.

“I’m not sure I follow, Mrs. Delgado,” he says.

“You asked who else has the right to say yes.” Rosa taps the spoon once more against the rail. “The woman asked it. I am only pointing at the answer. Ambrose wrote a number in his book and then he never said it. You have a number. You have a right. You will do the same thing he did, a nicer way, unless somebody makes you say it out loud to the people it belongs to.”

“Mama,” Rafa says. “It’s four hundred and six people. Half of them are dead.”

“Then ask the half who aren’t.”

Ines, beside me, has the expression she wears when a client has just come up with a better argument than hers. “It is not legally required,” she says. “I want that on the record. A right of first refusal belongs to the holder. Mr. Whitfield may exercise it on his own.”

“I know,” Beckett says. “That’s the problem.”

I look at the road down to the harbor, at the Winifred C. with her bucket, at the five of us on the steps in our coats, and I do what I do for a living. I build a run of show in my head. Friday at 5:00 is the end of the window. Today is Saturday. That is five business days, and a bride would call it a short engagement.

“Sunday,” I say. “The Grange, at four. The Committee, Rafa, Charles, Ferris on the phone if he’s strong enough. Beckett asks. He doesn’t explain why it would be good. He explains what it costs, and what it makes him, and then he sits down and stops talking.”

“That last part will be difficult,” Beckett says.

“I’ll hold your coat.”

He laughs, once, like a man surprised in a doorway. It is the first sound of that kind I’ve heard from him since Wednesday, and Rosa looks at me over his shoulder with the faintest lift of one eyebrow, which I decline to see.

---

At 6:15 that evening, the packet from Halvorsen’s counsel arrives at the Mercantile by courier, which on Pemberton means that Mr. Bray’s nephew drives it down from the ferry in a pickup with the radio on.

It is a manila envelope as thick as a phone book. Under the federal rules of exasperation, a right of first refusal is only as good as the terms you’re offered, so the notice must come with the entire agreement Margaret signed: purchase price, schedules, side letters, the lot. Ines spreads it across my desk in neat piles and sits on the stool with a highlighter. Tomás brings tea nobody drinks.

I take the part she hands me, which is Schedule 4.

It has a title I don’t like. It is RESERVE-RELATED CLAIMS: INDEMNITY AND ESCROW. It says that of the purchase price, $2,100,000 is to be held back for two years against “any claim by or on behalf of any current or former employee of the Whitfield Packing Company, or any trust or fund established for their benefit.”

“Two point one million,” I say. “On top of what the workers are owed.”

“On top of nothing. It’s not for them.” Ines doesn’t look up. “It’s for Halvorsen, in case they come after Margaret. A buyer’s cushion. It’s a very good clause. I’ve drafted it for clients and been proud.”

“Halvorsen priced in the workers.”

“Halvorsen priced in a lawsuit.” She turns a page. “Which is what you do when somebody tells you one is coming.”

I read the front page again. The agreement is dated at the top, in a typeface far too pleased with itself: Executed the 17th day of October.

I count forward on my fingers like a child, from a Friday in the middle of October to the Sunday, sixteen days later, that Charles Whitfield came off the Eleanor W. with a cello case and said he wasn’t sure he’d be allowed to bring anything else.

“Ines.”

“I saw.” She puts the cap on the highlighter very slowly. “The agreement was signed sixteen days before Charles confessed to anyone. Eighteen days before the Courier ran the story. Seventeen days before your phone tree found a single name.”

“Then who told Margaret there would be a claim?”

“That,” says Ines, “is a question I’d love to ask somebody under oath. In the meantime I’ll note that I don’t think Margaret learned this from a newspaper. I think she’s known the reserve existed for years. I think the day Charles got on a boat, she knew what was in it.”

“Known for sixteen years,” says a voice from the doorway, and we all turn.

It is Charles, in his gray cardigan, with a loaf of Rosa’s bread under one arm, which he holds like a man who has been told to hold something and has no idea why. He has been listening. His face has the clean, scrubbed look of someone who has cried all the way through and come out the other side of it.

“She came to the hospital in June of 2009,” he says. “I told you that. I did not tell you what she said to me in the corridor, afterward. She said, ‘Charlie, there is a room in your father’s head that is full of Aldous money. Don’t open it. It isn’t yours either.’” He sets the bread down on my desk, as if it might go off. “I was fifty years old, and I thought she was being kind.”

I decide, on the spot, that I love this man a great deal and will never tell him.

---

At 8:20 I am alone on the Mercantile porch with the sealed copy of Box 212’s inventory in my bag, because Ines said keep it on a person, not a desk, and Beckett comes up the steps in the dark with two paper cups.

“It’s cocoa,” he says. “Tomás said you’d had enough coffee for one week of your life.”

“Tomás is correct, which is irritating.” I take it. “You’ve been on the phone.”

“Dennis Orr.” He sits on the step below mine, his shoulder a hand’s width from my knee. “I told him I may ask him for a bridge facility. I told him I may ask for it on Friday morning. He said, ‘Beckett, there’s a speed at which one does these things, and it isn’t Friday morning.’”

“What did you say?”

“I said I was asking the island first.” He turns the cup. “I’ve been on the other side of this a thousand times, Marnie. I’d call a number, sign a paper and then tell the people who lived there. It’s efficient. It works. I’m good at it.

“And I get to Sunday, and I’m sitting in a Grange hall in front of nine people, and I realize I have never in my life said to anyone the words ‘what would you like me to do with this?’ and meant a real answer.”

“You said them to me. On Wednesday.”

“I did. And you told me to say them out loud.” He looks up. “That’s the problem with you. You’re a very hard person to apologize to, because you have a rule about it.”

“I have several rules.”

“I know. I’ve started keeping a list.” His mouth moves. “Number four is: don’t touch the wedding.”

I laugh, and then I don’t, because the cocoa is hot and the stars are very near and he is looking at me the way he did on Wednesday night when he said someday and then asked whether I minded him knowing.

“There’s no wedding,” I say. “I’d like it noted. I’m saying that for both of us.”

“Noted.” He takes a sip. “Tomorrow, whatever they say, I’m going to do it. If they say don’t, I won’t. And if they say yes, I’ll be the largest shareholder of a company that spent forty years taking money from the people I’m asking permission of. I’d like you to be there. I’d like you to say it to me if it’s wrong.”

“You always get that.”

“I’d like to get it in public,” Beckett says.

---

At 4:00 on Sunday, the Pemberton Grange Hall holds forty-one people, and it smells like radiators, wet wool and the stale metallic cheer of the coffee urn.

I did not plan on forty-one. I planned on nine. The nine are in the front row, in the folding chairs: Mrs. Pham with her handbag on her knee, Dale Cobb in his good flannel, Linda Szabo with her arms crossed, Anselm Terrio, who keeps the Committee’s books and counts everything twice, and five others whose names I have learned over six days and would now defend in court.

Behind them the rest of the hall has filled up the way an island fills a room, which is to say quietly and then all at once. Ferris is on speakerphone from Rockland, on the folding table, propped against a napkin dispenser.

Beckett stands. Rosa has put him there. He isn’t allowed a podium.

“I’ll say what it costs first,” he says. “Thirty-eight million, six hundred thousand dollars. I can pay it. I’ll have to pledge most of what I own, and I’ll have to borrow against the rest, and for some years I’ll be what people in my business call leveraged, and what my mother calls a fool.”

A couple of people laugh. He waits.

“If I exercise the right, Halvorsen doesn’t get the block. Margaret doesn’t sell. I become the largest owner of Whitfield Holdings, thirty-one point nine percent, and I take a block with the workers’ lien already stamped on it, which means on December fifteenth I’m sitting on the other side of the table from you.”

“Which side is that?” says Linda.

“The side of the one who owes you.”

The hall is quiet. Linda doesn’t uncross her arms.

“Here’s what I’m asking,” Beckett says. “I’m not asking you to approve the money. It’s mine to spend or waste. I’m asking whether, if I do this, you want me to. I don’t want to buy a thing that’s yours without being asked. I also don’t want to let it go because I was too polite.”

He sits. It takes him about as long as it takes to lower a very full glass. Beside me, Rosa lets out the smallest breath.

Linda stands up.

“I’ll say it,” she says. “Somebody should. If he buys that block, then the debt isn’t Margaret’s anymore. It’s Beckett’s. And he is a nice man, I’ve eaten his casserole, and he owes us nothing but his name, and my mother sorted fish on that floor for thirteen summers and never saw a dime of it. You will own the debt. You’ll own the lien. And the day it suits you, Mr. Whitfield, you’ll settle it for a number a lawyer likes.”

“Linda,” Mrs. Pham says.

“No. I mean it.” She turns, and she is crying a little with her chin up, which is the most dangerous way. “I don’t dislike you. I think you’d be fair. I think you’d be fair until you weren’t, and I think that’s what the whole island has had from this family for forty years. A fair man with a good reason.”

Nobody argues. I want to, badly, and Beckett’s hand moves on his knee in a way that says he knows it and is holding the other end.

“Yes,” he says, from his chair. “That’s the right objection. I’d like to know how to answer it.”

“You can’t,” says Linda. “That’s what I’m saying.”

“Then maybe it isn’t mine to answer.” Beckett stands again. “Maybe I should ask what would make it safe.”

It is, I think, the best thing I’ve ever seen anyone do in a folding chair.

---

At 5:10, the Committee votes by paper, because Anselm Terrio will not tolerate raised hands. The slips go into Mrs. Pham’s handbag. She shakes it, an unnecessary gesture she appears to enjoy.

It takes forty minutes of argument, mostly about conditions, and then eleven of them in a row from Mr. Terrio, who writes them on the back of a bingo card.

First, the Committee gets its own lawyer, not Ines, who is Beckett’s. Rafa knows a woman in Portland, Priscilla Amadi, who fought the credit union over a foreclosure in 2012 and won, and who will take the job for the usual hourly rate and an unusual amount of scorn.

Second, Beckett does not negotiate any settlement of the Reserve claim while he holds the block. Not a dollar, not a deadline. Priscilla Amadi speaks for the claimants. Beckett’s lawyers stand outside the room.

Third, the shares carry the vote of the people. Whatever the 406 decide at the hearing, Beckett’s block votes the same way. He signs it. He signs it before he closes.

And fourth, because my grandmother has been sitting through all of it with her spoon across her knee and her mouth in a flat line, the one that decides the matter.

“No,” says Rosa.

The hall turns to her.

“Not nine.” She doesn’t stand. She never stands for these. “Nine people are not four hundred and six. Ambrose put the money in the hands of three. I will not have it put into nine. Ask every one.”

“Mama,” says Rafa, very gently. “It’s three days.”

“The tree is already made. You made it last week.” She looks at me. “She made it. Ring them.”

I do the arithmetic aloud, because I can’t help it. “A ballot. Every name on Rafa’s list and every name on the summer list that’s still alive and findable, by phone, by door, by whatever Mrs. Pham says. Close Wednesday at five. That’s two days before the window closes.”

“Thursday for notice and Friday for the paper,” says Ines, writing. “It’s tight.”

“It’s four hundred and six,” says Rosa.

The Committee votes on that, too. It is six to three, with Linda, Dale and Mr. Terrio against, and for reasons I could have guessed: Dale says he won’t ask a man to buy a thing his own mother’s name is on, and Terrio says a ballot is a mess and a count is a count. Linda says nothing. Her slip says NO in block capitals, and she puts her coat on before the tally is read.

“It’s yes,” Mrs. Pham says at last, and sits down. “On our terms. If the people say no, he does not buy. If the people say yes, he buys, and he is our servant until he sells it back.”

Beckett has stayed in his chair with his hands open on his knees. “Thank you,” he says. “I’ll sign all four.”

“Don’t thank us,” says Mrs. Pham. “You haven’t paid anything yet.”

---

At 7:48, on the pickup’s tailgate outside the Grange, I find Linda alone in the dark with her hands in her armpits.

“I wasn’t going to apologize,” she says.

“Good. I wasn’t going to ask for it.”

“I want him to.” She’s looking at the harbor. “I want him to win and I want him to be careful and I think those might be different men. My mother would have liked him. She’d have told him his tie was crooked and fed him. She never got a single envelope from anyone, you know. Not even a lie.”

“She’s on the list. Page 41.”

“I know where she is.” Linda wipes her nose on her sleeve. “Are you sure about him?”

It is the real question. I’ve been circling it all week in the shape of other questions: what he owns, what he’d do, whether the man I hired for a weekend could be the man who signs a paper that gives the island a veto over his own money.

“No,” I say. “I’m sure he asked.”

Linda nods slowly, as if that is a more sensible answer than the one she’d wanted. “That’s a start. That’s what’s missing from everyone else.” She pushes off the tailgate. “I’ll call my mother’s friends tomorrow. The ones who didn’t want to talk. They don’t like it when you call. They like it when you come.”

“Then I’ll drive.”

“You’ll get lost. Take Mrs. Pham.” She stops at the edge of the light. “And Marnie. Margaret’s agreement. The one you found. The October date. I heard Ines on the phone.”

“You weren’t supposed to.”

“I’m a dental hygienist. I’m very good at hearing through a closed mouth.” She almost smiles. “She signed it before Charles ever got off the boat. So somebody called her. Somebody called her before the island knew a single thing.”

“Yes.”

“I’d find out who,” says Linda Szabo, and goes to her car.

At 8:15 I check my phone in the dark. There’s a message from a number I don’t know, a Portland area code, and it’s four words long.

Ask Margaret about June.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!