Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 40

Surety

Calder tells me the hour at 11:40 on Saturday night, which is not a time I would have chosen for a man to tell me anything.

We are on the Justice Hall’s back step, in the cold, under a sky with more stars in it than I have seen all fall. The drought has not broken, but a high wind has scoured the smoke out of the valley, and the Hall’s scraped windows throw a faint gold bar across the weeds.

Inside, the benches are filling. I can hear the long low murmur of the Moot arriving, the stamp of boots, a dozen voices saying a name and a dozen more not saying it.

“I have decided,” says Calder.

His cast is gray with dust. He holds his arm against his ribs as if it belonged to someone he was escorting.

“About the drawer?”

“About the hour.” He does not look at me. He looks at the door, which is behind us, and at the two windows on the side wall, and I wait for the counting. It does not come. He simply stands there, a big man in a good coat with nothing to count, and says: “After this sitting.

Not before. If I open it tonight I will carry it into that room, and I will not be able to tell whether what I do in there is a thing I choose or a thing that was handed to me. I would like to walk into the Hall with only what is mine.”

“That’s not a withholding.”

“No.”

“That is a reason.”

“It is the first one I have ever given you in advance,” says Calder. “I find it is very much harder than the other kind.” He turns then, and the amber is not in his eyes at all. They are ordinary dark eyes, tired and frank. “Is it enough?”

“It will have to be.”

I hear what I have said. It is Margo’s phrase, the one she said to him on the afternoon of the second of October. Is that enough? It will have to be. I watch him hear it too, and watch it not hurt.

“Noted,” says Calder, quietly.

“Noted,” I say.

We go in together.

---

The Hall at one in the morning is as I first knew it, a dark vaulted cavern under the long lamps, with the planked floor and the pressed-tin ceiling lost in shadow and the windows black again, because Truitt has had the paint scraped from them but the night has put the dark back. Judge Hickory sits on his bench with his brass eye turned to the room. I do not look at him. I am, at this moment, afraid of what I might remember.

There are a hundred and four wolves tonight. There is also a woman in a green cardigan, sitting in the front pew with a paper bag of candies in her lap and a county deputy on either side. And Emmett Lark, in a borrowed shirt, who has not slept, and who raises his hand to me from the third row with an expression of the purest gratitude and terror, like a man at the rail of a ship.

At the long table, Penhallow is in lavender. Truitt is in his brown suit, with a gavel of bone, glued, wound with black tape, which he holds like a man holding a sparrow. To his right Nell has set her machine beside mine. Nobody remarks on it now.

I take my seat. I open the lid of Constance. I lay my hands on the keys, and she comes up into them at once like a creature that has slept a very long time in a cold room and has just been brought a blanket.

“Order,” says Truitt. “This sitting of the Moot of the Sable is convened to hear the Matter of the Impounded Water, to continue, and the Matter of the Lender, which is new. The Advocate-General.”

Penhallow rises. Her cameo catches the lamp.

“Speaker. I put two facts before the Moot, both established in the Court of Common Pleas of Marlow County, which this Moot has long accepted as the voice of the human law.” She lays a paper on the table.

“First, that Imogen Rook, Chair of the Concord, died on the night of the tenth of April 1987, and has been dead for thirty-nine years. Second, that every instruction since then attributed to the Chair was given by a clerk, Ilse Barrow, on the sole authority of a card from a Lender whose name no one has been able to read.”

A sound goes through the benches, like wind in a field.

“The Concord,” says Penhallow, “is a dead woman and a telephone. I say it as a woman who has retained for it, in my time, at some expense. I withdraw my appearance. I would like it entered that I have been, for thirty years, a very well-paid fool.”

“Entered,” says Truitt.

“Then the Moot will call Mr. Dane Kessler.”

---

He comes forward from the front pew on the left without being touched.

Kessler is a large man in his fifties with a barber’s haircut and a sheepskin collar, and tonight he has dressed for a funeral. He has shaved so closely that he has cut himself. Behind him the benches of Kessler Ridge are quiet. I look for the faces I know. The woman with the set jaw.

The two men who looked down. Lucinda Marrow, thin as a candle in the second row, with two Wardens, and her hands folded as if they were not hers. And, at the end of the pew, in a clean white shirt and a gray beard, with his scarred forearms bare and his hands open on his knees, sits Bram Okafor.

He has come back. The Ridge has let him sit.

Kessler takes the well. He lays one hand on the brass rail and stops, and looks, for a long moment, at Constance. He has not stood this near her since the night he could not shift. I see him measure the distance between his hand and the tape, and I see him decide, with an effort that shows in the muscles of his jaw, not to step back.

“With respect, Ms. Daly,” says Dane Kessler.

“Mr. Kessler. You are not sworn.”

“I am prepared to be.”

“Then I’ll put the oath as you would hear it. It is a short oath. You say the true thing. The machine says whether it was true.” I take a breath. “Mr. Kessler, I am going to ask you four questions. I will not ask you a fifth. I am asking in my own voice, as the Scribe, on my own motion, under the Matter of the Lender. Do you understand?”

“I understand.”

“Do you consent that what you answer be taken down?”

“I do.”

The tape feeds smoothly. Cream. I do not look at it. I look at him.

“First. Did you, in September, instruct Ridgeline Timber and Haul to cut a ditch to the quarry?”

“I did.”

Cream.

“On whose authority?”

“On the telephone.” He swallows. “A woman’s voice. She told me I was acting for the Concord. She said it would save the river. She said, in her words, that the water was being held in deposit and that the deposit would one day be called, and when it was called, the Ridge, which had been first to give, would be first to be made whole.”

“And you believed her.”

“I believed her,” says Kessler, “because she knew what I had lost.”

Cream. The room is very quiet.

“Second question. When she said the water was being saved, did you understand that people would die for want of it?”

He is silent for a long time.

“I understood,” says Kessler, “that the packs would be short-tempered. I understood there would be a quarrel. I told myself it would be a short one. I did not say aloud what I understood after that.” He looks at the table. “That is not an answer, Ms. Daly. I am sorry. It is the best I can do.”

Cream. It is the whole truth, and I know it as I know my own hand. I hear Penhallow, to my right, let her breath out.

“Third.” I do not look at my notes. I do not have any. “Did you wish for a war?”

“No.”

Cream.

I do not take my eyes from the tape. It rolls out, the plain black type, NO, and the room lets go of a breath it has been holding since the barge, since the barn, since the first of the petitions on my kitchen floor.

“And the fourth?”

I have thought about it for two days. I have thought about it on stairs and in cars, and in a pew in Dept 4 with a good man’s hand in mine. A question is a thing you phrase. It is not a weapon. It is a door, and you build it the right size for what you hope will come through.

“Mr. Kessler. Of the four times your name appears in the Lender’s register in the debit column, which of them did you take for yourself?”

He goes the color of the plaster.

I have not told him about the register. I have not told anyone but Bram and Calder and Quade, in a basement, in the smell of gasoline. And I see his eyes go to the end of the pew, to the white shirt and the gray beard, and Bram Okafor, who has never in twenty-two years wasted a word, lifts one scarred hand an inch off his knee, and lets it fall.

It is not an accusation. It is permission.

“Three of them,” says Dane Kessler.

Cream.

“I took three things, and I signed for four,” he says, and his voice, which has never in my hearing been anything but smooth, breaks. “I took them from a drawer that was not mine. I did not know whose they were. I was told I could draw on what I was owed.

My father died when I was nineteen, and they told me I had lost four years of him. Four winters. The last four. They said they were in the deposit. They said I could have them back, a day at a time, if I did what the voice said.” He stops. “I have had three of them. I have been fed my own father’s last winters on the installment plan.”

“And the fourth?”

“I haven’t taken the fourth.” He holds out his hands, palms up. They are shaking. “It is the one where he says my name. It is due on the day the water is called. I’ve been waiting for it for four years, Ms. Daly. It is the only reason I am a man who would dig a quarry.”

No one speaks.

“Mr. Kessler,” I say, gently. It is the gentlest I have ever said anything in this room. “May I ask you one more thing? It is not a question. It is a request. It is not on the Record.”

“You said four.”

“I did. I lied. It is a lie I expect to pay for.” I look at the tape. It is blank; it has not moved; the cream sheet hangs at the end of the platen as clean as a wedding sheet. “Will you tell the Moot who the surety was?”

“The surety?”

“A surety stands behind a petitioner’s conduct. You were the petitioner. Who stood behind you?”

“Nobody,” says Kessler.

“That’s right.”

“Nobody stood behind me.” He is looking at me, wide-eyed, a large man in a sheepskin collar with the pieces coming together in his face, as a child’s face goes when he sees that the monster in the corner is a coat.

“The Chair was dead. She was the surety. I had no leash. I have had no leash since nineteen eighty-seven. I have been a man holding a dead woman’s end of a rope, and the whole time my hand was the only one on it.”

“Yes,” I say.

“Dear God,” says Dane Kessler.

---

He yields his seat at 2:11 a.m.

It is not dramatic. Nothing in the Moot ever is. He asks Truitt for the floor, and takes off his sheepskin collar and lays it on the rail, and says in a level voice that he has been Alpha of Kessler Ridge for twenty-one years, and that he has used the seat to dig a hole in the earth and make his neighbors thirsty for a promise that was never made.

He says he does not ask to be forgiven. He says he would like to ask the Ridge to choose again.

“The Ridge,” says Truitt, “will choose.”

They choose in four minutes. It is a thing I would not have believed. The woman with the set jaw rises first, and then the two who looked down, and then half the pew, and then Lucinda Marrow, on her feet with her thin hand shaking on the rail, who says clearly, in a voice I have not heard her use since the night of the Finding, “I recall it that way.

I would like to change my vote.” And in the end the whole Ridge is standing, and it is not Penhallow or Truitt or me they look at. It is the man at the end of the pew.

Bram Okafor does not move.

“No,” he says.

“Warden,” says the woman with the jaw.

“I am a Warden. I am not a Speaker. I carry bars. I do not tell people what to do.” He looks, for a moment, at Calder, who is standing at the rail with his cast and his coat.

He is looking at him as one looks at a very large debt that has turned out to be a gift. “But if the Ridge will have a man who learned his letters at forty and is not fond of speeches, I will keep the seat warm. Until somebody braver sits.”

“Noted,” says Truitt, and the gavel comes down, the bone with its black tape, softly. “The Ridge has an Alpha pro tem. The Matter of the Impounded Water is closed as to the quarry. The Matter of the Lender is continued.” He looks at me. “Scribe. You have the Record.”

I look down.

The tape is not clean.

I have been so careful. I have not asked the Moot to take a thing I could not stand behind. But in the very last inch, under the final black NO, in the long unrolled silence while Kessler stood in the well, there is a line I did not strike. It is ash-gray. It is in the voice I know. It says:

HE WAS NOT THE ONLY ONE WHO HELD AN END.

And the cost arrives. It is quiet, and it comes as a hand on the shoulder, and I know it by now. I had asked a question in which I used the word lied. I had said, I lied, in the well, at the instrument, about the number of questions. The machine takes a lie as a debt, even a small one, even a kind one. “Dr. Raman,” I say. “Card.”

“I have it.”

“Seven. I was seven. I had the fever. It was the first night I typed. Mom held me and I screamed and there was a woman in the doorway, small, with a cold hand. She put it on my forehead.” I stop. The room is going out like a tide, and I hold what I can.

“She said, in a very flat voice, This will pass. It is only a very large thing in a very small girl. And she was lying. She did not know that it would pass. She said it so I would stop being afraid.”

“I said it,” says Raman, from the second row, in a low wet voice, “because Margo had told me to.”

“I know.” The memory is a candle in a window, going. “It was the kindest lie anyone ever told me. It’s the card. Number twenty-two.”

Raman writes. She does not look up. She is crying very quietly, the doctor, the guardian, the woman who has objected eleven times in thirty-two years, who has never once been asked to say what she wanted. I hear the pencil. I hear it stop.

---

After the adjournment, in the emptying Hall, Penhallow comes to me.

She is putting on her coat. The cameo is at her throat. She is a handsome woman of sixty-three with a silver bob and a cello voice, and she holds the lapel of the coat a little too tightly, and when she speaks she does not call me my dear.

“Ms. Daly. I told you in a barn that I was asked once, in 1987, a question, and the answer was worse, and I have never been asked about it since.”

“I remember.”

“The Lender has sent a card to a clerk. The Chair is dead. The Concord is a telephone.” She does not look at me. “I think nobody will ask me. I think I would like to say it before someone does.”

“Speaker’s still here,” I say. “If you want it on the Record.”

“No. Not the Record.” She lays her hand flat on the brass rail. “It was in this room. It was the tenth of April. I was twenty-three. I was Mr. Szymanski’s junior, and the Accused was an empty chair, and Margo Daly stood in the well and did a thing no Scribe is permitted. She asked the chair a question of her own.”

“What was it?”

“She said, Constance, I am going to ask you once. Who will be in the machine when the Lender comes to collect?”

The Hall is empty. The lamps are guttering. I hear Calder, somewhere behind me, put down a bar he was carrying.

“And the answer?” I say.

“It was not on the tape,” says Penhallow. “The tape was held down, you know, by the clerk, Dolores, with her thumb. It was only heard. By Margo. By me. By one old man at the back who has since died.” She looks at me then, and her eyes are quite dry and very blue. “The chair said a name. It was not a name that had ever been said in this room.”

“Whose?”

“It said, Wren.”

I stand very still.

“Wren,” says Penhallow. “In a voice like a woman’s, low, as if it were trying a word for the first time. Wren. I did not know it. Nobody in the Hall did. I did not know a single person of that name.”

She breathes. “Ten years later, Joan Daly gave birth to a child at 4:12 in the morning in the snow. And I read the notice in the paper. And I sat at my kitchen table for an hour with the newspaper in my hand.”

“Why didn’t you say?”

“Because it would have been a prophecy,” says Odile Penhallow, “and I do not hold with prophecies. I hold with the Record. But I am a woman who can count, Ms. Daly. And I counted.” She picks up her bag. “Margo named you. Or the wolf did. Or the wolf was told. I have been trying for twenty-nine years to decide which would be worse.”

She goes out, past the empty chair with its black shawl, and the door swings shut behind her on the cold, and the lamps flicker, and in the dark of the Hall behind me I hear, very softly, the latch of an instrument tick, once. Then again. A sound like a sleeper saying a name.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!