Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 43

Bailment

On Monday morning I sit in the public gallery of Dept 4 with a cardboard cup of coffee and a pencil, and watch another woman do my job badly.

It is not Mrs. Tilley’s fault. She is sixty-six, a retired freelance, called in from a list of substitutes the county keeps for the day somebody’s mother dies. She has good hands and a decent machine and a cardigan with a cat on it.

She is also eleven words a minute behind the room, and she knows it, and every time Pat Orlowski sneezes or a lawyer says “to wit” she looks toward the gallery with a quick, apologetic flinch, as though I might stand up and take her wrist.

I do not. I have been benched. The word is exact. Judge Haskett said it from the bench on Thursday with the whole room listening, in her plain judicial voice, and then in chambers afterward, in her real one: “I am sorry, Wren. Salary continues. The seat does not. It will be a week, or until the Annex matter is closed, whichever is longer, and you will not sit within ten feet of the bench.”

“You could have asked me to recuse.”

“I could have. You’d have said no.”

“Probably.”

“Then it is better that you are benched. You can be furious at me honestly.” She did not smile. “I am not enjoying this.”

“Noted,” I said.

“It is a hateful word,” said Dolores Haskett, “in your mouth.”

So I sit in the third row, on a bench that was designed by a man who disliked the human spine, with my elbow on the rail and my pencil idle. I have never been in the gallery on a working day. I had no idea how much the room changes when you are not hiding behind a machine. People look at you. They see a young woman with no recorder. They wonder what she did.

Calder sits one row back, on the aisle, with his cast across his lap and a coffee he does not drink. He has been here since eight. He has not asked me a single question since Sunday night. I think he is waiting to be told what to ask.

I am thinking about a line of capitals on a cream sheet. REDEEM. NAME OF THE HELD.

---

The first case of the morning is Estate of Dray v. Reyes.

I know the docket the way I know my own hands. I typed the pretrial last week, an hour of the dullest procedure in the county. A man named Leopold Dray, a retired surgeon, died in March at eighty-eight.

Eleven years ago he lent a cello to a young woman named Tamsin Reyes, then a conservatory student, on terms he wrote on a hospital notepad: Tamsin Reyes may keep and play my cello for so long as she plays it. That was the whole agreement. He signed it. A nurse witnessed it. Eleven years later his nephew, who inherits everything, wants the cello back.

The nephew’s lawyer is a brisk gray woman named Ferrante. Reyes’s lawyer is a tired man named Okoye with a shirt collar that has been washed past its usefulness. Tamsin Reyes sits between him and the aisle. She is thirty-one. She has her hands in her lap, and I see at once that they are a musician’s hands, the left one callused at the fingertips and slightly curled, as if still resting on a string.

She has the cello at her feet, in its case. I can see the corner of the scroll.

“Your Honor,” says Ferrante, “this is a simple loan. A loan, by its nature, may be called. The lender is deceased. His heir calls the loan. The borrower has the instrument. I ask for its return.”

“Mr. Okoye?”

“Your Honor, the agreement says for so long as she plays it. She plays it. She has played it every day for eleven years. There is no term that has run.”

“It’s a loan at will,” says Ferrante.

“It is a loan for a term, with an event.”

“Gentlemen, and lady,” says Haskett, and takes off her glasses. “Let me tell you what I would like to hear. Not who owns the cello. We know who owns the cello. I would like to hear what has happened to it.”

Okoye stands. He is already smiling, a little, in the way of a man who has been saving something.

“Your Honor, in eleven years of use, the instrument has had a new bridge, a new sound post, two sets of pegs, and, in the third year, a neck reset by a luthier in Cleveland, after a fall in an airport. The fingerboard has been planed twice. The varnish on the lower bout is gone where the player’s knee rests. The cost to Ms. Reyes of the neck alone was three thousand two hundred dollars. The total is just over nine thousand.”

“She wasn’t asked to,” says Ferrante.

“She wasn’t asked not to. An instrument kept in playing order is an instrument kept. A cello left in a closet would have cracked.” He turns a page. “Your Honor, the law of bailment is not obscure. A bailee who holds property for the owner’s benefit is entitled to the reasonable expenses of keeping it. And when the owner calls it back, the bailee holds a lien on the thing until those expenses are paid.”

I have stopped breathing.

It is a small noise in the room. Nobody else hears it. It is only a word, said in a flat Midwestern voice by a man in a bad collar, and the word is not one I knew I knew, but I know it the way you know the name of a street you have only ever driven down at night.

Bailment.

I put the pencil down on my knee. I do not say it aloud. I think I only move my lips.

“Say it again,” says Calder, behind me, so low that I feel it in my neck more than hear it.

“Bailment,” I whisper.

“I thought so.”

“Nell said it. Last night, on the phone. It’s what the old Scribes called a lend, before the Record learned the word.” I am gripping the rail. “The man who lets you keep his horse.”

“I am aware of the doctrine,” says Calder. “I have spent eleven years of my life reading a contract that was not shown to me.”

“A bailee holds a lien.”

“A bailee holds a lien,” says Calder, “until she is made whole.”

I turn my head. It is the first time in two days that I have looked him in the eye, and his eyes are ordinary and dark and quite steady, and I see in them an expression I know from a hundred courtrooms: the face of a person who has just read the clause that the other side thought you would skip.

---

Haskett takes it under advisement for eleven minutes. She does it from the bench, with her glasses on the blotter and her eyes shut, a small gray woman with her hands folded in front of her, and the only sound in the room is the air handler and a spoon in someone’s thermos. Mrs. Tilley looks at me. I look at the ceiling.

When Haskett opens her eyes she speaks directly to Tamsin Reyes. It is not the way she speaks to counsel. It is the voice she used on me, once, in a car park, six years ago.

“Ms. Reyes. Do you know what a bailment is?”

“No, ma’am. I mean, I know it’s what this is.”

“It is a very old and decent idea. One person has a thing, and puts it into another person’s hands, for a purpose, and expects it back. The law has had four hundred years to think about what that costs. It has come to three plain conclusions.” She raises one finger. “The borrower must take care of the thing. You did.

I have heard Mr. Okoye list it for the last ten minutes.” A second finger. “The thing must come back in the condition it left, less ordinary wear. That is a lovely phrase. Ordinary wear. It means the damage you are not responsible for. The scuffs. The varnish where a knee rests. The wear of being used for what it is for.”

Tamsin nods. She is gripping the arm of her chair.

“And the third,” says Haskett. “The third is the one the lender always forgets. When the owner calls the thing home, he must first account. He may not simply hold out his hand. He must set out what the borrower has spent keeping it alive, and make that good, because the borrower has been doing his work for him. And until he does, Ms. Reyes, the borrower may lawfully keep the thing in her hands, and say, Pay me first.”

She puts on her glasses.

“The court finds that the loan was for a term, that the term has not ended, that the instrument has been kept at a cost of nine thousand four hundred and twelve dollars, and that the estate, in calling the instrument, has not accounted. The call is stayed. Ms. Reyes holds the cello under lien. Ms. Ferrante, you will want to speak to your client about a check.” The gavel comes down, a little hard. “Next matter.”

Tamsin Reyes bends double in her chair. She does not cry. She puts both hands over the lid of the case and stays like that, her forehead nearly on her knees, a woman who has been told she may keep the one thing she was afraid to ask whether she could.

Mrs. Tilley’s hands are still. She has missed the end. She looks at me, stricken, and I mouth, It’s all right, and I do not know whether it is.

---

I find him in the corridor by the vending machines.

He is the young counsel from the daylight sitting. Fitch. He is twenty-five or twenty-six, long, narrow-shouldered, with a pale clerical face and a suit one size too big, and he is standing in front of the pretzel machine with a dollar in his hand, looking at the pretzels as if he has never seen food before.

I know him from the Hall, from the end of a bench, where he sat with a stack of cream stock on his knee, beside the seat the Chair did not fill.

“Ms. Daly,” he says.

“Mr. Fitch.”

“Gideon.” He doesn’t turn. “It’s Gideon. I would rather you didn’t call me Mr. I have not been Mr. anything for some time.”

“What do you want, Gideon?”

“I was in the gallery. At the back. I came to see if you would say it.” He feeds the dollar into the machine. It spits it back. “You said it. I saw your mouth.”

“Said what?”

“Bailment.” He says it so softly that it seems to leave a mark on the glass. “I was told to give you something if you ever said that word in this building. I was told it eight months ago, by a card, in the hand of the Lender.

I did not know what it meant. I thought it was an instruction to a clerk for a dead woman. I have had it in my coat all this time, and I have been afraid to leave my coat anywhere.”

He opens his jacket. From an inner pocket he takes a long cream envelope, thick as a paperback, tied with white tape, and holds it out the way you would hold out a very hot dish.

“I took one thing,” says Gideon Fitch. “From the deposit. I want you to know that. It is in the register. Debit, Fitch G., one. I took it when I was twenty-three. My mother died in January. I had my bar exams in February. I had them in my head, the whole body of law, in great hard blocks.

And I could not sit down and write one word, because every time I opened my mouth I heard her breathing.” His throat moves. “A woman called me from a number I didn’t know. She said, would you like to put it down for a while. And I said yes.”

“You put down your mother’s death.”

“I put down the last nine days. I have not had them since. I passed. I am quite good, you know.” He smiles, and it is a dreadful smile. “I have been paying the Lender back in clerkships for three years. I thought that was the cost. I thought I was only being useful. I did not know I was also the one who held the telephone.”

“Why give me this?”

“Because the card also said, Do not read it.” He pushes the envelope into my hands. “And I thought: she has put the last nine days of my life in a drawer, and I have been the only person who cannot read what is written on it. I would like, for once, to be the reason that somebody else can.”

It is heavier than it looks. The tape is knotted twice. There is a label pasted on the front in blue-black ink, in a hand with a tail on its S and a foot on its L.

STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT. W. DALY. TO BE DELIVERED ON THE WORD.

I look up. Fitch is already walking away, down the long corridor, past the water fountain and the notice board and the elderly man in the plaid cap who is sitting under it. He does not look back. He is a long narrow shape with an envelope-shaped hole in his coat, and he is walking as a man walks who has put something down and cannot get used to his hands.

“Wait,” I say. “Gideon. Is it forty-one pages?”

He stops. He does not turn around.

“How did you know?”

“I counted the thickness.”

“It is forty-one,” says Gideon. “I counted too. Every night. I never opened it. I held it up to the light.” He lifts his shoulders. “There is a last page. It is not in the same ink. I can tell you that much. I saw it through the paper, in February. It was blank then. It has been written on since.”

He goes.

---

I do not open it in the corridor. Calder is at my elbow, and a kind of low gray hum has begun at the base of my skull, and I walk with the envelope under my arm all the way down the east stair and out the side door to the little concrete yard where the smokers go. It is empty. It is a cold bright day.

The drought has laid a fine dust over everything, over the dumpster and the benches and the bare plane tree, and when I sit down on the low wall, the dust lifts in a thin gold cloud about my knees.

Calder stands. He doesn’t hover. He keeps four feet away, with his back to a wall, so that both doors are in his eye.

“You don’t have to stay,” I say.

“I would prefer to.”

“I’m not going to read it here.”

“No.”

“I want Nell. And Quade. And paper. And a pot of tea the size of a bucket.” I turn the envelope over. The tape holds. The label stares up at me with its flourish. “And I want to know why a woman who was buried a month ago tied this up with a clerk’s tape and the best wax paper in the county, and left it in the hands of a boy who wanted to forget.”

“Because she wanted it read by someone who would not be tempted to throw it away,” says Calder.

“Is that what you think?”

“I think she was afraid of the last page.”

I look at him.

“Wren,” he says. His voice is level. He has not moved. “I do not know what is in that envelope. I want to say that now, plainly, as a thing I know and not a thing I am hiding. I have not read it. I have never seen it. I do not know what is on the forty-first page.

But when the boy said it was not in the same ink, I felt the amber come up in my eyes. I did not call it. It came because the machine, in the case, was warm.”

I look down.

The case is beside me on the wall. Calder carried it out, as he has carried it everywhere for two days, and set it in the dust at my feet. I put my hand flat on the lid, and I feel it: the slow rise and fall, the breathing. And under my palm, through the walnut, a second thing, fainter, a tick, a tick, like a woman at a keyboard in another room striking one key at a time.

I do not open the case. I untie the tape.

It is a small stack, the size of a family Bible, wrapped in tissue. The pages are cream stock, typed on a machine I know, with a black ribbon and a worn letter e, and the first sheet says at the top, in the voice of the telephone:

STATEMENT OF ACCOUNT. THE SCRIBE W. DALY, IN ACCOUNT WITH THE LENDER. OPENING BALANCE: ONE INSTRUMENT, LENT, SOUND. ITEMS KEPT IN DEPOSIT, BY DATE AND SOURCE, FOLLOW.

I turn the page. A column. Dates. Descriptions. A little brass-colored number at the end of each line, which I take at first for a price. It is not a price. It is a drawer.

I do not read the entries. I cannot. I skip to the end the way you skip to the last page of a book, because I am a coward and I have always been one. Forty-one is not a sheet of cream stock. It is a single card, tucked in a paper sleeve at the back, newer than the rest. The ink is blue-black, and as fresh as a thing written this morning.

HELD PERSONS, BY NAME.

ENTRY ONE. M. DALY. HELD SINCE 16 OCTOBER, 6:10 A.M. BY THE LENDER. CLAIMANT: NONE. ENTRY TWO.

The second line has a number and nothing else. It is not blank like the Redeem line. It has been scraped. I can see where a blade has gone across the paper, thin as a whisper, and the fibers lift in the sun like a field after a harrow. Something was written there and then taken away. Only the faintest dent of a pen remains, a long vertical stroke, a hook, an upright.

I tilt the card to the light.

“What is it?” says Calder.

“Held persons,” I say. My voice is far away. “There are two. One is Margo.” I breathe. “Six-ten in the morning on the sixteenth of October. That’s the hour of the funeral. It’s the hour she was in the box. She was not dead at 6:10 on the sixteenth. She was held. The Lender has held her since the morning of the funeral, and it has written her name in its own hand, and it has said, Claimant: none.”

“And the second?”

“I don’t know.”

“Wren.”

“It’s been scraped out.” I hold up the card. The sun comes through it. “Somebody didn’t want the Lender’s book to say it.”

Calder comes across the four feet of concrete. He crouches in front of me, with his cast on his knee, and looks, with his tired dark eyes, at the little scar of paper where a name used to be. And his face, which has been the face of a man making a promise to himself all week, changes.

“That is a W,” he says.

“What?”

“The first stroke. The long one with the hook.” He puts a finger, very lightly, a quarter inch above it. “It is not an M. Margo’s name is M. Look at the first line. It starts with an upright and two diagonals. This one goes down, and out, and up.” He raises his eyes. “It is the same letter as the first letter of your name.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!