Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 63

The Price of a Claim

Odile Penhallow rings the bell at five minutes to nine on Sunday morning, and she rings it the way she does everything, once, softly, as if the door might prefer to be asked.

The laundromat below us is already running. On Sundays the machines start at seven, and by nine the whole floor of my apartment hums with the long wet roll of the big dryers, and the kitchen smells of warm cotton and lint. My mother is at the stove with a pan of eggs.

She slept in my bed and I slept on the couch beside Ike, who sleeps on his back with one arm across his face as he has since he was six, and Calder came at eight with a paper sack of doughnuts and sat at the end of the table, saying nothing, with his cast on the cloth like a place setting.

“Don’t answer it,” says Joan.

“It’s Penhallow.”

“I know whose bell it is. I can hear the manners.” She turns the eggs. “Don’t give her coffee. She’ll stay.”

I open the door. Penhallow stands on the landing in a camel coat and a gray felt hat with a pheasant feather in the band, with a small leather case in one gloved hand and the other resting on the head of a cane I have never seen her use.

She is seventy, perhaps. She has a long handsome face and a mouth that has been trained to say terrible things with great courtesy. In the Moot she was an Advocate-General, and I have watched her take a pack’s honor apart in forty words and hand back the pieces in tissue.

“Miss Daly,” she says. “I have come without notice, which is vulgar. I shall be brief, which will make up for it.”

“You’d better come in.”

“Thank you.” She does not look at the stairs, or the laundry light on the wall, or the three unmatched chairs. She looks at me, with her whole attention, for rather longer than is comfortable. “You slept very little.”

“Enough.”

“No,” says Penhallow. “But you are kind to say so.”

---

She takes the chair at the head of the table, which is the one nobody sits in. My mother, without turning, sets a mug in front of her. It is coffee. I look at Joan’s back and I know exactly what she has decided.

“I am no longer Counsel to the Concord,” says Penhallow, when she has had a sip and put the mug down on its handle side, as a courtier does. “I wish that understood. The Concord, as it has turned out, is a dead woman and a telephone, and I have been taking instruction from both for eleven years without once being asked to confirm it. I resigned on Thursday week. It was accepted by a clerk who did not seem to know who I was.”

“I heard.”

“You heard the news. You did not hear the cause, because there was none. One morning I woke, and I found that I could no longer do it.” She smiles faintly.

“I mention it so that you will know I am a private person this morning, with a private errand. The Moot has asked me to carry a message. I have agreed, because the Moot’s messenger is the only voice it still trusts. I will say it plainly. Then you may throw me down the stairs.”

“I don’t throw people down stairs.”

“You will find it useful to have the option.” She opens the leather case. It holds one sheet, on heavy cream stock, folded in half. “The Moot has learned, by the usual channels, that the Scribe holds a claim. It does not know the nature. It knows only that it exists, that it is large, and that it is assigned to her by a dead man. It would like to purchase it.”

Calder has stopped eating his doughnut.

“With what?” I say.

“With the one thing you have asked for and not yet been given.” She slides the sheet across the cloth to me. “The Moot is prepared to guarantee the release of Ruth Sorrow.”

---

I do not pick it up. I read it where it lies, with my hands in my lap, because I have learned that the first thing a good offer does is make you want to touch it.

It is short, and the Moot’s scribe has a clean hand. In exchange for a full assignment to the Moot of any and all claims of reimbursement now held by the Scribe against any member of her family, the Moot undertakes, by a vow made on the Record and underwritten by its own treasury of refused sentences, to stand surety for the redemption of the held person Ruth Sorrow, and to pay whatever the Lender names for her days.

My mother has stopped stirring.

“It’s good,” I say.

“It is very good.” Penhallow’s voice is dry. “I should like to be able to tell you that it is a trap. It is not. I have read it three times, and I know a trap. There is no catch in it. There is only a price.”

“The price is Margo.”

“The price is the claim.” She folds her gloved hands on the head of the cane.

“A claim is a lever, Miss Daly. In your hands it is a weapon you will not use. In the Moot’s hands it is a lever that can be used to move a thing that has not moved in thirty-nine years. The Speaker has been very frank with me. He says that there is a debt, and that he knows where it is owed, and that he would like, before he dies, to see it collected or forgiven by someone with the right.”

“And if I forgive it myself?”

“Then you forgive it, and the Moot gets nothing, and Ruth Sorrow remains in a drawer in the Annex. I do not say that to frighten you. I say it because I think it is what you were about to say, and because it seems to me that you should have all the stakes in front of you before you do.”

I look at her. She looks back at me with her long face and her feather and her hands folded on the cane, and I think of what Margo once said of her, in the attic, on a tape: that Penhallow had never once lied to her, and that it was the worst thing about her.

“What’s the other thing?” I ask.

“I beg your pardon?”

“You said you had a private errand. This is the Moot’s. What’s yours?”

---

Penhallow sets down her cup.

She does it carefully, in the exact center of the saucer, and when it is down she goes on looking at it, as if she had once been told that a cup placed so would not break. There is a long moment in which the dryers roll under the floor and my mother does not move her pan.

“There was a thing said in the Moot in April of nineteen eighty-seven,” she says. “I was thirty-one. I had been Advocate for four years. I sat at the long table in my second-best suit with a notebook, and I heard it, and I wrote nothing down. It is the only time in my life I have heard a thing and not written it.”

“The answer,” I say. “The one Margo asked.”

“The answer.” She nods, without looking up.

“Your grandmother put the question as the Scribe puts it, which is to say that the machine put it. She asked the accused whether she would stand. It is a formality. It had never once been refused in the history of the Moot.”

“There was a chair, and a wolf in it who was not there, and a hundred and ten faces turned to it, and the keys of the machine had been warmed by Margo’s own hand for an hour. She said the formula. ‘Will the accused stand?’”

I find that my left hand has closed on the edge of the cloth.

“And the chair answered,” says Penhallow. “I do not mean the accused made a sound. There was none. The keys moved. Margo had her hand on the lug, as Dolores Haskett has told you, and her thumb was white, and with the other hand she was holding the carriage. The machine typed. The tape came up. It was the cleanest cream you ever saw. I read it upside down from fifteen feet.”

“What did it say?”

“MY FRIEND IS NOT HERE.”

Nobody moves. Downstairs, in the laundromat, a dryer buzzes and stops.

“It said nothing else,” says Penhallow.

“It did not say no. It did not say it refused. It said that her friend was not here. And your grandmother, who had known for eight weeks that the friend was dead, and who had been told in so many words by the Speaker that the accused would not be informed, because to inform her would be to unsettle the Record, read it, and went the color of paper.”

“She said, so softly that I believe I was the only one who heard, ‘Oh, my dear. Nobody told you.’”

---

I do not know how long it is before I can speak. It is long enough for my mother to turn off the burner, and for Ike, on the couch, to come up on one elbow and stare, and for Calder to put down his doughnut in the exact middle of its napkin, as one lays a wreath.

“The Speaker decided,” I say.

“The Speaker decided.” Penhallow’s voice has gone quiet and clear.

“I want to be exact. I do not accuse him of the lock. I have never been shown any evidence that he went near it.”

“He decided that the Moot could not stay its business, and then he decided that the accused should not be told, and he made the second decision at his own table in the first week of February, in the hearing of three people, of whom I was one. I did not object. I sat in my second-best suit and I wrote down the date.”

“Why tell me now?”

“Because last night I read in a clerk’s note that the Scribe had asked who paid.” She lifts her eyes. They are gray and wet and entirely steady.

“And I thought, she will find the lock-keeper. And she will find that his friend never knew. And she will think that it is a thing the Moot did to a wolf, and it is.”

“But it is also a thing that I did to a woman of forty-one, who wept at her own machine in front of a hundred and ten wolves and did not know why. I would like it said, before I give you the Moot’s offer, that I know the weight of what I am carrying across your floor.”

I look at the case.

It is on the end of the table beside the sugar bowl, under its sheet, as it has been since we came home at dawn. I have not touched it. I promised, on a Friday, in the cold, to ask before I signed anything, and I have taken that to mean I should ask before I do a great many other things. I get up. I do not remember getting up.

“Please,” says Penhallow, very low. “I would sooner you did not. If it is to hear that, I would sooner you were told by a person.”

“She should hear it from a person. I’m the one who’s here.”

---

I lift the sheet. The walnut is warm, a little warmer than the room, in the way a sleeping animal is warmer, and the lug on the left frame is the color of a candle seen through a hand. I open the lid. I put my fingers where the keys wait, not on them, a half inch above, and I say aloud, in the Record voice, because there is no other voice in this kitchen that is entirely mine:

“I have to tell you something about Aubrey Daly.”

The keys do not move. The tape under the carriage is blank.

“He was your next friend. He stood beside you from January to the second week of February in nineteen eighty-seven, and then he died. It was a Tuesday night. He went to the lock. The Moot did not tell you.”

“The Moot decided not to tell you, so that you would come to the hearing without knowing, and so that when you were asked to stand, you would say what you said. You did not refuse. I think you were waiting. I think you thought he’d been delayed.”

The silence in the kitchen is the silence of the Annex. It is the silence that comes before the lug begins to glow.

It begins to glow. White. It is a thin white, a flame seen through frost. And then, with a slowness I have not seen in her, with the care of a person putting a foot on ice, Constance types.

HE BROUGHT ME PEPPERMINTS.

It is a minute before the next line. My mother has put her hand over her mouth.

I DID NOT EAT THEM. I HAVE NO MOUTH. HE UNWRAPPED THEM ANYWAY, AND PUT THEM ON THE CASE LID, AND SAID IT WAS ONLY MANNERS.

I THOUGHT HE HAD STOPPED LIKING ME.

I make a sound. I did not know I was going to. It is not a word, and I do not try to make it one, and from the other side of the table Calder is on his feet, and has put his good hand on the back of my chair, and is saying nothing, which is the whole of what he has.

IT IS ALL RIGHT, types Constance. THANK YOU FOR TELLING ME. I WOULD RATHER KNOW THAN BE KEPT.

A pause, and then, very small, in the thinnest white I have seen:

WAS IT QUICK.

I look up at my mother. She has her hand pressed flat to her mouth and her eyes squeezed shut. She nods, once, hard, and then shakes her head, and then, with the whole of her body, holds still. I do not know the answer. I do not think anyone in this kitchen does.

“I don’t know,” I say. “I’m going to find out.”

---

It is a long time before anyone can do business.

My mother makes more coffee, and nobody drinks it. Ike sits on the arm of the couch with his hands between his knees and does not look at anyone. Penhallow has not moved from the head of the table, and I notice that at some point she has taken off one glove and laid it on the cloth, and that the hand that has come out of it is shaking a little, as an old hand does.

“I am not going to sell it,” I say.

“I thought not.”

“And I’m not going to collect. And I’m not going to forgive it yet, either, because forgiving is a choice and I don’t know what it is I’d be choosing.” I put the sheet over the case.

“But I won’t have Ruth in a drawer one day longer than I must. If the Moot wants to help, it can help without owning anything of mine. I’ll swear not to assign it, not to sue on it, and not to release it until the Moot has sat at the place where he died and heard what happened there. Under oath. On the Record. At the lock.”

Calder says, very low, “Wren.”

“I mean it.”

“It is a forbearance,” says Penhallow. She says it slowly, like a woman tasting a vintage she had not expected to find in this cellar. “Not a release. Not an assignment. A promise not to act. It is the oldest instrument in the book. It binds the maker and no one else.” She tilts her head. “And it forces the Speaker to the lock.”

“It forces him to sit. I can’t make him speak. But I can ask the Moot to hear a matter at the place of the event, and I can ask the Speaker to attend as a witness, and I can keep both hands in my lap until he does.”

“He will say it is beneath the dignity of the Moot to be summoned by the Scribe.”

“Then he can say it to a wolf in a chair.”

Penhallow looks at me for a long moment. Then she laughs, one short astonished note, and puts her bare hand over her mouth, and says through it, “Forgive me. It has been a very long time.”

---

I swear it where I stand, at the table, with my hand flat on the sheet that covers the walnut lid, and my mother and my brother and Calder and Odile Penhallow for witnesses. It is thirty-four words. I have it by heart before I begin. I do not claim it is elegant.

I speak it to the Record, and the lug warms under the sheet, and I feel the old coldness take me through the wrist, up the arm, behind the collarbone, where it keeps a seat for such occasions. The card falls without ceremony. It comes down in the middle of the cloth like a dropped napkin, and nobody reaches for it but Penhallow.

She picks it up. She does not read it. She holds it by the corner as she would hold something she had been told was hers.

“Miss Daly,” she says. “I believe I know what this is.”

“Read it. If it’s yours.”

She puts on a pair of rimless glasses from the case. She reads, and the long handsome face does something I have never seen it do in the Moot, which is to rearrange itself, once, into a very much younger one.

“The first week of your Scribeship,” she reads, in a voice stripped of every manner.

“At the long table. I rose to address you as ‘the Machine’s operator.’ You did not look up from your tape. You said, ‘Madam Advocate, if you wish to speak to the Scribe, you may do so. If you wish to speak to the Scribe’s secretary, she’s at the dry cleaner’s.’ I wanted to laugh. I was very good at not laughing. I went home and told my sister, and for a week I could not stop.”

She lowers the card. “Eighty-three words,” she says. She is not looking at anything.

“Card 40. Eighty-two.”

“I counted the ‘I’ at the start.” She holds the card out to me, and when I do not take it she lays it on the sheet over the case, very gently, as one lays a flower on a stone. “I believe I would like that one not to be returned. If the court has no objection.”

“It’s not up to me.”

“No,” says Penhallow. “Nothing is, any longer. It is delightful.”

---

She has gone, with her cane and her feather and her cold gloves, and the Moot’s sheet folded back into its case, when the bell rings again, three-quarters of an hour later. It is not Penhallow. It is a boy in a gray hoodie who is nobody’s relation, with a fat envelope that he thrusts at Ike and leaves without a word.

It is the Speaker’s. It is heavy cream stock, sealed with a thumbprint in black wax, and in the wax there is a fragment of bone the size of a thumbnail, from a gavel that was cracked in half in October. Inside there is one sheet. It is in a large, shaky, carefully formed hand that I have seen only once before, on a witness card, and it is dated this morning.

Scribe.

I have been waiting thirty-nine years to be asked. I did not think it would be you who asked, and I did not think it would be by way of a woman I had not the courage to meet in 1987. I will sit. I will speak. The Moot will meet at Pennock Landing, in the lock chamber, at the first light on Tuesday.

Dress warmly. The lock is full again. I do not know who has filled it.

T.

I read it aloud. When I come to the last two lines nobody in the room is looking at anybody else. The dryers run on under the floor, steady and warm, and in the quiet I hear the small bright tick of a key on the walnut lid beneath the sheet, as of something that has understood a joke it was not meant to.

“Full,” says Calder. He has taken the paper from my hand. He is looking at it as he looks at a window he cannot see out of. “That lock has been dry since the winter of nineteen eighty-seven. The gates were chained. I have counted the chains.”

“Someone’s unchained them.”

“Someone,” says Calder, “has been very busy.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!