I put the peach can back on the Voss windowsill at six in the morning, exactly where it was, and I do not sleep a minute of the rest of the night.
That is not strictly true. I sleep forty minutes, upright in the corner chair, with my father’s coat over my chest. I wake because Receipt is sitting on my feet. Gray light is coming through the kitchen window, and for one dizzy second I think the cans on the sill are people.
I wash my cup. I set the chair back where the Vosses keep it. I check the floor for the splash of anything I might have dropped, and in the pantry I check the three cans and the little pile of flattened labels, which have not moved. I turn the bolt on the mudroom door back to the position it was in when I arrived, thrown but not caught.
Then I take the green logbook out of my coat and write in it, in my slanting running-for-the-bus hand.
Sunday night, 31, Gerrity. Heat 50. Shutoff closed. Roof clear. Nothing to report.
It looks like every other line in the book. That’s the point of a lie. It should look like the weather.
At ten fifty-eight on Monday morning I’m sitting in the truck at the foot of the Hartnell driveway with two keys on my palm.
One of them is my father’s. One of them has a letter B cut into it. They open the same lock, and I can’t think of a single honest reason for a lock to have two keys when the man who guarded the locks had a rule against it.
I put the new one in my left pocket. I hold the old one by its tag, the paper soft as cloth from my father’s thumb and mine.
The silver sedan turns off Loop Road and pulls up beside me, exactly on time.
“Nika. Thank you for this.” Rex Hartnell gets out in the same fleece vest and a pair of shiny loafers that have no business on a snow-packed drive. He’s holding a clipboard. He pushes his glasses up his nose. “I tried to wear boots. I couldn’t find them.”
“It’s fine.”
“Greta would have.” He looks up the drive. “Greta would have had a bin for them.”
Number seventeen sits on a rise above the water, two stories of silvering cedar with a wraparound deck, a screened boathouse, and a view of the lake that probably cost more than my father earned in a decade. A flagpole stands beside the garage with no flag. In summer the porch has a swing and eleven window boxes. Now the boxes hold gray stalks, and the swing has been unhooked and leaned against the rail.
The path to the front door is a clean white ribbon. I plowed it by hand last Thursday, when I did the walk-around, because the board likes to see the walks clear.
I put the key in the lock. It turns the way a key turns in a house that has been kept up by somebody who cared. Smooth. Almost silent.
“Wait,” Rex says, behind me. “Let me.”
I step aside. He pushes the door open himself, as if he has to be first, and I follow him into a front hall that smells of lemon polish and cold.
The first thing I notice is the labels.
They’re everywhere. Greta Hartnell ran the potluck sign-up sheet for the Association for eleven years, and she ran her house the same way. A strip of white tape on every coat hook. SPARE KEYS on a little brass box by the door. GAMES on a wicker trunk. In the kitchen, on a row of glass jars, the same neat black label-maker print: FLOUR, SUGAR, DARK SUGAR, OATS.
I stand in her kitchen and a pang goes through me that I wasn’t ready for. I never met the woman more than a dozen times. She was brisk and kind and wore her hair in a clip. She brought my father a loaf of banana bread every Christmas and always asked if I was eating. But I know, standing here, that she was a person who knew where everything was.
“Pipes,” Rex says. “That’s the thing.”
“Right.”
I take him through it. Thermostat, which reads fifty. Main shutoff, which I closed in October. The pressure tank, the heat tape, the line to the boathouse, all things I’ve done every week for thirteen weeks and I narrate them to him in my caretaker’s voice, the low flat voice my father used.
Rex nods at everything. He doesn’t write a word down. His clipboard hangs loose from one hand like a thing he picked up on his way out of a meeting.
“You do this every week,” he says.
“Every week.”
“Even though nobody’s here.”
“That’s what the board pays for.”
“Ah.” He walks to the kitchen window and looks out at the lake. “I’d forgotten that.”
His reflection in the glass is a pale shape with a gray ring around its eyes. I look at him a little longer than I should.
Rex is a man who spent thirty years finding out why people were not telling the truth. He ought to be good at it himself. But I’ve known him since I was twelve, and I have never seen him keep a secret without his hand going to his glasses. It goes there now. He pushes them up. He doesn’t need to.
“The note,” I say.
His hand stops.
“I’m sorry?”
“Greta’s note. I never saw it. I was in Milwaukee. Everybody talks about it, but I never knew what it said.”
For a moment I think he won’t answer. Then he takes a breath and lets it go.
“It said she needed time. That she was sorry. That she’d call.” He speaks to the window. “She didn’t call.”
“Did you keep it?”
“The sheriff has it. Well. The county does. I went in, in January. I thought they should have it.” He pushes his glasses up again. “They said it wasn’t a crime to leave your husband.”
“No.”
“No.” He turns around. “Let’s do the upstairs.”
The stairs are carpeted and the third step creaks. I’d forgotten about that step, and I know it only because my father mentioned once, in the course of explaining the whole house, that Greta Hartnell could always tell when somebody was coming up before they reached the landing.
The upstairs hall has three bedrooms and a bathroom, and the door to the biggest bedroom is open. The bed is made. There’s a sweater folded over the chair. On the nightstand sit a pair of reading glasses and a paperback with a bookmark about two-thirds of the way through.
Rex stays in the doorway. He doesn’t come in.
“I haven’t changed anything,” he says. “I couldn’t.”
“I understand.”
“Can you do the bathroom? I’m no good with toilets.”
It’s such a small, plain request that I walk past him without thinking and open the bathroom door.
White tile, a clawfoot tub, a window facing the lake. A neat wicker basket of folded towels. On the counter beside the sink, a toothbrush in a glass.
And next to the toothbrush, a small orange bottle.
I don’t pick it up. I read it where it stands, bending at the waist, the way you read a grave marker. The label is clean and printed in a pharmacy’s tidy font.
GRETA A. HARTNELL. METOPROLOL TARTRATE 50 MG. Take one tablet by mouth twice daily. The fill date is the second of December. The quantity is sixty. It’s the kind of pill you take if your heart has been sending you warnings.
I give the bottle a gentle tilt with one finger. It rattles, heavily, with a shape inside it like a full handful of rice.
Fifty-eight pills. Maybe more.
She filled this twelve days before she left. She took two of them, maybe. And then she walked out of her house and went off to a desert without them.
“Rex,” I say. “She left her heart pills.”
I hear him breathe in the doorway, behind me. I hear his weight shift from one loafer to the other.
“Yes,” he says.
I turn around. He’s standing very straight with the clipboard against his chest, and his face has gone smooth, the way a face does when it has been told what to do with itself.
“She’d stopped taking them,” he says. “Last fall. She said they made her tired. She said they made her feel like a person who was already old. She had a doctor at the county seat who said she could try without.”
It’s a good answer. It’s smooth and complete and has a small, convincing detail in the middle of it. But it’s the way he says it, at an even pace, with all the stresses where a stress belongs, as if he’s said it before and been told it was fine.
Rex adjusts his glasses.
“She never took them with her,” I say, carefully, “because she’d stopped.”
“Yes.”
“And she wouldn’t have forgotten something she’d stopped taking.”
“That’s what I’m telling you.” He clears his throat. “I’d rather you didn’t mention it. To anyone. There’s an insurance matter, if someone ever declares her. It’s complicated.”
“I’m not going to mention it.”
“Thank you.” He takes a long, shaky breath. “I think I’ll wait in the car. You do the basement. You don’t need me for the basement.”
He goes down the stairs, and the third step creaks under his loafers. I stand in the bathroom, looking at an orange bottle with my fingertips cold, and I listen to the front door open and close.
I check the rest of the upstairs, because that’s what I’m paid to do. Then I go down through the kitchen and into the attached garage, because the garage is on my list, and because I need a minute alone before I do anything with my face.
The garage is cold and smells of rubber and old oil. A two-bay, with one bay holding a rack of canoe paddles and a pair of snowshoes, and the other holding a small green hatchback with a roof rack and a bumper sticker for a public radio station.
Greta’s car.
It’s been sitting for a year. A fine gray fur of dust lies on the hood, and a long dry leaf has blown in under the door and stuck to the windshield wiper. The tires are soft. The inside of the windshield has a faint bloom of mildew in one corner.
I don’t open the door. I stand at the driver’s window with my light angled low and look in.
An airport parking stub sits in the cupholder. A pair of sunglasses on the dash. A phone charger cord plugged into the lighter and coiled on the passenger seat like something asleep.
Greta Hartnell was five foot three. I know because I stood next to her once at a funeral lunch, and she had to tilt her head up to tell me to eat something. A short woman sits close to the wheel. She keeps the seat all the way forward, with her chin nearly over the dash, and she pulls the mirror down with it.
The driver’s seat in the green hatchback is pushed back as far as it will go.
I put my face closer to the glass. The mirror is tilted high. There’s about a foot of empty space between the pedals and the seat’s front edge, and a gap above the wheel that would fit a basketball.
Somebody tall drove this car last.
I stay there, with my forehead almost on the window, until the cold from the glass reaches the bone. Then I straighten and breathe out, and my breath makes a little cloud and fades.
It doesn’t mean anything. A mechanic could have moved the seat. A friend could have driven her to the airport. Rex himself, who is five foot ten, might have sat in it and pushed the seat back to think.
But there’s the parking stub. An airport parking stub in a car that didn’t go to the airport.
I read the date on it, and then I read it again, because I don’t want to be right.
It’s dated the ninth of December. Five days before she disappeared. Greta Hartnell parked at the airport and came home. She did not leave from it. If she took a flight, she did it from some other lot, in some other car, and nobody has ever said so.
I take out the green logbook, and in the margin of the page for number seventeen, in tiny pencil, I write a single word.
Seat.
Then I scratch it out, because I’m a woman who doesn’t leave notes, and I write it again, smaller, where I can read it and nobody else can.
Then I go down to the basement.
The basement of number seventeen is the best-kept basement on the lake. Concrete floor, painted gray. A workbench with a pegboard of tools outlined in marker so you could tell at a glance what was missing. A freezer chest. A furnace, a water heater, a sump pit in the corner with a plastic cover and a battery-backed pump.
I check them all. The pump alarm is a small gray box with a green light, and the light is green. I slide the cover off the pit with my foot and look down into black water, a foot below the lip, perfectly still.
I’m about to slide it back when I see the door.
It’s in the north wall, behind the water heater, and it’s the only thing in the basement that isn’t labeled. A low square panel of plywood painted the same gray as the wall, hinged on one side with a hook and eye on the other. It’s the hatch to the crawl space under the sunroom. My father and I opened it once in the spring, together, when Greta asked us to check for mice.
I crouch beside it with my headlamp.
The hook is in the eye. But the paint around the edge of the plywood has been rubbed pale in a long clean curve, the way paint wears when a panel is opened and closed a few times a week. Down at the bottom, where the plywood meets the floor, there are two thin dark lines in the dust.
Drag marks. Something narrow was slid in or out, over and over.
Cold touches the back of my neck.
I don’t open the hatch. I stay on one knee with the light very steady and my hand flat on the cold concrete, and I feel something I haven’t felt since I was a child lying awake at the top of a dark stair. The sure knowledge that behind a thin wall, someone is awake.
“Anyone there?” I say.
My voice is smaller than I intended. It goes out into the basement and falls.
Nothing answers. The furnace ticks. Somewhere above me a floorboard shifts with the quiet creak of a house settling in the cold.
I stand up slowly. I put the light on the hatch one more time, and I see that the hook-and-eye has been wrapped with a piece of red plastic.
A cable tie. Bright red. Looped through the eye and pulled tight, with the flat tab at the end bent over.
There’s writing on the tab in black marker. Four small square capitals.
12/19.
It’s my father’s handwriting. It’s the mark he made on every door he had checked, and every door he wanted the next visit to find unchanged. I’ve seen it a hundred times. I’ve done it myself.
But my father cut and replaced his ties every week. He never let one stand through a second visit, unless he wanted something proved.
Nobody has cut this one in almost a year.
Which means the hatch has not been opened by this door since the nineteenth of December, five days after Greta Hartnell walked out of this house for good.
I stand there, with the light on four numbers, and the thought comes into the room and sits down beside me.
Somebody is using the crawl space. They are not using the door.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!