Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 60

The Snapshot

Priscilla Amadi takes the news the way a surgeon takes a dropped instrument, with no sound at all, and a very small movement of the hand toward the next one.

She is in Courtroom 4 with her red pen still in her hair, packing the exhibit binder while Frye and the clerk argue gently about the order of the cart. I give her the phone. She reads three lines. She looks at the clock over the door, which says 4:19, and says, “Ines. Who has the hospital’s general counsel?”

“Nobody has her. She’s on a plane to Phoenix.” Ines is already walking. “But somebody has her deputy, and somebody has the privacy officer, and I know where the privacy officer parks.”

“How do you know where the privacy officer parks?”

“Because I read the deposition notice,” says Ines, “and because I’m a woman who reads the whole thing.”

It’s a pattern I’ve begun to recognize in my lawyers. They do not hurry. They get quieter and more exact, as though speed were a sort of noise, and the faster the clock runs, the more slowly they put on their coats.

At 4:22 Priscilla is on the phone with Justice Ouellette’s clerk, who has a name that I’m told is Mr. Dewar and who sounds, over the speaker, like a man holding a plate of something he has been told not to drop.

At 4:24 Frye, who has not hurried since the Carter administration, takes off his white gloves, puts them in an envelope, signs across the flap, and walks down the corridor to the elevator at a pace that I can only describe as a funeral for a man who is late. At 4:26 Rosa appears at my elbow with her handbag and says, “Where are we going?”

“Abuela, you should rest.”

“I have been resting since 2009. Where are we going?”

I look at Ines. Ines looks at Priscilla. Priscilla shrugs, which in a lawyer is a signed consent.

“The hospital,” says Ines. “Rockland. It’s an hour and ten if I drive.”

“You will drive,” says my grandmother, “like a person who has had her tea.”

---

She doesn’t. Ines drives Route 1 in the dark and the first light snow like a woman running from an unpaid bill, and I sit in the back with Rosa’s hand in mine and my phone on my knee, and the road goes by in gray ribbons, past closed clam shacks and a lit church sign that says WINTER HOURS and a long white field with a single orange cone in the middle of it, for no reason.

Rosa asks, somewhere past Damariscotta, whether anyone has eaten, and when nobody answers she opens her handbag and produces four wrapped sandwiches of queso and ham on Pham’s Bakery paper, which she has been carrying since the courthouse, in case.

Ines eats hers with one hand on the wheel. Priscilla eats hers without looking at it. I hold mine in my lap and watch the snow come toward the glass and part around it, and think that a person could spend her whole working life learning to run a room, and still be undone by a woman who thought, at noon, to pack for the evening.

“Eat,” says my grandmother, without turning around. “You’re counting again.”

“I’m not counting.”

“You are moving your lips. It is the same face you made at nine, when you did the sums for my register.” She faces forward again. “Whatever is at the hospital will be there or it won’t. A sandwich will be a sandwich either way.”

I eat the sandwich. It is, annoyingly, exactly what I needed.

At 5:01 Ms. Pellerin calls Priscilla back on speaker, and her voice is the voice of a woman who has been crying in a stairwell and has just washed her face.

“I locked it,” she says. “I’m sorry. I couldn’t lock it all. I turned off the session, but whoever it was had already changed the count. I didn’t know how to put it back.”

“You don’t have to put it back,” says Priscilla. “You just have to tell me whether the system keeps a copy of what it was before.”

“It keeps everything. It’s a hospital. Everything is audited. Every time somebody opens a record, or changes one, there’s a line. It’s called the audit trail.” A pause. “But I can’t read it. I’m only a records clerk. I have the Records office key because the director retired and nobody asked for it back.”

“Who can read it?”

“Mr. Pagano. In IT. He lives in Thomaston and he’s at his daughter’s basketball game, and he doesn’t answer on Fridays.”

“Ms. Pellerin,” says Ines, leaning toward the speaker without taking her eyes off the road, “is there anything in your life that you would rather do tonight than make Mr. Pagano answer his phone?”

A silence. Then, in a voice with an edge on it I’d never have guessed at: “I’ll go and find the gym.”

---

The privacy officer is named Imani Boyce, and she meets us at the hospital’s side entrance at 6:10 in a puffy blue coat over a cocktail dress, with her car keys in her fist.

“I was at a retirement party,” she says. “I was holding a plate. I’m told I’m to open the Records office at the direction of a Superior Court, and I’d like to see the order before I take off my shoes.”

Priscilla has the order. It’s four paragraphs and a signature, emailed from the clerk at 5:44, and printed in the hotel business center of the Rockland Days Inn by a night clerk who read it as she went. Boyce reads it twice. She takes a long breath through her nose.

“This isn’t the way things are done,” she says.

“No,” says Ines. “It’s the way they’re done when a retired physician’s password starts editing the chart of a man who died in 2009.”

Boyce looks at her. Then she turns and unlocks the door.

The Records office is a long low room full of gray cabinets, with a single dim lamp in the corner and a smell of toner and old carpet. Ms. Pellerin is there already, in a gray cardigan, standing guard at a computer with her lunch bag still on the desk beside it like a sentry.

And next to her, in a Camden Hills basketball sweatshirt with a lanyard around his neck and the expression of a man who has been dragged out of a good game, is a thin gray-bearded person who must be Mr. Pagano.

“Don’t talk to me,” he says. “I’m not sorry. I’m going to look at it and then I’m going to go back and watch the fourth quarter.”

“We’d be grateful,” says Priscilla.

“I don’t care if you’re grateful. I care if somebody’s using a dead man’s login. That’s my whole life.” He sits down and cracks his knuckles, a gesture I’d thought only happened in movies. “Give me the patient.”

“Aldous, Hollis J.,” says Boyce. “Medical record number eight, four, one, seven, two.”

He types. Nothing happens for a very long time, and then a great many things happen at once, in a column of small gray text that scrolls up the screen like the credits of a film I’m not going to enjoy.

“Okay,” says Mr. Pagano, in a voice that changes. “Okay. Well. Somebody’s been busy.”

---

I don’t understand most of it. I understand the shape, the way you understand the shape of a storm from a window.

There’s a log, he says, of every touch. There’s a line for eleven pages, entered under the heading of *Scanned Document,* on the twenty-fifth of November, at 1:12 in the morning, under a user named *aseavey.* A line for the page count going from three hundred and ninety-eight to four hundred and nine at the same minute. A line for the count going from four hundred and nine to four hundred and eleven at 4:12 this afternoon, under the same user.

And a third line, which he reads out slowly, as though it embarrassed him.

“Source address,” he says. “That’s where the connection came from. It isn’t the Rockland VPN. It’s a hotel Wi-Fi. A chain. The log has the hotel’s address block. It’s, ah.” He squints. “It resolves to the Residence Inn at the Portland Jetport. There’s a room number, because they bill by room.”

“Which room?” says Ines.

“Three-fourteen.”

Nobody says anything. In the corner of the room Ms. Pellerin has put a hand over her mouth.

“Deputy Rennie,” I say. “He said the van was in the garage and the ticket was never scanned. He said he wasn’t at the hotel.”

“He said he wasn’t at the *Hampton,*” says Ines. “The one on Congress Street. The one on his booking.” She is already dialing. “Nobody ever said the Residence Inn.”

It’s 6:37. On the other end of the line, a deputy with a calm slow voice says that he’s in Westbrook on a different matter, that he’s sorry, that he’ll send two cars. Ines puts the phone down and looks at me over a stack of gray folders.

“Marnie,” she says. “He’s *still there.* He doesn’t know we know. He changed it from the same hotel room, from the same laptop, at 4:12, because he thought he had until midnight.”

“And Pagano’s log has the old count?”

“The log has everything.” She turns to the screen. “Mr. Pagano. I’d like you to tell the Court something under oath, tomorrow, in a courtroom, in front of everyone. I’d like you to tell the Court what that count was on the twenty-fourth.”

“Three ninety-eight,” says Mr. Pagano, not looking away from the screen. “And on the twenty-fifth at one-twelve in the morning it was four-oh-nine, because the first batch he logged was eleven pages. The last two sheets sat in the box, unlogged, until four-twelve today, which is why the paper chart and the index never matched. That’s the sort of thing a person can’t do cleanly.

“Every time you edit a record, the system takes a snapshot of what it looked like the moment before. I’ve got eleven of them. I’ve got every version of that index since he opened it.”

“A snapshot,” says Rosa, in a voice like the first note of a bell.

“Yes, ma’am.”

“It’s a photograph of what he did.”

“It’s a photograph of what he did *before* he did it, ma’am. That’s the part they never think about.”

My grandmother looks at me, small and upright in her black coat, in a room full of gray cabinets, and nods once, the way she nods when a delivery is right.

---

The deputies take Room 314 at 7:48.

I know the time because Ines is holding the phone like a chalice, in the corridor outside the Records office with her back to the wall, and because she holds up one finger. Then two. Then she says, “Say that again,” and then, in a very odd voice, “Yes, we’d like that held for the master.”

She lowers the phone.

“He was there. Alone. Kevin Dunne, in a bathrobe, at the desk, with a laptop and a tin of cashews.” She says it flatly, as if she’s forced herself to go over each word. “He didn’t run. He closed the computer, and said, *Ah.* And then he said he’d like to speak to counsel, and sat down on the bed with his hands on his knees, like a boy who’s been called to the office.”

“And Dalton?”

“There’s no Dalton. There’s a second keycard. A woman’s, from the lobby, a green coat.” Ines’s mouth moves. “She signed for it at noon. The coat’s in the closet. The woman isn’t.”

“The woman in the corridor,” I say. “Who stood next to him this morning.”

“I don’t know that, yet. We’ll know tonight.” She breathes. “They’ve bagged the laptop. They have to get a warrant for the contents, and there’ll be three days of motions, but the laptop’s in a bag with a seal on it, and it’s in the deputy’s trunk, and Mr. Pagano’s log is in this building, and it says what it says.”

I realize I’m leaning against the wall, because the wall is there.

“Marnie,” says Priscilla, coming up with the red pen finally out of her hair and in her hand. “There’s a thing you should know. It isn’t a victory. The Court may not rule on the pages for weeks, and the ruling may be that thirteen forged pages are a forgery by a person, not by Holdings. Marsh will say Holdings never knew. Dalton is gone, and Dunne is a vendor.”

“I know.”

“What this gets us is the truth, and a judge who’d like to be told it.”

“That’s all I’ve asked for since September.”

“I know. That’s the part that’s usually the hardest to deliver.” She puts a hand briefly on my shoulder, a light, practical weight, like a tradesperson testing a wall. “Go home. Sleep. We’ll be at the courthouse at eight.”

“It’s a hundred miles.”

“Then sleep in the car,” says Rosa. “I’ll sit in front. I’ll tell Ines what’s wrong with her driving.”

---

We’re on Route 1 at 9:20, in the dark, with the snow come on again in a fine loose scarf across the headlights, and my grandmother is asleep in the front seat with her chin on her coat collar and her handbag in both hands. Ines drives slowly now. Priscilla is in the back beside me, working on three phones.

My own phone has been buzzing against my knee for a quarter of an hour. I turn it over. There are eleven messages from Tomas, nine from Mrs. Pham, one from Rafa that is only a photograph of the Grange hall stove with the words *it’s lit.*

And one, at the bottom, at 9:14, from a number I know by heart and have not used.

*Can you talk? I’m in the truck. I don’t need you to say anything.*

I look at Priscilla. She doesn’t look up from her phone. “I haven’t seen a thing,” she says, “and I don’t have a thing to say. Take the call.”

I take it. I turn to the window, with the dark and the snow on the other side of the glass, and put the phone to my ear.

For a while there’s only an engine on the other end, and the tick of a turn signal, and wind.

“I called her,” says Beckett.

“When?”

“Six-thirty. Arizona time, it’s four-thirty. She picks up before noon on no day of the week, as far as I know, and she picked up on the second ring.” His voice is very even and very careful, as if he were carrying it a long way in a bowl. “I said, *Mom, it’s Beck.* I said, *I’m sorry to call you on a Friday.* She said, *I wondered how long it would take.*”

“Beckett.”

“I haven’t asked her anything. I told you I’d tell you first, so I’m telling you first. I said I’d like to come out. She said, *Not on the phone.* She said it twice. She said, *Don’t let Charles be the one to tell you. Come and hear it from me.*” He breathes. “That’s all. That’s the entire call. It was fifty seconds.”

“I’ll go with you.”

“I didn’t ask.”

“I know you didn’t.” I put my forehead against the cold glass. “I’m saying it anyway. I can hold a bag.”

He makes a sound that is partly a laugh and partly something that isn’t, and then it stops, and there’s the tick of the turn signal, and the long white sound of tires on wet road.

“There’s one more thing,” he says, more quietly. “Ines called me. About the hotel. I asked her whether she’d seen the laptop’s lock screen, because Deputy Rennie texted a photograph to our counsel and I wanted to know if it was true.”

“What was on the lock screen?”

“A wallpaper.” He pauses. “A map. A very ordinary map, in blue and green, of the whole eastern seaboard, with sixty or seventy small red dots on it, and the name of a company at the top that I don’t know. It said *Phase Two.* And across the center, over Maine, in the same careful hand as the return address on the storage unit, somebody had written, *Whitfield Holdings, Special Meeting, Jan. 12. 51%.*”

I sit up. Beside me, Priscilla has stopped typing.

“They never wanted the Aldous block,” I say slowly. “That was the *door.*”

“I think the Aldous block was the *key,*” says Beckett. “I think someone has spent a year working out which doors it opens. And I think I have thirty-eight days to find out which ones are left.”

Outside the window the snow comes down on the dark sea of the fields. In the front seat my grandmother makes a small sound in her sleep and says, quite clearly, a name that I have never once heard her say.

It’s *Ambrose.*

It’s 9:43. The meeting is on the twelfth of January, and I’ve never been so tired, or so awake.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!